Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Value/devalue of restoring turn of the century pieces: also need advise...

Featured Replies

Hey guys,

New to the forum but have been refinishing pieces that the wife and I have picked up at auctions for $1 and about to start on the restoration of family heirloom settee...

 

It's a pretty basic set: rocket, chair, bench for two, from late 1800's to very early 1900's from what I'm told. My parents left it in an outbuilding in Iowa for 20+ years. Needless to say it's a complete overhaul needed. Old animal glue letting go, leather torn to shreds, veneer peeling. Pieces have the zig-zag seat support. Normally I'd pass up a project like this because they aren't comfortable to sit on nor are they particularly ornate. However, this is a family heirloom set. Pics to come soon...

 

My questions are mostly going to center on:

1: am I going to kill any value by stripping the old super dark finish and staining lighter to reveal oak grain?

2: I'll need assistance/advise on what to do with the peeling veneer on curved surfaces.

3: easiest/best way to strip that old dark varnish over a chemical stripper?

 

The last piece I did was similar, quarter-sawn oak claw foot buffet. Complete tear apart, strip, rejoint, and stained in a medium red hue stain. Replaced veneered top with marble slab. Also had to glue oak back into the broken out claw feet and re-carve them by hand. I was thinking of staining this settee to a medium red hue to match the clawfoot buffet and maybe make a coffee table to match: they will all be in the same room.

 

It was an easy choice to strip and stain the buffet since we paid $1 at auction but this family heirloom set gave me greater pause for quality of work and value after the fact, since I want to keep it in the family.

 

Gathering information before I begin on this one! Any thoughts for me?

Quote

 

1: am I going to kill any value by stripping the old super dark finish and staining lighter to reveal oak grain?

Honest question here. If it's a a family heirloom, do you care about the resale value?

The hard truth is that to get good results on a project like this, you need a pretty advanced skill set. Welcome to the forum and good luck with it.

It seems like it will never be worth enough to recoup anything for your time, and materials to put into it, in dollars.  It sounds like any real value is already gone anyway.

The only pieces I know of really worth the time are almost priceless to start with.  "Refinishing" can cover many variations in percentages of parts fixed, and authenticity to original.  The only way for it to be really worth a lot is if you can redo what a piece needs, and make it look original, as if no repair was ever done.  In other words, you have to be a really good furniture forger, and it's not done quickly.

I fixed a Walnut bed in the last old house we worked on.  It was over 200 years old.  The bad part was that someone had tried to fix it before.  When the owners came and looked it over, they said that they couldn't tell that it had been fixed.  I told them that if they had been able to tell that it had been fixed, that it wouldn't be fixed.  It made them very happy.

  • Author
  • Popular Post

 

It seems like it will never be worth enough to recoup anything for your time, and materials to put into it, in dollars.  It sounds like any real value is already gone anyway.

 

The only pieces I know of really worth the time are almost priceless to start with.  "Refinishing" can cover many variations in percentages of parts fixed, and authenticity to original.  The only way for it to be really worth a lot is if you can redo what a piece needs, and make it look original, as if no repair was ever done.  In other words, you have to be a really good furniture forger, and it's not done quickly.

 

I fixed a Walnut bed in the last old house we worked on.  It was over 200 years old.  The bad part was that someone had tried to fix it before.  When the owners came and looked it over, they said that they couldn't tell that it had been fixed.  I told them that if they had been able to tell that it had been fixed, that it wouldn't be fixed.  It made them very happy.

 

 

 

Well nothing is ever done quickly around here... the last buffet I spoke of looks great but took me the better part of a year in between all my other hobbies: chainsaw rebuilds, milling logs, fixing our cars and acreage equipment, fixing 2 driveway blow outs, fixing up the house, etc etc etc. I will repair and fix anything that will save me money. Anyhow most woodworking will never be worth cash vs time in the end, and I understand that.

 

 

As for the other points above. Yes, if it stays in the family, I guess who cares what the sale value is worth. Right now we don't have kids yet but we are hoping to start that soon... which is another reason I wanted to get the rocker fixed up. [emoji16]

 

 

Can't watch the video right now at work but will on my way home.

 

 

As far as skill level is concerned I am middle of the road? I have made some real nice shaker style furniture with clean simple lines out of the wood I mill. My grandfather (who has since passed) was a master of wood working. He would make grandfather clocks with wooden gear internals. Unfortunately I didn't get as many of those skills passed to me before he died.

 

 

I know most forums like pictures so here's a few...

 

 

 

Oak and walnut 3.5" thick to 5/4.

 

54b30a9c548437c63af67b91d955e5c0.jpg

 

 

What are oak burls worth? This one is about 3' across and 16-18" deep!

 

b3b87415ee7b68e4c3f361ceb80fd786.jpg

 

 

Hard dry elm that I was cutting wooden bowl blanks from for a friend. (37" bar and that's a medium size saw for me!)

 

4f42163aebf811f74498aaa8674a8c51.jpg

 

 

Refinished buffet I previously mentioned. Does anyone have access to antique keyhole inserts? I don't want new brass ones...

 

f4e79fb4a96bb84217133a15b9b319a1.jpg

 

Looks great.  I do a bit of chainsaw rebuilding too.  I've never been in the bottom end of a saw, but have one mid sized one that's on its third piston and cylinder-middle one shown below.  Replacement carbs have gotten so cheap, that I haven't rebuilt a carb in years.  I'm down to all Stihl, and one reason is there are so many aftermarket parts available that they're really cheaper to replace parts on than other brands.   I do a bit of porting too if a cylinder comes off for any reason.  The 066 with the 42" bar is a ported, and muffler modded bad-ass.CIMG1834.JPG.ed36507849c5a1fd848d61b222e13dd5.JPG

  • Author
Looks great.  I do a bit of chainsaw rebuilding too.  I've never been in the bottom end of a saw, but have one mid sized one that's on its third piston and cylinder-middle one shown below.  Replacement carbs have gotten so cheap, that I haven't rebuilt a carb in years.  I'm down to all Stihl, and one reason is there are so many aftermarket parts available that they're really cheaper to replace parts on than other brands.   I do a bit of porting too if a cylinder comes off for any reason.  The 066 with the 42" bar is a ported, and muffler modded bad-ass.CIMG1834.JPG.ed36507849c5a1fd848d61b222e13dd5.JPG

What size bar on that 036? I usually stick with 20" on 60cc unless they really have the guts to pull a 25". All my personal stock is mostly Dolmar/Makita. Easy to find parts and their resale isn't near as high as Stihl. Dolmar is a professional saw out of Germany and a brand that is older than Stihl. Makita bought Dolmar in 1991 and they still make great saws. I sell the Stihls because they bring more $$ and run the makita/dolmars b/c they are just as good.

 

Here are a few of my saws.

e26f2f4d861dd740f0514098c5eb1e4e.jpg

 

Not pictured:

118cc 3120xp husky 54" bar

111cc 076 stihl

2x 6100 makita's

Another makita 9010 or 2

5-6 stihl 044/440's

3x Stihl 066's

2x poulan pro 655bp 100cc

166 dolmar 188cc

4x Dolmar 143's 95cc

Etc

Etc

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

  • Author

I read the article and feel like I already knew that information but needed reinforcement to do what I want to our furniture.

 

That being said I am going to struggle with a stain decision for this settee. I want to go with a lighter color in order to show off the beautiful wood grain but... I also want to preserve the original look.

 

So maybe I'll leave it up to chance! I plan to look through old photos from my great great grandparents who owned the furniture. I planned to hang pictures of them in the sitting room with their furniture that I'll refinish. If by chance there is a photo with the furniture I'll leave it dark like the photo, and if not I'll pick another tone that reveals the wood grain.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I see why you have "chainsaw" in your user name now!   I just work on my own.   That's a 24" bar on the 036.  It's not to cut trees that big, but just so I don't have to bend over as much as with a shorter bar.  It's ported a little bit, but not a lot more power than stock.  It's mostly a limbing saw, and I let the guys who work for me use it for their firewood, so it gets used the most.  I think I bought the 036 in 1999.  The 066 is older, but it was used, with a scored cylinder when I bought it.

I've heard of Dolmar for years, but never seen anyone around here who owns one.  All the loggers around here run Stihl or Husky.

  • Author
I see why you have "chainsaw" in your user name now!   I just work on my own.   That's a 24" bar on the 036.  It's not to cut trees that big, but just so I don't have to bend over as much as with a shorter bar.  It's ported a little bit, but not a lot more power than stock.  It's mostly a limbing saw, and I let the guys who work for me use it for their firewood, so it gets used the most.  I think I bought the 036 in 1999.  The 066 is older, but it was used, with a scored cylinder when I bought it.

I've heard of Dolmar for years, but never seen anyone around here who owns one.  All the loggers around here run Stihl or Husky.

Makita's problem with loggers and tree services is that they don't have a high end top handle or 90cc in their line up any longer. I have mostly makita tools where possible. Their 18v/36v line is amazing to say the least.

 

And yea I have over 150 saws in the shop at any one time. It was a hobby/obsession that turned into a small after hours business. It also helps heat the shop and house since I have 2 wood boilers.

  • Author
I like the lumber stack nice selection of sizes.

Very envious here.B)

Aj

Thanks, the lumber will turn into a nice king size bed one of these days and maybe a nice glass front case for the bourbon collection if enough wood left.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,012 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • JAR Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.