Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Minimum thickness and age for live edge countertop

Featured Replies

Going to look at some live edge cedar tomorrow for use as an "eat-in" countertop in my house.  It will be at a pass-thru from kitchen to living room.  Maybe 16" wide.  What's the minimum thickness you'd recommend for this type of countertop and how long should it dry before working with it and sealing.  I certainly plan to support it on the kitchen side of the wall.  

If it's me, and I'm no expert.. I'd say 1.5 inches thick. Depending on your climate, 1 year per inch is the common advice. But.. if it's western red cedar, I'd not buy it at all. Too soft. I won't use it again personally, even for outdoor projects. I dented it every time I looked it, but that might be what you want. :)

For cedar I would shoot for 1 inch 9 sixteenths and one 32nd. Because when you stay away from common sizes we see everyday it looks custom or unique.

I like cedar who cares if it's soft.

Aj

If it's a really rough slab ( chainsaw mill ? ) I would want a 2 1/4 " thick or better slab to be able to flatten it and still have about 1 1/2" left. Moisture meter is a good investment if your going to work with green wood.

1 hour ago, Unknown craftsman said:

 

I like cedar who cares if it's soft.

Probably lots of folks. 

  • Author
10 hours ago, Cliff said:

If it's me, and I'm no expert.. I'd say 1.5 inches thick. Depending on your climate, 1 year per inch is the common advice. But.. if it's western red cedar, I'd not buy it at all. Too soft. I won't use it again personally, even for outdoor projects. I dented it every time I looked it, but that might be what you want. :)

 

10 hours ago, Unknown craftsman said:

For cedar I would shoot for 1 inch 9 sixteenths and one 32nd. Because when you stay away from common sizes we see everyday it looks custom or unique.

I like cedar who cares if it's soft.

Aj

 

10 hours ago, wdwerker said:

If it's a really rough slab ( chainsaw mill ? ) I would want a 2 1/4 " thick or better slab to be able to flatten it and still have about 1 1/2" left. Moisture meter is a good investment if your going to work with green wood.

 

Thanks for the replies.  Most likely, it's eastern red cedar.  I'm on the east coast.  I looked at some pics of other people's tops online.  The nice ones look to be 2" thick or more.  The seller just milled them at 1.25".  Probably too thin and too wet for my current needs.

Unknown Craftsman, I don't understand "1 inch 9 sixteenths and one 32nd".  I think the live edge will let everyone know it's custom.

 

subscribed

You've got a long wait to use that material, I'm afraid. Can you get a kiln dried slab, or is this a friend clearing trees, and you have the opportunity to get one?

  • Author
4 hours ago, Tom King said:

2-1/4"  and ten years.

 

3 hours ago, rodger. said:

You've got a long wait to use that material, I'm afraid. Can you get a kiln dried slab, or is this a friend clearing trees, and you have the opportunity to get one?

10 years!  Are you being serious?  Just a guy on craigslist selloing it.

I looked at it this morning.  Intellegent guy who seemed knowledgeable.  He gets wood from friends who are in the tree cutting business.  Has another guy mill it.  Not a chainsaw mill.  When I told him that I planned to use it for a countertop, he mentioned that cedar was soft and may not be the best choice.  Suggested that I use an epoxy finish rather than poly which was going to be my choice.    He also said the slab would be dry (13-16% moisture) in just a few weeks.  

I need to do more studying before making a decison to buy a slab.  Just leanred about how the pith causes warping from reading another thread.  

4 hours ago, LarryJ said:

Thanks for the replies.  Most likely, it's eastern red cedar.  I'm on the east coast.  I looked at some pics of other people's tops online.  The nice ones look to be 2" thick or more.  The seller just milled them at 1.25".  Probably too thin and too wet for my current needs.

Unknown Craftsman, I don't understand "1 inch 9 sixteenths and one 32nd".  I think the live edge will let everyone know it's custom.

 

subscribed

I'm not against off sizes for your thickness, but for "minimum" I was thinking 1.5. For a big slab to be 1.25" thick and air dried - There could be warping. I started with 2 1/4" walnut boards for my counters and the 10' one ended up being 1 1/8" thick because of the warpage. And it would have been thinner had I not broken the boards down finally and made it sort of butcher block style. 

Of course there are ways of faking it by buying multiple sequential boards, you can sort of try to make it so it looks 2 or so inches thick but it's just the trim on the outside. Lot of waste that way cause you'd just want the parts that match on the edges and none of the center except the very top 1.25". If that makes sense - It would be almost like it's hollowed out. From my own experience, I learned that customizing something inside is just a series of hacks because nothing is perfect in your house anyway.

Eastern red cedar is about 2 1/2 times harder and a little bit denser than western red cedar. However it is much more likely to shrink across the grain as it dries.

I think if you have some support under any overhangs bigger than 3 - 4" and get a moisture reading under 12 % that a 1.25" thick slab should work. You can also use a couple accurate scales to weigh the slab every few weeks. When the weight stabilizes for a month or 2 it might be ready .I think an initial coat of epoxy would harden the surface nicely. A satin poly topcoat would finish it off. Failure to have the slab dry before you finish it will turn into a nightmare !

  • Author

I'm thinking I'll just glue up some thick boards and go from there, rather than the live edge route.

Thanks for all the input.

I wasn't joking.  I wouldn't make anything of consequence, out of wide boards, that weren't some number of decades old.  As wood expands and contracts (which is multiple times a year), every time it contracts, it never quite expands back to the pre-contraction width.  Since it's not likely that a wide board will have nothing but quarter sawn grain, it will cup over time-no way around it. 

 The older it is, the closer it gets to an equilibrium state, where the cupping is negligible.

I had one board in a 1767 church door to replace, because the original had cupped to the point that the door would not latch.  The one board was 1-3/8" inch thick, 15" wide, and almost eight feet long.  It was a Gothic Arch shape, and the problem area was on one of the double doors at the peak of the arch.  It was a battened door, and the top 3 feet going up to the peak of the arch was unsupported. It had cupped pretty badly.   It took me a couple of years to find a suitable candidate slab to get that one board out of, and it was something over 30 years old.

I would never even look at a slab milled to less than a couple of inches to start with, to be able to mill a flat section out of it that leaves some reasonable thickness.  I've seen a lot of wide boards a couple of hundred years old, and older, and have some feel for what they will do.  I've been doing this for a living for 44 years now, but anyone that says a green slab will dry down to 12% in a few months, knows a lot more about it than I do.

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,011 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • bobtjanitor Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.