alindsey Posted February 3, 2011 Report Posted February 3, 2011 Woodcraft has added another plane to the Woodriver line, along with the v3 benchplanes in #s 3, 4, 5, ? 6 and the standard/low angle blocks and chisel planes. It's a side-rabbet. (Not yet appearing on the website but if you have the most recent catalogue check out the "new items" section near the back.) Sells pretty inexpensively (even more inexpensively if you work there ;-)). Cheap enough for me to pick one up and test it. I ordered it in as we don't have them in the store yet and should have one to play with a bit this week so review will be forthcoming. Not just saying this as an employee, I've found the Woodriver planes, so far, to be a pretty decent plane for the money. Not so excited about the block plane, though it's certainly more serviceable than the Groz or Kunz planes, mainly because the "knuckle cap" that holds the iron in place pops loose too easily. Haven't tried adjusting it yet. I've been wanting a side-rabbet for years, though. Haven't been able to find a decent used one and the Lie-Nielsen variety is more than I want to spend at the moment. $225 for the LN left and right set. The Woodriver, which is dual-sided, goes for less than $100. Quote
jHop Posted February 3, 2011 Report Posted February 3, 2011 This has been my issue, as well. I find I'm looking at the side rabbet plane for both rabbets and dadoes, but have not squirreled away enough coin to pony up Lie Nielsen's price. I'm anxious to hear how the Woodriver version works out. Quote
Bobby Slack Posted February 3, 2011 Report Posted February 3, 2011 This is my vote http://www.lie-nielsen.com/catalog.php?grp=1219 I tried the wood river smother plane against my LN 4-1/2 and there is no comparison. If you made your mind to invest on LN, do it. Stop thinking because you will always get 80% of your money back worst case scenario. This has been my issue, as well. I find I'm looking at the side rabbet plane for both rabbets and dadoes, but have not squirreled away enough coin to pony up Lie Nielsen's price. I'm anxious to hear how the Woodriver version works out. Quote
Dan S Posted February 3, 2011 Report Posted February 3, 2011 Bobby, what version of the wood river palesn did you compare to 1,2, or 3? I have heard nothing but good things about the version 3 planes. This is my vote http://www.lie-niels...og.php?grp=1219 I tried the wood river smother plane against my LN 4-1/2 and there is no comparison. If you made your mind to invest on LN, do it. Stop thinking because you will always get 80% of your money back worst case scenario. Quote
PaulMarcel Posted February 4, 2011 Report Posted February 4, 2011 That'll be a great addition. I have the Veritas side-rabbet plane and it saves my butt in many oddball situations. Definitely worth considering. Quote
dsaracini Posted April 24, 2013 Report Posted April 24, 2013 That'll be a great addition. I have the Veritas side-rabbet plane and it saves my butt in many oddball situations. Definitely worth considering. I've been considering getting a Veritas side-rabbet plane. It's that kind of night price point between Woodriver and Lie-Nielson. Anyone else out there have one? Do you find it worth the ~130.00 USD? Quote
Jonathryn Posted April 24, 2013 Report Posted April 24, 2013 I've been considering getting a Veritas side-rabbet plane. It's that kind of night price point between Woodriver and Lie-Nielson. Anyone else out there have one? Do you find it worth the ~130.00 USD? You don't need it . . . Until it's the only plane in the world that can help you. I have the Veritas-- it's very well made and I can recommend it. The machining is excellent, the irons sharpen up nicely. I got the O-1 irons because it's just a plane you'll use sparingly and it doesn't take a lot of time to sharpen O-1. They might have the PMV-11 (?) irons available but I haven't tried it so cannot comment one way or another, but initial reports seem to be very positive. The only criticism I can give is that if you're not careful, it is easy to let the depth stop swing over/graze one of the blades and make it dull, which is inherent to the design. Never used the bullnose capability. But overall a very good plane, especially if you're going to be doing a lot of operations that would justify the purchase. Quote
dsaracini Posted April 24, 2013 Report Posted April 24, 2013 You don't need it . . . Until it's the only plane in the world that can help you. I have the Veritas-- it's very well made and I can recommend it. The machining is excellent, the irons sharpen up nicely. I got the O-1 irons because it's just a plane you'll use sparingly and it doesn't take a lot of time to sharpen O-1. They might have the PMV-11 (?) irons available but I haven't tried it so cannot comment one way or another, but initial reports seem to be very positive. The only criticism I can give is that if you're not careful, it is easy to let the depth stop swing over/graze one of the blades and make it dull, which is inherent to the design. Never used the bullnose capability. But overall a very good plane, especially if you're going to be doing a lot of operations that would justify the purchase. Yeah; seems like good advice. I think it's one of those planes that rarely gets used, but when you have a need for it, you are really glad you have it. I think I'll save my pennies and use them some place else for now -- and down the road get one. I still don't have a shoulder plane yet. Seems like I would use that a lot more often then this side rabbet. Thanks for the reply. Quote
ChrisG Posted April 24, 2013 Report Posted April 24, 2013 I've been considering getting a Veritas side-rabbet plane. It's that kind of night price point between Woodriver and Lie-Nielson. Anyone else out there have one? Do you find it worth the ~130.00 USD? I got one for my birthday this past November. I don't use it very often but its one of those tools that's nice to have around when you need it. If you find yourself needing to periodically adjust your dados or sliding divetail sockets its pretty handy. Or if the dados are a little rough around trhe edges and you can afford to widen them a bit it also cleans them up quickly and easily. If you cut them by hand like I do its a lot quicker then adjusting the walls with a chisel...if you do them by power its probably preferrable to setting the router or TS back up just to remove a couple thou of material. Definitly not a must have tool, and not the easiest tool to setup but again, comes in pretty handy when you need it. Do I find it worth the $130? Yes, but again it was a tool that I waited to ask for for my bday rather than spend my own money out of pocket for it, I wanted it but not THAT badly. I actually like the LN pair better but wasn't prepared to spend that much money on a pair of tools I use so little. Ultmatley I felt like the LV was right balance of bang for buck. Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted April 24, 2013 Report Posted April 24, 2013 You don't need it . . . Until it's the only plane in the world that can help you. I have the Veritas-- it's very well made and I can recommend it. I also have the Veritas, and agree! You'll never use this plane... until you really need to use this plane! If you need a lot of other stuff, this is not a top of the list item. Filling out a great shop? It's really nice to have. Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted April 25, 2013 Report Posted April 25, 2013 I don't understand the knob on the WR... These get used on edge, the knob looks really wonky. The design looks like you'd have a metal edge jamming into your palm as you use the plane. Has anyone who has tried one of the others tried the WR? Quote
ChrisG Posted April 25, 2013 Report Posted April 25, 2013 I don't understand the knob on the WR... These get used on edge, the knob looks really wonky. The design looks like you'd have a metal edge jamming into your palm as you use the plane. Has anyone who has tried one of the others tried the WR? Haven't tried the WR, but the LN pair also has knobs like that. They don't look comfy, but in use (or when I VERY briefly used them at a show) I found that my thumb and pointer sorta pinched the plane and my other fingers sorta wrapped around and underneath the knob. Its actually a pretty comfortable grip (on the LNs anyway). I imagine the knob on the WR feels similar, but the body is less countured than the LN so it may not be as comfortable..you may be right about the metal edge jamming into your palm, but I can't speak to that, only the knob. Anyway, point being it might be a comfy grip, but I'd certainly want to hold the WR before I bought it, which was not a concern for me when I bought the LV which I was sure would be comfy. Quote
derekcohen Posted April 25, 2013 Report Posted April 25, 2013 It's a copy of a Preston ... Regards from Perth Derek Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.