Recommended Posts

Posted

After having used hundreds of festool discs of rubin, granat, and brilliant, i wanted to compare them a bit for people looking to buy new discs. I still dont understand the difference all that well, and i was even more clueless when i first picked up a 150/5 and rotex sander. Originally, i purchased used rubin and brilliant paper from the guy selling his ets 150/5 that i bought. I had rubin from 80 grit to 180, and then brilliant 220,320, and 400. Brilliant is fantastic for refining a scratch pattern on bare wood and sanding between coats of finish. Even on bare wood, i noticed it cuts pretty well for a long period of time. Rubin on the other hand never impressed me. I found it clogged a lot the second you hit glue/epoxy residue(despite constant cleaning with a rubber stick), and it loses its cutting ability very quickly. Ive noticed degradation after about 3 minutes of continual sanding. Fast forward to 4 months ago when i was almost out of 80, 100, 120, 150, and 180 grit(all my original 100 disc boxes of rubin), and i started combing craigslist for used paper. Eventually, i found a guy selling a sander and a boatload of paper. This time, it was granat paper. I convinced him to split up his sander from the $600+ of paper he had, and i restocked my shelf for 50% off. I only have a few months with granat, but it is wildly superior to rubin for general purpose sanding. It lasts 2-3x as long, doesnt clog nearly as fast over glue and epoxy, and maintains a consistent cutting/abrasive rate over the course of the disc life. I think it is more aggressive than the stated number compared to rubin. For example, the granat 80 and 100 are much more aggressive than rubin 80 and 100. 120 and above are comparable, but 80 granat leaves a very heavy scratch pattern with my rotex compared to 80 rubin on the rotex. 

 

In my experience, i cant imagine why you would buy rubin over granat for general sanding. While i think rubin is more refined than granat in similar grits, i dont particularly care, because i never go from rubin/granat to finish. If you are like me and switched from using mirka paper on your big box ROS to festool and rubin, i think you should give granat a shot. I was dismayed when i spent a lot of money to step up to festool sanding, and the pricey discs performed poorly compared to previous mirka discs. 

  • Like 1
Posted
15 minutes ago, Pwk5017 said:

I found it clogged a lot the second you hit glue/epoxy residue(despite constant cleaning with a rubber stick), and it loses its cutting ability very quickly.

Why are you sanding glue/epoxy?

Posted

I totally agree, Rubin is worse that mirka paper honestly and when i compared mirka to granat side by side on my festool sander  the only difference i noticed was that the mirka wore out a bit faster costing less that makes some sense. I never thought about trying brilliant on wood, but i did see some titan on festool products on sale in the 1200 grit and was tempted to buy it and try it for finishes. I didn't because it was still a lot of money for paper i didn't know if I'd use.

I've never seen festool paper on the used market kinda jealous.

Posted
19 minutes ago, WoodMan said:

Why are you sanding glue/epoxy?

Because squeeze out and knots happen?

 

4 minutes ago, Chestnut said:

I totally agree, Rubin is worse that mirka paper honestly and when i compared mirka to granat side by side on my festool sander  the only difference i noticed was that the mirka wore out a bit faster costing less that makes some sense. I never thought about trying brilliant on wood, but i did see some titan on festool products on sale in the 1200 grit and was tempted to buy it and try it for finishes. I didn't because it was still a lot of money for paper i didn't know if I'd use.

I've never seen festool paper on the used market kinda jealous.

Gotta search the whole country. None of those paper buys were local. 

Posted
16 minutes ago, Pwk5017 said:

Gotta search the whole country. None of those paper buys were local. 

Ain't nobody got time for that! :P I should modify that from never to hardly ever. There is some RO 9 rubin for sale locally on C list but it's rubin and for the RO90.

Posted

I like the Granat better too. My Festool rep quit carrying the Brilliant in stock, he sold me all of his partial boxes at 1/2 price. They were ones he used for demo's so 35 - 40 discs at 1/2 price. I only use the Brilliant between coats of finish. Primer/sealer sanded 400/600 leads to an incredible surface for the finish coats. Sanding finishes is tricky and can clog paper if you sand an area that is still a bit soft. Brilliant discs are thin and Cost less than Granat or Rubin.

I'm using up my Rubin discs by changing as soon as it quits cutting quickly. I've had boxes of the coarser grits around for years. It's disturbing how much we have invested in a decent selection of abrasives.

  • Like 1
Posted

I dont use scrapers that often, but i do plane away the bulk of the offending adhesive before sanding. Im saying rubin clogs over the residual leftover stuff. Im not attacking a 1/4" thick glob of epoxy with the sander and then bemoaning the paper for clogging. I need it to take care of the 1/32-1/64" thick skim i didnt take off with another pass of the plane. Same goes for a panel glue joint. I really dont want to plane that absolutely flush and free of adhesive for fear i get tearout, more plane tracks, etc. I get things close with hand tools, but i want 80-100 grit to hold my hand and see me home the last 1/32" or so. Its why i have a rotex--its a stupid and fast way to remove material. By the time i sharpen and mount a plane blade or put a hook on my scraper, i could have made a lot of noise and buzzed through it with the rotex. This is especially where rubin falls on its face. 

 

Posted
14 minutes ago, WoodMan said:

Thanks for the clarification. The post made is seem as though your were sanding globs!

haha oh no! Actually, sanding epoxy in general makes me nervous, which is part of the reason i try to plane/pare it away. I really need to pony up for a chisel plane for this task. I know people develop reactions to its contact, so i can only imagine what the sanding dust can do to you. Lets hope the festool vac does what it is supposed to do in that regard.

 

Also, i should add that 75% of my sanding is done on large countertop/island commissions, so i experience multiple iterations of the sanding disc performance during the sanding session. 50+ sqft means i use multiples of the same grit back to back allowing for instant feedback and comparison between paper types, longevity, cutting efficiency, scratch patter etc. For awhile, i was switching directly between rubin discs and granat to do my own direct comparison. 

Posted

Why does sanding epoxy make you nervous? Isn't epoxy a polymer so it creates large strings to create a solid? If i'm thinking about this right the dust created fro it should be no different in size from saw dust and is unlikely to bypass a HEPA filter.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   3 Members, 0 Anonymous, 36 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined