Recommended Posts

Posted

So I picked up a brand new set of WoodRiver chisels last night. They look great. Anyway, I have a project that I'm working on that I'm cutting lap joints on 2x4s and 4x4s(base for workbench) and I wanted to chisel this out to practice with my chisels before working on nicer projects. After I got two done I looked at my brand new chisel and the edge looks like it has nicks in it already. Is this normal wear and tear? I have yet to invest in a sharpening system but would sharpening these bring that clean edge back? Am I doing something wrong, should I not hammer it down against the grain?

I got these: http://www.woodcraft.com/Product/2082796/31499/WoodRiver-4-Piece-Butt-Chisel-Set.aspx

Posted

I haven't used or seen any reviews on the WoodRiver chisels, but this is a trait of poor quality steel. It my also be that you were using the chisels out of the box without putting a good edge on them. Give them a good sharpening (removing the nicks) and see if the problem continues. If so, I would take them back, they will be more trouble then they are worth.

Mike

Posted

Sharpening "systems" take some money, but sort are must have. You may do research to figure out a system that fits your budget until you can optimize to your true taste.

Sharpening is important beyond being sharp enough for the task. A polished edge will retain its edge much better as there are not the small fractures that get worse quickly.

Woodcraft specs claim the steel should be hard enough for the task, but reality is not always the same as published specs. After a proper sharpening if they do not hold up, they should be returned. As Mike said they might not be worth trying to get right.

Good luck with your new tools and projects.

Posted

Hi Ryan

It is not uncommon for new chisels (and plane blades) to chip when first used. This is due to the edges being a little brittle as a result of the heat treating process. In such cases, grinding the bevel back about 1/32" often takes the edge back into "good" steel. And thereafter all is fine.

If these were mine, I'd grind them back a snitch, rehone, and try again.

You can always take them back after this if it makes no difference.

Regards from Perth

Derek

  • Like 1
Posted

Ryan - many people (myself included) start with the 'scary sharp' method - essentially, sandpaper stuck to a flat surface such as granite or a piece of plate glass. With a decent jig, you should be able to sharpen and maintain those chisels with no problem. The key to SS is to get some very fine grits - I got them at a local auto parts store. I have a half dozen plates of glass with different grits. Flattening (lapping) the back is a must, as is getting a proper bevel. A small 'microbevel' on the tip makes for a quick and easy touch-up sharpening.

I had a set of old crappy Stanley chisels from way back, that I pretty much did not care about. I practiced sharpening on these, and while they no doubt are not up to par with many of the better lines of chisels, it's like having a totally new set. They cut very well, and the only knock I have is that I need to touch them up more often than I would like. They'll hold me over until I decide to invest in a better set.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.