rubus Posted January 9, 2012 Report Posted January 9, 2012 As a hobby woodworker, I would like to take it to the next level and aquire some more power tools. When purchasing a jointer, my research shows I can spend around $250 for a bench top (6" by 24"). Is it worth buying a small one like this? Will the table length restrict my projects? Also, what do people think of 14" Grizzly bandsaws? Thanks, Shane Quote
dwacker Posted January 9, 2012 Report Posted January 9, 2012 As far as jointers go the longer the table the better, benchtops are a drag. Yes griz makes some good saws but they have a few 14" models. Just depends on which one your looking at. Don Quote
Mister Pants Posted January 9, 2012 Report Posted January 9, 2012 I have a Grizzly 14" G0555 bandsaw, it works just fine as a hobbyist. The stock guides aren't the best, but they're no worse than the stock guides on just about any 14" saw on the market as well (I upgraded to Carters and they're quite nice, but not necessary). I'm not sure about their 14" saws that are below the 0555 though, as they look a little underpowered. As for a jointer, a lot depends on a few things, how much space you have, what you find your interests being drawn to from a build perspective and how much you expect to stick with the hobby. Personally, I'd stay away from a benchtop jointer, I'd save my money for an 8" jointer which would allow more surface space and a larger bed length. More expensive and they take more room, but it tends to fall into the first and last tool you'll buy (you can by larger of course, but personally I've yet to run into many situations where 8" isn't large enough). Quite frequently when purchasing rough lumber it'll be somewhere between 6 - 8" in width which makes it more difficult with a 6" jointer, and a benchtop is going to be more difficult to work with longer boards. Just my .02 obviously, and you're mileage may differ. Quote
mikem Posted January 9, 2012 Report Posted January 9, 2012 Stay far away from the bench top jointers. I have a Delta bench top jointer, and I can tell you it is not worth the money. It is the next machine I need to replace. Quote
Texfire Posted January 10, 2012 Report Posted January 10, 2012 I have the Jet 10" combo benchtop planer/jointer. It's good for the breed, but I wouldn't buy it again, I'd save my money for a full sized jointer and lunchbox planer, or really save up money and get a full sized combo if space is an issue. Quote
jmaichel Posted January 10, 2012 Report Posted January 10, 2012 I just recently bought the Grizzly 0555P and seems to work just fine. I put a 1/2" woodslicer resaw blade on it and have not had any issues with ripping 8/4 material or resawing a 6" piece of cherry. I have never owned a bandsaw before so setup was a little bit of a PITA. I did add the 6" riser block and a base, out the door for just over $630. This includes the woodslicer blade from highland woodworking. I don't currently own a jointer but I did own an older Ridgid that I bought off CL for $100. I thought I could clean it up, tune it up and getting it working fine. This turned out to be more work than I was reading for and this is a very finicky piece of equipment and I could never get it work right, so I just put it back on CL. I will probably end up buying a jointer again at some point but it will be new and probably a Grizzly. The arguement for 6" vs 8" is one that never seems to get solved. The Theory is buy the best you can afford. While this is sound advice theroretically it is not always practical. It really depends on what other tools you need to buy in order to build projects. I don't think there is anything wrong with owing a 6" jointer, you may find that you want you next jointer to be 12" instead of 8" and IMHO resale value on a 6" jointer is pretty high. Without owning a tool its really hard to decide what features you want it to have and where compromises can be made. One caveat that has already been discussed is that benchtop jointers should not be considered...agreed! Good luck! Quote
rick thom Posted January 10, 2012 Report Posted January 10, 2012 Without knowing things like your woodworking interests, aspirations, budget, space availability it's impossible to offer much in the way of specific advice. I don't know anything personally about Griz beyond what I've read and that's for the most part positive for hobbyist use for most common woodworking equipment in common sizes.. good quality, very good customer service and very attractive pricing compared to their competitors. I have a 14" Delta w 1 hp and it's been ok and adequate for my needs. It was pretty much the industry standard hobbyist-size machine for a long time, but the market is tending to larger, more powerful machines ie 15-17" euro-design w 2 or more hp making them more capable for resawing, perhaps more structurally ridgid and faster at cutting thick stock. It's pretty easy to talk yourself into 8" jointers, and for good reason if you intend to do much cabinet making using solid wood rather than sheet goods. When confronted with choosing rough stock at the mill. some of the wide boards (6-12") are certainly common and appealing. There are options to joint the extra wide boards that exceed the normal capacity of your jointer, and many woodworkers find 8" to be a good middle-ground capacity. These tend to have longer beds and require space to use and also store when not in use, as well as 230V power supply since most are 2+ hp motors. If you aren't into cabinet making with rough lumber, you may find 6" is perfectly adequate. Most are considerably shorter.. @ 45" long bed so storage and space is less an issue, and they are typically @ 1 hp.. 115/230V capable. Normally I have no hesitation to want to err on the go-larger side if in doubt... betting that eventually you will use the extra capacity. If budget is an issue/consideration, today I'm not so sure there isn't great value in the used market regardless of size. If you can buy an exceptional 14" bandsaw or 6" jointer for a small fraction of the cost of new, and it meets your needs for a number of years, that's not such a bad option either. Seems there's always a buyer for good quality used equipment as long as it's priced right. Then you shop for the machine of your dreams .. maybe the bigger resaw BS or 8+ jointer with spiral knives, or maybe it will be a planer/jointer combo machine. Just a different voice. Quote
rodger. Posted January 25, 2012 Report Posted January 25, 2012 Take a pass on all benchtop jointers. If you are serious about building furniture, you need something with more power and capacity. I bought a Delta 37-275X, and am quite happy with it. My only complaint is that I wish I would have saved a bit longer and bought the 8" model. You will "outgrow" a benchtop jointer very quickly. Save your 250 dollars to put toward a better machine. You could also look around for a used one on kijiji or craigslist, or maybe even find one at an auction. Quote
Jfitz Posted January 25, 2012 Report Posted January 25, 2012 Hi Shane - it would help if you shared what you like to build (or plan to build), as well as what your shop situation (space/size) is. My brother has a small bench top jointer he's used with quite a bit of success on smaller projects - face jointing small pieces, or just edge jointing. Beyond that, I think that size jointer quickly reaches its limitations. Quote
knotscott Posted January 25, 2012 Report Posted January 25, 2012 Shane - If price is the driving factor, I'd either buy a used 6" stationary jointer or the one from Harbor Freight. Both would be preferable to a benchtop IMO. Quote
over40pirate Posted January 30, 2012 Report Posted January 30, 2012 Stay far away from the bench top jointers. I have a Delta bench top jointer, and I can tell you it is not worth the money. It is the next machine I need to replace. I bought the Delta benchtop at a yard sale for $30. It was like new, and I bought it to resell. I tried it on some short boards, and it did a nice job. I think for some with a small shop, who does only small projects, like jewelry boxes, etc, it would be fine. Not on a 24/7 basis, but for a home shop. I have a PM50 and don't need another jointer, but actually thought of keeping it, so in the future, if I decided to downsize my shop, I would have it. Other than not a very powerful machine, that can joint long boards, what did you dislike about it? Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.