STL Woodguy Posted March 26, 2012 Report Posted March 26, 2012 As I said in my 220v thread, I've been warming up to the idea of getting a jointer. I've done jointing by hand and other workarounds just fine, but I can't deny how helpful - and time saving - a jointer would be, and my time is valuable. Hoping to pull the trigger once the second room of my basement is clear and some of my shop organizing projects are done, hopefully by this summer. Think I'm going with Grizzly. As the final two things I need to complete my shop is not only a jointer, but also a bandsaw, I'm hoping to rent a trailer, drive down to Grizzly a few hours south of here, and get the bandsaw (probably the G0555 with riser block) at the same time as the jointer, save good money on all that freight and make a day of it out in Springfield at the Grizzy and maybe the Bass Pro. But back to the point. I was considering this jointer... http://www.grizzly.com/products/8-x-72-Jointer-3-HP-w-Mobile-Base-Polar-Bear-Series-/G0656P ..but spiral cutterhead jointers seem to be all the rage... http://www.grizzly.com/products/8-x-72-Jointer-with-Spiral-Cutterhead-and-Mobile-Base-Polar-Bear-Series-/G0656PX I've already done my research on this forum and other forums as to the benefits of spiral cutterheads (no tearout on figured woods, noise, etc), but as enthusiastic as some were about spending the extra money for one, others said that the regular blade jointers were perfectly fine. Of the benefits the spiral offers, the one that appeals to me is that apparently they are more quiet. Noise is an issue I have to be careful of, as I live in a townhouse and have neighbors on both sides. But 'how' much more quiet are we talking here? Is there a very noticeable difference, and what would the noise on a spiral be comparable to? (In my shop, the noise of the table saw is fine, whereas my DeWalt planer is obnoxiously loud.) Also, the other thing I'm waffling on is the higher cost on the spiral - $400 - which nearly buys that bandsaw alone. Is the extra cost really worth it? Or couldn't I change the regular jointer with an aftermarket spiral blade down the road at the same cost (or less) if I want to improve the regular model? Quote
dwacker Posted March 26, 2012 Report Posted March 26, 2012 If I was going to spend the extra money Id get a parallelogram jointer. Id rather have a parallelogram model with straight cutters than a dovetail with a spiral. The noise wont be all that much different on a jointer. Don 1 Quote
Trip Posted March 26, 2012 Report Posted March 26, 2012 ==> If I was going to spend the extra money Id get a parallelogram jointer. Id rather have a parallelogram model with straight cutters than a dovetail with a spiral. The noise wont be all that much different on a jointer. +1. Spiral won't make much of a difference, but parallelogram will. Been there, done that... Quote
STL Woodguy Posted March 26, 2012 Author Report Posted March 26, 2012 Hmm...very good point(s). That would be this guy then: http://www.grizzly.com/products/8-Jointer-with-Parallelogram-Beds/G0490 More than the first jointer above, but cheaper than the second. Besides, it's impossible to 'upgrade' a dovetail to a parallelogram once bought, but I can always upgrade the parallelogram's blade to a spiral later if I wanted to, am I correct? If so, that might be the most logical path. Quote
dwacker Posted March 26, 2012 Report Posted March 26, 2012 Also be sure to check your power requirements. Download the manual and check that you have a large enough circut. Some jointers and planers although only 3hp will need a 30a. Don Quote
STL Woodguy Posted March 26, 2012 Author Report Posted March 26, 2012 Also be sure to check your power requirements. Download the manual and check that you have a large enough circut. Some jointers and planers although only 3hp will need a 30a. Don Looking at the manual now... Type.................................................................................................................. TEFC Capacitor Start Induction Horsepower.................................................................................................................................................3 HP Voltage........................................................................................................................................................220V Prewired......................................................................................................................................................220V Phase........................................................................................................................................................ Single Amps.............................................................................................................................................................18A Speed.................................................................................................................................................3450 RPM Cycle..........................................................................................................................................................60 Hz Number Of Speeds........................................................................................................................................... 1 Power Transfer ................................................................................................................................... Belt Drive Bearings...................................................................................................................................................Sealed Quote
konkers Posted March 26, 2012 Report Posted March 26, 2012 If I was going to spend the extra money Id get a parallelogram jointer. Id rather have a parallelogram model with straight cutters than a dovetail with a spiral. The noise wont be all that much different on a jointer. I whole heartily agree. Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted March 26, 2012 Report Posted March 26, 2012 Save the spiral money for the planer head. Quote
kyleheon Posted March 27, 2012 Report Posted March 27, 2012 I'm at the same point, reviewing all three of those. From all I've heard about parallelogram jointers and the royal PITA it has been trying to calibrate an old jointer I inherited from my grandfather I'm pretty sure I'll go with the parallelogram when I have the funds. Not sure yet if I'll go with straight or spiral yet, leaning towards straight to start. Good luck and let us know what you go with and what your thoughts are after using it for awhile. Quote
Vic Posted March 27, 2012 Report Posted March 27, 2012 If you're not in a really big hurry, get the parallelogram jointer WITH the spiral head. I disagree that it doesn't make that much of a difference. Try to buy the best you can with each purpose. Resale in tools sucks. You Quote
lighthearted Posted March 27, 2012 Report Posted March 27, 2012 I agree with Vic. I saved and got the 8" parallelogram jointer WITH the spiral head. I love it and I'm happy I went for it. Did I mention this was my second jointer I purchased.... Quote
STL Woodguy Posted March 27, 2012 Author Report Posted March 27, 2012 I'm at the same point, reviewing all three of those. From all I've heard about parallelogram jointers and the royal PITA it has been trying to calibrate an old jointer I inherited from my grandfather I'm pretty sure I'll go with the parallelogram when I have the funds. Not sure yet if I'll go with straight or spiral yet, leaning towards straight to start. Good luck and let us know what you go with and what your thoughts are after using it for awhile. I think at least at this time, I'm sold on the parallelogram jointer, the G0490. I hear the opinions on the spiral, but as I said, the blade can probably be changed out for a spiral after the fact if the straight cutter isn't agreeable. (Otherwise if the straight gets my boards flat all the same, that's all that matters.) Would have to buy a whole new unit if I went with the dovetail unit and wanted a parallelogram one. Quote
Sac Posted March 27, 2012 Report Posted March 27, 2012 Ends, I think that you are making the right sacrifice here. I have a 12" w/spiral that is a parallelogram bed. If I had to give one up, it would be the spiral. It is so easy to tune these things up. You can upgrade later, but the knives will be just fine. On a different note, might I suggest to take some of that money that you are saving on the spiral head, and invest it in a better bandsaw. Now I own the G0555, and I do like it. With a bit of time tuning it up, it has performed surprisingly well. But if you are buying a 6" resaw capacity and upgrading it to 12", why don't you just get the 12". My saw was a better saw when it was a 6" saw. Yes, it does the job, but there are saws that can get the job done better for just a little bit more. I would think about this saw. I think that you would be happier in the long run. But that is just my two cents. Quote
STL Woodguy Posted March 27, 2012 Author Report Posted March 27, 2012 On a different note, might I suggest to take some of that money that you are saving on the spiral head, and invest it in a better bandsaw. Now I own the G0555, and I do like it. With a bit of time tuning it up, it has performed surprisingly well. But if you are buying a 6" resaw capacity and upgrading it to 12", why don't you just get the 12". My saw was a better saw when it was a 6" saw. Interesting, so do you mean that saw doesn't perform as well when adding the riser? That G0513P isn't too much more than the G0555 + riser, so that's a sound argument. Anyway, that G0490 jointer and that G0513P bandsaw is probably that sweet point for me. (I do believe in buying quality, but I also believe in not buying more than you need, either.) On the topic of Grizzly, I don't keep up with them, having only purchased a drill press from them...do they ever have sales (5%, 10%?, etc) on power tools throughout the year? I already know about the tent sale, but I'm not interested in doing Black Friday in the summer for an unsure bet, so to speak. Quote
Sac Posted March 27, 2012 Report Posted March 27, 2012 I am saying, if you want the capacity, buy the capacity. Don't buy something smaller and then make it fit what you want. Quote
STL Woodguy Posted March 27, 2012 Author Report Posted March 27, 2012 I have a 12" w/spiral that is a parallelogram bed. Have one other question if you don't mind. Granted you have a 12" and I'm looking at an 8", but how difficult was it to get the unit onto the stand/base? I was looking at the directions for the 8" and the crate the machine comes in is over 400+ lbs...I assume the actual unit is still close to that. The directions were talking about using forklifts, etc to get the unit on top. Don't think I have a spare forklift anywhere in my townhouse, and realistically only have one other dependable person to help out. (And still have to get the crate down the stairs to the basement, at that.) Can this still be done with two people? I'm now wondering if the 8" jointer is a realistic endeavor for my basement shop. Quote
Vic Posted March 27, 2012 Report Posted March 27, 2012 Rob Bois, got an 8" Powermatic into his basement shop. He could maybe help with the logistics. I have the 12" Griz and it came all together, for the most part. I rolled it in pipe to get it into position. 1000lbs! Also, what I was saying earlier is that if you can hold off and save a little more, I'd get the spiral head , also. It is a huge difference in cut quality, set up and changing out knives. But, I hated trying to get the knives perfect on my old Jet 6". Just something to consider. Quote
dwacker Posted March 27, 2012 Report Posted March 27, 2012 If they come partially disassembled then two people should have no problem with an 8". Once you take the bed off the base you have two semi heavy parts. Don Quote
STL Woodguy Posted March 27, 2012 Author Report Posted March 27, 2012 If they come partially disassembled then two people should have no problem with an 8". Once you take the bed off the base you have two semi heavy parts. Don That's the thing, it's the top half / table alone that weighs that amount. The bottom half / base really doesn't weigh that much. But if two guys can lift that weight and get it on top of the base, then I'll trust in that. Two of us did get a heavy table saw downstairs fine, but I was able to disassemble the entire granite top from the saw prior which made our work incredibly easy (and I re-calibrated the table top later). Other than maybe the fence, probably not wise to take apart the jointer unit, I'd imagine. Quote
konkers Posted March 27, 2012 Report Posted March 27, 2012 That's the thing, it's the top half / table alone that weighs that amount. You could also consider renting a material lift. I just check hertz equipment rental's website and you can rent one (http://www.genielift.com/en/products/new-equipment/material-lifts/superlift-contractor/index.htm) for $60 for 1 day. Quote
dwacker Posted March 27, 2012 Report Posted March 27, 2012 That's the thing, it's the top half / table alone that weighs that amount. The bottom half / base really doesn't weigh that much. But if two guys can lift that weight and get it on top of the base, then I'll trust in that. Two of us did get a heavy table saw downstairs fine, but I was able to disassemble the entire granite top from the saw prior which made our work incredibly easy (and I re-calibrated the table top later). Other than maybe the fence, probably not wise to take apart the jointer unit, I'd imagine. Shipping weight is 564. The motor and base should weigh quite abit, remove the fence and you should be closer to 350 which is easily handled buy two guys. Don Quote
STL Woodguy Posted March 30, 2012 Author Report Posted March 30, 2012 I am saying, if you want the capacity, buy the capacity. Don't buy something smaller and then make it fit what you want. This is a good point. A little update on the above and the jointer: I'm pulling the trigger today on a Rikon bandsaw 10-325 bandsaw with 13" resaw capacity today. It's on sale through the end of today at Woodcraft for $799 ($150 off), and as the reviews are very favorable from here and other places I've researched on the web - and the bandsaw has everything I want/need - I would be stupid not to pull the trigger on it as it's cheaper than the other Grizzly I was looking at. Better yet, I can pick it up locally, so no freight charges. As I'm completely stuck on one project I'm working on (which requires sawing curves into a 6+ inch block of wood), I have a more immediate need for the bandsaw, so going for this first. Far easier to get into the basement too. But back to the jointer...short story, going down to Grizzly won't work: am going to have to pay the freight charges (and the bull**** lift-gate fee) to get it to my place, so I'm going to have to put that purchase off for a while. But because the expense of the bandsaw will be long out of the way, I will have more money to put into the jointer, so I may end up going the parallelogram + spiral route. Depends on either how much freelance I get this summer, or how generous my Christmas bonus is this year Quote
Eric. Posted March 30, 2012 Report Posted March 30, 2012 That's the thing, it's the top half / table alone that weighs that amount. The bottom half / base really doesn't weigh that much. But if two guys can lift that weight and get it on top of the base, then I'll trust in that. Two of us did get a heavy table saw downstairs fine, but I was able to disassemble the entire granite top from the saw prior which made our work incredibly easy (and I re-calibrated the table top later). Other than maybe the fence, probably not wise to take apart the jointer unit, I'd imagine. I have the G0490. A buddy helped me lift the table onto the stand and it wasn't a problem. It was heavy but easy enough. You can get it down the stairs...but it's gonna suck. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.