cusas6 Posted March 29, 2012 Report Posted March 29, 2012 Has anyone used one of these for sanding? http://www.rockler.com/product.cfm?page=31328&site=ROCKLER I saw this the other day and thought it sounded a little dangerous. Was kinda suprised that Rocker was selling it. Quote
duckkisser Posted March 29, 2012 Report Posted March 29, 2012 afraid not seems like a pain to get on and off the table saw. rather use my upright sander with the sanding disc attached to it. Quote
Mike M Posted March 29, 2012 Report Posted March 29, 2012 The only use I can see for this is as an alignment aid (without the sandpaper) assuming the plate is true. Otherwise, it would be more bother than it is worth to mount it. Also, with a real disc sander, the disc center is close to the table top so you are sanding with the portion of the disc going perpendicular into the table. In a table saw, the arbor is about 2 inches below the table so the disc is pushing the material toward the front of the saw. Be careful it doesn't get thrown back. Quote
dwacker Posted March 29, 2012 Report Posted March 29, 2012 The only use I can see for this is as an alignment aid (without the sandpaper) assuming the plate is true. Otherwise, it would be more bother than it is worth to mount it. Also, with a real disc sander, the disc center is close to the table top so you are sanding with the portion of the disc going perpendicular into the table. In a table saw, the arbor is about 2 inches below the table so the disc is pushing the material toward the front of the saw. Be careful it doesn't get thrown back. With a real disc sander the center should be well above the table or well below the table. If not you end up with a circular pattern at the center left unsanded. The problem with these discs is side load on the bearings. Saws dont have thrust bearing. The larger disc sanders are direct drive with thrust bearings. Im sure for light use or occasional use they are fine but dangerous. Quote
Dave H Posted March 29, 2012 Report Posted March 29, 2012 Although I can see the side loading argument, I'm trying to see the dangerous side as there is no teeth on this product it is essentially a sander, yes you could possably sand your finger tip or manicure a nail down to the quick. with a zero clearance plate on your saw. Other than side loading the saw what makes this any more dangerous than anyother disk sander out there? I'm just asking Quote
dwacker Posted March 29, 2012 Report Posted March 29, 2012 Although I can see the side loading argument, I'm trying to see the dangerous side as there is no teeth on this product it is essentially a sander, yes you could possably sand your finger tip or manicure a nail down to the quick. with a zero clearance plate on your saw. Other than side loading the saw what makes this any more dangerous than anyother disk sander out there? I'm just asking Their to thin. Thin cuts you quick especially when it turning at more than double the speed of a similar design. Thin flexes and cracks at the arbor. No gaurd. They are nothing new osha made them against the rules decades ago. They dissapeard for awhile and now their comming back. My theory of why they are comming back is the voluntary new guard design standards. You can put one of those on a newer saw and still use the guard for the back and top while leaving the sanding side flipped up. Just a theory. Of course your going to have the moron that mounts it backwards. Don Quote
duckkisser Posted March 29, 2012 Report Posted March 29, 2012 Although I can see the side loading argument, I'm trying to see the dangerous side as there is no teeth on this product it is essentially a sander, yes you could possably sand your finger tip or manicure a nail down to the quick. with a zero clearance plate on your saw. Other than side loading the saw what makes this any more dangerous than anyother disk sander out there? I'm just asking rather cut myself on table saw blade sanding burn is like a rug burn and then you rub sand intot he burn. Quote
Trip Posted March 29, 2012 Report Posted March 29, 2012 These are one of those tools that sounds good on paper, but NFG in the real world... Just say no... Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted March 30, 2012 Report Posted March 30, 2012 I gave one away 8-10 years ago Quote
Dave H Posted March 30, 2012 Report Posted March 30, 2012 Their to thin. Thin cuts you quick especially when it turning at more than double the speed of a similar design. Thin flexes and cracks at the arbor. No gaurd. They are nothing new osha made them against the rules decades ago. They dissapeard for awhile and now their comming back. My theory of why they are comming back is the voluntary new guard design standards. You can put one of those on a newer saw and still use the guard for the back and top while leaving the sanding side flipped up. Just a theory. Of course your going to have the moron that mounts it backwards. Don Thanks Don that makes sence. rather cut myself on table saw blade sanding burn is like a rug burn and then you rub sand intot he burn. Huh? Quote
knotscott Posted March 31, 2012 Report Posted March 31, 2012 Compare a TS to a real disc sander RPM....TS RPM is pretty high and is more likely to cause burning. Quote
WoodKutter Posted March 31, 2012 Report Posted March 31, 2012 Also, think about all the grit getting into the mechanisms in your table saw. Every time you raise and lower your blade. Tilt the blade. The grit will be wearing out the screws and lead nuts on your saw. The motor will pull some of that grit into its self. I shutter to think about. Quote
knotscott Posted April 1, 2012 Report Posted April 1, 2012 Also, think about all the grit getting into the mechanisms in your table saw. Every time you raise and lower your blade. Tilt the blade. The grit will be wearing out the screws and lead nuts on your saw. The motor will pull some of that grit into its self. I shutter to think about. Hadn't thought of that, but it's an excellent point. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.