pagel Posted June 18, 2012 Report Posted June 18, 2012 Completely slack so there's no tension on the blade? That's what I've been doing, but it seems that when I retension the blade back to where I had it the tension is different. The blade is tracking just fine. Lately I've just been listening to the blade as I adjust the tension and when it sounds smooth I stop or, if all else fails, I do a quick version of the flutter method all over again. I don't want to over tighten it. I'm using a 1/2" 3 TPI Olsen blade. Any wisdom from you experts would be appreciated. Quote
Vic Posted June 19, 2012 Report Posted June 19, 2012 I just flip the tension lever off and only if I'm done for the day. (null) Quote
pagel Posted June 19, 2012 Author Report Posted June 19, 2012 I don't have a lever to flip but a wheel. How loose would you say your blade is when you flip the lever? Thanks, Vic! Quote
Jim Heinbuch Posted June 19, 2012 Report Posted June 19, 2012 When I flip the lever on my BS the blade is completely loose. Of course, this only happens when I "flip out." Quote
lawrence Posted June 19, 2012 Report Posted June 19, 2012 I detension my blade every time I change it... and that's it. I know that after a certain period of time I'll probably have to replace my tires... and I'm OK with that. I haven't had any problems with blades breaking etc from stress, and of course YMMV. Just my .02 Lawrence 1 Quote
pagel Posted June 19, 2012 Author Report Posted June 19, 2012 Thanks everyone for the advice. I decided to take the middle road on this one and stop worrying about it... Quote
dwacker Posted June 20, 2012 Report Posted June 20, 2012 I would agree with just leaving them tight if you have an industrial saw. No way Id do it with any of todays 14 -20" high resaw capacity saws. Don Quote
CubsFan Posted June 20, 2012 Report Posted June 20, 2012 I'm certainly no expert, but attended a session with Roland Johnson of Fine Woodworking, and he said that with any newer bandsaw that you don't have to worry about it. He said he only does it if it's going to set for 6 months or more, but even then he didn't think it was terribly necessary. 1 Quote
dwacker Posted June 20, 2012 Report Posted June 20, 2012 I'm certainly no expert, but attended a session with Roland Johnson of Fine Woodworking, and he said that with any newer bandsaw that you don't have to worry about it. He said he only does it if it's going to set for 6 months or more, but even then he didn't think it was terribly necessary. The new saws are the worse saws to leave tensioned especially the cheaper ones. If you measure the spine flex on your saws and you have flex then you definatly dont want to leave it tight. Spine flex turns into bent spine. Most makers are building to much resaw capability into the saws without building up the spine. Of course this is what people want, big resaw capacity numbers. This is why most industrial saws dont have matched resaw height. Don Quote
pagel Posted June 20, 2012 Author Report Posted June 20, 2012 Interseting... I have the MiniMax 16" S400 P which is probably adequate reagrding spine strength but they do recommend detensioning the blade. Quote
rmac Posted June 20, 2012 Report Posted June 20, 2012 Never mind the spine, seems to me that detensioning is a good idea just for the sake of the tires. -- Russ Quote
pagel Posted June 20, 2012 Author Report Posted June 20, 2012 Never mind the spine, seems to me that detensioning is a good idea just for the sake of the tires. That's been my understanding too, but the MiniMax tires are flat rather than crowned, so what difference does that make in the "equation"? Quote
dwacker Posted June 20, 2012 Report Posted June 20, 2012 Interseting... I have the MiniMax 16" S400 P which is probably adequate reagrding spine strength but they do recommend detensioning the blade. I spent alot of time yapping with Sam Blasco while deciding how to outfit my shop and even his many beloved MM saws have their share of spine flex. Tires are an issue with any bandsaw with arched tires, not so much on the little flat ones. Don Quote
HuxleyWood Posted June 20, 2012 Report Posted June 20, 2012 The new saws are the worse saws to leave tensioned especially the cheaper ones. If you measure the spine flex on your saws and you have flex then you definatly dont want to leave it tight. Spine flex turns into bent spine. Most makers are building to much resaw capability into the saws without building up the spine. Of course this is what people want, big resaw capacity numbers. This is why most industrial saws dont have matched resaw height. Don If you measure spine flex and do NOT find flex then you either have poor measuring skills, poor instruments or have found a way to avoid the laws of physics. All spines flex even with the slightest tension, period. The spine of the saw is not going to enter the realm of plastic deformation unless you exceed the steel or cast iron's yield strength, the only way you are going to do that on a properly engineered saw is continue to crank down the tension once the spring has bottomed out. My point is simple, you are NOT going to end up with a permanently bent spine no matter how long you leave the tension on IF the spine was not permanently damaged (past its yield strength) the second you applied that level of tension to the blade. If you do pass the yield strength the permanent damage is immediate, if you do not pass the yield strength then 100 years at that tension will not cause any permanant damage. 2 Quote
rmac Posted June 20, 2012 Report Posted June 20, 2012 That's been my understanding too, but the MiniMax tires are flat rather than crowned, so what difference does that make in the "equation"? I'm not sure if crowned vs. flat would make any difference or not. On my bandsaw, the current set of tires is made out of some kind of semi-soft plastic stuff. The ones before that were made of rubber and were even softer. My thinking is that if you left the blade tensioned for long periods of time, the blade would deform the tires where it was in contact with them, but not elsewhere. That would in turn make the whole wheel out of round to some degree, which would be a bad thing. I don't know if any of this is actually true or not, but that's why I back off the tension knob when I'm not going to use the saw for a while. -- Russ Quote
HuxleyWood Posted June 20, 2012 Report Posted June 20, 2012 That's been my understanding too, but the MiniMax tires are flat rather than crowned, so what difference does that make in the "equation"? The issue has more to do with the durometer of the substance used to make the tire than the configuration of the crown but it is not the only factor. Some bandsaws have crowned wheels and use softer and thinner tires to conform to this crown, they are the most likely to flat spot. Some bandsaws use thick relatively hard rubber on flat tires where the tire itself is crowned, these are SLIGHTLY less prone to flat spotting but they still carry the tension on a relatively small area due to the crown. Flat tires with flat rubber wheels like most European bandsaws are the least likely to flat spot, the vulcanized Agazzani tires are the least likely of those to flat spot. I have left wide carbide blades tensioned at 28,000-30,000 psi on my Minimax MM20 and MM24 saws for over a month without any ill effects I can see/feel. I tend to reduce the tension about a half a turn on my big saws if I expect them to sit around for weeks without use, partly since the tires are expensive. On my small saws (Delta 28-350 20" and PM 141 14") I never bother since the bands on them are quite small and don't have much absolute pressure on them. Quote
dwacker Posted June 20, 2012 Report Posted June 20, 2012 If you measure spine flex and do NOT find flex then you either have poor measuring skills, poor instruments or have found a way to avoid the laws of physics. All spines flex even with the slightest tension, period. The spine of the saw is not going to enter the realm of plastic deformation unless you exceed the steel or cast iron's yield strength, the only way you are going to do that on a properly engineered saw is continue to crank down the tension once the spring has bottomed out. My point is simple, you are NOT going to end up with a permanently bent spine no matter how long you leave the tension on IF the spine was not permanently damaged (past its yield strength) the second you applied that level of tension to the blade. If you do pass the yield strength the permanent damage is immediate, if you do not pass the yield strength then 100 years at that tension will not cause any permanant damage. Not accurate. We have saws at the plant that are upwards of 30 years old that the blades are shortened due to the spines being deformed from years of being tensioned and have been this way for the last 20 years. These saws run every day all day long and only shut down for blade changes. All are 36" Even the 48" three wheel is deformed and runs blade shorter than spec. Even the 3 newer northfields are showing signs that the blades need shortening. All of these saw are old northfields. I would not leave a blade tensioned on one of todays saws that was not being used on a daily basis. Don Quote
HuxleyWood Posted June 20, 2012 Report Posted June 20, 2012 Not accurate. We have saws at the plant that are upwards of 30 years old that the blades are shortened due to the spines being deformed from years of being tensioned and have been this way for the last 20 years. These saws run every day all day long and only shut down for blade changes. All are 36" Even the 48" three wheel is deformed and runs blade shorter than spec. Even the 3 newer northfields are showing signs that the blades need shortening. All of these saw are old northfields. I would not leave a blade tensioned on one of todays saws that was not being used on a daily basis. Don You can argue all you want and if you are able to win the argument there will be a lot of scientists very interested in your work and probably a Nobel prize for you as well. You are using anecdotal evidence and even at that you have presented no empirical numbers to support that evidence. Have you acounted for mis-use? Have the springs ever been bottomed out, even once, for even a second? Have the springs been pushed past their yeild strength? Bottom line you are arguing against the laws of nature and everything we understand about metals, if you think you know more about the subject than countless engineers and scientists then you better start publishing since if you are correct then the metal world around us is about to crumble. I expect what you are saying about the bandsaws is indeed true but I would be willing to bet your proffered explanation is without merit there are plenty of other variables involved and Ochem's razor would suggest it is likely a spring issue or misuse rather than the bending of the laws of physics... 2 Quote
pagel Posted June 20, 2012 Author Report Posted June 20, 2012 Soooo, I'm probably okay with my 16" semi-daily use band saw - physics notwithstanding? 1 Quote
HuxleyWood Posted June 20, 2012 Report Posted June 20, 2012 Soooo, I'm probably okay with my 16" semi-daily use band saw - physics notwithstanding? Well, I haven't broken two of its bigger siblings yet... Quote
Brian VanVreede Posted June 21, 2012 Report Posted June 21, 2012 When I know I won't be using it for a day or 2, I detension all the way, otherwise I keep it tensioned. If your tensioning knob is difficult to turn bc of its location, I would recommend doing the following. I saw it on FWW.com it extends the knob above the top of the BS and only costs like $5 Quote
dwacker Posted June 21, 2012 Report Posted June 21, 2012 You can argue all you want and if you are able to win the argument there will be a lot of scientists very interested in your work and probably a Nobel prize for you as well. Im not arguing at all and honestly not a physicists nor do I understand physics but rather work in the real world. At the plant every aspect of the saws are monitored by plc systems that feed information to the computer guided feed systems, controlled in the tower. Every wheel angle, cuts per tooth, motor load, band tension...... absolutely everything. Caster is an uncontrolled spine function but is the most important angle for the system to watch in order for the saws to cut perfectly with the guide system. As the spines flexes the caster angle changes and the computers programing adjust the feed angles accordingly. Take any small and most larger band saws and leave it tensioned and the un tensioned caster angle will increase over time. Not physics, not smart enough for that just real world working experience. Don Quote
HuxleyWood Posted June 21, 2012 Report Posted June 21, 2012 OK away from the thoery the fact remains your real world experience does not account for all the variables in the system, plastic deformation of the spine is only one reason the wheels would be closer together over time, of most of these potential factors plastic deformation of the spine is probably the least likely and would require the metal to be pushed past its yield strength. My personal ownership experience only goes as far up the ladder as 36" Northfield and Tannawitz bandsaws but down to 14" cast clones so the uber-large are out of my personal experince range but within the realm that most hobbists and light commercial users are ever going to see I think it is impossible to do permanent damage to any of these bandsaws SPINES (you can easily bend or break a 14" Delta cast saw or its clones tracking arm) without bottoming out the spring, this will be part of the design criteria when designing the saw. There is nothing wrong with detensioning a bandsaw but the only thing one is helping is longevity of the tires. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.