ScoFF Posted August 27, 2012 Report Posted August 27, 2012 I’ve been woodworking for about 5 years now and haven’t had this situation come up yet. I’ve always owned a Triton 2 1/4hp router, the router bits always just came out once the collet was loosened with a light pull of the fingers (router unplugged of course). I recently bought a Porter Cable 7518 from the deal announcement of it being $109 with mail in palm sander so I mounted the in my table. I loosened the collet but the bit was very very tight. I had to completely unscrew and remove the collet and had to pull it out using a rag so it wouldn’t accidentally cut me. I was thinking of using plyers but didn’t want to scratch or deform the metal or hurt an edge. What do you guys do? Quote
Trip Posted August 27, 2012 Report Posted August 27, 2012 different style collet -- after the nut becomes loose turn it one or two more revolutions it will then re-tighten. when you break this bond, it frees the bit... Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted August 27, 2012 Report Posted August 27, 2012 So, turn the nut until it is loose, then until it is tight, then until it is loose again? Quote
Trip Posted August 27, 2012 Report Posted August 27, 2012 not really 'loose' on the second time, more like cracking the bond between the sides of the collet and shaft...a couple of router guys work that way. never bothered to find out why. just is... Quote
JayWC Posted August 27, 2012 Report Posted August 27, 2012 I'd recommend you read this article. You may have a self releasing collet. I think that's what Beech is referring to. http://www.popularwoodworking.com/techniques/your-guide-to-router-collets Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted August 27, 2012 Report Posted August 27, 2012 I think that's what Beech is referring to. I was just trying to understand what hhh was saying. Quote
JayWC Posted August 27, 2012 Report Posted August 27, 2012 I was just trying to understand what hhh was saying. I understand and apologize if I put words in your mouth. Quote
rmac Posted August 27, 2012 Report Posted August 27, 2012 I've got a 7518 and I understand what hhh is saying. 1. Loosen the nut with the wrench. It will seem to turn freely, but the bit won't come out. 2. Continue to turn the nut counterclockwise. After a revolution or two, you will feel some resistance. 3. Keep turning counterclockwise. When the nut turns freely again, the bit should come out. Sometimes I find that it heps to push the bit INTO the collet a little ways at this point to help loosen it up. -- Russ Quote
Trip Posted August 27, 2012 Report Posted August 27, 2012 russ, you've got it. ive got 8 PC routers and they all work that way. All my FTs work the same way. I like the article on collets -- everything you didn't want to know.... Quote
Dave H Posted August 28, 2012 Report Posted August 28, 2012 On my Porter Cable router I loosen the nut, if the bit is stuck I tap the collet nut with the wrench just a light tap the bit slips out every time. Quote
Dave's Not Here Posted August 28, 2012 Report Posted August 28, 2012 I don't know if this will work for you or not but it works for me. When I load the bit into the collect, I push the bit in until it bottoms out then I pull it back out just a tiny little bit then tighten the collet. Not sure why or if this helps but I very rarely have any trouble getting a router bit to release from the collet. Quote
Trip Posted August 28, 2012 Report Posted August 28, 2012 ==> Not sure why or if this helps shaft/bit metal-on-metal slippage/movement/vibration. you shouldn't mount a bit 'bottomed-out'. Quote
Boatworks Today Posted August 28, 2012 Report Posted August 28, 2012 I've got a 7518 and I understand what hhh is saying. 1. Loosen the nut with the wrench. It will seem to turn freely, but the bit won't come out. 2. Continue to turn the nut counterclockwise. After a revolution or two, you will feel some resistance. 3. Keep turning counterclockwise. When the nut turns freely again, the bit should come out. Sometimes I find that it heps to push the bit INTO the collet a little ways at this point to help loosen it up. -- Russ All my PC routers are like this. There seems to be a double compression around the bits. Keep loosening past the 2nd 'resistance' and the bits should pull right out.. Quote
ScoFF Posted August 29, 2012 Author Report Posted August 29, 2012 I tried again, I loosened it to the point where it almost comes off (the collet) but it's still snug (this is a brand new router and collet, I haven't used it yet). It's fine though, it comes out if I tug on it a bit. Maybe it'll cooperate over time. I did try pushing it in and then pulling it out so it broke free of it's resistance and that helped. I don't really like tugging on a sharp with with my finger though, no cuts yet. Quote
TRBaker Posted August 29, 2012 Report Posted August 29, 2012 Bob, I've had a PC router for the last thirty years and getting the bits out of the collets has always been hard. There have been times when I had to tap it with a hammer to get it loose. My Bosch is no problem at all, but every PC I've ever owned had the same collet problem. Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted August 29, 2012 Report Posted August 29, 2012 I've heard that it helps if you remove the bit when you are done working. I have a tendency to leave the last bit I used in the router, and I've been told that can lead to trouble when it's time to remove the bit. Quote
Trip Posted August 29, 2012 Report Posted August 29, 2012 ==> every PC I've ever owned had the same collet problem i'm not convinced it's a problem. I have about a dozen routers from PC and FT -- all behave identically. I think there are several basic designs to collets with pros/cons around each. Maybe PC and FT have gone one way and Bosch has gone another... ==> I have a tendency to leave the last bit I used in the route +1.. that's why i have so many routers. I basically have them setup for certain operations and leave them alone until the bit needs sharpening. I use quick-change collets in my router table because it's one of the few routers that i change frequently. Quote
ScoFF Posted August 29, 2012 Author Report Posted August 29, 2012 I'm not liking the two wrench thing, how hard would it be for them to stick in a collet lock mechanism? Quote
Boatworks Today Posted August 29, 2012 Report Posted August 29, 2012 I'm not liking the two wrench thing, how hard would it be for them to stick in a collet lock mechanism? I agree. Finally it dawned on me that it's much easier to completly remove the base (it twists right off) for getting access with the wrenches :-) Still need to use 2 wrenches but at least now I'm not trying to fit them through the little slots between the collet and base.. Also, I'm curious if the bits you're using are the same brand (part of a set)? It may be an outside possibility that the shafts of the bits are slightly oversized? Would be interested to see if a different brand bit is as tight as the ones you've been using... One last thing I can think of is maybe the collets have been over tightened? That could damage the insert to the point where it can't relax and open up enough to properly remove the bits? They should be tight, but don't necessarily have to really crank on them. Just a thought :-) Quote
TRBaker Posted August 29, 2012 Report Posted August 29, 2012 Boat, you may have a point there. Early on in my career I had bits that "migrated" downward as I routed long runs of profiles. This resulted in a piece of trim that was one size on one end and another size on the other. Not good. I solved this problem by making sure that I always "bear down on it" when I tighten the bit in the collet. I'll try to ease off a little on the trigger. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.