Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Tenoning Jig Shop built vs. Store Bought

Featured Replies

Hi, I'm new to the forum and have question I could use some help on. I'm a relatively new woodworker and I'm getting ready to embark on a couple of project that I'm going to use bridle joints on. From doing research etc. I've settle on using the table saw and a tenoning jig. However I'm pretty split on whether to build one that rides the fence (slight pun intended) or just break down and buy one. I know of a decent used Delta jig at a local used tool store for about $60. I guess I'm really debating whether or not that money could be going to other things I need for the shop, while on the other side sometimes it seems like I've started a jig making factory and never get to my actual projects. Any input would be great.

I'm relatively new as well, but I would buy the delta. I tried to build one from plans and it's tough to get it level and square to the fence with no play in it. $60.00 is not a bad price used. I bought a craftsman jig reduced and wish I had spent the extra for a delta.

I cut most of my tenons flat, in a dado sled, as I have a 92" basement ceiling. Keep that in mind for your workspace.

That said, in other shops, I've used both store bought and shop-made fence riding versions, and I'm sticking with the shop-made version. Every purchased version I've seen still required fettling, and possibly added backer boards. In a similar amount of time, you could have whipped up the shop-made version. The micro adjust looks cool, but is often not more precise than a hammer tap.

Keep in mind, unless you're a factory, most of the identical tenons you cut will be in relatively small numbers. It's pretty easy to adjust a tenon during dry fit, with a shoulder plane, router plane, rasp, float, sanding block, etc... and often faster than futzing with a jig to get a jig exactly right directly from the saw.

I guess it depends on your tool budget and your likes and dislikes. A home made tenon jig is simple, quick and accurate. A store bought isn't too expensive and is adjustable with multiple uses. I prefer the store bought.

post-206-0-20750300-1352510733_thumb.jpg

post-206-0-84373100-1352510750_thumb.jpg

I've never had a store bought tenoning jig only a home made one once you make one you can adapt it to many tasks, tenons, raised panels, spline joints, only your imagination is your limit. You can add toggle clamps to secure your work to the jig, and the good thing is you can make it out of scrap plywood a little wax and it will slide nice and easy on your fence. Here is a link http://www.highlandwoodworking.com/tablesawtenonjig.aspx

I have the Delta, it works pretty good. You have to extremely accurate if you built a shop made one. The older Delta/ Rockwell tenon jigs were amazing huge heavy cast iron and I wish I could find one today.

One more thing...

If you're considering a jig because you want to cut a lot of tenons, consider a dual blade setup.

To do this, you "marry" a pair of rip blades, and space them with an MDF spacer and dado shims. If you start with 1/4" MDF, you'll have to shim it out to exactly 1/4", as the teeth overhang the saw plate. Once you find the combo that exactly matches your mortise machine chisel or router bit, write the spacer info down, and the mortise cutter it matches. I know a school owner who went as far as having a steel spacer machined for each of his chisels to match a specific blade pair. Dado blades can also be used, but they only extend far enough from the table for short tenons.

Cut a zero clearance insert to match each setup. I use reversable ZCI's for tenon and dado setups, so I can put two setups on each insert.

The beauty of this is instant repeatability, and the tenon thickness is not dependent on exact stock thickness. All you need to do is center the tenon on the particular stock.

I do this when I can, but my ceiling limits the length of parts where I can use the technique.

  • Author

I appreciate everyone's input. I think maybe I wasn't completely clear though. I'm really more concerned with clearing out the bridle part, not the tenon as much. I would probably use it for some tenons too, but I have some vertical space limitations and using a dado makes me feel more Normlike.

I have a generic tenoning jig the kind that you can find everywhere for tenoning with a table saw. Rockler make them and countless others all to similar designs and they are great to a point.

However I recently stumbled across www.workshopessentials.com and the host Steve Maskery designs all manner of jigs and fixtures for woodworking. He sells them in fully detailed video format to build in your shop on DVD with the plans included in either PDF or both PDF and Sketchup formats. I bought the entire set of 10 DVDs although he sells them individually in all regional formats.

His DVD#3 has the Ultimate Table Saw Tenon Jig in it. He shows you how to make it and use it. If you do lots of, or even a few, tenon cutting this jig really is the business. It'll probably cost you less to make than a commercial one as it is made from MDF.

The difference with Steve's jig and a commercial one is that Steve's is accurate and repeatable and cuts both sides of the tenon with just a spacer even if you don't need a centralized tenon. It will also do double tenons again with just a pair of spacers. It takes the kerf of the blade into consideration and it rides on the rip fence of the table saw.

A commercial one will cut accurately but takes a lot of setting up. If you need to cut non centralized ones you have backlash of the adjustment screw to take into consideration and you end up batching out cuts on one side, adjusting the jig and batching out the other side. If you forget to make one (making 7 instead of 8 for instance!) it's difficult to get back to the initial setup. Steve's jig does not have this limitation/irritation.

I have to say it blew me away when I saw it as it was really well designed. I am in no way associated with Steve but I think everybody needs to look at this. He has a few taster videos on YouTube but head over to his website for a look.

  • Author

I have a piece of scrap MDF sitting on the rack so I think I'm going to take a shot at making one myself and see how it works, worst case I have to go buy one, best case I save a few bucks. Probably really won't save it because it seems like every projects brings with it need for a new tool : ) Thanks for everyones help.

I got a mint powermatic T-Jig from eBay -- they come-up about every month. I paid $60 and it is by far and away more useful that what I could whip-up in the shop in an afternoon. It just comes down to time -- do you want to spend time building jigs or furniture? For $60, I'd rather spend the time on furniture.

I also have the Delta (older version). I bought it on kijiji for 35 bucks. It works great, and is very solid/heavy.

That being said, I prefer to cut my tenons flat with a dado blade when possible. It just seems less "finicky" to me to cut them flat. Then I clean them up with a shoulder plane before doing a dry fit. Avoid cutting tenons with a single blade. It takes FOREVER and the results are less than stellar, in my experience. It's worth the extra 2 minutes to change to a dado stack.

There is a technique that was posted a while ago called "the speed tenon". It's controversial (potentially dangerous), but worth a look. Just type it in the search box here, ot head on over the FWW.com.

Barry offers some good advice (as always!). Using a dual blade set up will be a very fast way to cut a ziliion tenons if your project requires them.

I built my own from plans I bought from Woodgears.ca. Spent $21 on the needed parts and the plans.

post-202-0-16350100-1352591988_thumb.jpgpost-202-0-84313700-1352591995_thumb.jpgpost-202-0-54077000-1352591999_thumb.jpg

I second this jig. Matthias makes some amazing stuff in the shop.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.