Nick2cd Posted November 29, 2012 Report Posted November 29, 2012 I know I'm posting a question about a power tool in the hand tool section, but I thought it was appropriate since the power tool is used to sharpen hand tools. Anyways, does or has anyone use a work sharp for chisels and planes? Does it overheat them? Does it provide a good edge? Quote
Dave H Posted November 29, 2012 Report Posted November 29, 2012 I have a Work Sharp, I really like it, it's never heated a chisle enough to lose the temper, but yes it heats them up. I think it's a good system, and fast. 1 Quote
Jfitz Posted November 29, 2012 Report Posted November 29, 2012 Although I use waterstones or scary sharp for maintenance and final sharpening, I do use the Worksharp as part of the 'preparation' of irons and chisels, to either flatten the back or do the bulk of the work on the bevel if a lot of material needs to be removed (e.g. from a chip). Even though I use it infrequently, I like it. Quote
dodgeram99 Posted December 2, 2012 Report Posted December 2, 2012 I use mine for all sharpening. It is fast and make all blades supper sharp. I would recommend it fir the smallest of chisels. 1/8. It can roundiver the edge ir the back. This sounds silly. But I times how long it took a new chisel. To super sharp. Only 7 minutes. I should have bout it years ago. Quote
Mike M Posted December 2, 2012 Report Posted December 2, 2012 I've been using mine for chisels and carving tools. Does a great job and is fast. I got some 1500 grid PSA paper from Klingspoor and use it for the last pass to get a razor sharp too. Quote
TDog77 Posted December 7, 2012 Report Posted December 7, 2012 i agree with most of the above posts, I too use it for some chisels specifically my mortise chisels that I don't need that hand made razors edge on plus I can do a QUICK touchup in the middle of the project. I also really liked it in assisting me it getting things "flatter" first and then moving over to the Shaptpton stones. Regarding the heating issue the smaller width chisels do tend to get a little toasty pretty quick but I alternate them in and out of the chest freezer which happens to be my sharpening table as well (oh my tiny shop woes) and it does help. It is a nice tool to have that can save some time but I DO NOT consider it a replacement to my water stones because with those and my MK II veritas guide I can make things wicked sharp. Would I get one again...you bet. Quote
rroselavy Posted December 14, 2012 Report Posted December 14, 2012 I bought a Worksharp 3000 early on, and then moved onto waterstones with a honing guide, and recently onto a modified version of Paul Seller's method which includes freehanding on a combination of diamond plates and then stropping on leather (or in my case an 8000 grit waterstone). I personally will not use the Worksharp again to flatten or polish the backs of any chisel or plane iron. I feel it is not really well suited for that purpose, and the abrasive disks get consumed too quickly if used for flattening. The wheel really grabs on the leading side even when carefully "laying down" the back. My attempts were typically dubbed on one side of the chisel due to the grabbing. I was also not fond of the way the wheel can only polish the first inch or two of the back along an arc. I prefer to have the entire chisel back flat, and polish at least the first inch or two if not more. I find that I can flatten more safely and evenly using 3"x8" strip of 80-120 grit paper laid wet on top of a duo-sharp plate or other flat surface. Perhaps this just reflects my inexperience with the Worksharp more than anything else. As far as bevels are concerned, the Worksharp works well enough, but I found that the sharpening port can put scratches on the back of my polished back if I used the self-adhesive abrasive they supply for relieving the burr. I took out the insert and just use it against the bare aluminum, and tried to make sure any metal dust does not settle on the bed of the port where it can also scratch the polished back. Because of this, removing the burr required an additional step for me. I also have the wide blade jig and optional table for wider plane blades. I found that wide jig to work pretty well, but had a hard time finding an effective method for introducing any camber to plane irons while using that jig. I also have the leather strop disk (got that on super sale one year). Seems to work well, but I have not yet embraced "power" stropping for fear of dubbing over edges. I will have to try again with the lightest of touch... In conclusion, I can see someone using the Worksharp effectively for bevel work, either to correct geometry or polish a microbevel.However, I do not think it is the proper tool for flattening or polishing backs. 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.