dodgeram99 Posted December 7, 2012 Report Posted December 7, 2012 I am looking at a new hand plane. I am also not sure what brand to go with. Ie verities Stanley sweetheart etc. I have the Stanley sweetheart low angle block plane. Since the really good ones cost so much. And can't afford a hole set a t one time. Any suggestions? Quote
aengland Posted December 7, 2012 Report Posted December 7, 2012 What do you already have? What tools are your current project(s) needing? Quote
jbs550 Posted December 7, 2012 Report Posted December 7, 2012 i love all my veritas planes, but I have some old stanley's that came from my grandfather / garage sales that I tuned up that work great. depends on what you need and how much you are actually willing to spend. still haven't sprung for a LN yet... Quote
rodger. Posted December 8, 2012 Report Posted December 8, 2012 I am very happy with the veritas handplanes I own. I would make sure that you stay away from low quality brands, as they will most likely frustrate you. What size plane are you interested in? A good first hand plane is a verits #5 bevel up jack plane. Quote
dodgeram99 Posted December 8, 2012 Author Report Posted December 8, 2012 The only good plane I have is the block plane. I did pick up a very old #7 #5. But after I figured in new parts they would almost be just as much as a new one. Quote
dodgeram99 Posted December 8, 2012 Author Report Posted December 8, 2012 A far off project is a walnut TV stand. The case work is 3/4 in walnut plywood. But I want to put a real walnut top on it. I can't use my 6 in jointed. So what plane would be best for flattening a 12 wide board? Has any one used the wood river brand? Quote
mkirby Posted December 8, 2012 Report Posted December 8, 2012 I have a quensheng (woodriver in the states) jack plane and it is a really good plane. It could easily handle all you want to do and is a lot cheeper than veritas, clifton etc. They don't have all the bells and whistles but they are good quality planes, if you have a bit of money left over you might consider upgrading the blade but i haven't felt the need to yet. Quote
aengland Posted December 8, 2012 Report Posted December 8, 2012 IMO, your options should be directed by your (1) needs and (2) preferences. A quality block plane is a great start. First, I'm not convinced of only one right way in the hunt for handplanes. Second, needs can be altered by what works best for you. Third, buy quality--buy once, so buy right the first time. Fourth, vintage planes (MF, Sargent, Stanley) work just as well (once tuned) as LV, LN, WR, and Clifton. In my experience, only a LN or LV work well right out of box (but, that's limited by experiences). It's taken me several years to arrive at nearly the same performance via my vintage planes. Now, shorter planes make better finishing planes (smoothers) and longer planes make better jointers and produce a better, squared surface (that still needs smoothing at times). That means the #5 (Jack) is perhaps the best all-round plane.When sharp, it can smooth; and, it's just long enough (barely) to joint. For jointing, the #6, 7, or 8 are much better, with extra length and weight providing potential benefits at each step up. The #2,3,4 planes are smoothers. I like 4s a tad better but sometimes in narly grain, the narrower #3 performs better. In the end, the blade quality and bevel degree makes the genuine difference. I have multiples of some planes for use as coarse, medium, and fine users. For finishing, I'm using the "fine" planes. Those have blades that I've sharpened in excess of 6,000 grit. Medium planes get sharpened to 3-6k; coarse, to about 1200. Each range fulfills a different task in the surfacing process. With a #7, you could by-pass the 5 and 6 and 8 and get a 3 or 4 or 4 /12 to serve as a smoother. Or not! Whatever works for you is what best fits you! Enjoy. Quote
dodgeram99 Posted December 8, 2012 Author Report Posted December 8, 2012 Thank for all the great info. A few more questions. What is a scrub plane for? Is a smoothing plane a general use plane? Should I go low angle? Will this prevent me from having to bye two planes? I dont do a lot of hand planing. So would the woodriver be a good bye Quote
aengland Posted December 8, 2012 Report Posted December 8, 2012 Thank for all the great info. A few more questions. What is a scrub plane for? Is a smoothing plane a general use plane? Should I go low angle? Will this prevent me from having to bye two planes? I dont do a lot of hand planing. So would the woodriver be a good bye Coming off my chainsaw, the scrub plane is essential for quickly dressing the grain. I also use it when I've got more than 1/8 of stock removal for surfacing or jointing. The Jack plane (#5) is really the general use plane but a 4 still does alot. I've just bought my first low angle (LN) this year, after six years of hobby activity. It's good but not game changer. Sharpening has been the game changer!!!! Uh, needing to buy--what's that?! I buy planes because I want it (okay, yes, I might need it,too). Chris G has a WR#6, loves it, and gets great results out of it. The quality control appears to be quite good. You should have little problems with them. I still spend my money on the LN and LV first! And, I have yet to be disappointed. Quote
RJsumthn Posted December 9, 2012 Report Posted December 9, 2012 From what I have researched, the woodriver planes are good but take more tuning up than the LN or LV. If time is money then get the better get a LN or LV. But if you want to save a few bucks and spend a little more time tuning then the woodriver will be fine. But when they are all tuned up correctly there is very little difference, if any, in the results. Quote
nateswoodworks Posted December 10, 2012 Report Posted December 10, 2012 I Have a Woodriver #5 and I love it.. Upon on boxing it took me maybe five minutes to hone the iron, a couple minutes to clean the packing oil off, a couple minutes of drooling and I was in business. Most of my planes are pre WW2 Stanley's with Hock irons a i have couple beloved Bedrocks but my WR is my favorite (not to mention cheaper than the Bedrocks) Smooth adjustments and tight tolerances make it a very nice plane. In case you don't know Rob Cosman, who was Lie Nielsens Canadian rep is the one who worked with Woodriver when designing the last version of their planes. He is a huge fan and states that they are every bit as good as the L.N., i think you still get a free month to his online membership when you buy a WR plane but double check first. Just thought you may want to know. Quote
dodgeram99 Posted December 11, 2012 Author Report Posted December 11, 2012 After a few days of looking at all the pros and coins of hand planes I went with the LV #5. I think it will serve my need the best. I think I'll get a LV plane each month tell I have a set that I can do any job. Thanks every one for the great advice. 1 Quote
rodger. Posted December 11, 2012 Report Posted December 11, 2012 After a few days of looking at all the pros and coins of hand planes I went with the LV #5. I think it will serve my need the best. I think I'll get a LV plane each month tell I have a set that I can do any job. Thanks every one for the great advice. Sweet plane. You won't regret it. Now, make sure you take care of it. My #5 took a dive off of my bench a few weeks ago (my own carelessness). Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.