Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Big issue with maple table top

Featured Replies

Good day,

Question.... I've just finished a new table top, 56 inch long by 40 inch wide. It's maple. Now when I glued it up, it was nice and flat... I made sure of that.

Now what I did, was put a coat of water based finish on the bottom (only one coat) and then flipped the table top over and put a total of 4 coats of finish on... now the entire table has cupped... and alot!!! If I put on a strait edge, it's about 3/4 of an inch off.... am I ever happy!!!!

My question is... is it because of the uneven amount of finish I put on... (I'm thinking maybe the wood absorbed enough finish to cause the cup), and my other question is... if I flip the table and put 3 coats on the bottom will this fix it?

Thanks..

D

Unfortunatley more finish now won't fix it. The cupping is normally because of uneven drying, which has already taken place.

Theoretically you could strip off all the finish, soak the wood and try to push it flat again.

Did you use an dowel or biscuits between the planks (I am assuming it isn't one board wide)? Depending on the flex in the wood, you could also compress it flat and shoot some dowels through to try and hold it flat. This is pretty risky though (wood could crack), depending on the flex in the wood. It also won't fix it 100%, but should bring you down to 1/8 - 1/4 bow.

Was the lumber dried? Did you use any kind of sealer before finishing? I like to use a sanding sealer to try to stabalize the wood before applying a finish. I have had several pieces bow on me during finish. Unfortunatley there isn't a good way (that I know of) to hold the work flat while the finish dries without damaging the finish, so a sealer is typically the best bet because it doesn't need to look good. You can just lay scraps across the top to hold it flat while it dries.

How long has the finish been on the table top (days)? Hand applied or sprayed? Yes I would probably hit the bottom with another coat to seal it a little better.

Sounds to me the top is still wet and need's to flash off. Your wood should move back to its original position, or pretty close. Was the wood kiln dried or air dried?

-Ace-

What is the table frame like? Strong aprons and plenty of figure eight fasteners will help pull it down flat. I always use balanced construction and finishing. If you laminate one side , then do the other. Same with finish coats. Back side doesn't have to be stained nice unless it shows.

I start on the back, spray it and flip it, then do the top and let it dry. Sand between coats and repeat. I use painters pyramids and a few tiny marks in the wet bottom finish do not bother me.

==> now the entire table has cupped... and alot!!!

3/4" over 40" top is not going to be fixed with finish alone... There is no getting around that... Sorry... You are headed towards a structural solution...

As observed previously, this is most probably due to insufficient drying prior to purchase, insufficient acclimatization to your shop or incorrect milling/glue-up workflow.

How thick is the top? If thin enough, you may be able to 'bend' it back in place with the base -- but that is really treating the symptom, not curing the underlying disease... But hay, it works... Of course, you could crack the top, base and/or both... :)

To help with a solution that works now (and will also be effective in the summer months of high-humidity), let's get a little more data...

If the stock is from a box store, air-dried, from 'a friend' or some other (or multiple) sources, then we need to look at the stock itself for answers (think moisture meter)... If the stock was all purchased at the same time from a hardwood dealer, then it's [probably] the same species of 'maple' and kiln dried to the same level - so we need to look at your workflow...

How long did you let the stock acclimatize to your shop prior to milling? Did you mill it all at one, or in stages? How long after milling until glue-up? How long after glue-up until you finished?

How thick is the top? How this was the starting material? If you have to rip it back down and re-glue it, how much thickness could you stand to loose?

  • Author

I bought the lumber from a hardwood dealer... kiln dried...

I rough cut the lumber... it sat for about a week... milled it to final dimension and it sat for two weeks... then I milled it again and glued up the following day... I was completing the frame in between...

The table sat for 48 hours before I put the first coat of finish on the underside... but it was flat when the first coat went on... I let it sit for 3 hours and flipped the table top and put the first coat on the top side... The next night I put two coats on the top...and the following night (Tues night) I put another coat on... I noticed some cupping after the 2nd/3rd coats but it wasn't anything to be concerned about because I thought the fig 8 fasteners would bring it true.... but after the 4th...when I checked this morning it was way off... First two coats were put on with a foam brush, the second two with an earlex

Thickness is about 7/8th... I have about 8 fig 8 already installed on my frame... now my thought is to clamp the top to the frame (after I hit the bottom with a few coats of finish) and just drive some screws in to bring it true... but again, not sure if I want the top to be under that kind of stress... I really...really don't want to lose any thickness

Thanks!!!

D

Tables can be a pain this time of year and you have to be real careful about how you stack your lumber. Usully the procedure you mentioned is fine but not in the winter unless your working in a well heated house or shop. Strip the finish off the top on both sides. Set it on your frame/leg set with a pile of bricks and just let it set preferably in a warm house or well heated shop. It migh take a day a week or it may not work at all.

Don

You could try clamping it to your frame with a 1/8 strip under the center to let you over bend it in the opposite direction. Use thick cauls to spread the clamping pressure and go slow! Tighten partway, wait a few minutes then give it another 1/2 turn. If you get it all the way down without cracking it leave it 24 hours and see if it springs back close to flat.

You could rip the top into 3 sections and re-join it, but that means refinishing as well.

I sand and wax the top of my frame before screwing the top to the figure eights so it won't stick when it expands and contracts.

your workflow is solid... Maybe a few points...

I would have let the stock acclimatize for 2 weeks prior to initial milling if your shop is in a climate-controlled space... In the summer (high humidity at the hardwood dealer), I let it sit for a month in my climate-controlled shop prior to milling... I assume you started with 5/4 to get to a finished 7/8? If you started with 6/4 or thicker, then you should mill in two or three stages over a couple of days... I try not to remove more then 1/4 - 3/8" stock on any given day.... I would also mill alternating sides to try to remove an even amount of stock from each face...

I forgot to ask, is your finish area the same as shop area in terms of climate control? Some folks mill/assemble in a climate controlled space and finish outside -- this can be a big mistake in the summer/winter -- spring/early fall is not so bad...

One thing I would change -- I usually spray a quick 1/2lb cut super blonde on all surfaces just to seal everything up. On thirsty wood, I spray two coats... You can lay down both in an hour.... The other nice thing is it's a barrier for subsequent schedule steps from stray finger-print oils, tool oils, shop grime, etc...

Based on your description, the stock should have been is fine (RH and all from the same species) and your workflow solid...

I think you should strip everything and see if it flattens out using some of the techniques in these forums -- pressure/humidity tarp/applied heat/etc. Most of the techniques take about a week -- go slow to avoid cracking -- 3/4" is a lot to pull-out quickly... I think there was a good thread on flattening a butcher block-top table a couple of weeks ago.

If you get close (say within 1/8 - 3/16)... Find a local cabinet shop.. They will run it through a wide belt for a small donation to the sanding belt fund... Before I got my wide belt, I had to resort to that a few times... It's amazing how much ass-saving can be had for $25...

If that doesn't do it, then it's time to rip/re-joint/re-glue....

I'm not offering a solution to your problem, but I am curious about the cause. How you mill your stock can play a big part in how your lumber reacts. My guess is that the stresses were there before you applied the finish and the water based finish was the catalyst that put them in motion.

Check out this test Rob Bois did regarding this subject:

http://theboisshop.blogspot.com/2010/08/flat-truth-about-milling-stock.html?m=1

Make sure you read the comments as well.

I'm curious to hear your thoughts.

I'm not offering a solution to your problem, but I am curious about the cause. How you mill your stock can play a big part in how your lumber reacts. My guess is that the stresses were there before you applied the finish and the water based finish was the catalyst that put them in motion.

Check out this test Rob Bois did regarding this subject:

http://theboisshop.blogspot.com/2010/08/flat-truth-about-milling-stock.html?m=1

I'm curious to hear your thoughts.

Sort of. The answer is a real simple one word answer. Moisture

NEVER trust "kiln dried material, get a moisture meter with a deep probe like a slide hammer probe, take it to the lumber yard.

Don

I'm also curious...is it cupped like a smiley face or a frown? And did you ever lay it flat on another surface without elevating it with stickers or pyramids or something that would prevent even airflow?

If you lay a raw board on another flat surface, it will want to cup smiley face, since the top will dry faster than the bottom. If your top is cupped smiley face and you never laid it flat on another surface, then the extra coats of finish on the top wouldn't have anything to do with it...you'd know it was the moisture in the lumber itself, since adding moisture to the top of the table should cause it to cup in the opposite direction. If it's cupped like a frown, then the finish is a possible cause. Just trying to eliminate some variables...

  • Author

It's cupped frown... air flow wouldn't have been an issue...

Only think I can think of is that the finish absorbed into the wood...and there was too much on the top vs the bottom and therefore the top surface expanded as it drew in the finish... therefore, a cupped frown!!!

I think it's to uniform of a cup to be the material... if the stresses were already in the boards (I would think I would have milled most of them out), I don't think it would look as consistant (in terms of the arc)...

Thank you all for your interest and suggestions...

Only think I can think of is that the finish absorbed into the wood...and there was too much on the top vs the bottom and therefore the top surface expanded as it drew in the finish

That'd be my guess too then. Just one more reason not to use waterbased finishes. :)

You did not induce warping with the moisture in the finish unless you used a garden hose to apply it. Your wood was not at equilibrium for your relative humidity. You skewed the process by adding a barrier to the top.

Is this a heated insulated shop with consistent temps?

Did you turn up the heat to finish?

Don

My best guess would be the wood was not dry which I'm guessing is air dried. Only a guess. These guys have given you some good suggestions to try and salvage your top. I have know idea how you've glued up your top, but alternating the pattern of the wood can help the chances of cupping.

If your lumber recovers a bit, you could try sanding down the finish as much as possible. Then moistening the cupped surface with water to see if it will expand to flatten the board. This is probably my absolute last resort to salvage a glue up.

chris

  • Author

Well.... desperate times call for desperate measures... I just flipped the top... and laid down a "thicker then normal" coat of finish... I'll post the results tomorrow

  • Author

Would you believe me if I told you it's working... I kid you not!!! and only 30 mins after I put it on....cup has been reduced (and I should have measured) to about half...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.