Recommended Posts

Posted

these are two things i have very little experience with...   i recently purchased a #4 and i can't, for the life of me, get it to make clean cuts...   it just skips and gouges along the way...    any pointers?   know what i might be doing wrong?  its a stanley plane..  not a sweetheart but decently priced..  blade is very sharp...  

 

as for the scraper..  i cant seem to get it to hold a burred edge...   how long should it hold one?     ill make maybe 15-20  15" passes and it seems to lose its edge...   

 

thanks in advance for your help

Posted

Tony make sure you have the blade adjusted right and the frog if thats adjustable .  Try taking lighter cuts with , have you done anything to the blade like flattening the back or sharpening it ? 

Posted

Marc has a great video. On card scrapers. And there is another at fine tool.com on how to use one. It took me almost two years to figure out how to use one. Once it clicked. They are a great tool. Also Very ad has a burnisher that works great.

Posted

I had an old timer show me how he used and prepared scrappers and it was amazing how misinformed I had been. Some of the things I discovered is people press much to hard when burnishing. Just the weigfht of the hand and a few swipes were all it took. In fact, when we were done, most of the time I couldn't even get the bur to catch on my skin or nail. And then the shavings coming off were pretty awesome, all I had seen before that time was crumbles. It lasted much longer than 15 swipes for me on red oak but I couldn't tell you exactly how many and when it started to feel dull I just moved over a few cm's. I ended up having to wear gloves as I was having such a blast and burning my thumbs up from scraping.

Posted

I had an old timer show me how he used and prepared scrappers and it was amazing how misinformed I had been. Some of the things I discovered is people press much to hard when burnishing. Just the weigfht of the hand and a few swipes were all it took. In fact, when we were done, most of the time I couldn't even get the bur to catch on my skin or nail. And then the shavings coming off were pretty awesome, all I had seen before that time was crumbles. It lasted much longer than 15 swipes for me on red oak but I couldn't tell you exactly how many and when it started to feel dull I just moved over a few cm's. I ended up having to wear gloves as I was having such a blast and burning my thumbs up from scraping.

thats cool... my uncle has a "good enough" mentality and insists that everyone on this website it overdoing everything...  when it comes to scrapers he says to "just use a metal file and you get just as good of shavings as William Ng" who has a process for sharpening...   i insist he is wrong but noone could ever convince him of that...   but i do appreciate everyones help on here, i really do...   glad to see the purist are still out there...

Posted

thats cool... my uncle has a "good enough" mentality and insists that everyone on this website it overdoing everything...  when it comes to scrapers he says to "just use a metal file and you get just as good of shavings as William Ng" who has a process for sharpening...   i insist he is wrong but noone could ever convince him of that...   but i do appreciate everyones help on here, i really do...   glad to see the purist are still out there...

Tony, Your Uncle is mostly right in my experience.  By just using a bastard file, you can create a very functional edge.  I would say, if you're planning on sanding a bit in addition, this is a great way to go.  I think if you want to get a surface finish ready only with scrapers, you'll want a few that have a higher polish and a very small, or short, hook.  If the hook is too drawn out, it is fragile and soon breaks.  Be sure to get a good burnisher.  If its too soft and catches,  you wont produce a really clean hook.   Watch the William Ng video already referenced for the stone method and this clip from Todd Clippinger for the down and dirty method.     http://blip.tv/american-craftsman-workshop/the-american-craftsman-workshop-sharpening-cabinet-scrapers-episode-1-1629380

  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.