idratherplaytennis Posted February 20, 2013 Report Posted February 20, 2013 Hey, I have a quick couple questions and am under a time restraint so I felt the quickest way to the solution is to ask you guys for opinions off the top of your heads, and while I wait for responses- to go ahead and continue my research on my own. Quick intro- first time poster, been following the WW for quite awhile. Not so new to the profession as I grew up (27 now) for the better half of my last 20 years working around/for/with my dad in his garage on apartment rental property we own and developed a bug for liking woodwork. Went to school for architecture and so I have the design thing as well as the construction thing down pretty well, but in terms of working on fine wood work in a shop- I am relatively green. We have a 90's unisaw (in need of minor tuning) in our garage and a decent selection of other tools that have been pertinent to our jobs on fixing up the apartment property (all 40-50+ year old buildings so plenty of knowledge and work has gone into them). I have built a few things, my desk (nearly 8' wide, with custom shelving and such for computer and movie holding options etc, curved indent to maximize arm reaching space where you sit and all that jazz) being the primary, and that's a rough idea of where I stand. Love this site too- lots of useful knowledge, hoping the forum is as nice and helpful/friendly. We are rapidly getting started on renovating two units (which we have already gutted 1 fully, another partially) to get rented as soon as possible and I've decided to really focus my craft on learning cabinetry and will be making paint-grade cabinets for the fully gutted apartment. The issue is we've always run into hassles with plywood doors ( I know, BIG Nono, but I was limited to my tools around me at the very few times we've replaced one or two) and I am looking into building good, solid- built to last hardwood doors, which no matter what style I choose means we are in desperate need of a quality planer and jointer which we don't have. Not to mention in the last 10 years they would have been worth their weight in gold for various projects of ours. Question is this- I have done moderate reading on jointers and planers, the brands, sizes etc, but I really don't know as much as you guys in a collective would. I know we want something in the 8"+ range, as I plan to get more involved with desk and other large-scale furniture making (cabinets, tables etc) which will require the use of said planers and jointers. I also know that ideally we need to eventually invest in a drum sander as well but I'm working on going as we go and in the meantime, belt sanders and 1/2 pad sanders will work fine for our immediate needs. I've heard of several brands... Jet, Grizzly, Delta, Powermatic, Steel City, and seen many of the WW's videos of his equipment and the shows he's gone to, but what I don't know is what would work well. We don't want to break the bank but we also are of the mindset to buy the best we can. That being said- we also are going to be purchasing a lot of material for the apartments through the Home Depot bidroom as we have 2500+ in purchasing to make (by gutted, I mean we are redoing everything- electrical, plumbing, drywall, etc..), and they offer a few selections of jointers (I haven't looked at the planers yet) mostly from Steel City with a Jet JJP-12 Jointer/Planer combo (without helical cutters, but one is available on amazon- however I don't know much about the cutters either way, whats best etc) so I was wondering of anyone's opinions on the above. I tried a few quick searches but got mixed results, probably because I used the wrong nomenclature in the search. We are looking for ones that will sit permanently in our home shop (4 car garage that we will have the space for them in) and basically the middle to high-road but more like the Audi's of the planers and jointers than the Ferrari and Lambo versions- if that makes sense? I read a few reviews of the Jet dual which sounds interesting but am unsure of if the cutter head can be replaced with a helical or other type of cutter (still plenty to learn) and if a combo unit is better than a job-specific (jointer-only/planer-only) setup. I do know of cases where all-in-one is not as great as specific tools. I will keep looking but I just wondered if someone could provide insight to current brands they recommend, models and what not- at least that I can look into, reviews and all that. I'm doing this in the middle of various jobs I'm supervising so the time I have to actually sit and search is limited but we are looking to buy in a few days to week's time so that after shipping/assembly we can have the time to get a move on setting everything up to work out well. Gotta go for now. Any more questions I was too vague on about what I want to do, please feel free to ask. Otherwise- thanks for your time. Quote
Eric. Posted February 20, 2013 Report Posted February 20, 2013 Get ready for a bunch of different opinions. The conventional wisdom is that the combo machines are good if it's all you can afford or you're very space constrained. Otherwise, they offer no real benefits. Try to get individual machines if you can. What's your budget? Quote
dwacker Posted February 20, 2013 Report Posted February 20, 2013 I'd stay away from combo machines unless you're going to look into Felder or Minimax. Felders start at $6900 and go up from there, way up. Personally I'd pick a decent 8" parallelogram jointer from Griz and maybe a dewalt lunch box. As for your cabinet doors, no plywood. I suggest Barker door until you got set up properly to make good doors. You can get a bigger heavier planer but you're not going to see any real benefit unless you step up to a 20". The lunchbox planers are fine for most anyone and the 15"'s are not a big enough jump to make them overly worthwhile. Don Quote
mwatkins Posted February 20, 2013 Report Posted February 20, 2013 I have to disagree with the prior statements that the combo machines don't have any real benifits to offer or are less quality. I think the fact that for far less than the cost of stand alone pieces, you often can gain far greater stock capacities within your jointer. Another huge benifit is the ability to retain both pieces of machinery in a single foot print. Most guys only think of this in the means of where the equipment is currently sitting...but you also have to take into account the working space needed to feed/recieve stock in and out of it. So being able to cut that space in half is HUGE. Also the negativity around swapping between jointer to planer etc. is completly bogus and way "old school" thinking. Having grown up in a cabinet shop with stand alone pieces I was hesitant on buying a combo machine, but now that I have, I don't believe I'll be purchasing separates at anytime in the future. If you're in a true cabinet/furntiure shop that's always running in production mode with deadlines breathing down your neck then yes...the costs of stand alone are probably warranted. But in this case the advantages of being able to pick up a 10" or 12" jointer with spiral head cutter far, far out weight that extra 45 seconds that it takes to flip the jointer beds up or down. The $2500 bucks I spent on a Grizzly G0634XP is by far the best investment I've made in my shop, hands down. At this point I have easily run 3K feet of hardwood across it (in both directions so in reality more like 6K feet) and it has yet to flinch. And before anyone jumps in to poo poo the hardwood statement, I'm talking hard maple, walnut, cherry, bubinga, wenge, bocote, zebra, etc. and I have yet to make an adjustment to the beds, fence or carbide inserts. So my advice is that you can't go wrong with the G0634XP. But as with any tool purchase it's all personal...ultimately my point is that for whatever reason, we in the US are soooooo against combo machines for little to no reason other than the "2 is always better than 1" mentality. My recommendation is to put in a little leg work and get hands on. Find some local shops, guilds, hobbiests etc. and see if you can get a few minutes with the pieces they're using and find what you like and don't...and then make your decsion. Quote
stahlee Posted February 20, 2013 Report Posted February 20, 2013 Hey, I'm onboard with the combo machine all the way. I have both an 8" Grizzly jointer and a Grizzly G0634 with a spiral cutterhead and I rarely touch the 8" jointer. First, it's a solid machine and takes less than a minute to switch over. Second, with the spiral cutterhead will joint anything you throw at it without tear out and the carbide will last a very, very long time. It's a big deal if you plan to run a bunch of board feet through it. Some people will say they are concerned that the beds are shorter, but it has not ever been a problem for me. I'm not short of space in my shop, so the footprint is not an issue. I just like the idea of one machine to do both jobs and it does both very well. You're not selling yourself short by purchasing a combo. If you can foot the bill for the 16" version, I would do that in a heartbeat to get the 16" planer capability. Quote
TRBaker Posted February 21, 2013 Report Posted February 21, 2013 Welcome to the forum. I find myself thinking more along the lines of what Don recommended. Get an 8" Grizzly jointer and a Dewalt 735 planer and you will be able to do most of what you want to do. I don't know anything at all about combo machines so I can't be of help there. I've used an 8" jointer and 13" planer for thirty years and they've done the job for me. I have a cabinet shop and do custom trim work and stairs as well. If you decide you need a bigger planer, I'd go with a Grizzly or Powermatic 20". Quote
pghmyn Posted February 21, 2013 Report Posted February 21, 2013 I will be picking up my Grizzly G0656P 8" jointer tomorrow, and I will try to have it running Friday evening. When it comes time to cut wood on it, and you are still looking for a jointer, I will let you know how I like it Quote
idratherplaytennis Posted February 21, 2013 Author Report Posted February 21, 2013 Thanks for those replies so far, they've been helpful. On my phone at the moment so I'm going to keep this short...ish for now. My only hesitation in the dual machines for the most part was something along the lines of if I did want to run a fully laminated piece of cabinet door through the planer- but as I had read elsewhere, there's ways around it, plus depending on the sizes that I laminate together- there could be snipe issues, sometimes not. The other thing I wasn't sure about is the cutting head and the bed length. I think I remember as far as jointers go, the longer the better, or at least to match as closely as you can the size of your stock to it, which I think mainly would come into play if I were milling the face frame parts down to size. The counter argument to this being- if I properly clamp and glue and joint well, I may never even need to run through a 20" planer. As far as the cutting head- I know there's a lot of options that I'll try and look into tonight. There was some video I saw on fine woodworker or something that showed a grizzly with removable and rotatable carbide tip cutters which sounded like a good idea. Still going to look into those grizzly's mentioned here. As to the price limit- I don't really know if my dad has one for the most part- he likes to buy as good as he can but I'm trying my best to be conservative and go bang for the buck. It just needs to be good enough that it can be fixed via sanding if need be but it's not like our livelihoods depend on the machines- ours go through rent- I'm looking for something that is, however good enough in the future that if I want to get into some furniture making for personal use, that this will serve well. I like the added advantage of a full length jointer on the duals as well, however we do have a tendency to pack up our garages a lot so the dual planer/jointer might be the way to go, despite our space. The flip side (not to ignore those who think two is better, I haven't forgotten you guys is that I'm only 27... If I decide later in my life that I need a 20" planer... Well- I am pretty sure I'll have the time to figure that out (my grandmother just turned 98.. Very good family blood, haha). Anyways, thanks again. I'll be back later I'm sure for more thanks or questions. Quote
G S Haydon Posted February 21, 2013 Report Posted February 21, 2013 Hi idratherplaytennis I think http://www.woodtalkonline.com/user/3084-terrymck/ might have bought a combination machine recently so perhaps drop him a line. We do have a combination machine at work but it's a beast . If you can have afford and have the space for two do it. Less likely to have problems. Regarding cutters we use disposable tersa . Really quick to use and you can buy chrome, hss or tungsten depending on your work. Plus if you nick a cutter you can slide the cutters past each other just a little and loose it. We did have re-sharpen HSS in an older machine and they took longer to set up. I am interested in these cutters but have no experience of using them. Quote
dwacker Posted February 21, 2013 Report Posted February 21, 2013 Thanks for those replies so far, they've been helpful. On my phone at the moment so I'm going to keep this short...ish for now. My only hesitation in the dual machines for the most part was something along the lines of if I did want to run a fully laminated piece of cabinet door through the planer- but as I had read elsewhere, there's ways around it, plus depending on the sizes that I laminate together- there could be snipe issues, sometimes not. The other thing I wasn't sure about is the cutting head and the bed length. I think I remember as far as jointers go, the longer the better, or at least to match as closely as you can the size of your stock to it, which I think mainly would come into play if I were milling the face frame parts down to size. The counter argument to this being- if I properly clamp and glue and joint well, I may never even need to run through a 20" planer. You dont want to re-run your door panels back through the planer. The glue destroys knives and if you have a helical it plugs the cutters. The advantage of the 20 is to run all your loose boards in one pass. The 20s are also more robust and have a pressure bar. The key to good door glue ups is knowing how to joint and fipping your faces to make up for the fence. Or just backfence cutting through the shaper. Also some sort of panel flattening clamp there are many out there or you can make your own. I use the Larry's clamp and JLT make a manual one. The chances of a home woodworker actually needing a 20" planer is pretty slim. The advantage for a home woodworker is the more robust machine. The issue with all in ones like the bigger Griz is the center post table. With the table desigh the cutter head had to be condensed to an area small enough to only apply pressure to the center of the table right above the post. This skew's the build to size ration making them under built for the capacity. With the smaller ones they sort of copied the euro machines and went with a four screw adjuster but left out the mass of the adjuster post. Quote
Texfire Posted February 21, 2013 Report Posted February 21, 2013 I have the exact combo unit you mentioned, the JJP-12. The only difference is I decided that it was worth the extra up front expense to go with the HH model instead of getting a Byrd Shelix later on and having to go to the trouble of swapping out cutterheads. I chose it for the 12" jointing capacity, as it only lost 1.5" over a lunchbox planer. This matches the cut capacity of my miter saw, so I'm able to work with 12" stock throughout the shop without having to worry about cutting and gluing stock back together. The cuts are very clean, with zero tearout experienced so far. I love the large Jet combo, and the changeover is the quickest of the units that I looked at. Bonus you don't have to remove anything to make the change, most of the combos with split tables require you to remove the fence and store it offboard. I previously had a Jet 10" benchtop combo and would steer you away from them, or any combo unit that's not a full sized standing tool. That said, you may decided to go with two dedicated units, for a lesser cost if you have plenty of room and a limited budget. Quote
G S Haydon Posted February 21, 2013 Report Posted February 21, 2013 Found the blog article here. And it was http://www.woodtalkonline.com/user/3084-terrymck/ . He must of had it a while, I am sure he has a good opinion on a combination machine. Quote
stahlee Posted February 21, 2013 Report Posted February 21, 2013 Mwatkins and I both own combination machines with spiral cutterheads that have carbide inserts and we are both very happy with our purchases. My point is that we own these machines and say they are great. I'd say that's a glowing endorsement. OP, I wouldn't hesitate to buy the combo machine. Instead of worrying about a large planer, I would put your money toward a nice drum sander. You can thickness lumber with a nice drum sander and if you get a dual drum, use two different grits to speed up your work. My drum sander works hard and I would never give it up. Quote
TerryMcK Posted February 22, 2013 Report Posted February 22, 2013 Found the blog article here. And it was http://www.woodtalkonline.com/user/3084-terrymck/ . He must of had it a while, I am sure he has a good opinion on a combination machine. Yep I sure do have a combination machine. They usually get a bad press as it is perceived that they have to compromise on something. However in the case of the one I have it takes about 20 seconds to convert from jointer to planer. It is listed as a trade machine and I have found it great as a hobby woodworker. Have a look at my blog article http://tmcwoodworks.blogspot.com/2013/01/axminster-aw106pt2-planerthicknesser.html This one is very similar to models in the Jet range and it is built like a tank. I have used discrete jointers and planers in the past and this particular combo machine produces just as good quality as separates. 1 Quote
wdwerker Posted February 23, 2013 Report Posted February 23, 2013 Like particle board said joint and plane your lumber , then glue up panels. After glue up I use my drum sander on the panels to smooth out any difference between the boards. I have found that a drum sander is very useful for taking stock to an exact size without any chip out or torn grain. The Jet 16/32 has plenty of capacity for a small shop. It does need dust collection , I use a Dust Deputy and a big shop vac with a Hepa filter. Quote
stahlee Posted February 23, 2013 Report Posted February 23, 2013 My drum sander may be one of the most used pieces of equipment in my shop. I couldn't be without it. Quote
stahlee Posted February 23, 2013 Report Posted February 23, 2013 Haha hhh, I usually don't think about how much it gets used, but it's really every project. Not all projects get run over the TS though. I have a Performax 22/44, but one of these days I'll buy a nice dual drum unit. However, I can't complain with what I have now, it's been a great machine. hhh brings up a lot of great points. Don't expect to save money on a nice combo system. They are expensive. If there is a savings, it's simply the use of a single cutterhead. Awesome if you use spiral type heads. Batching will always be much better process when using a combo machine so you're not constantly converting back and forth. hhh, what combo did you have in the past? I'm saving up to buy a Felder, but it's not going to be for a couple years. I really want one of their sliders first. Quote
idratherplaytennis Posted February 23, 2013 Author Report Posted February 23, 2013 Yep. In regards to what I said about gluing together and planing on a large one- I ron't know what I was thinking cause I know plywood kills jointer blades from my research and I know it's the glue that does it- so it would figure the same foes for a planer. Silly me. I actually had another job coming up that may not be able to wait on a drum sander (I'm building a custom fence and have dozens, okay- 3 fences.. of 5x15x5/8-3/4" cedar boards to sand down for it). The more I think about all the sanding I need to do, the more I wish I had a drum sander already, gulp. At least I get to break in my new 1/2 sheet Makita pad sander in... I am pretty much thinking of going for something that sounds the best review wise. Combo or solo machines, either way. May have to start looking into a drum sander as well... But that's a totally different topic- as is the question of how glue affects those. Going into brands- I'm thinking of just looking into the Jet, Powermatic or Grizzly's and avoiding Steel City because of possibly some less admirable reviews I may or may not have read and I know Delta used to make a great Unisaw- but I haven't heard much about their other stuff or them in general as of late... Plus I get hesitant (in regards to Steel City) when it comes to something sold by Home Depot- online only or not. Most of my power tools and quality tools may be Makita- but they're the upper end ones that are not sold at Depot or their online store. Something about big box seller screams lower quality at times. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.