Recommended Posts

Posted

Anybody familiar with either of these tools? We have a recurring order for parts for plumbing fixture displays all covered in plastic laminate. Very high standards expected and edges have to be flawless. Hoping the Festool dust collection port will pick up most of the chips.

Posted

I know nothing of the Lamello but I can speak on my thoughts with the MFK: I had one for a very brief amount of time, but I didn't get much use out of it and ended up returning it. What put me off about it was how the horizontal base could only take a limited height of router bit, in other words, nothing in my collection would fit it, nor anything that Rockler had would fit. Of course I could buy Festool's own straight bit for it, but while I am invested in the Festool ecosystem as well as power tools goes, I don't feel the same way about doing that for router bits, blades, etc.

 

Back to the bit height thing...I know I saw Paul Marcel mention in a video (and may have a post) that he modified his horizontal base to take longer bits, but that's something I didn't want to do. The other thing I didn't like was how the MFK only came with the 1.5 degree base. Don't get me wrong, I understand why they have that as I would certainly use that on laminate and thin edge banding, but I wanted a zero degree base for other edge and thicker purposes but that'd be another $170 (or whatever it was). So ultimately while I was okay with paying a premium for the MFK as dust collection is incredibly important to me, and I already am invested in the Festool system and appreciate the conveniece, I didn't want to pay a premium on top of a premium so to speak.

 

I may eventually try for the MFK again when I have extra money to invest as I haven't found another trim/laminate router that catches my eye, but there are other things I want for my shop right now. Now your situation is different so the MFK might be ready to go out of the box for you, but just sharing my thoughts on it.

Posted

I've got the MFK..

 

 

==> What put me off about it was how the horizontal base could only take a limited height of router bit, in other words, nothing in my collection would fit it, nor anything that Rockler had would fit.

 

Yes, it 'just so happens' that you need to source FT bits [very expensive, i might add] to get the most from an MFK.  If this happens to be just an oversight or a designed-in requirement (kind of like the Schick-model) I don't know, but you end-up spending a couple hundred on FT bits before you are done...

 

Assuming you bite the bullet and get the bits, the horizontal base is a really nice feature.  I did about 200lf of shelving and it finished the 1/4" solid wood edge treatment just fine --- now, the bits were of new, of very good quality and sharp -- so that probably contributed...

 

Best bet would be to get one for a 30-day trial and get the bits at the same time...  The bits are quite good quality, so even if you return the MFK, I'd still consider hanging-on to the bits...

Posted

You could check with a guy over on the jlc forums that goes by tjbnwi. Hes on FOG as well. I think he does alot of veneers/laminates and uses the mfk 700. Heres a vid he did. Not exactly what youre looking for but check it out.

Posted

Steve, all I've ever used are Bosch and PC trimmers. I actually like the PC's better than the Bosch. Neither comes with DC though. I use a broom for that. The chips aren't as bad to clean up as sawdust. A lot of the time I just put a laminate trim bit in my router table so I can hook up the shop vac. That works great for small stuff. I've done several hundred miles of laminated shelving using the router table and to really make a nice seam, I always follow up my filing with a razor sharp 1-1/4 chisel. That seems to eliminate that little burr that seems to grow overnight.

Posted

The laminate we are using is a custom ordered matte finish (#38 Wilsonart) and is shows scuffs and scratches very easily. Local Festool rep brought one by for me to play with today. Seems to do the trick. The dust collection isn't perfect but no scratches so far.

Yea the bit limitations are annoying but after a week of routing and filing edges an expensive router and bit seems lke a solution.

I still like my Porter Cable HD trimmer with a no file bit for several steps on these display parts .

Thanks for the input!

Posted

The dust collection isn't perfect but no scratches so far.

Lamilube or trim ease is trick. In the shop using your jointer set up as a lipper will increase your straight production 100 times on all edging from laminate to hardwood.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.