Wayniackc Posted March 6, 2013 Report Posted March 6, 2013 What's the difference in a scraper plane like this: http://www.lie-nielsen.com/catalog.php?grp=1227 And the more traditional cabinet scraper like this: http://www.leevalley.com/US/Wood/page.aspx?cat=1,310&p=46266 Are they just different ways of doing the same task? Or are they for totally different applications? When would you use one versus the other? Quote
wdwerker Posted March 7, 2013 Report Posted March 7, 2013 I use my antique Stanley scraper plane for bigger surfaces, and the regular one for medium surfaces, and a card scraper for freehand work on small surfaces. I also use the regular one for rougher work and the scraper plane for fine finish work on large surfaces. Quote
nateswoodworks Posted March 7, 2013 Report Posted March 7, 2013 I did do what Steve said. I have an old #12, little different design than the LN but same concept, and I wouldn't trade it for nothing. I put a very nice and thick Pinnacle blade in it and now it takes anything I can throw at it. I still use my #80, basically the LV, but now more for the more aggressive work. That doesn't mean it can't do the finessing stuff because that's all I used for many yrs with great results, its just that I feel the plane is a higher lever of precision as well as some added features that make using it nicer. The angle adjustment I use for fine tuning the scraper projection to adjust the cut as well as letting you go a bit longer before re-burring it. The other nice thing is it gets you over the top a bit more which helps you direct your force where it needs to go. Quote
TerryMcK Posted March 7, 2013 Report Posted March 7, 2013 I have the both the LN cabinet makers scraper plane that you linked to and conventional card scrapers. I user the scraper plane to prevent burning my fingers on larger surfaces. It is awesome in use and produces very fine results. I use a card scraper for smaller surfaces and again the results from that are awesome too. So to answer your question yes they do produce the same results it's just one doesn't burn your fingers when used heavily. Quote
wdwerker Posted March 7, 2013 Report Posted March 7, 2013 Yea mine is a Stanley #12 too, beautiful rosewood handle! It was black when I got it ,cleaned it up and I was amazed to find rosewood. I need to get me one of those heavier blades for mine. Quote
Eric. Posted March 7, 2013 Report Posted March 7, 2013 I played with the LV scraper plane at the wood show a few weeks ago. I hated it. Granted, I didn't have much time with it, but the adjustments seemed very finicky and tuning it was difficult. I asked one of the LV guys to help me out, and after he tuned it to his satisfaction, it still performed with mediocrity...to put it nicely. I saw no advantage over a cabinet scraper or smoothing plane and touching up with a card scraper. I offered that opinion to him, he looked around to be sure others weren't listening, and quietly agreed. If you're looking for a tool to "smooth roughly," to be oxymoronic about it, or to clean up glue joints on panels, it may be useful. But for finish smoothing, it seems like an inferior choice to card scrapers, cabinet scrapers and smoothing planes. That's just my opinion of my first impression, given with limited experience with the tool. Quote
nateswoodworks Posted March 7, 2013 Report Posted March 7, 2013 Yea mine is a Stanley #12 too, beautiful rosewood handle! It was black when I got it ,cleaned it up and I was amazed to find rosewood. I need to get me one of those heavier blades for mine. My handle was painted a real ugly green when I bought mine! What are the chances? Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.