Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Argh! Which would make the better shop space???

Featured Replies

  • Author

Spencer,  OH YEAH, I am well aware of the confusion of boxes, hence the building of the extra storage of the potential workshop/storage outside.  When we moved we lost about 1000 sq ft of living space, and are in the ongoing process of downsizing.  The shed will be insulated, no matter what I use it for, with the minimum of a dehumidifier installed in it.

 

Nyles (and everyone), Just to clarify, can a breaker box for the shed be wired via the existing breaker box in the garage, or does it have to be installed from the electic company?  Or is that just the meter? (yes, I know I don't need another meter! ;) )  I plan on drilling out the necessary pathways through the studs to run wiring though and installing numerous outlets along the walls, and even in the two lofts so I can have "above the head" plugs to get wiring out of the way of the workbench.

 

Thanks for all the advice.  I found a guy that used to work for the company who I go the shed kit from (he's retired), and I am going to hire him to help me finish up.  That should make things speed up I hope!  Plus I've never shingled a roof before.

 

More later,

 

Milo

  • Replies 71
  • Views 15.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • Spencer_J
    Spencer_J

    after viewing the pictures, i recommend consolidating your cardboard & boxes. It's hard to see through the mess when you first move but it makes a huge difference when you condense things and orga

  • It was a dream shop idea, I was more supporting the idea. Circuits can be overloaded to the place where you are "browning" out tools further down the line. I may never draw 100amps but being able to a

Posted Images

electric company does the meter. you have to wire the shed through your existing panel but you'll want to put a second breaker ( sub panel) in the new shed so that if you trip a breaker you don't have to go all the way back to the panel to reset. another benefit to the sub panel inside the shed is the ability to add separate circuits for your plugs and lights, that way you don't have to mess around in your existing panel, potentially tripping other circuits in your house while you're trying to run wires into the panel. 

 

to be clear- main breaker box > sub panel breaker> sub panel> branch wiring inside the shed 

 

nice find on the shed helper!

A 220v breaker fits in two knockout spaces you have lots of room in that panel box you'll be driving crazy with all the noise for years to come. I would do the divider wall between the shop space and the laundry that gives you another wall to add more outlets also the wall would give you storage space, hanging cabinets from or, peg board plus it will isolate the noise level  to some level.

  • Author

Spencer, if I run a subpanel, where does the line run from? Do alsace some high capacity breaker in the current box, and run a line out from it to the subpanel?

Thanks for all the help, everyone!

Milo, couple of things.  If you run a sub panel off the existing panel youll just need to install one 220v breaker in your existing panel to feed the new sub panel.  Youll want to install an appropriatly sized breaker in the main existing panel based on a 2 part question.  How much electricity do you want available out there and how big is the new main breaker in your sub panel.  Now heres where it gets a little tricky reguarding the sub panel, there are several different styles of sub panels.  Some sub panels dont have a main breaker and youll either need to purchase it seperatly or get one with one already installed.  There are also a few electrical codes that allow you to get by with a sub panel with out a main breaker by like back feeding into the panel, or if there are less than a certain number of breakers that the sub panel can hold.  Dont confuse yourself more than you need to.  Id just try and find a reasonable price on a small sub panel with say about 12 spots in pry the 35-60amp range.  They should be fairly reasonable.  Once you know the size of that breaker in the sub panel you just buy an appropriatly sized one to go into the main panel in the house lets say in this example 40amp.  You would just install that 40amp 220v breaker as i outlined above and then run wire appropriatly sized for 40amps in this case that would be number 8 gauge.  Youll want to run 4 wires total between the 2 panels: 2 powers(blk or red), 1 neutral(white), and 1 ground wire(green). Put the 2 power wires to the breaker that you just installed in the main panel. Put the neutral (white) wire with the other white wires in your main existing panel. Put the green (ground) wire in with the other green or bare copper ground wires in your existing panel. The ground (green) wire can be smaller but youll have to consult some NEC charts to figure that out so your safe bet is to just run it the same size as the other wires. Itll cost you marginaly more but its not worth the hassel of having to fix and waste that wire if its not right the first time and when it comes to the ground its a safety issue so no reason to be cheap.  Then just run those panels into the new sub panel and land them to the appropriate locations. Youll put the 2 power (red/blk) to the main breaker in the subpanel(make sure its off first).  Youll put the white (neutral wire) to the sub panels neutral bar. Youll put the green (ground) wire to the sub panels grounding bar.  Your last step will be the ground rods.  Youll need to pound 2 8' grounding electrodes and use ground rod clamps to hook them up to thenumber 6 wire. Then run the number 6 grounding wire into the sub panel grounding bar. The ground rods need to be pounded flush with the grade of the earth and at least 6' apart no closer.  You can rent a ground rod pounder for a half day or get sweaty and use a fence post pounder.  Once the breaker in the main panel is installed and the 4 wires between them hooked up in both panes and the ground rods in place youll be done.  I suggest you have it inspected as well as pull an electrical permit.  The cost may seem like alot upfront but theyll tell you if its done right and at least if its done right the first time youll only have to do it once.  The other suggest i have is run 1 size bigger wire then you think youll need.  This will allow for more updating in the future if your at all hesitant about how much juice youll need out there.

 

 

If you have questions ask, Ill be on more the next few days since birthday stuffs done.  Have fun, youll learn alot if you tackle this yourself.

 

 

 

Nyles

 

  • Author

Cool. Then I am on the right track, because you just verified everything I had been researching. I had already decided on the subpanel having its own main, that just sounded too logical and safety oriented.

If someone can answer this though, How on earth do I estimate the amount of electricity I will need for a new shop? I know the new subpanel will need a 220v breaker, because the Unisaw needs that to run. But as for the amount of electricity?

Anybody? I am guesstimating I will want a total of 9 outlets, minimum. Four for the long walls, two for the short, one each for the loft, and a last one up on the roof for lights. Then I have the 220v Uni, a jointer, planer, dust collectors, shopsmith, OSS, miter, and misc. chargers for tools.

Does that help?

Thanks!

You will need to do a load calculation if you plan on wiring up the place so every tool can be on at the same time.  Id pry just suggest you go slightly above your largest tools ampacity.  That should cover you for any of your other tools to be used 1 at a time as well as for lights and basic outlets etc.  So if your biggest machines a 220v 20amp unit, then id do 30 amps.  Thats not rocket science electrical nor is it a true load calc, but it should cover you for most circumstances if you just want each machine on one at a time.  You can certainly google load calcs and do one but to be honest its pry not worth your time and the headache of doing it.  Ill tell you what you dont need to do and thats add up all of the stuff and come up with a total number, it sorta doesnt really work like that when doing load calcs.  A perfect example would be if you added up all the breakers in the panel of your home I am sure its over 200 and you pry have a 200 amp main panel.  Read up on load calcs or just take the easy way out that i suggested,  If you have questions on load calcs ill do the best i can to help you but i really dont enjoy them.... one of the other guys might have different or better advice or really enjoy doing load calcs ;-)

 

 

 

 

 

Nyles

 

Milo, remember that your dust collector and lighting will be running at the same time as your tools. Some of the larger cyclone DCs need 30 amps. Add that to your 30 amps for the tool circuit and 15 amps for lighting, and you'll then need at least 80 amps for the subpanel breaker. I wonder if it might be best and cheapest to just install a 100 amp panel and breaker, since those are so common and presumably cheaper? 

Milo, Andy is correct youll pry find that certain sub panel breaker sizes are more common and there for more cost efficient.  Id also suggest going a little bigger then what you decide you think at this time to cover yourself for the future.  Dont forget the wire size you have to run to the sub panel is dictated by the ampacity of the wire so 100amp sub panel wire is going to cost more than 60amp wire.  If you get above 40 amps or so i would suggest you look into aluminum wiring.  It will save you a reasonable amount of cash compared to copper.  The employee at the big box store should be able to help you size the appropriate wire (copper or aluminum) to the appropriately sized sub panel main breaker.  Youll also have to match the breaker size in your house panel and obviously the bigger the breaker the more they charge, IE a 100amp breaker usually costs more than a 60.  So just keep this stuff in mind when your piecing together your stuff.  The costs can and do add up.  Usually theres sort of a breaking point when it comes to the costs so with out knowing your budget ( I assume its a tight one) all I can really say is run it by us here before you purchase, shop around and try and get it right the first time.  Nothing eats up a budget quicker then re doing something you just did because it wasnt up to par with what you needed.

 

 

 

 

Nyles

  • Author

I have decided to go with the 100 amp breaker box. Ideally I'd like to have a breaker box with a master switch, and made 8 - 10 spots for breakers. The big box stores don't have smaller boxes (20+ slots). Just seems like more than I will need for a 160sq ft shop. Any suggestions on where to find a smaller box?

Thanks!

Milo,  you can try an electrical parts supply house in your area.  They may not all deal with the public but there is usually one that does and it may not be obvious so you may want to call them and ask if you have to be a contractor or if they deal with the public.  Personally id suggets the 20+ spot.  Most of the smaller subpanels and possibly even that 20 spot can not be thined out as i described earlier.  Youll see that panels are listed as like 20/40 or 20/30 that second number means the number of spots youll get if you use the thin/twin breakers.  IE a 20/30 you can thin out the last few spots to achieve a total of 30 circuits, a 20/40 you can thin out the entire panel and get 40 circuits.    Youll eat up those breaker spaces pretty fast especially with 220v circuits.  A 120v lighting circuit, a general 120v outlet circuit, and a 220v breaker for your saw will be 4 spots. That doesnt include another spot for your dust collecter if its 220v, nor does it really leave any room for additional 220v breakers for other machines that you may or may not have now or much room for breaking up your branch circuitry inside the building. A perfect example is when I wire a shop I usually install one row of outlets on one wall on one circuit and then another row on another circuit on the opposite wall.   I do this so if one breaker trips it doesnt affect the machinery on the opposite wall.  Some guys also achieve the same thing by wiring every other outlet on every other circuit.  To do something even like this will cost you another breaker spot, same thing with the lighting if you for what ever reason wanted to split that up.  Since youll have plenty of power with the 100amp sub panel you might as well get the bigger sized subpanel so that you can take advantage of the power.  The 100amp main breaker in the sub panel will do you no good if your only using (guestimating here) 30 amps of power between your 4 or 5 spots youll be using.  The reason to go with the 100amp other then the cost (its pry cheaper cause of supply and demand) is the ability to adapt for the future.  You never know when youll want to add a heater, or an A/C, or maybe a 30amp RV outlet on the outside of it to plug a recreational vehicle into it, or perhaps you build another building and want to power it up off the sub panel.  Just my two cents but id get as many spots as you can, again plan for the future.  Also I want to make sure your very clear that you cant really add up breaker sizes to determine what youll need for a minimum main breaker size.  IE you cant say my says 20amp and my dust collectors 30 so i need 50amps plus my lighting and outlets.... I dont want to get to involved as to not confuse you but a load calculation takes alot of factors into consideration especially when it comes to motors.  Theres start up values, continuous run times, etc that would be taken into consideration. I am not sure how to counsel you best to go about doing the load calc except that you can pry google it and find out or just go with alot more than you know youll ever need like the 100amp sub panel.    If you hit an electrical forum someone may even do it for you if you give them the information.  Your choice of the 100 amp sub panel should be sufficient for an entire shop and then some, but youll be limiting yourself drastically if you get to few breaker spots in the sub panel for the future.  A little more now is going to pay big time later if you think there might be other future endeavors coming off that same sub panel. 

 

 

 

Nyles

 

 

PS - I would offer to do the load calc for you but its been years and years since ive had to do one by hand so to speak.  The last place I worked had a very expensive piece of software that did it all and a very over paid estimator  that figured out all that stuff then as the electrician on site was just told what to install via some prints.    I am sure I could fumble through it but id hate to make a mistake.

 

 

 

 

I had a local electrician make the following recommendation to me as I thought about shop space.

He recommended 400amp service and meterage for the cite. He recommended splitting this feed in two 200amp service panels. One for the house and one for the shop. The thinking was that the shop would require a greater number of dedicated 240v circuits and would benefit from the larger panel space. This was a plan based on a three man crew so may be excessive for the small shop but it used this reasoning. The local power company was not charging to increase the service provision to homes (assuming the home was within so many feet of the pole etc) and so an increase to 400amp service eliminated the need for careful load calculations and it used standard equipment and wiring that residential electricians or DIYers can easily research and wire to code. I think based on this that you are receiving good advice above.

400A is HUGE for residential service...unless you live in a mansion with 20 women constantly doing laundry and blow-drying hair.  That's great if the power company is upgrading for free (I'm quite sure that's not the case around here), but that's still total overkill for a one man hobby shop.  I only have 100A service, and with an electricity-loving family inside the house, I can still run all the lights in the shop, a 220 space heater, the 220 DC and one other 220 tool with no problems off a 50A sub-panel with three 220 circuits and four 110 circuits and one circuit to spare.  Adding a sub-panel with as many dedicated circuits as possible running to the shop is more important IMO than an enormous service amperage.  How often will one guy run more than one tool and a DC at a time?  I've never tripped the main breaker, and there have been times that I've run those three 220 circuits while the wife was doing laundry and baking something in the oven.  Those are the big juice hogs in a house, aside from the AC.

 

I still wish I had 200A service though.  :)

It was a dream shop idea, I was more supporting the idea. Circuits can be overloaded to the place where you are "browning" out tools further down the line. I may never draw 100amps but being able to assign the 60amps I do draw to more dedicated circuits prolongs the life of the freezer, fridge, microwave, computers, hair dryers, and curling irons that just twice a year may be drawing at the same time. Agreed 400amp is huge (dream shops always are:-) but it offered a reasonably modern 200amps for the four bedroom home as well as 200amps to the standalone shop which would have had its own heat and air etc. Cut ratings in half and the concept is still worth consideration. Plan now to never need to call an electrician back.

Eric and C Shaffer,  You are right a 400amp service is huge for a residential property although not that uncommon anymore, atleast in my neck of the woods.  The cost is mostly in the materials, the extra labor is pretty minimal.  Most new custom homes in my area are 200-400amp services.  While most people never come close to maxing out thier 200amp service it usually comes down to the breaker spaces that people want.  If I recall correctly the smallest service that can go on a home these days is 120amps but buying a 120amp set up is usually more money then buying a 200amp set up because the 200amp panels are usually more common and there for its a supply and demand thing as far as the cost. This is also the reason most homes have a 200amp service on them.  Believe me if a contractor could save a buck sticiking a 120amp panel in they would.  Most power companys should offer each residence upto 400 amps (it could vary from power co to power co so always check first) anything greater then that and they usually start having to change stuff on thier end so they charge you accordingly and can be thousands of dollars.  The 400 amp service they just do a second 200amp drop and they are done.  So really a 400amp  service is 2 200amp services side by side so to speak.  I usually never recomend a 400amp service to someone unless they ask for it.    In your case Milo the 100amp sub panel should be plenty sufficient it really just comes down to breaker spaces for the future.  The reason i was suggesting a load calc is because you can pry get by with much less then a 100amp sub panel and i wasnt sure if perhaps getting a smaller sub panel would be more with in your budget.  Regardless of what size sub panel you get I suggest you get as many spaces as you can for breakers, and I also suggest you run your wires to the sub panel 1 size bigger (size your conduit appropriatly)  both of these things will have the biggest impact in keeping your future costs down in case you need to upgrade later.  A perfect example would be someday swapping out that 100amp subpanel for a 120amp or bigger sub panel.  In which case if the wire size to the sub panel was appropriatly sized, and the conduit appropriatly sized already  all youd really have to do is swap out the main breaker in the sub panel which is a fairly easy straight forward job.  Most people as mentioned by Eric above come no where near maxing out thier panels capabilties  It usually always comes down to breaker space for  branch circuits.  If the main breaker on the main panels tripping then your maxing out the service.  If the breaker feeding the subpanel or the main breaker in the subpanel are tripping then your maxing out the subpanel.  Ive really only seen one time in 9+ years of electrical work that a main breaker was really taxed and tripping and that was at the local gun club where they installed a TON of 1000w HID lighting to light up the shootring range for nighttime shooting.  Hope this helps clear anything up.

 

 

 

 

Nyles

 

If you are going to upgrade, may as well go big. I do occasionally run into the limits of my 200 amp service (at least what is dedicated for certain ciruits).

For a voice from the other side.... I'd love to have even one outlet in my shop.  All my power tools run from an extension cord sneaking through the front door of my house.  When I use the lathe or the drill press, I have the cord connected to a power strip, so I can run a "shop vac" (not a name brand) as the dust collector.  It's connected to a 15A fuse (not a circuit breaker) so I've got to be careful.

For a voice from the other side.... I'd love to have even one outlet in my shop.  All my power tools run from an extension cord sneaking through the front door of my house.  When I use the lathe or the drill press, I have the cord connected to a power strip, so I can run a "shop vac" (not a name brand) as the dust collector.  It's connected to a 15A fuse (not a circuit breaker) so I've got to be careful.

 

jHop, I hear you on that. The garage in the house we're renting had one outlet on the wall, and I had a single extension cord I'd carry around and move from tool to tool. Fortunately, I added a couple outlets on another circuit in a very removable way, so I can pull them out when we buy a house. But that's just on circuit, so when I run the table saw, I have to run the shop vac on the old extension cord and the saw on the new circuit.

  • Author

Sorry I haven't updated lately folks. I will, with pics soon.  We had someone fired at work, and another get violently ill, so I haven't done a thing on the shop in over a week! ugh!

Good news is that Buddy (the retired guy that used to build this very building for a living) was here yesterday, go everything leveled, and ID'd some mistakes I made in the process.

 

Go figure. ;)

 

More later...

No problem Milo, I was however hoping your quietness ment you were laying conduit and running wires, but youll get to that when you get some free time I am sure.  The panel looks good, price seems about right, and its got an adequate amount of spaces.  You will probably need to pick up an additional grounding bar kit unless that comes with one.  It should only be a few dollars but youll need to separate your neutrals and grounds inside the sub-panel, and only inside the sub-panel.  So youll have one grounding bar and one neutral bar.  Green wires all go to one and white wires all go to the others.  The grounding bar is easy to install, has directions and usually there are several pre-drilled spots inside the panel so you just pick a spot and screw it to the frame of the panel.  If you have any questions just holler.

 

 

 

Nyles

  • Author

Update!

 

Here are shop update pics I told you I'd upload.  We got a HUGE amount done today.  We have to move the shop a little today, but my builder friend assures me it won't be a big deal.  Insulating the ceiling is going to be harder than I though. :(  The way the ceiling trusses were made is not "clean", so it's going to take some work to get the ceiling panels in.

 

post-10429-0-58913800-1365633872_thumb.j

 

post-10429-0-74433800-1365633878_thumb.j

 

post-10429-0-72218100-1365633880_thumb.j

 

post-10429-0-87477300-1365633882_thumb.j

 

post-10429-0-09096200-1365633885_thumb.j

 

Hey, question for you builders.  HOW to you measure panels to know where to cut out for electrical sockets?

 

Whew!  I'm beat! If all goes well, I'll start installing the electrical wiring, and maybe start moving in next week.

 

Thanks for all the help!

 

Milo

 

p.s.  If you click on the pics this time, they do expand. I did it better this time. ;)

  • Author

No problem Milo, I was however hoping your quietness ment you were laying conduit and running wires, but youll get to that when you get some free time I am sure.  The panel looks good, price seems about right, and its got an adequate amount of spaces.  You will probably need to pick up an additional grounding bar kit unless that comes with one.  It should only be a few dollars but youll need to separate your neutrals and grounds inside the sub-panel, and only inside the sub-panel.  So youll have one grounding bar and one neutral bar.  Green wires all go to one and white wires all go to the others.  The grounding bar is easy to install, has directions and usually there are several pre-drilled spots inside the panel so you just pick a spot and screw it to the frame of the panel.  If you have any questions just holler.

 

 

 

Nyles

 

Whoa!  Thank you Nyles!  I thought the box would come with the ground, or even that the original panel ground would be this panels ground!  YIAIIAA! ;)

 

Are grounds "universal" in these panels?  When I searched the Home Depot site under "panel ground" only a couple of items popped up.

 

I'll look at more, of course. Thanks for the assist!

lookin' good! for drywall i usually just hold the panel up to the outlet, beat on it a few times and the cut where the marks are. the subs i've used in the past use a rotozip once the panel is in place. it takes some experience. make sure all of your outlets are at the same height. that will make it easier to do your layout. 

So you guys don't spring for the cheap(ish) plastic template?  The one you push into the drywall, trace around the edge (or inner edge) with a pencil, and then remove?  (Marks single/double outlets, switches, supposedly still cuts drywall after shaving a tin can, can also calculate pi to six digits and handle those annoying stains?)

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.