Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Argh! Which would make the better shop space???

Featured Replies

Ok, I am torn between two spaces which I have available to move into.

The first is the garage.  Pluses include flat cement floor and electricity.  I have a 220v Delta Uni, so this is important.  Cons include having to build a wall to wall off the back of the garage for the wife and shelving for items she doesn't want to get dust on.

The second is the 160 sqft free stand shop I am building out back.  Pluses include it's completely empty, so I can set up tools as I like, and it's seperate form the house, so noise is reduced for the folks inside.  It's right behind the garage, so I COULD run electricity back to it, and would have to make some kind of work around for the Uni.  Cons of course include small size and not electricity yet.

I have standard power shop tools. TS/planer/jointer/sld. miter/Shopsmith w/bandsaw/workbench/etc.

Please share your thoughts and experience!

Milo

  • Replies 71
  • Views 15.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • Spencer_J
    Spencer_J

    after viewing the pictures, i recommend consolidating your cardboard & boxes. It's hard to see through the mess when you first move but it makes a huge difference when you condense things and orga

  • It was a dream shop idea, I was more supporting the idea. Circuits can be overloaded to the place where you are "browning" out tools further down the line. I may never draw 100amps but being able to a

Posted Images

Hi Milo,

 

I would go for the free stand.

 

Concrete floor is fine but a good sturdy & solid wood floor is nicer. Tools will bounce rather than break on a wood floor.

 

Sharing is fine but having you own space is great.

 

Could an electrician put a cable to the free stand shop? Sounds like you would need to spend money building a dividing wall in the garage anyway. Perhaps put that money towards the electrician's fees. 

You never really said how much space youd have in the garage after you walled it off and i know garages can vary from one to another?   Id pry suggest the out building or option b for most of the reasons GS stated. 

 

As an electrician I can tell you if its as straight forward as it sounds and if that was originaly a dedicated 220v line it should be fairly simple to j-box that connection, put a blank plate on it then run some conduit 24" or so underground to the other building and come up from the ground in conduit and  run it into another box and put the appropriate recepticle back in.  Material wise thats a pretty minimal job the most expensive part would be the wire then the pvc conduit. Labor wise a competant electrician should be able to knock that out in half a day or so.  If your not doing it yourself you might want to find someone whos willing to do it for time and materials  and dont forget to check craigslist theres usally a hungry electrician on there.  Do the trenching yourself if you can or hire a neighbor kid for 10$ an hour and work the snot out of him (atleast offer him a soda if its hot ;)  you dont want the electrical contractor to have to trench theyll charge you and charge you well. Thatll save you the most on labor.  Ask him what his mark up is on materials and if its more than 15% Id suggest going to get the materials yourself at Homedepot just ask him for a list.  If you get the right electrical contractor theyll work with you.  If its not possible or feasable to go underground  because im assuming theres no swimming pool or other large obstruction in the way of a fairly straight trench, youd have to go over head which will be more involved but probobly not that outrageous again depending on any wierd circumstances but again pry not outragesly costly, definately slightly more in materials though.  Id also suggest if the building doesnt have other electrical services such as lighting or general outlets, Id go ahead and run them now cause itll be more difficult later and definately not as cost efficient.  Best case scenario and my advice is if the panels in the garage delete the original 220v line install a slightly large 220v line on larger wire for more amps, run that to the other building as per above and install a small subpanel and ground rods in the out building.  then off the subpanel  install your electrical outlets as needed.  that would get you all the power youd need for the saw, lighting, and general outlets and leave you room for future needs long as you ran the appropriate sized wire to the subpanel.  if you have any specific questions Id be happy to answer them and your codes may be slightly different in your area but that should cover you for most NEC applications.  If you do the work yourself make sure you pull a homeowners electrical permit and have an inspector look at it that way your assured its done right.  your electrical contractor if you hire one will pull the permit for you, and make sure they do pull a permit otherwise its a sign they are shady. Its also a good idea to think about heat and or AC if youd want that sort of thing as thatll affect your wire size that youd want to run.

 

 

 

Nyles

Milo, I would tend toward a stand-alone shop, but you definitely need more room than 160 sq.ft. Since you are in the process of building it, why not just spend a little more and make it larger? Do you have the room to do that? You might also consider putting a roll-up or sliding door at one end, or both ends, to give you more light, air, and room. The addition of a lean-to roof over the doors allow you to work under them when weather permits. By all means, do as Nyles suggests and run more electrical capabilities than you need at the moment. I tried using the garage for a while, but my wife and I are like the movie the odd couple. She's like Felix and I'm pure Oscar Madison.

I'm leaning towards the garage.  My current space is tiny, and split between an indoor closet and the outdoor pad beside it.  so I'm looking at about 100 square feet.... none of it powered unless I run an extension cord from the house.  While being outdoors has a benefit at clean up time (hard to deny you made the wood mess floating about the neighborhood, but the wind will carry it where it will), and having a large open space to "shoo" the mess out makes cleaning up with a leaf blower fast, I run out of power options faster than I thought possible, even running a "mostly" handtool shop.

 

If'n yer still interested in a small shop space, Wood had a special interest magazine over the holiday season, I think entitled Small Workshop Solutions.  (It's in the bathroom downstairs, and I just finished taking sinus meds; I'm not sure footed enough to get the issue right now.)  There were write-ups for three guys using spaces smaller than a single car garage, including one for a backyard shed.  I'll get the exact info up tomorrow, after classes.

  • Author

Hey guys, I wanted to answer some questions and add a little info...

 

Nyles, the saw was never connected to the current cicuit box.  I have moved, hence the changes.  And teh current box is pretty full.   Any ideas on options?

 

TRBaker,  yeah, I am limited by space, hence the 160sq ft.  16x10, but I have a gabled roof design, so I'll have additional loft space for storage. Perhaps 80sqft or so.  Plus the hanginging wall space.

 

jHops, I'd appreciate the additional info.

 

Thanks all!

Even a 1 car garage walled off is going to be larger, so I say the garage.

 

Building a wall isn't really a great dust solution. Some wood dust will escape from the shop area. The items will get dusty just from sitting there and dust normally present anywhere, and guess who will get the blame? ;)

 

Maybe the items need to be somewhere else, in sealed plastic containers, covered with plastic sheeting, or in some type of sealed cabinet or Lexan-front display case?

depending on how full it really is there are ways around it.  If you have the entire panel full of full sized breakers you can usually replace them with what they call twin or thin breakers.  These in essence do the same thing just called different by their respective manufacturers.  They are in essence two circuits that take up the space of one tradition full sized breaker.  They are different then the 220v ones that run your dryer and range and stuff as they dont have a handle on them that ties the two phases together.  if you goto home depot and look at thier breakers you can see what im talking about.  They are generally a few dollars more than your traditional breakers but not much (depending on manufacturer) and usually as cheap or cheaper then a 2phase 220v breaker.   Beware however not every panel takes these 'thin' breakers and not every manufacturer has it so you can 'thin' out an entire panel.  Worst case scenario usually you can 'thin out' the bottom 5-10 spots on your panel.  If you give me the name and model of your panel i could help you more there.  If your panel is already 'thined out' then your looking at adding a subpanel next to it which is fairly easy or upgrading your existing home panel to a larger sized panel  unless you already have that and its full then your stuck with sub panels.  To do a subpanel  in a nutshell youd just install the sub panel next to the main panel and then remove a couple of circuits  from the existing panel to make room for the breaker to feed the new sup panel off the main panel.  Then youd want to hook up the circuits you removed from the original panel and power those up off the sub panel.  I can give you more advice if you get me some more info or even want to email or post me a picture.  Installing a sub panel next to an existing panel is usually not a major job depending on circumstances and how much of a rats nest the existing panel is.  You do however start to get your costs adding up between breakers, sub panels and then the costs i outlined above.  If your current garage is not wired up for your shop you are proboly looking at adding a sub panel reguardless.  I do suggest you get the biggest sub panel you can if you do install one as that will give you the most flexability for the future.  Tell me a few things also, where does the main panel for the house sit? garage? basement? living room? were? Is the room that the main panel in finished or unfinished? Is the  garage finished or unfinished?  go ahead and post  a picture of your panel or at the very least like i said the make and model which should be somewhere on the inside on a sticker.  A picture of the panel with the cover off would be beneficial but dont do that if your not comfortable doing so.

 

 

 

Nyles

  • Author

AndyF, I had planned on actually walling the entire back section of the garage off, from side to side, roof to floor, like a separate room. I sure hope that would work, combined with dust control in the shop.

Nyles, working tonight, but I'll post a pic of my fuse box tomorrow.

Thanks all!

Btw, leaning back towards garage. Did the Grizzly floorplan and UGH, no room in the shop at 16x10. Garage will at least be 20 wide, not sure on the depth yet.

Milo

Alright, finally got that information.  Here is the link to the magazine on Amazon.  If you find it other places, by all means, jump on it.  It's Big Ideas for Small Workshops 2013, by Wood Magazine.  Backyard shed starts on page 43, 1 stall garage on page 32, 2 car garage shop on page 36, and a backyard shop/shed (12'x12') on page 47.

Milo, no problem ill check back in soon as I can.  Todays my birthday so I may not have as much time to lurk today as I had earlier in the week.

 

Jhop,  is that magazine worth buying? I have a very very small shop in my basement and was wondering if its worth buying for ideas/tricks/tips for storage, layout, etc.  Care to point out any great ideas it has in it? or perhaps even give a small review?  Im only hesitant cause ive thumbed through these magazines at times and read some of the articles on this subject and usually im dissapointed.  It seems its either a rehash of all the same stuff with maybe 1 new idea if your lucky.  Thanks

 

 

Nyles

There are some great features in it, and some that I thought could have been expanded.  For example, there is a flip top station described on page 22, with two photos, but no plans.  The blog Half Inch Shy covers a similar flip-top stand with more description on how to make the stand.  The differences between the two are a) that Half Inch Shy is published by a WTO member, and b ) the hinge on the magazine version was mounted lower and "were shop-made from 1/4" plate steel and 1/2 x 2 1/2" carriage bolts," but it doesn't mention how.  (Sometimes, I need that image to reinforce the concept.  Just my learning style.)

 

The magazine also has a copy of the grid sheet to lay out your own shop, with scale sample tools and lumber on page 19.  There's a plan on how to make mobile bases that wrap around the legs of your steel bases for your existing tools, a workbench plan, storage cabinets of a couple varieties (including how to add extra space/doors to them to increase functional space), an article on 5 small shop power tools (mostly hand held power or cordless), an article supporting benchtop power tools, a review of benchtop spindle sanders, planers, and portable miter stands.

 

If I hadn't already made a storage panel for my sanding pads for my ROS, I'd be using the plans they include for one, which has nearly double the storage (and an eighth the space) of mine.  Plus there's a pair of plans on folding work surfaces using sawhorses or custom hide-away tables.

 

If you haven't already set up a shop, it' well worth the read.  If you're looking to do major improvements on the shop, I highly recommend it.  If you're looking to get a couple of tricks for an already tuned (if not well tuned) shop, I'd suggest seeing if your library has it.

 

And I know that there are some articles I skipped, simply because my situation does not need or support the articles.  Does not mean they aren't worthwhile, just means I saw no personal benefit to reading them at this time.  (Then again, like many wood workers, I tend to keep every magazine on wood working for long times, and something that wasn't applicable then becomes applicable later...)

 

I'd have to say my three favorite tips/plans/articles out of the shop are the plans for turning an irritating support pipe/pole into a useful tool stand, the rolling workshop storage (even if it is too big for my shop, I'm trying to figure out how to use parts of it), and the cabinet plans, along with additional articles describing optional doors or clamshell doors to improve storage space.  (Sadly, that project is three or four out... but it is on the list for this May.  I'll try to document it as I go.)

Garage...definitly the garage...space is invaluable...plus if you are already building the.shed why not just dedicate that for the storage area for the wife and forget the partition wall which would give you even more space in the garage...I've had the chance to work out of a space about 180 sq. Ft. And its a pita. I know a lot of great woodworkers on this site do it but I bet not a one wouldn't take more space if they could...jmho

what type of projects do see yourself working on in the next few years? 

 

i'd say the free standing shop if you need a place where you can leave things in whatever state you feel like leaving them in, as opposed to the garage which is bound to get more foot traffic by the family. 

 

if you're rockin' big sheets of plywood and making larger pieces of furniture, the garage sounds much more spacious and could help you grow the shop more comfortably. 

  • Author

Argh! Sorry for the delay in getting back to everyone. I'll try to get some pics up this afternoon.

Milo

  • Author

Here are the pics.

 

The first is a pic of the crowded garage I may turn into a workshop.  You can easily see why I need extra space.

 

The second is the fuse box

 

The third is the outdoor shed under construction. I have fubared up the constuction (the walls are not square), and need to find someone with more experience to see if I can salvage it.  I fear I will need to tear down some of the siding, probably adding to the expense.  What a pain in the @ss.  >:\  

 

What do you guys think?

post-10429-0-38250500-1364679647_thumb.j

post-10429-0-15487500-1364679681_thumb.j

post-10429-0-75733400-1364679694_thumb.j

Milo,

 

Its very hard for me to see such a small picture but I believe you have plenty of room for more circuits or at the very least to add a subpanel.  The fact that you have one more breaker on one side then the other leads me to believe there are more spots availalbe below the existing breakers.  There should be little tabs that can be knocked out on the front of the panel to expose more spots for new breakers.  Panels almost always exclusively have an even number of breakers on each side.  So that leads me to believe yo have room.  Secondly I dont notice any twin or thin breakers in that picture so you should be able to install some of those as well if needed.  I believe thats what a siemans panel?  They make twin/thin breakers for those and are available at home depot.  If you are going to knock out some of those tabs for more breaker slots make sure you remove the panel when you do, and take a peek at the inside where the breakers actuall go into the panel on the back to make sure.  Sometimes there are more knock outs on the cover then there are spots but I dont believe thats the case with your panel, but just count the number of knock out tabs on the front and the number of available spots on the back inside of the panel.   That looks like a good modern panel with main disconnect and plenty of room from what I can tell from that picture.  If you need help advice on actually doing the upgrades let me know which route your going and the specifics of your question and Ill do the best i can to help you.  If you are going to hire an electrical contractor he should have a fairly easy task of adding a few new circuits to that existing panel.  If you have any more questionst dont hesitate to ask, ill be on more over the next few days.

 

 

Nyles

 

  • Author

Nyles, didn't the picture expand when you clicked on it?

How would I know if a 220v breaker would fit? I really only need to add the beaker for the phase converter.

Electrical AIN'T my thing! ;)

Thanks!

220 is achieved in your panel with a breaker that fills two spots side by side in one column of your panel. You have space for multiple 220 volt feeds.

It is difficult to see from your picture in the black but certainly 9-11 is a 220v breaker in your panel currently. See how a single throw switch operates both spot 9 and 11. I think from the stickers that 1-3 and 5-7 are also 220v.

Based on the middle picture ... I'd take the shed in a heartbeat.  That and the shed looks like, with a bit of judicious planning, it could work quite well.

Millo, no it did not expand but its probobly my computer, I am having some issues with it at the moment.  C shaffer is correct.  You look to have plenty of room.  To double check just remove the panel cover screws and gently lift the panel cover off, youll see the buss bars that run vertically in the middle of the panel that the breakers attatch to.  Just count the number of those available to determin if you have space.  Your standard 220v breaker will take up two of those spots.  While you have the panel cover off make sure your new 220v breaker is in the off position and go ahead and snap it into place underneath the last breaker already in place. Use the same orientation of the screws were the wire connects to make sure you have the correct orientation of the breaker if your concerneda bout which way it goes in.   Placement of the breakers location inside the panel is really irrelivent, and it doesnt matter which side you snap it into, just make sure it fits snugly into place and is firmly seated.  Then knock out the corresponding knock outs on the panel cover to make room for the breaker on the panel cover.  You can in your case just remove the two corresponding knock outs below the existing breakers spot, just make sure you do it on the correct side of the panel cover.  The knock outs can usually be tapped from the back firmly with a screw driver and a heavy object and then bent out 90 degrees with pliers.  Then just grab it with a pair of pliars and work it vigerously back and forth till it snaps off.  Repeat for the second opening as needed.  Its helpfull to have two peple taking the panel cover on and off if your not used to working with both hands and holding something at the same time ;)  Stear clear of the buss bars in the center of the panel, the main lugs up top that the big wires hook upto as well as the screws on the other breakers, these are really the only hot things that should be inside the panel and that could shock you.  If your at all hesitant and want to make it as safe as possible then go ahead and throw your main breaker OFF, id suggest doing it this way reguardlessly if you can get away with having the power off while you work.

 

If your not comfortable dont do it yourself, but its really really easy and theres no reason to pay someone to install a breaker for you.  I dont know what your other piece of equipment you were referring to requires specifically so if your comfortable wiring that up you may as well do the breaker too, if you arnt planning on wiring that up for yourself whom evern installs that can easily install the breaker for you as well.

 

 

Nyles

 

after viewing the pictures, i recommend consolidating your cardboard & boxes. It's hard to see through the mess when you first move but it makes a huge difference when you condense things and organize properly. once you have a little more open space in your garage, i think you might reconsider the garage area... We provide a move-in service and create custom storage solutions for almost every client. the first thing we do is take EVERYTHING out of the cardboard boxes and get as much garbage out of the room/ house as possible. from there like items get put with like items followed by an assessment of goodwill items and then storage containers etc. just my .02

 

the shed looks awesome! the t1-11 looks clean. depending on how much you nailed it on you might be able to pop some of the panels off enough to square it up. good luck- don't get too frustrated! some people can't even think about building a shed, let alone begin to build one. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.