Recommended Posts

Posted

Hey all, i was looking into getting some sharpening stones and i'm not sure which would suit me better. Is there a difference between oil stones and water stones other than the obvious water or oil to sharpen? does 1 last longer than the other, or give a better edge? Would i still need a flattening stone with oil stones?

Posted

I was told yesterday (by a manufacturer of oilstones) that casual users like us should never have to have them flattened.

I've used a water stone once and although it was alleged to cut faster than oilstones, it didn't seem much faster to me. I still had to scrub a lot to get my plane iron flat.

Posted

Oil stones are messy especially if you are in the middle of a job and your chisel/plane just needs a hone. You end up inevitably getting oil onto the wood from your hands. Most oilstones I've seen are rough grits

Waterstones go to some mighty fine grits and polish the steel. .

Diamond plates have a plateau where they are great for the first two regrinds of plane irons and then seem to lose their edge. However the plateau then stays the same for the life of the plate never getting any worse just taking much longer to do a regrind than the first 2 times. Now I use a diamond plate to flatten my waterstones only. It never loses its edge as it is removing relatively soft stock.

  • Like 1
Posted

I use water stones. I love them. I sharpen before every project, and a couple times during the project if required. They work quickly, cleanly, and are easy to use. The only drawback, besides cost, is that they need to be flattened. I flatten after every use,but many people wait longer.

Posted

Do Oil stones have to be flattened as often as waterstones do? Also it seems like a quick wipedown after sharpenning would take care of the oil getting into the wood. Is that an over simplistic way to think about it?

Posted

All stones should be flattened after every use or two.  Otherwise you WILL eventually dish them out.  Whoever told you they don't need to be flattened doesn't know what he's talking about.

Posted

The quality of the edge that you get shouldn't be a concern when picking between waterstones vs. oilstones vs. sandpaper vs. diamonds. They all work. I think that people pick the sharpening regimen that they do because it is less annoying than all the other ones, not because one gets you a sharper edge than the others. With waterstones, you need to manage the water. Other methods of sharpening tend to be faster than oilstones. Diamonds give me the "fingernails on a chalkboard" feeling. Sandpaper needs replacing and dealing with the spray adhesive you used to stick the sandpaper down with.

 

I agree that whoever said that you don't need to flatten oilstones has no idea what they are talking about, unless they were thinking of carving tools, which do benefit from a sharpening surface that conforms to the shape of the tool. But I doubt that's the case.

  • Like 1
Posted

thanks for all the replies guys i really appreaciate it, i think i'm going to go with oil stones because they are cheaper and I don't think wiping them down will annoy me to much. Only time will tell, i will stick with it for a few years and see. Thanks again

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.