Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Turbine vs. HVLP vs. LVLP

Featured Replies

I need to do a bunch of research, but I'd like to get a general consensus (or a trainwreck argument :) ) from people I trust before I start.

 

In another thread I explained that a friend of mine gave me a decent HVLP gun he had.  But my compressor is probably inadequate.  So my options are buying a bigger compressor for the gun I have, or buy a LVLP gun, or buy a turbine.

 

What I'd like to know is what the pros and cons are of each.  I have to assume there's some disadvantage to the LVLP since a lot of guys have compressors good enough to run them, yet it seems most people go with a turbine...a nice Fuji being twice the cost of a high-end LVLP.  Why is that if LVLP can perform just as well as a turbine?

 

Talk to me like I don't know anything...because I don't.  Thanks! :D

HVLP: you need a good compressor which can cost a lot. But then you'll lose out on portability but gain a compressor to use with other tools. Less overspray as well.

Turbine: They can heat up the material which depending on who you talk to is either good or bad. Bad because your finish will dry in the air faster which'll cause orange peel. Great in the winter because the heat will warm your cold shop. Bringing a lower viscosity for your product. Less overspray as well. Way more portable.

LVLP: Runs on small compressors. Uses more material than HVLP guns and lots of overspray.

I cannot recommend a system for you. However do you have a budget, what are you spraying, indoors or outdoors. I'd like to leave this point out though. The Earlax turbine system which cost ~$300 is a great gun which many users pointed out and infact use. The Whisper himself has one along with a video on it. I'd recommend that you watch it.

HVLP: you need a good compressor which can cost a lot. But then you'll lose out on portability but gain a compressor to use with other tools. Less overspray as well.

Turbine: They can heat up the material which depending on who you talk to is either good or bad. Bad because your finish will dry in the air faster which'll cause orange peel. Great in the winter because the heat will warm your cold shop. Bringing a lower viscosity for your product. Less overspray as well. Way more portable.

LVLP: Runs on small compressors. Uses more material than HVLP guns and lots of overspray.

I cannot recommend a system for you. However do you have a budget, what are you spraying, indoors or outdoors. I'd like to leave this point out though. The Earlax turbine system which cost ~$300 is a great gun which many users pointed out and infact use. The Whisper himself has one along with a video on it. I'd recommend that you watch it.

 

Good LVLP guns have less overspray than comparable HVLP help. LVLP is sort of the "new latest thing" and is more of an auto body thing than woodworking. I wouldnt suggest an earlex bleeder gun over a $300 lvlp gun if you already own a compressor. A good LVLP gun is a great tool and will spray as well as a $1000 plus turbine with just as low of overspray.

 

My 3m rep just left and gave me their accuspray gun. We sprayed a sheet of plywood with GF performance with a 1.8 tip running half the suggest cfm and I can honestly say that system is worth a look. Im going to do a review on it in the next couple days. 

  • Author

Yeah I guess I should have added a few details...

 

It'll be for shop use only.  Portability means nothing to me.

 

I'll be spraying mostly shellac, lacquer, and WB finishes.  No interest in paint...although it would be nice to have the option...but it's not important.

 

Hobbyist.  I build small to medium projects...one offs.  I'll never have an entire kitchen's worth of cabinets to finish.

 

I'm not really worried about budget...for the last couple years I thought I would just end up buying a Fuji 3 or 4 stage, so in my mind I was already out a grand, give or take.  But if I can get the same results for less money, great.

 

However, I'm a "buy it once" kind of guy.  I tend to go one step beyond what I think my needs might be, just to be safe.

 

 

 

I guess for me it comes down to a turbine or LVLP.  If I'm going to drop the coin for a big@$$ compressor, I may as well just buy the turbine, as I have no other use for huge compressed air capacity.

 

 

 

Just to simplify things, let's just compare these two options...

 

 

Fuji Mini-Mite 4   $700

 

http://www.amazon.com/Fuji-2904-Mini-Mite-4-Stage-System/dp/B000EWJYF6

 

 

 

 

Iwata LPH400-134LV  $615  (haven't looked around for better deals on this one)

 

http://www.toolsource.com/lph400134lv-spray-with-700ml-p-143669.html

 

 

 

Head-to-head...pros/cons?

I have sprayed with a turbine for over 20 years. The warm air is helpful spraying WB finishes, fall, spring and winter. Never had much trouble with orange peel . I have a big compressor but my turbine never runs out of air when spraying a long time. I have an Accuspray gun from before 3m bought them. American Turbine is my current blower .

You have to be careful with LVLP. Alot of them still need more air like the Iwata @ 9 or 10. The asturo is 5 or 6. Also need to make sure you get the right needle sizes 1.5 and 1.8 are all I ever use 1.8 most of the time for top coats.

  • Author

Thanks for the input...feel like I'm on the right track already.

 

Sounds like turbine probably is right for me.  I kind of don't trust my compressor anyway, even if it were suitable for LVLP.  I could just see it going out and I'd end up worse off than if I just went turbine from the start.

 

Couple other questions:

 

If I have no intention of ever spraying paint (which I don't), is there any reason why I would still consider a four stage over the three stage?  That would save me another $150.

 

Is there a good forum that you guys know of that is all HVLP topical...and aimed more toward woodworking?  I looked a bit but found nothing except auto body stuff...didn't know if that would even be relevant.

 

Appreciate the help...

Here ya go I thought I would muddy up your thread. :) These guns are for those that are hoping to get into the laziest woodworkers hall of fame. They spray just as well with WB poly as a expensive Iwata but you do need a bigger compressor. :) The heads can be rinsed and when they get to crappy you just throw them away. I got this gun free from my 3m rep he called it a primer gun but it sprays with almost no overspray. Uses only the 3m pps cup sytem, perfect woodworking compressed air gun for the lazy woodworker. 

 

==> If I have no intention of ever spraying paint (which I don't), is there any reason why I would still consider a four stage over the three stage?

 

be careful about 'never'....  I got the 4-stage fuji 'just because'... I never intended to spray paint either, but then one day I had the requirement....  

Here ya go I thought I would muddy up your thread. :) These guns are for those that are hoping to get into the laziest woodworkers hall of fame. They spray just as well with WB poly as a expensive Iwata but you do need a bigger compressor. :) The heads can be rinsed and when they get to crappy you just throw them away. I got this gun free from my 3m rep he called it a primer gun but it sprays with almost no overspray. Uses only the 3m pps cup sytem, perfect woodworking compressed air gun for the lazy woodworker. 

 

attachicon.gifphoto 1.JPG

attachicon.gifphoto 2.JPG

 

Few years back they were givin those guns away if you bought volume or gross of the 3m pps liners and lids. It is a primer gun, hence the larger 1.8 needle to handle the solids that are in primers. Suppose to save you labor and solvent cost of gun cleaning. 

 

Keep us posts how this works out for you. Great idea for water-based....hear it sprays really nice.

 

-Ace-

Few years back they were givin those guns away if you bought volume or gross of the 3m pps liners and lids. It is a primer gun, hence the larger 1.8 needle to handle the solids that are in primers. Suppose to save you labor and solvent cost of gun cleaning. 

 

Keep us posts how this works out for you. Great idea for water-based....hear it sprays really nice.

 

-Ace-

3m reps are like drug dealers at an elementary school. Ill probably just give it away to someone that needs it. Im thinning out the tool herd.

I learned the hard way to anchor the turbine when you are spraying. I just have a loop of wire that hooks over a screw to keep the turbine from falling of the bench when you hit the end of the hose. A running turbine that hits the floor will suffer damage to blades , bearings and the case. It still ran but increasing noises let me know it's days we're numbered.

I got a new 30 ft turbine hose recently. It has a heat absorbing section that keeps your gun from becoming to hot to handle during long spray sessions in the summer months. Nice feature but it may not be offered in some package deals.

I learned the hard way to anchor the turbine when you are spraying. I just have a loop of wire that hooks over a screw to keep the turbine from falling of the bench when you hit the end of the hose. A running turbine that hits the floor will suffer damage to blades , bearings and the case. It still ran but increasing noises let me know it's days we're numbered.

I got a new 30 ft turbine hose recently. It has a heat absorbing section that keeps your gun from becoming to hot to handle during long spray sessions in the summer months. Nice feature but it may not be offered in some package deals.

 

I just mounted mine to the wall up high so it doesnt suck up dust and overspray plugging the filters.

  • 7 months later...

Resurrecting an old thread...

 

Just curious what system and brand you went with? Can you share what you have liked and disliked about your choice?

 

I am in the $500 dollar budget range and debating between an upper end Earlax, low end Fuji, or should I save a few more benjamins and get a Q3/4 Fuji or Apollo?

 

Cheers

  • Author

Sadly I am still without a spray system.  But I made the decision and it's going to be the Fuji 4 stage.  PM estesbubba if you have questions about it...he's been playing with his for a while now and he has some good tips.

I almost bought the mini mite 4, but after using the earlex 5500 (and getting a killer deal on it of 249) I bought the earlex. It's a great machine, but it does have some drawbacks over a higher priced system. I'm going to write a review on it soon and post it under the reviews section.

Mostly, the earlex does a great job. It's sprays well, and leaves a beautiful finish.

I had the Earlex 5500 and think I got a bad unit as others have had decent luck with it. One thing it didn't like about it is it had a bleeder gun which blows air all the time. I got the Fuji Mini-Mite 4, and while it's quite a bit more than the Earlex, is a complete joy to use and has great results. I haven't had to thin any finish running through it. 

What size tips do you find you use most often when spraying for furniture and cabinets?

If you're getting the Fuji, they come with new guns and a 1.3mm tip. I would try that and see how it goes. The 1.0mm will give you a little better atomization but less coverage. It all depends on what you're going to spray. If you plan on spraying acrylic something like a 1.8mm will be needed. This Fuji chart will give good details:

 

http://www.fujispray.com/FUJI%20Quick%20Reference%20Sheet%2020130822.pdf

If you're getting the Fuji, they come with new guns and a 1.3mm tip. I would try that and see how it goes. The 1.0mm will give you a little better atomization but less coverage. It all depends on what you're going to spray. If you plan on spraying acrylic something like a 1.8mm will be needed. This Fuji chart will give good details:

 

http://www.fujispray.com/FUJI%20Quick%20Reference%20Sheet%2020130822.pdf

I spray general high performance water base, and I use a 1.5 mm tip

You should consider what type of spraying your doing .... You said you mainly do small to medium projects ....

I use both HVLP and LVLP because both have their pros and cons .

I use my HVLP on larger less intricate projects such as doors, backs and sides of wardrobes and kitchen cabinets and barfronts. The large fan ( spray guns usually spray the finish in a flat fan pattern ) and large quantity of finish applied means I can work very fast but if I slow down I'm going to get an uneven coat or if I hit my arm and stop for a second the finish will run. There is a lot of over spray from the HVLP system and you should spray in a well ventilated area preferably with some kind of extractor and no matter what type of system you use always wear a mask or resparators with the proper filters ...

And I use my LVLP for smaller and more intricate pieces. The LVLP system has a smaller fan and releases less finish so I don't have to move as fast as the HVLP so I can spray both sides on the front face of a round spindle on a stair case or child's cot. I also prefer this system for my smaller projects boxes and small frames etc etc. there isn't as much over spray from the LVLP but I'd still spray in a well ventilated area and wear a mask.

Also the thought of not having a compressor in my shop is insane !!! I have a 100ltr 3hp and I run everything on it pneumatic sanders and drills, dust blowers and my spray guns :)

I hope this helps

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.