Recommended Posts

Posted

I recently bought a Stanley spokeshave. http://www.amazon.com/Stanley-12-951-SpokeShave-Flat-Base/dp/B00002X1ZG/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1369833996&sr=8-1&keywords=spokeshave  I have some cabinet legs that I need to shape and figured this would be the best tool.  I get TONS of skipping.  I've tried pushing, pulling, skewing the tool, etc. without luck.  I have never been able to get a nice shaving with it.   The mouth is open quite a bit, but there is no way to adjust it, but I dont have any tearout, just skipping.    I'm looking for any advice I can get.

 

 

Posted

First, is it sharp? I don't think they come particularly sharp out of the box.

 

Second, I think those Stanleys will have the same problems as the Kunz spokeshaves - which is to say, they don't perform well. I got mine performing adequately once I flattened the bottom of the spokeshave, as well as removing the excess paint on and flattening the bed for the iron (and the back of the cap). Also, I find, generally, you have to take a very small cut.

 

Third... a spokeshave is a plane with a one in sole. It's going to skip and bounce. What's the profile you're trying to cut?

Posted

I've tried both with and against the grain, really anyway that I could.  The blade is honed to 8000 grit.   The legs are like these: http://www.woodcraft.com/Images/products/600/855393.jpg Nothing too complicated.  I cut them out with my bandsaw and was hoping to clean up the surfaces with the spokeshave. 

 

I did notice a small nick in the blade which I need to touch up, but it isnt anything that would cause my skipping problems.

Posted

I have a cheaper spokeshave as well and had the same problem, what I did was exactly what Baron said. The flattening of the bed where the iron(blade) sits is the most important thing, next is flattening the front edge of the cap so, all this is crucial so that the iron is held flat to the base with consistent pressure across the entire width of the iron. I am sure it would also perform a LOT better with an aftermarket iron, like a Hock iron, I was planning on buying one but decided on upgrading to a Veritas spokeshave instead, I get decent results with my cheapie but amazing results with my Veritas. New spokeshave $95, having the last cheap tool in the shop replaced-priceless! That being said doing the mods to my cheapie got me by for several years just fine and all it takes is a small file and ten minutes or so of your time.

Posted

I've found that the spokeshave (at least that type of spokeshave) is a very difficult beast to master, particularly if the cut is very wide. I very frequently get chattering - the blade vibrates and leaves behind little furrows about 1 mm (1/16") apart. Certainly a little bit of fettling goes a long way (I wrote a topic on an Italian forum, but I think the photos explain everything). There's also a video (comment #6) showing its use on a maple paddle - one of the very few decent videos I found on using spokeshaves.

 

Apart from the excellent advice from Baron and Nate, I'd suggest lubricating the sole (cadle wax in my case) and always make sure that the front of the sole is registered on the wood. The wider the piece you're trying to smooth the harder it is to avoid chattering. For a wide piece straight from the saw (rough), you might find it easier to use a rasp or course sandpaper on a block first (medium), before moving to the spokeshave (fine).

 

I use a fine sliver of wood, run over the sole, to adjust the cutting depth on each side. The finer the cut you can get, the better (but slower) the results. Sharpen more frequenty than less, a quick swipe now and then on the #8000 grit will keep you in business longer.

 

These thing have worked for me, though it doesn't take much, a slight lapse in concentration, and the chattering comes back. The following is purely conjecture (I have no personal experience) so should be taken with a heavy pinch of salt:

 

- I'd imagine that a bevel up spokeshave could give a better result (must get myself one), because I sometimes revert to a block plane for the outside curves with good results.

- Much as for smoother planes, perhaps a slightly cambered blade will help - I'll try this myself when I get a spare blade.

 

John

Posted

Thank you everyone for the advise and I'll do the things mentioned.   I messed around with it a little more last night.  I'm making a porch swing out of pine for a friend, so I practiced a bit on that nice soft wood.   On curved surfaced it seems there is a bit of technique to it and you really really have to pay attention to the grain direction.   Another problem that I think I was having is that I wasn't holding it firmly enough.   I found if I "limp wrist" it, like some people do with pistols, the spokeshave does not work well at all for me.   A firmer more deliberate grip makes a lot of difference.    It seems to make sense to me, when I compare it to using a regular plane.  On a regular plane the "firmness" is really accounted for in the weight of the plane itself. 

 

I'll take it apart this weekend and flatten and wax everything.  I need to touch up the nick in the blade too, its driving me nuts. 

Posted

Ditto to all of the above when dealing with a cheaper cast body like this.  There could be a lot of things tweaked that will give the blade a more solid foundation.  However none of that will do any good without a little attention to your technique.  It sounds like you are starting to figure that out in your last post.  The short sole of a spokeshave means that it is easier to flip forward onto the toe.  Some shaves have the handles positioned up too high making them tippy.  This model drops them down a bit which puts your force in line with the blade but then you tend to not put enough pressure down specifically on the wear plate directly in front of the blade.  Always use a light finger tip grip and when pulling place your thumbs on the blade to steady the body.  If you grap the handles in your palms you lose the sensitivity and can't tell where the pressure needs to be.  With such a short "wheel base" there is a lot of touch involved to keep the blade engaged just right as the grain may change or the curve radius changes.  In other words this is one of those touchy feely tools that requires a light touch and a sharp blade.  Your chatter may be attributed to all of the above points but as a new spokeshave user I bet it mostly can be corrected with a little practice and a light tough.

Posted

Just to update:  I took a file to it and flattened the bed and sole.  And I saw a couple little tabs sticking out from the casting that were causing the cap plate to not seat correctly. I filed those down too and that helped a bit.  I did resharpen the blade, the nick was driving me crazy.  I still get some tear out and skipping when use it on these cherry legs, but I am contributing that to technique.   Like pretty much all of woodworking it it is about acquiring skill, and that is where I am at with the spokeshave.  Hopefully some more practice will cut down on the frustrations.  Thanks everyone for the help. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.