m1chaelf Posted June 16, 2013 Report Posted June 16, 2013 I bought a Powermatic 23 shaper several years ago for dirt cheap, because the previous owner had switched motor direction while powered and burned up the motor. I've found a nearly suitable used motor, but it isn't reversible. Since I've never used anything but routers, can someone shed some light on why the direction of a shaper can reversed so I can decide whether to install the motor I've found or keep looking? Do all shapers reverse, or is this an extra feature? While I'm not fully committed to the decision, I'm leaning toward just re-selling the shaper once I get it working and putting the proceeds toward an 8" jointer. Thanks. Quote
Trip Posted June 16, 2013 Report Posted June 16, 2013 ==> why the direction of a shaper can reversed many shaper cutters can be used CW and CCW. ==> I'm leaning toward just re-selling the shaper once I get it working and putting the proceeds toward an 8" jointer. Most sharpers can be reversed. Anyone purchasing a Powermatic shaper will expect it to reverse. Quote
G S Haydon Posted June 16, 2013 Report Posted June 16, 2013 Hi Mi, We have a Wadkin EQ that reverses and it can be a useful feature. For us it's mainly when we have an awkward mold to do or we have doors with diminished styles to work on. Diminished stiles Be very cautious when using the shaper in reverse, the locking nut threads work the wrong way and want to come loose. Obtain a manual and check for the appropriate way to secure the tooling when working in reverse. Quote
rodger. Posted June 16, 2013 Report Posted June 16, 2013 It's probably also helpful in eliminating tear out, as you have control of the feed direction and the bit rotation. Quote
dwacker Posted June 16, 2013 Report Posted June 16, 2013 Climb cutting. Reverse for grain direction Cutter flipping / This important. You don't flip cutters or reverse without a keyed lock. The 23 was a boat anchor, not worth spending money on. Quote
tim0625 Posted June 17, 2013 Report Posted June 17, 2013 Climb cutting. Reverse for grain direction Cutter flipping / This important. You don't flip cutters or reverse without a keyed lock. The 23 was a boat anchor, not worth spending money on. Come on Particle....tell us how you REALLY feel.... Quote
dwacker Posted June 17, 2013 Report Posted June 17, 2013 Come on Particle....tell us how you REALLY feel.... sorry for the short post. I will try to elaborate now that Im back to a computer. First reversing a shaper is one of the benefits of owning a shaper and it makes no sense to own a shaper that doesn't reverse. BUT as GSHaydon mentioned the spindle nut can come loose. So if your thinking about running a shaper in reverse there needs to be a way to lock the spindle nut, double nutting is dangerous. Attached is a photo of one of my spindles you can see the spindle is keyed and the first spacer matches the key. The top washer is also keyed and that is because this spindle uses a bolt rather than a nut. The advantage to the bolt is that you can relieve your heads so that you can cut all the way across the top as in making long tenons. Now why I would not spend any money to fix up a model 23. First its called a shaper but really is closer to a router table in many ways. Starting with the spindles, 1/2" is to small for a shaper. 3/4" is acceptable but needs a few things to be of any real use. First 1/2 cant a have any decent under the nut capacity because folks get dumb and put spacers under the cutters which breaks off the spindle. 2-2 1/2" is about max for 1/2". 3/4 is better but you need a bigger table opening to get the use of any decent cutters. The 23 had a very small table opening this was to keep you from using bigger cutters because the spindle assembly was very light duty. The 23 was more like a router in that it had really no usable spindle travel. For a router you mount a cutter and push the wood over the cutter. With a shaper you mount the cutter and push the wood under the cutter, this is one reason they cut better. Attached is a tiny under cutter mounted on a little 3/4" spindle. For the non shaper user or router table guy that set up looks proper but in reality the cutter is mounted upside down and is to low in the table. The cutter should be above the panel surface. The table opening on the 23 is to small to mount as in the photo using a router configuration. But the under nut capacity and spindle travel is to small to mount properly. Your sort of screwed either way. Getting away from actual cutter capacity. The spindle mechanism is more along the lines of a cast PC 690 router. Which would be is some scary shit* if the machine had the capacity to use real shaper cutters. The overall size of the tables is tiny more along the lines of a small router table. The dust collection sucks or I should say doesnt suck. All this means your stuck using the machine to drive cutters that are really nothing more than over glorified router bits. Overall it would not be a wise investment to fix up the model 23. There are plenty of small inexpensive shapers out there that will do a much better job and cost about as much as fixing up the model 23. Even the little 1.5hp grizzly would be a much more versatile machine. 2 Quote
Tpt life Posted June 17, 2013 Report Posted June 17, 2013 For those without a router table setup, would this machine be acceptable as a "glorified router" as long as the limitations were known and the expectation was appropriate? Quote
dwacker Posted June 17, 2013 Report Posted June 17, 2013 For those without a router table setup, would this machine be acceptable as a "glorified router" as long as the limitations were known and the expectation was appropriate? If you wanted full use of a router table then I would say no. A cheap router table would be a better option if your going to use things like panel raisers, larger round overs and taller bits. The 23 only has about 3/4" of useful spindle travel and about a 3" opening. The model 23 was made in the days when the thinking was that a router was a freehand tool made for small bits. It was a step above a router but not really a shaper. Today we have big routers that are affordable. I would prefer a shaper over a router table any day but not this one. For the cost of a good motor and rehabbing an old machine you can have a good router table or a small modern shaper. If it wasnt broken already Id say keep it and use it for small edge profiling but since the motor is shot and you dont know what shape the spindle cartridge is in Id skip the repairs. 1 Quote
pghmyn Posted June 17, 2013 Report Posted June 17, 2013 If you wanted full use of a router table then I would say no. A cheap router table would be a better option if your going to use things like panel raisers, larger round overs and taller bits. The 23 only has about 3/4" of useful spindle travel and about a 3" opening. The model 23 was made in the days when the thinking was that a router was a freehand tool made for small bits. It was a step above a router but not really a shaper. Today we have big routers that are affordable. I would prefer a shaper over a router table any day but not this one. For the cost of a good motor and rehabbing an old machine you can have a good router table or a small modern shaper. If it wasnt broken already Id say keep it and use it for small edge profiling but since the motor is shot and you dont know what shape the spindle cartridge is in Id skip the repairs. Very well said. Quote
m1chaelf Posted June 18, 2013 Author Report Posted June 18, 2013 You have all made very good points, so if I can get my money back on the motor I bought, I'll drop my project. If not, do I cut my losses or continue on? I spent $35 for the shaper, $70 for a 3HP used motor, and would need to source a new belt pulley to match the motor's shaft size. As an electrical engineer, I've already torn the motor down and know how easy it is to bring the additional wires to the peckerhead to make the motor reversable. 3HP is overkill, especially for the spindle size, but I reckon the belt will slip before full load is applied. Therefore, the biggest disadvantage I see is the motor is only 230V (not convertable to 120 like the stock motor) and could draw a higher current if the motor ever does reach full load. After looking for 3 years, this is the first fan-cooled woodworking motor I've found locally. It came from a Jet tool. Thanks Quote
G S Haydon Posted June 18, 2013 Report Posted June 18, 2013 PB, The shaft sizes sound quite small. All of my spindles are 30mm. Would that be typical of a more industrial machine? Regarding the reverse, we have it but I don't find it as essential as you do. Just our blend of work I guess. Glad we highlighted the same safety issues on the reverse Quote
tim0625 Posted June 19, 2013 Report Posted June 19, 2013 Resell the shaper for the money you have in it. Shelve the motor...you'll use it for something. $70 isn't gonna break the bank. Quote
dwacker Posted June 19, 2013 Report Posted June 19, 2013 PB, The shaft sizes sound quite small. All of my spindles are 30mm. Would that be typical of a more industrial machine? Regarding the reverse, we have it but I don't find it as essential as you do. Just our blend of work I guess. Glad we highlighted the same safety issues on the reverse The spindle sizes are pretty small. For the most part 1 1/4" is standard thats 31.75mm for you. 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.