Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Air filter vs. better dust collector

Featured Replies

I have a delta 1.5 HP dust collector that does a decent job of collecting dust. There is still too much dust that escapes though. So I was thinking of getting an air filter or maybe upgrading my dust collector to a 3 HP. Which would be better?

My first recommendation, it's always better to collect the dust at the source with a dust collector.  I installed an air filter in addition to the dust collector because I found no matter how well the dust collector performed there was some airborne dust.

It would be helpful to know more about your current dust collection setup and woodworking equipment you are experiencing issues with.

What's the Delta connected to and which tools seem to be the worst offenders?  How big is your shop and how is the Delta connected to the tools in question?

My gut tells me that your collector is already moving plenty of air.  But sadly, the dust collection ports on many tools (chop saws in particular) are merely decorative.  If you want to fix the problem, then you're looking at either a.) upgrading the tools or b.) spending some serious time re-engineering how dust gets collected from the tools you have now.

I used my dust collector for a while without an internal fine filter cartridge. Some very fine dust still got through (you could see it around the metalwork of the collector flat surfaces). I replaced the standard filter with a new one and also at the same time added an internal micro filter. I no longer get any fine dust. The collector is 2HP and there was no appreciable loss of suction when the micro filter was added.

Its all about air volume. A 4" port is only going to move 450 cfm no matter how big the collector or hose going to the machine. If your moving the single hose from machine to machine you likely will not se any benefit by increasing HP. If you have a ducted system it will help. The fines are delt with at the collector. The filter can make a big difference but the lower the micron the less air flow so a double edged sword. 

My first recommendation, it's always better to collect the dust at the source with a dust collector.  I installed an air filter in addition to the dust collector because I found no matter how well the dust collector performed there was some airborne dust.

Pete, a few years ago I installed a "JDS Air Tech 2000" air filtration system for the same reason you did.  However, recently I heard that they do more harm than good because they actually keep the finer dust, that you really don't want in your lungs, suspended in the air.  I'm sorry I can't remember where I heard this, but it upset me because I thought all this time I was being safe by using it when in fact (possibly) I've been making things worse??  What do you think?  Am I miss understanding something here?  I've recently moved my shop and have not installed my unit yet, and now I'm thinking maybe I shouldn't.  What do you think?

Here's my understanding:

 

Dust extractors (shop vacs) are for removing the dust from tools with small hose connections, like sanders.

Dust collectors are for removing the dust from tools with large dust ports, like jointers (surface planers).

Dust masks protect you from the dust that gets past the dust extractors and dust collectors.

Air filters are for cleaning the air after you leave the shop.  Run them for a few hours on a timer.

Pete, a few years ago I installed a "JDS Air Tech 2000" air filtration system for the same reason you did.  However, recently I heard that they do more harm than good because they actually keep the finer dust, that you really don't want in your lungs, suspended in the air.  I'm sorry I can't remember where I heard this, but it upset me because I thought all this time I was being safe by using it when in fact (possibly) I've been making things worse??  What do you think?  Am I miss understanding something here?  I've recently moved my shop and have not installed my unit yet, and now I'm thinking maybe I shouldn't.  What do you think?

 

The inner filter on my Jet is 1 micron, which is pretty good.  It's the same as the filter on my DC.  I think the problem you are referring to has more to do with dust collectors that have 30 micron filters.  About the best filters you can get will go down to 0.5 micron.

  • Author

my shop is 23ft by 23ft with 8 ft ceiling. the dust collector is 1 micron filtration and connected to the tools with 4 inch drain and sewer pipe and flexible hose by the tools. I use a big gulp hood for my miter saw that definitely doesn't collect everything. I don't use the miter saw that much though. I have a ridged 4650 table saw with a 4 inch port on the bottom, but it spits dust off the blade at me and is probably the worst contributor of dust in the shop partly because it gets used more than anything else. the last big contributor is a grizzly 14 inch band saw.

Yup, you're in the same boat as me.  I'm breaking in a new table saw and need to replace the blade guard with something that will collect dust off the top.  As I said, expect to do some re-engineering and surgery on your tools if you want any prayer of keeping the dust under control.

I am not sure if you have explored the Wynn 35A options for addons to your existing DC.  If not, just google it up.  I have the microfiber option on a HF 2HP, and the airflow increased dramatically over the standard 5 micron bag.  

 

I have no idea how it compares to other models, but I don't have dust settling around the unit anymore, and air flow is noticeably better.  

Like Chris said spen the money (not alot) and get a wynn cartdidge. I have the same system he has and what a difference. Best to get the dust at the source.

my shop is 23ft by 23ft with 8 ft ceiling. the dust collector is 1 micron filtration and connected to the tools with 4 inch drain and sewer pipe and flexible hose by the tools. I use a big gulp hood for my miter saw that definitely doesn't collect everything. I don't use the miter saw that much though. I have a ridged 4650 table saw with a 4 inch port on the bottom, but it spits dust off the blade at me and is probably the worst contributor of dust in the shop partly because it gets used more than anything else. the last big contributor is a grizzly 14 inch band saw.

A 1.5 Hp does not have what it takes for a ducted system in a 23x23 shop. A 3hp cyclone barely makes the cut for a ducted system in a shop that size and that's with a max of two gates open at one time.

  • Author

Particle board, I forgot to say that I do have blast gates and only use one tool at a time. My tools are only on one side of the shop, so the ducting isn't spread out too far.

  • Author

Do you recommend 6 inch ducting instead of 4 inch?

  • Author

Chris h and jimmy kx250, I like the idea of the wynne filter. Are there any negative things about it? Will I get better suction even though its .5 micron compared to 1 micron? Does the 80/20 paper last, or should I get the nano?

Otis, I have the nano, I upgraded after talking with one of their sales people about the benefits.  Ironically, she was pushing the less expensive paper model, but I wanted the better filtration and air flow.  The $100 version has more restrictive airflow than the other two models.

 

Check out their website.  I know it sounds contradictory, but the 0.5 micron Wynn filter has much...much better air flow than the 5 micron bag that was on my unit originally.  The less expensive model has 100 sqft of filtration surface, while the nano has 274 sqft.  More sqft = better flow.  (HF bag has ~25 sqft)

 

EDIT:  I should mention that you will need either a separator or build a collet.  I had a separator / 55 gallon drum, so it didn't matter.

 

http://www.wynnenv.com/35A_series_cartridge_kit.htm

 

 

Wynn Environmental Sales Company

sales@WynnEnv.com

(215) 442-9443

 

From an economic stand point, it was ~$160 for the 2hp DC, and ~$200 for the nano filter with shipping.  So ~$360 for an good DC system.  I can't say how it compares to others because literally all the woodworkers I know with decent shops use the HF.  It's just a good unit, at a great price.  My understanding is that the grizzly 1HP has a filter, but their 2HP is the same bag system as the HF version.  Again, no experience with grizzly, so it could be a much better unit. 

 

As for ducting, I use 4" (PVC).  I am sure 6" would be better, but I can't justify it in my shop at the moment.  (Maybe the new shop, we'll see).  Shop size is ~400-500 sqft.  I am in the same boat, I only use one machine at a time.  I have the shop partially ducted, and then have a 25' flex hose to take it where I need it.  I am sure I lose airflow with all the bends and flex hose, but it still gets the job done well!

Do you recommend 6 inch ducting instead of 4 inch?

 

Your main duct should be the same size as your collector inlet. You can do a simple loss test. Throw a pile of sawdust on the floor. Go to your furthest from the collector gate and install a hose. Position the hose so that it just barely starts to move/suck into the collector. Mark that spot on the floor. Now connect just a hose to the collector and do the same without the duct. I think you will notice a big improvement without the duct. 

Since I liked PB's testing idea, and I am probably overdue for a filter cleaning, I decided to give the saw dust distance test a try.  I wasn't testing duct size, but instead filter vs bag performance.  Now, I should say there is nothing terribly scientific about the test, and no doubt shop setup plays a big part.  The Wynn cleared dust about 5" away from the flex line, and the standard bag cleared about 4" (just shy actually).  So rough math would suggest about a 25% improvement in air flow in my system. 

 

I am in no way shape or form an airflow guy, so that may or may not be an accurate way to test, but either way I thought I would share the results.  It was certainly interesting.  I would love to hear if others experienced similar results with other brands.

Pete, a few years ago I installed a "JDS Air Tech 2000" air filtration system for the same reason you did.  However, recently I heard that they do more harm than good because they actually keep the finer dust, that you really don't want in your lungs, suspended in the air.  I'm sorry I can't remember where I heard this, but it upset me because I thought all this time I was being safe by using it when in fact (possibly) I've been making things worse??  What do you think?  Am I miss understanding something here?  I've recently moved my shop and have not installed my unit yet, and now I'm thinking maybe I shouldn't.  What do you think?

 

The idea that an air collector keeps the finer dust suspended in the air longer and is therefore more harmful comes up every so often. Unless the air collector has a filter porous enough that it will catch 0% of the fine dust particles, or if the air cleaner's capacity is way undersized for the size of the shop, I find this hard to believe.

 

I have a JDS 750 in a shop that is 200 sq. feet. I immediately noticed a reduction in airborne dust after installing it.

 

It is true that the gold standard of dust collection is to trap all the dust at the source. It's also true that this goal is extremely hard to achieve, and because of that, you need a backup plan.

The idea that an air collector keeps the finer dust suspended in the air longer and is therefore more harmful comes up every so often. Unless the air collector has a filter porous enough that it will catch 0% of the fine dust particles, or if the air cleaner's capacity is way undersized for the size of the shop, I find this hard to believe.

 

I have a JDS 750 in a shop that is 200 sq. feet. I immediately noticed a reduction in airborne dust after installing it.

 

It is true that the gold standard of dust collection is to trap all the dust at the source. It's also true that this goal is extremely hard to achieve, and because of that, you need a backup plan.

Thanks W.P. - you've renewed my trust in my JDS, I will be installing it once again but will also work on better dust collection around my sanding bench.

One of the things that is nice about air cleaners is that it's easy to upgrade your air cleaner capacity, as compared to upgrading your dust collector. All you have to do is hang another air cleaner, and you have more CFM.

 

This was way nerdy of me, but I once did a back-of-a-napkin calculation on the effect of increasing the CFM of your air cleaner(s). The usual advice is to have enough CFM to circulate the air in your shop once every 10 minutes. My guesstimate was that this would take about 2 hours to clear out 99.99% of the dust. 

 

Given that my shop is on the small side, the CFM of my JDS 750 circulates the air once every 2-1/2 minutes. Running the same calculation showed me that it only takes 30 minutes to clear out 99.99% of the dust.

 

So I've become a big believer in adding enough air cleaner capacity to circulate the air more quickly than the quoted "once every 10 minutes". I can completely see the benefit in my shop. And again, it's really easy to hang a second air cleaner.

  • 3 weeks later...

Did some work with a water damage company once.  They had a couple of rules about their blowers, one of which was that the blowers needed to be spaced no less than 6 feet and usually about 8 feet apart.  The small blowers were used, because they improved the air flow throughout the room.  This tells me that one large air filter is not always the solution; sometimes you can get by with just a couple of smaller ones.  (In fact, i'm wondering if it's better to have a couple ones rather than just one...?)

 

To add capacity, you don't necessarily have to buy big, either.  You guys probably already know that I'm a big fan (get it?) of the filter duct-taped to the box fan.  quick, simple, 30 bucks and you've got added capacity.  (plus a nice breeze at the ankles.)

 

(The company also had a rule about the dehumidifiers: get the right sized one for the job.  There were three of the "big boys" in the basement.  Nobody wanted to use them unless you had to because they took a quarter of the space inside the van, but in the short time I was there, we pulled all of them out at least twice.  It was easier to just unpack the one than to unpack eight of the smaller ones to get the same effect.  I'd relate the dehumidifiers to the dust collectors.  Getting it "sized right" the first time will help immensely.)

 

-a caveat: my shop is too small for even a shop vac, and I've gone mostly hand tool anyway, so my Dust collection information is mostly on the theory side.

In order for a ceiling mount filter no matter the size to filter 99.9% of the dust it would have to be discriminate, meaning it rejects already filtered air and do it so quickly that no dust had a chance to settle. Air filters do some good right over a source like a lathe or sander. On the other hand they have an exhaust so they blow dust around the chances of the dust they blow circling the shop and getting back into the filter are slim to none. This is why most systems are vented to the exterior much like a spray booth.

Pete, a few years ago I installed a "JDS Air Tech 2000" air filtration system for the same reason you did.  However, recently I heard that they do more harm than good because they actually keep the finer dust, that you really don't want in your lungs, suspended in the air.  I'm sorry I can't remember where I heard this, but it upset me because I thought all this time I was being safe by using it when in fact (possibly) I've been making things worse??  What do you think?  Am I miss understanding something here?  I've recently moved my shop and have not installed my unit yet, and now I'm thinking maybe I shouldn't.  What do you think?

Late reply, sorry.  Air filters are a excellent source of clean air.  To take advantage of the clean air you should position the air filter so that it blows the clean air where you are so you can breathe it.  I positioned mine to blow at my sanding station where I have disc, horizontal belt and spindle sanders.  Each machine is connected to the dust collector to collect the dust at the source and the air filter blows clean air where I am standing.  I have 4 air cleaners in my 1600 sq ft shop providing clean air when and where I need it.  When I run all four on high it's a real windy shop (LOL). 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.