Recommended Posts

Posted

Ok everyone,

 

Please go steady this is my first video. The idea was to just get a basic feel of how to take a basic video, how to upload it and to gauge from you how much of a loser I look.

 

My topic of choice is Splitting a tenon vs Sawing a tenon.

 

I have split tenons before on large scale work, repairs on site or when a single end tenoner couldn't quite finish the tenon depth as I wanted. I always felt it was not best practice to split a tenon on account of the chisel following the grain and potentially causing an irregular finish.

All the text books that I have show tenons being sawn with a view to them fitting "off the saw" without any paring. On small rails I thought a saw would be quicker than splitting (for me at least). 

So to that end I shot a video. There is not much in it although as you will see I am quicker with a saw, just.

 

How do you cut yours, saw, split or a mixture?

 

Ok, now to add some caveats.

 

It's my first vid so the phone ringing and me saying bye to my bro would not be in a proper vid.

 

On the sawing, this is the first time I have used the saw. An ebay new but unused find, half the price of new. It grabbed harder on the cross cut so my first batch of shoulders stink as I'm still getting the feel of it.

 

I would work harder on close ups on proper vids, and give a voice over too. 

 

Yes i'm using a 20oz Estwing claw hammer, and FWIW on a plastic handled chisel I'm cool with it. I'm so used to the balance and it works well for me. 

 

I'm just cutting to gauge lines and starting the saw on the edge with no notch made by a chisel.

 

I know when I try to show the joint I don't line it up with the camera, like I said, it's my first ever so much to learn and get a feel for. 

 

I will add a colour version in a moment, let me know what you like best.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=upJPpClwXLU&feature=youtu.be

Posted

Wow!  For a first shot at a video, that was pretty good!

 

Obviously, color, voice overs, talking your way thru it, etc would make a difference but, awesome job!

 

Not sure what you're using for the microphone but, it did a really nice job!  I think you could have talked thru the video and had it pick up quite well.

 

Now, like with wood working, most of the time, if you don't point out the mistakes, most people won't see them :)

 

Fantastic work!

Posted

Thanks for the feedback TIODS

 

Microphone was just from the phone, a samsung galaxy S3

 

I like to be straight up with what's good and bad. My favorite video moments are when woodworkers cut a joint, knock it together and then angle it in such a way so you cant see the shoulder lines. Real LOL moments  :D. Much like me trying to cross cut a shoulder with a new saw  :lol:

Posted

As the owner of a recording studio for many years, I was really impressed with that mic...lol  Just goes to show that you don't always have to put out big bucks to get great results!

Posted

Oh yeah, the black and white is a nice touch. I don't need to know what color your shirt, saw, or wood species is.

 

If you can get that quality of video and sound from your phone, you are well on your way to making superb videos. Great job, Graham.

Posted

Oh yeah, the black and white is a nice touch. I don't need to know what color your shirt, saw, or wood species is.

 

If you can get that quality of video and sound from your phone, you are well on your way to making superb videos. Great job, Graham.

Thanks pghmyn 

 

My bench looks a little different from Mr Cosman's :)   

Posted

One of the cool things about video is not only that you can share it with others but that you can watch yourself and pick up some pointers.  A couple things I noticed are 

 

- take a look at your saw technique when you do the final (flat) cut on the cheeks.   You have a tendency to lift the back of the saw on the pull (return) stroke and so end up not only taking a deeper cut on toe at the initial part of the push stroke but then slamming down on the rear the saw toward the end of the stroke to compensate for it.  Working on taking a flat consistent stroke in both directions could aid your technique

 

- I love seeing someone who knows how to properly set a vice.  I get frustrated some times watching the videos of some "mentors" who use a *holding tool in a way that doesn't hold at all.  This include Paul Sellers in the mortise video that someone posted on this site.  I've seen several different guys - most seem to be hand tool guys - that are banging away on a piece and it's moving all over the place.  As far as I'm concerned that will affect quality of outcome.  Never saw the piece move in your video.  Take note, folks!  That's the way to set a vice.

 

Oh, and as far as the actual topic of your post, I have no problems with either the quality or execution of the video.  I am a little surprised to find that it was done with a phone and I think it's well thought out and done.  Color or not doesn't make a difference to me.  In fact, I think the B&W might actually be a little less distracting.

Posted

Hello Byrdie,

 

Thanks for being honest. I'm glad you touched on my technique. I think we all have some kind of crit when we watch a vid but are maybe afraid to say because you we don't want to offend. And BTW I'm not offended at all  :). I think the lift and slam problem was two fold. I don't often use a back saw and when I use a disposable panel saw I lift on the return stroke and then push forward again. This translates to a really exadurated lift and slam on the smaller back saw. I think the other part was "I will cut this tenon fast" . I will make sure these get improved on other vids.

 

Thanks on the vice compliment. I did let myself down a bit when I took some downward strikes on the last split tenon. Just got away with it as it was only a couple blows  :). I think some of the reason when the vice holds well is because it has softwood cheeks. Ply or hardwood does not grip so well IME. On the flip side they wear faster. Nothing to do with the quality of the vice. It's the cheapest quick release in the UK.

 

I was impressed with the B&W too. The resolution is lower on that as I was messing about trying to compress the file. I did B&W on my dovetailing guide and as you alluded too it focuses on the subject in hand quite well

Posted

Nice video Graham demonstrating two techniques. Having done both methods myself I prefer the saw method cleaning up with a shoulder plane or rabbeting block plane. Of course if I'm batching out many I use the table saw and tenoning jig (no dado stacks here ;) )

The video quality on both is great and, as somebody else already said, the sound quality is great too. I like the Pax saw as well I have a few of their products and am impressed immensely with the quality.

I like the bench hook idea on the end of the bench too. Is that removable on a couple of pegs or such like?

 

T
 

Posted

Graham, love the black and white video; much cooler than colour :-) look forward to some more.

Byrdie +1 on the Paul Sellers mortise video. I almost posted a comment in my recent post on whether I should cut mortises by hand...

Graham perhaps your next video could show how to cut the mortise...

Posted

I am going to write a new novel called "The Headless Carpenter." It will be about a guy who rides a horse...:-)

Voice over would handle all my comment. I notice you chisel more and split less than Mr Sellars. I assume with voice over that you'd cover this. Great first go, I think you are picky enough that by the time you are satisfied, most of the audience will be as well.

Posted

Thank you Terry

 

"I like the bench hook idea on the end of the bench too. Is that removable on a couple of pegs or such like?"  It's a strip of 12mm ply screwed to the bench  :) 

 

Thank you also Darren 

 

On my bench build I will show how I would chop a mortice. I really appreciate the feedback on the black and white film too. You guys have helped make the choice on using it for my bench build.

 

C Shaffer, Thank you for the amusing comment  :D

 

I split less as it you are able to gauge how the grain is working. I do point to some grain on the split out version which illustrates why I take it easy. I avoided my head being in the shot so you could watch the process. I will appear in the videos but the idea of doing a point of view film close to the tools seem appealing. I also noticed when my face is in shot I hang my mouth open which make me look real gormless. I will also make sure a good voice over is on there too.

Posted

Thank you Terry

 

"I like the bench hook idea on the end of the bench too. Is that removable on a couple of pegs or such like?"  It's a strip of 12mm ply screwed to the bench  :) 

 too.

Simplest are the best :)

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.