Llama Posted July 21, 2013 Report Posted July 21, 2013 Hey there! Another question as I delve deeper into hand work. My main question is what the advantages over modern nails? I know I need to drill a pilot or use a gimlet. Quote
calblacksmith Posted July 21, 2013 Report Posted July 21, 2013 Cut nails and hand forged nails bite better into the wood and hold better, however traditionally though the nails were longer and extended through the work then were clinched or bent over on the far side of the work, the hold was excellent but by today's standards the looks are not acceptable. Pilot holes are not needed. What caused you to ask about cut nails? Is there a specific look you are after? 1 Quote
Trip Posted July 21, 2013 Report Posted July 21, 2013 ==> Pilot holes are not needed. depends on the wood species... Quote
Llama Posted July 21, 2013 Author Report Posted July 21, 2013 I'm asking because I'm making a pine milk painted cabinet. I recall reading about them, but I'm not sure if that's what I need. I'll post pics of the project. Quote
Llama Posted July 21, 2013 Author Report Posted July 21, 2013 Pallet Wood... Very rough mock up. Rear panel bead detail... This is as far as I got in a few hours. From pallet wood, to all pieces jointed and planed smooth. I even beaded the joint on the back panel for effect. This is basically a Shaker inspired tool cabinet. I will be painting this piece with Milk Paint. I wanted to keep it as traditional as possible. I am not working off a plan, just my memory from an episode of Woodwright. He said they (Shakers) started with the back, and made the other pieces comply to that. So, in that spirit, I took some pallet wood I had, removed the nails and just went at it. Freestyle! The piece is roughly 48 inches tall, and about 20 inches wide. I will add some shelves, likely nailed in from the side or with a dado. Quote
G S Haydon Posted July 21, 2013 Report Posted July 21, 2013 Like cal says I would say the holding ability. Although not all cut nails were clenched (classic area for clenching is on ledged and ledged & braced doors) they were not always clenched. If you have ever tried removing a cut nail from a floor board/joist you will know exactly what the extra holding ability is all about. Like H says piloting depends on the wood, closeness to the edge or ends of the boards. I have used cut flooring brads, (name defines the use). Cut Clasp used as a standard fixing on old joinery and second fix carpentry and finally Rose Heads, normally uses in boarded door construction of feature period work. Compare those with things like, lost heads, oval brads and wire nails (although much nicer to use on very fine trim) Perhaps that's why ring shanks were invented? Look forward to the project Mel, sounds really authentic Quote
Llama Posted July 21, 2013 Author Report Posted July 21, 2013 Thanks! A quick eBay search provided more types of nails than I ever thought existed! Cheap too... It will be an authentic made by me piece Easy working with pine instead of that flame maple I have It's almost like cheating! 1 Quote
Tom King Posted July 21, 2013 Report Posted July 21, 2013 I use them all the time in my restoration work. I wouldn't say they hold any better than a wire nail. Since they are tapered, one blow against the taper will generally break one loose. When I need to buy new ones, for outside work, I get hot dipped galvanized from these guys: http://www.tremontnail.com/index.htm I have a big collection of old ones, but we don't typically reuse them for outside work. They come in all sizes-from tiny little things for 1/2" wide molding, to about 4" long. Ones in flooring are as not as thick as any other uses, so they didn't have to predrill above the tongue, although the flooring nails are still pretty long. It's about impossible to save the old flooring nails. If you put one near the end of a board it does need a predrilled hole. Hole size is limited to the width of the nail the narrow way, and put the wider way with the grain. Quote
jHop Posted July 22, 2013 Report Posted July 22, 2013 What caused you to ask about cut nails? Is there a specific look you are after? There was something from Schwarz not long ago about cut nails / forged nails. Quote
calblacksmith Posted July 22, 2013 Report Posted July 22, 2013 I guess I was a bit too, sweeping in the no pilot hole comment, I stand corrected as I do with clinching. I have only used them in a door/frame application and was not thinking in a cabinet application, sorry for the confusion. The cut/hand forged nails I have used seem to hold better and it has always been told to me that they did. I suppose that the information I had received was more romantic than factual, I was told that the cut/forged square nail, cut the wood fibers rather than wedge them out of the way. That may be true for the side of the nail but the height would be a wedge. Quote
G S Haydon Posted July 22, 2013 Report Posted July 22, 2013 Cal, I think I'm with you on the cut nails holding better. Only based on the experience of having to pull them out (and failing) Quote
Tpt life Posted July 22, 2013 Report Posted July 22, 2013 Having pulled literally tens of thousands of nails of all varieties I respectfully disagree. Cut nails pull much easier under force than symmetric shaft nails do with the exception of very smooth finish hand drive nails. What is not consistent in the majority of these discussions is the timber out of which we are pulling the nails. Many make claims based on apples and oranges petrified virgin timbers. Cut nails are a uniquely different tool than symmetric shaft nails and this is sometimes desirable based on those properties but I would never tell a customer they hold better. At times however, I would say they can draw better to cure certain deformities in a board. Quote
G S Haydon Posted July 22, 2013 Report Posted July 22, 2013 Thanks for the contrasting view C. I guess like you mention it depends on context. What kinda stuff have you been ripping them out of? Perhaps it's, corrosion or the wood shrinking tight (bit of long shot perhaps) or even the ease you can get a wrecking bar under the head of a wire nail whereas a cut nail is harder to get purchase on. I know that builders have used cut nails for fixing into lightweight masonry blocks. Some one needs to do some tests, or we have a fiiiiiiiiight, which ever you like This person has found the same issue I have experienced I like this article (nice and biased as he's selling them) How dare you argue with the Schwarz One more view to add (biased again) This thread looks like it has the potential to become more contentious than a sharpening debate Quote
calblacksmith Posted July 22, 2013 Report Posted July 22, 2013 UH, to me they always felt like they held better but I did not want to "stir the pot" I CAN say that forged nails are square because that is the least expensive way to forge them, when we forge a taper, you do it square, you can see square and you keep the grain structure of the metal straight. To go round from square, you form the square to octagon by forging the points of the square down and making 8 equal sized flats, THEN you go round but you only rotate the stock 180 deg, you do not keep turning it round and round, you go 180 so that you keep the grain straight, if you keep going around, then you will cause the grain of the metal to twist like a cork screw. When you have made a few (hundred) you get to the point where you can make them in one heat. 1 Take the stock from the forge. 2 forge a single sided taper to a point, length of taper is variable depending on how long you want the nail to be. 3 Move to the hardy and cut 3/4 of the way through the stock at the desired length. 4 Insert nearly severed nail into nail header plate and twist off the bar of stock and return to forge. 5 With 3 or 4 blows angle and set the head of the nail. 6 Turn nail header over and drop finished nail into bucket (preferably one that will not burn) then start at 1. Do this over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over........ until you fill the keg. Nails were a stock in trade. If you did not have a paying job, you made nails. It was a rare customer who came in to buy one nail, they wanted kegs of nails and they wanted them now without waiting. YMMV! 1 Quote
Tpt life Posted July 22, 2013 Report Posted July 22, 2013 If you drive modern wire nails into the virgin poplar that is replete in the farm houses around here, wait 80 to 130 years for oxidation and then do your stress test. The other test that will yield apples to apples is to use a cut and a wire in the same new project wood. What you will find is that Schwartz missed a major factor. <gasp> Many who claim superior holding of cut nails are referencing projects that were nailed green. The fibers were more pliable. They bent or compressed far more easily. But beyond this, the timbers shrank onto the nail as the lumber dried. We try to replicate the success of the old timers and we never get the purchase the original nails did because the timber is now stable, the lumber is already shrunk and the cut nails are oxidized into the wood fiber. My $0.02 Quote
G S Haydon Posted July 22, 2013 Report Posted July 22, 2013 UH, to me they always felt like they held better but I did not want to "stir the pot" Stir away Cal, one thing is for sure this forum is populated with balanced people who although may have different views, still respect each other. C, I think you are on to something with the corrosion and green wood. TBH I don't think I nail enough to say unequivocally which is best. Cuts look nice though Quote
Llama Posted July 22, 2013 Author Report Posted July 22, 2013 I agree with the comment about green wood and corrosion. Just makes sense For what it's worth, I used "regular" nails for this little cabinet. It's for the shop and the look isn't as important as it would be if it were an interior piece. I did get my milk paint today! Soldier blue! I may leave the interior unpainted. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.