DaBear Posted September 4, 2013 Report Posted September 4, 2013 Just trying to make sure I have accurate expectations. Building a bunch of endgrain cutting boards for my wife (Real Estate agent, uses them as closing gifts.) and having some 'fun' with my drum sander. Once I have my boards glued up, running them through the drum sander to get read for final finishing. Starting with 36 grit to get everything level and get the last of the glue off. I've been reasonably good at getting the glue-ups aligned well, and most of the extra glue scraped off ahead of time, so this step seems to go pretty good. I flip back and forth until both sides are flat, but obviously still pretty rough at this point. My problem comes next... For my next step, I go to 80 grit paper, and I'm able to get rid of the scratches left over from the 36 grit, but the 80 grit leaves 'gouges' of it's own. I don't see any buildup on the paper, and I've tried several different pieces and they always have some sort of 'defect' like this. I'm guessing it's just a spot where there might be a small 'blob' of grit on the paper. Using VERY light cuts, and not seeing any indication of burning. In any case, to get rid of these lines, I'm forced to use quite a coarse paper on my orbital sander (I jump down to 60), then I can start moving back up the grits.. To be clear, these aren't huge gouges, but when you'd trying to sand them out of endgrain maple, walnut and purpleheart, it doesn't take much... My questions are: 1. Does this sound 'normal', and am I just asking too much of the tool? 2. Is there a 'premium' paper I can get to avoid this, or do I just need to go to a slightly higher grit as a 'third step', say 100 grit? Both? 3. Any other things I should change? For reference, I've used both Jet branded paper and some third party stuff I picked up at 'Busy Bee' (seems to be roughly the Canadian Harbour Freight..) I can't see a difference. Hope this all makes sense, thank you all in advance... David Quote
wtnhighlander Posted September 4, 2013 Report Posted September 4, 2013 I'm making a guess here, but the 'gouges' you see may be exacerbated because they are in the end-grain. I can't offer any solution except maybe follow the 80 grit with one step higher on the drum sander, if you can do that. Also make sure you have the best dust collection you can get in the machine, so the debris doesn't cause extra scratches. Quote
wdwerker Posted September 4, 2013 Report Posted September 4, 2013 I go 36 grit, 60 grit, 80 grit, 120, 150 grit for end grain boards. Tiny adjustments each time. I use cloth backed abrasives from Peachtree Woodworking( Chinese import stuff). Feeding too fast or not cleaning any resin build up will cause burns. If you make them in batches and start with the most uneven board and take small bites you can get them pretty smooth with just the drum sander. I use a random orbit sander afterwards starting at 120 grit, 150, 180 and maybe further but it is not much improvement past that. Quote
dwacker Posted September 5, 2013 Report Posted September 5, 2013 Give Kingspor a shot I keep 80 on my infeed drum and 120 on the outfeed. So far its been the one thats perforfomed the best and lasted. Quote
wdwerker Posted September 5, 2013 Report Posted September 5, 2013 Klingspor sandpaper is good stuff. I just found that the stuff I could buy locally plus tax was cheaper than Klingspor plus freight and lasted about the same. I usually ended up discarding a strip because of a burn long before the abrasive wore out, your results may vary. The blue zircon sandpaper is wonderful but it was hard to get and expensive. Quote
TRBaker Posted September 5, 2013 Report Posted September 5, 2013 You might also check to make sure your drum is clean. A small spot under the paper will telegraph through. Quote
T-astragal Posted September 5, 2013 Report Posted September 5, 2013 36 grit will leave a deep scratch. 80 grit scratch is about 18/1000. 120 gr is about 10/1000. My guess is that you need to make multiple 80 passes to fully eliminate the 36. Then take off more than 18/1000 with 120. Being end grain you would benefit by the next step of 150 gr. it is normal for us to orbital sand with 150 to improve wide belt sanded 180 surfaces. Steve Quote
DaBear Posted September 5, 2013 Author Report Posted September 5, 2013 Ok, some great feedback. Just to be clear, I'm making multiple passes on the 80 grit, enough to get rid of the scratches left by the 36, and all the lines are left by the 80. I can tell this by changing the angle I put the boards through the sander, the lines follow the new orientations. Some points I'm going to work on here: 1. Get some 100 or 120 grit belts, maybe even a 150. 2. Make sure the drum is absolutely clean, along with the back of the belt when I put the new paper on (never thought of this, but makes complete sense..) If anyone has any further suggestions or comments, keep 'em coming Thanks to all.. Quote
dwacker Posted September 5, 2013 Report Posted September 5, 2013 Also look at your rolls. Some companies will label J weight cloth as drum sander use. X weight is what your looking for. Quote
DaBear Posted September 5, 2013 Author Report Posted September 5, 2013 Also look at your rolls. Some companies will label J weight cloth as drum sander use. X weight is what your looking for. Thanks.. Quote
krtwood Posted September 6, 2013 Report Posted September 6, 2013 The same grit on a drum sander leaves a much worse surface than what you get hand sanding, while that same grit on a ROS gives you a better surface than what you get hand sanding. So going from the drum sander to the ROS it's totally normal to have to go back up to a coarser grit. Just because it's the same grit doesn't mean it behaves the same when you use a different type of machine, or your hands. Quote
Tpt life Posted September 6, 2013 Report Posted September 6, 2013 With "economy" belts and drums, gouging has almost always been a fault of crappy seam designs. The cheaper the belt, the more you can feel the cyclic vibration as the joint rides around. Quote
wdwerker Posted September 14, 2013 Report Posted September 14, 2013 Drum sanders usually have a spiral wrap of a strip of cloth abrasive. Mine uses a strip about 3" wide and 7 ft long. If you wrap it wrong or too loosely it can overlap. That causes the abrasive to load up and puts burns and gouges in your wood. With cheap sanding belts the most common problem I have found is joint failure. Quote
DaBear Posted September 16, 2013 Author Report Posted September 16, 2013 Ya, ran into an 'overlap' scenario a while back. I've since tried to ensure I always have a small gap between wraps (a 16th or so), and try to check after a couple passes to re-tighten. Seems to have eliminated that issue.. Another question for you folks on this same vein: Is 'jumping' grits nearly as much of a concern in case of a drum sander? Currently, I go from 36 to 80, and it seems fine (other than the streaks left by the 80, but I don't see anything that tells me going to 60 in between would help at all). I want to now go to 120 from 80, so I will be using 3 grits, 36, then 80, then 120.. Crazy? Quote
dwacker Posted September 16, 2013 Report Posted September 16, 2013 Ya, ran into an 'overlap' scenario a while back. I've since tried to ensure I always have a small gap between wraps (a 16th or so), and try to check after a couple passes to re-tighten. Seems to have eliminated that issue.. Another question for you folks on this same vein: Is 'jumping' grits nearly as much of a concern in case of a drum sander? Currently, I go from 36 to 80, and it seems fine (other than the streaks left by the 80, but I don't see anything that tells me going to 60 in between would help at all). I want to now go to 120 from 80, so I will be using 3 grits, 36, then 80, then 120.. Crazy? Jumping like that is fine on a single drum. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.