halbrn Posted October 11, 2013 Report Posted October 11, 2013 I found a 3 phase table saw and am wondering how can I use this in my garage shop with basic residential power. Quote
dwacker Posted October 11, 2013 Report Posted October 11, 2013 You will have to buy a phase converter. Quote
halbrn Posted October 11, 2013 Author Report Posted October 11, 2013 ok so I did a quick search and now am wondering how difficult this would be to add Quote
dwacker Posted October 11, 2013 Report Posted October 11, 2013 ok so I did a quick search and now am wondering how difficult this would be to add Its not hard if you have some experience wiring motors and magnetic switches. On the other hand a motor shop will do it for you for very little money. You just have to weigh it out cost wise. Quote
halbrn Posted October 11, 2013 Author Report Posted October 11, 2013 is there any converter you would specifically recommend, I did a search and found north America phase converters for 5hp for about 430$ Quote
dwacker Posted October 11, 2013 Report Posted October 11, 2013 is there any converter you would specifically recommend, I did a search and found north America phase converters for 5hp for about 430$ Look at rotary converters. It doesnt make any sense to buy a 3 phase saw 5+ hp and only have about 3 hp that you would get with a static converter. Even Grizzly has some good prices onRotary converters. Quote
halbrn Posted October 11, 2013 Author Report Posted October 11, 2013 ok good to know. didn't even think about grizzly. thanks Quote
halbrn Posted October 11, 2013 Author Report Posted October 11, 2013 so I did some more looking around and was wondering if it would just be easier to buy a single phase 5hp motor separate for another 300$ now im wondering if I can just buy the motor and put it in a pm1000 Quote
Tpt life Posted October 11, 2013 Report Posted October 11, 2013 This really depends on your future plans. A one time investment in a rotary converter can open you up to the used 3 phase market which is typically less competitive as many people walk wide of them due to a lack of 3 phase supply. Quote
dwacker Posted October 11, 2013 Report Posted October 11, 2013 so I did some more looking around and was wondering if it would just be easier to buy a single phase 5hp motor separate for another 300$ now im wondering if I can just buy the motor and put it in a pm1000 Not sure why you would put a 5hp motor in a pm1000. For the most part if you are talking about just one tool your better off swapping motors. I dont think I would try the 5hp in the pm1000 I dont know if its has the internals to handle that sort of work load. Ive seen them real quick in the WW store and it looks like they downsized most everything. Quote
Trip Posted October 11, 2013 Report Posted October 11, 2013 ==> I did a search and found north America phase converters for 5hp for about 430$ You must be careful about specs for 3phase rotary converters – they are kind of like HP specs – i.e. misleading… Rotary 3phase converters have two key specs: how many HP they can run and how many HP they can start. The former is about 3 times the latter… Marketing literature/websites typically lists the 'run HP' rather than the 'start HP' (it's a bigger number). For example: a 3phase converter speced as 15/5 could run several motors at a time up to a total of 15HP simultaneously, but only be able to start one motor up to 5HP at a time… If a converter is only speced with a single HP, then it's almost always the 'run HP'... ==> 5hp for about 430$ I doubt you can source a 15/5 for $430… Maybe a 5/3 for that $$... ==> Not sure why you would put a 5hp motor in a pm1000. +1 ==> A one time investment in a rotary converter can open you up to the used 3 phase market which is typically less competitive as many people walk wide of them due to a lack of 3 phase supply. +1 Not worth getting a 3phase converter unless you plan to add more tools, then it may be worth it to get into the 3phase tool market. Quote
halbrn Posted October 12, 2013 Author Report Posted October 12, 2013 The table saw I'm looking at is 5hp so I'll have to look more at the specs for a converter. Thanks guys Quote
wtnhighlander Posted October 12, 2013 Report Posted October 12, 2013 A 3 phase rotary converter is basically a 3 phase motor fed with single phase power. When energized and caused to turn, the rotation causes an appropriatly phase-shifted voltage to appear on the third motor lead. Using this, along with the original two leads provides three-phase power, but at quite a cost in efficiency. For long term use, I think I would recommend replacing the motor on your tool. 1 Quote
halbrn Posted October 12, 2013 Author Report Posted October 12, 2013 That's kinda what I was thinking. I wrote the wrong model earlier, I could buy this table saw and put a 5hp 1 phase motor in and I wouldn't even come close the the asking price of a table saw with the motor already in it Quote
PeteJr Posted October 13, 2013 Report Posted October 13, 2013 Craigslist the 3 phase and get a single phase as wtnhighlander suggested Quote
calblacksmith Posted October 16, 2013 Report Posted October 16, 2013 3 phase motors are actually better to use than single phase. They last longer, don't have a starting cap or the switching circuits to wear out. In addition, though you will not use it on a table saw, ALL 3 phase motors are very easily reversed in rotation, so for tools like lathes, all you need is a switch to reverse the motor. In fact, the PM 90 lathe I just bought, came with a single phase motor that was bodged into it, it also came with the stock 3 phase motor, off to the side. I reinstalled the 3 phase motor as I have the ability to run it. In addition, now there are VSD controls, these electronically convert single phase to 3 phase and allow you to vary the speed of the motor while keeping full power from the motor. This is how the modern variable speed lathes work, this is what I am going to add to my PM lathe to bring it up to date. On smaller motors, like the lathe, the control is only about $150 to run a 1 to 2 HP motor, they even have the reverse ability built into the control so no additional switches are needed. Rotary phase converters are really easy to make. A 3 phase motor, a voltage sensing relay and a few caps are all it takes. Ideally you use a larger motor than the one you want to run as the idler motor but one the same size will work. I found this site to be a huge help when making my converter, (some 25 + years ago now!) all you need and more is here, provided you can work with electric circuits. I now have most of my machines running on 3 phase. Table saw, band saw, mill, lathe and disc sander. All are X industrial machines and all were purchased for much less than the single phase versions run because, if a hobby person sees it, they say to themselves, I have to replace the motor to run it so the true cost is XXX more $, thus they do not pay as much so you will not either. I have been running my equipment like this for over a quarter century and have never had any problem with the 3 phase motors running this way. http://www.metalwebnews.com/electric.html The specific article I used, and I now am producing true, balanced 3 phase power, was http://www.metalwebnews.com/howto/ph-conv/ph-conv.html You need not go through the whole voltage balancing thing, a simple starter will work but if you do go through the whole thing, the produced power is for all practical use, the same as commercial 3 phase power. If you hunt a bit you can find the parts at good prices. Oil filled run caps last for a long, looong, loooooooooong time and can be purchased used for a fraction of new price. I used a voltage sensing relay to kick the start cap in and out of the circuit, it was about $20. In short, you can, if you are handy, make the same or better quality rotary phase converter for a fraction of the price that the retail companies charge. Hope this helps! Quote
wtnhighlander Posted October 17, 2013 Report Posted October 17, 2013 As an engineer working in heavy industry, I can certainly agree that using three phase motors is better, IF you have the power supply for it. I just don't think that attempting to drive a three phase motor from a single phase supply is an efficient way to go about it. Sure, it works, but I wouldn't do it my own shop, especially for a single tool. If I was working wood for a living, then I'd pony up for three phase service to my shop and do it up right. If you do decide to try the phase converter, commercial or home made, be sure to account for power loss in the converter itself, and don't overload your feeder circuit. Quote
Trip Posted October 17, 2013 Report Posted October 17, 2013 ==> I'd pony up for three phase service to my shop and do it up right. No arguments there... But some utilities won't provision 3p to residential zoning... Quote
T-astragal Posted October 17, 2013 Report Posted October 17, 2013 ==> I'd pony up for three phase service to my shop and do it up right. No arguments there... But some utilities won't provision 3p to residential zoning... That would be cool. A cool 20 grand. Steve Quote
Trip Posted October 17, 2013 Report Posted October 17, 2013 ==> 20 grand 20K to provision 3p? That must be some run... Quote
T-astragal Posted October 17, 2013 Report Posted October 17, 2013 Gotta bring it in from the nearest supply. Need 3 transformers a new main power can, breaker box and circuits. That's about what it was going to cost me to upgrade to 480 3 ph. Steve Quote
Trip Posted October 17, 2013 Report Posted October 17, 2013 ==> Need 3 transformers a new main power can, breaker box and circuits. When we needed new service, we got the transformers reimbursed by NJ Small Business Credit Initiative.. Most states have a similar program.... Quote
T-astragal Posted October 17, 2013 Report Posted October 17, 2013 The city ended up bringing in underground service a few years later. But still all of my side of the work would have been 5 figures. My service is old school high leg 120/208/120 3 ph. It would have to be completely replaced. And I'd need a step down transformer to run all my low voltage motors. Steve Quote
calblacksmith Posted October 18, 2013 Report Posted October 18, 2013 As an engineer working in heavy industry, I can certainly agree that using three phase motors is better, IF you have the power supply for it. I just don't think that attempting to drive a three phase motor from a single phase supply is an efficient way to go about it. Sure, it works, but I wouldn't do it my own shop, especially for a single tool. If I was working wood for a living, then I'd pony up for three phase service to my shop and do it up right. If you do decide to try the phase converter, commercial or home made, be sure to account for power loss in the converter itself, and don't overload your feeder circuit. I agree 100% that if it is available, commercial is the best way to go. However, that should not keep anyone from using 3 phase equipment in a home or hobby shop, I have been running metal and more recently wood working machinery on my own generated power since about 1987 and have had NO problems with either de-rating HP or any other issue, save a little noise from the fan cooled idle motor running as a 3 phase generator. I am using caps to balance the voltage on the lines and the result is perfectly acceptable, full power 3 phase. I have the motor setup as a generator and I have outlets wired along the wall just as you would with commercial power. I am just curious as to why you would not "make your own". There is no right or wrong and each person needs to do what is best for them, I am just wondering why it is not an option you would not pick. Quote
tim0625 Posted October 18, 2013 Report Posted October 18, 2013 halbrn....phase converters are expensive (rotary phase converter) or they're inefficient (static convertor). If residential 3 phase power to your shop is possible where you live, it's still expensive and not worth all the hassle. You have a nice saw, and if you're not a 10 hour a day production shop, just buy a new motor for your saw---chose from 3-5hp. I bought my Grizzly saw with 5 hp because it was about the same price as a 3 hp and like "Tim the Tool man" I said, why not??? Most of these guys (and gals!) here do great work with a lot less HP. My 5 HP will probably only 'have to put its back into it' if one day I saw some 12/4 hardwood......and that's a maybe. Keep life simple and make lots of dust. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.