Recommended Posts

Posted

Tim, I made my rotary converter for under $100 so they need not be expensive and the positives from 3 phase motors outweigh the slight expense of the operating cost of the converter. To that, now there are VSD converters for as little as $150 for 1 hp (as the motor get larger, the converters get more expensive) that electronically do the conversion from 1 to 3 phase and allow the speed of the motor to be altered while keeping the full power output of the motor. A table saw will not need to run in reverse or to alter the speed but a lot of machines do gain a lot from these abilities, such as a lathe, drill press etc.

 

Just a wild guess (not directed at anyone or any comment) and it can be WAY off the mark but I suspect a lot (not everyone by any means) of the reluctance of some to use 3 phase is because it is not something they are used to and it just seems like too much bother to deal with.  I know I was in that camp until I just "did it" and now I don't even have a second or third thought about it. YMMV!

Posted

Cal...I'm thinking like this, ..many of us (most?) do not have your skill level with the electronics....it's good that you do!  I mean that...and you save a lot of money by knowing things like this.... and to you, this stuff is simple but to many of us (most?) it is like re-inventing the wheel to learn this. You can see Halbrn's initial question and know that he's a lot more into wood than electricity.  Halbrn, that's NOT a swipe at you....and you've come to a good place to ask questions like this; but if I'm right, for you to undertake something like making your own phase converter, it would involve a lot of learning and learning a lot of basic electronics/electrical knowledge that Cal finds simple and he's interested in.  I have a delta 48" wood lathe that belonged to my father in law. He died, his shop burned, the lathe survived. Mother in law was tickled that I rebuilt it.  I have WAYYYY too much money in it!!!!!!!! As long as I'm down this Golden Brick Road this far, might as well go all the way to the castle.  I found a 1HP, 3 phase motor for $25 at a motor shop that was closing.  I talked with the Tec people at Grainger Industrial supply for a total of about 3 hours before I bought a Variable Frequency Drive (VFD) that varies speed of the motor by varying the 60 Hz frequency of the 220V input. It retailed for $508 but through my Farm Bureau Insurance member discount, I got it for $388. Yay??? :blink:   Say hello to my golden wood lathe. Halbrn could instead buy a VFD but for a 5HP motor, and use the residential 220voltage, but it's serious bucks!!! and the main function of a VFD is to slow the RPMs so it doesn't make sense. Point....it took a lot of research, time hooking everything up, and MONEY to make my 79 years old mother in law dance....and she did...really....she danced... and true, I now have a sweet lathe set up.  But...I have a background in electronics and am interested in this kind of stuff so it made (some) sense; but unless Halbrn is really interested in learning things like this, he's probably better off just retrofitting the saw with a new 110V or 220V motor and start making dust. BUT ME???? I WANT TO KNOW MORE ABOUT YOUR MAKING YOUR OWN PHASE CONVERTER!!!  :) :) So we'll talk because 3 phase power is a good thing but unless you're a production shop, it may not make sense except its part of what we like to do in addition to making dust. 

Posted

==> I'd pony up for three phase service to my shop and do it up right.

 

No arguments there... But some utilities won't provision 3p to residential zoning...

aahhh... but if I was making a living at it, I probably wouldn't still be in a residential garage ...

Posted

I just recently had the same problem. My table saw had a 5hp 3-phase motor. I researched my choices and I ended up going with a static phase converter off ebay. I know nothing about wiring but this converter had you watch a you tube video and I was able to wire it no problem. I was alright with the power loss because of the cost savings. I think it cost about 120. The only problem I have had and its just happened twice in 6 months is under heavy use for extended periods the convert or my switch will over heat and will shut off. This has only happened cutting 2" plus thick boards for 2 plus hours. 20 minutes off cooling and back to normal. I plan to buy more 3 phase machinery and will end up getting a rotary converter at some point.

Posted

Anyone interested, YouTube "make your own rotary phase converter" or "homemade phase converter." Several build descriptions in easy to understand imagery (not all are gifted speakers.)

Posted

==>  I probably wouldn't still be in a residential garage ... 

 

That's to true...  but 3ph isn't strictly for the commercial shop...   some folks around here do have some pretty sweet hobby-come-small-business shops, run 3ph and don't necessarily work out of their garages...

 

I've posted this one before, but it's always a good watch --- take a look at Ken't shop --- http://www.popularwo...nt-adkinss-shop ...

 

Marc's WW site also has a 'shop tour' section with several impressive setups... 

 

So if you want 3ph and can't get it from the utility, then a rotary generator is simply one way to go...  But as I've said before, if you've only got one 3ph tool, then it's probably more cost effective to convert to single phase.

Posted

As a retired engineer, I have dealt with 3 phase motors for many years.

The advantages of 3 phase motors are varied and many.

 

To use a 3 phase motor on residential power the most expiditious method is to purchase a small variable frequency drive.  Most of these can be supplied with single phase power and output 3 phase power.

They convert the incoming AC into DC then convert it back to AC by one of several methods so that they can adjust the frequency.  What this gives you is the ability to convert a fixed speed motor to a variable speed motor.  This could be particularly useful for something like the use of those sanding disks on a table saw.  Prices can vary from a couple hundred $ to several thousand $ depending on features/quality et al.  Your neighborhood industrial electrical distributor  can probably fix you up pretty quickly.

 

As with anything dealing with electrical conversion you will lose efficiency over a straight 3 phase hook up.  Most 3 phase motors will hook up to 240/480/600 volts.  Just make sure that the circuit you hook it up to has enough amp capacity.  For a 5 hp motor you will need a 40 amp circuit.

Posted

For those who are into serious pain and can sit through any poor video, I did a shop tour, it turned out to be a 4 part at 15 minutes each :o There is an overview part 1, wood stuff part 2, forging equipment part 3 and electrical/bandsaw/welding in part 4.

 

I started by just turning the camera on and talking, it seemed to be about 15 minutes but it went nearly an hour. You can see an overview in the first 5 or so minutes then it moves to machine shop, grind setup then to storage of wood tools.

 

The whole thing isn't for the faint of heart but it will at least show my toys and the thing that ties it to this discussion is in part 4 it shows the 3 phase conversion setup. The phase converter is at about 4 minutes into the last video.  The video puts me to sleep but then I have seen all this stuff before.

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9k9owLgKHSU

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J5FXcd_30Jk 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C25dQQdcC28

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xN4r2awj2dc

 

 

Allenc, I am sure you understand what is happening with your saw, as the motor is putting out less HP because the voltage on the third leg is missing, the motor has to work pretty hard to get the job done.

 

If you can get another motor the same size as your saw (bigger is better but smaller will help more than nothing) and wire that motor to run in paralell with your saw, you will get more power from the saws motor with them both running. 

 

This is because when a 3 phase motor runs, it acts like a generator on the phase that is low on power. A motor sitting on the floor, not doing any work but just sitting there turning, will generate a voltage into the missing phase of power, it will only be about 2/3 voltage but it will be there and that will help power the table saws motor.

 

It can be made much better and improved but in the rough form that is all a rotary phase converter is, a motor running with no load. Use the static converter to start the idler motor and let it run then just turn the saw on when you want to run the saw. You have just made a rotary converter.

Posted

As woodworkers we tend to be a resourceful bunch. Often driven to learn esoteric arts to enable us to complete a project that we are working on. With that in mind, I am sure each and every one of us can probably look back on a time where we had to think outside the box or learn a skill that may have had nothing to do with woodworking per se, to do just that.

 

In a recent project I learned to work sheet metal, having never done so before, and was able to make some simple boxes all the way up to a triangular pyramid with both ends open - all out of one piece of sheet metal! The project was a roll your own dust collector with distributors.

 

Point is, if you want 3 phase, there is a way to do it, go for it if you think you will need it. Don't know how to do it? As was pointed out, there are a lot of resources available to you to learn and there are a great bunch of pro's over at diychatroom.com in the electrical department that can fill in the specifics if you need them.

 

Good luck and be safe with electricity!

Posted

 

I am just curious as to why you would not "make your own". There is no right or wrong and each person needs to do what is best for them, I am just wondering why it is not an option you would not pick.

That would be my personal choice because:

A - building or buying a converter will likely cost more than changing the motor.

B - using a converter means one more piece of equipmemt to take up space and maintenance time.

C - in the case of home made, I have to be the one to fix it if it breaks (even though MY education and experience allow for that, not everyone's does).

D - As a small-time hobbyist, I don't see enough benefit to go through that much hassle. Call me lazy, but I'd rather be making sawdust than fiddling with home made electrical devices. Again, in a commercial shop, 3 phase is the best route for sure. Some hobbyists might find benefit in it as well, I'm just not one of them.

Posted

calblacksmith,  Thanks for the explanation I have a vague grasp on whats going on.  I was mainly trying to share my experience with the poster.  I plan in the future to have a rotary phase converter once I have another machine that is three phase.  I am just a hobbyist and it works fine for me now.  I figure what I did was the cheapest and easiest option and I wanted to share my results.  Over all I am happy with my saw and performance, if I wasn't going to have any more 3-phase machinery I think would just replace the motor with single phase and be done.  But for the time and money to get my saw up, going and making dust I am really happy.  

Thanks Allen

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 67 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined