tdale51@yahoo.com Posted January 22, 2014 Report Posted January 22, 2014 Hey all, Currently, in my router table I have a PC 690. Within the next year or so I'd like to build some raised panel doors. I know this router is not recommended for a standard raised panel bit but what do you fine folks think about this router with a vertical bit? Assuming multiple passes of 1/8" or less are made. Quote
wdwerker Posted January 22, 2014 Report Posted January 22, 2014 Nope! Tough router , I have about 6 of them, but not strong enough for raising panels. Or if you do it will shorten the life of the router considerably. I have cut miles of 1/4" by 1/4" grooves with one in a table with power feeder , even broke a few bits. But I would not use a long heavy bit with one. You need at least 3 hp. Quote
dwacker Posted January 22, 2014 Report Posted January 22, 2014 I wouldn't use a panel raising bit horizontal or vertical in any router. That being said vertical bits were made years ago long before 3hp routers. This was back when manufacturers claimed that you could not use a horizontal bit in a router. So yes you can use the vertical bit but the results are not great and you have to take many passes. Quote
pghmyn Posted January 22, 2014 Report Posted January 22, 2014 Vertical bits are just terrible. My dad has one, I used it for a project, and I had to take 4-5 passes in pine bought from the big box store. I was using one of those cheap delta shaper/router table things. I think it's 2-2.5hp. The thing works great with a horizontal bit, but the vertical is wretched. Quote
dwacker Posted January 22, 2014 Report Posted January 22, 2014 Vertical bits are just terrible. My dad has one, I used it for a project, and I had to take 4-5 passes in pine bought from the big box store. I was using one of those cheap delta shaper/router table things. I think it's 2-2.5hp. The thing works great with a horizontal bit, but the vertical is wretched. Anytime you raise a panel with a cutter under the wood the results are not great. With the vertical bits they need to be sharp and you need a heavy hand on your work piece to hold it tight against the fence. Quote
pghmyn Posted January 22, 2014 Report Posted January 22, 2014 Anytime you raise a panel with a cutter under the wood the results are not great. With the vertical bits they need to be sharp and you need a heavy hand on your work piece to hold it tight against the fence.Sharp enough to shave my arm hair at first, but as soon as it dulled just a LITTLE it was agony getting the job done. I also had a slough of feather boards holding it tight. I do have a horizontal bit that is about 3-3.5" in diameter. It's a different story with that bit. Just works like a dream. Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted January 22, 2014 Report Posted January 22, 2014 My older router table setup used two different Bosch 1617EVS' as the motor. In multiple passes it worked just fine, but it obviously took a lot longer than a shaper. For example, using a 3 1/2" Freud bit, I took 4-5 passes in hardwoods, and 3-4 in MDF. The first and last passes were often much lighter, but you have seek a happy medium to prevent burning certain woods. Too heavy of a cut really degraded the quality, and added "unwanted adventure". If doing it for a living, or I was making more millwork, I'd do it differently and spring for a shaper, but I've successfully made 100-120 raised panels in a router table since the early 90's. I use MDF and Masonite table and fence shim plates to change the cutting depth without changing final settings. My 1617's seem beefier than my 690's, but I've never tried the 690's in a table. I did manage to kill a 690 slotting composite decking for hidden fasteners, using three-wing slot cutters. The poor thing did well, dulling many cutters in many feet of decking before dying an honorable death one August afternoon... An interesting side note is that same cutters, seemingly regardless of size, in the same table, leave me a far better surface once I replaced the smaller 1617's with a Milwaukee 5625. Even smaller cove and roundover bits leave a far smoother surface. Quote
woodbutcher74 Posted January 22, 2014 Report Posted January 22, 2014 I think you need a variable speed router for the large raised panel bits. PC 690 is not. That's way too many RPM's for that large of bit. IMO Quote
dwacker Posted January 22, 2014 Report Posted January 22, 2014 I think you need a variable speed router for the large raised panel bits. PC 690 is not. That's way too many RPM's for that large of bit. IMO Vertical its are not large and are made to run on small low HP routers. Speed needs to drop with increased diameter. The major diameter on a vertical is usually an inch or just over. They are made for 1 1/2 hp and up routers. Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted January 22, 2014 Report Posted January 22, 2014 There is (was?) a variable speed version of the 690... If it's not the VS version, using a horizontal panel raiser at 27,000 RPM could be thrilling! Good point to those who mentioned slowing the router down... Quote
Janello Posted January 22, 2014 Report Posted January 22, 2014 Question for PB! Would you still advise against using a good quality horizontal bit, such as a whiteside or freud quadra-cut on a router table under the following circumstances? A.) Router Table has phenolic top and is new flat and in good overall condition. B.) Router is a Porter Cable 7518 31/4hp 15amp. used on recommended RPM setting for bit size. C.) taking multiple passes because time is not a factor Although I know this isn't the optimal set-up for production, what I really am asking is can it be done safely under these circumstances? Quote
dwacker Posted January 22, 2014 Report Posted January 22, 2014 Question for PB! Would you still advise against using a good quality horizontal bit, such as a whiteside or freud quadra-cut on a router table under the following circumstances? A.) Router Table has phenolic top and is new flat and in good overall condition. B.) Router is a Porter Cable 7518 31/4hp 15amp. used on recommended RPM setting for bit size. C.) taking multiple passes because time is not a factor Although I know this isn't the optimal set-up for production, what I really am asking is can it be done safely under these circumstances? Yes you can do it safely. Production times aren't everything profile and cut quality are important. The cut will suffer as will the proportions of the profile to the stiles. Router cut doors look off the profile proportions are to small. You could use either style they both have the same draw backs. Just choose a profile you can sand easily. Quote
Janello Posted January 22, 2014 Report Posted January 22, 2014 Understood. Thanks for your opinion and advise. Quote
Tom King Posted January 22, 2014 Report Posted January 22, 2014 If you are going to do it with any kind of router, and any kind of bit, hog most of the wood out of the way on the table saw with a tall vertical fence first. Quote
tdale51@yahoo.com Posted January 24, 2014 Author Report Posted January 24, 2014 Thank you all for confirming my suspicions. I just pulled the trigger on a 7518 and a woodpecker PRL-V2 router lift. Guess I'm going whole hog . Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.