bobcrosley Posted January 27, 2014 Report Posted January 27, 2014 I have a friend having a local handyman redo their bathroom shower. I saw the in-progress state last week and a few things didn't look right. Rather than bring it up on the spot and create a potentially-unnecessary battle with the handyman (who is also their friend) I thought I'd see if anyone here could let me know if what I saw was OK. I know that often, there's a difference between 100% by-the-book and 'good enough to get the job done.' But some of this looked like a potential future problem. The shower is being tiled with 12x12 porcelain tiles. The grout line would be 1/4 inch or so, requiring sanded grout. On the wall where the shower head was, he had cut out most of the existing drywall and replaced a section with the purple, moisture resistant drywall. However, he didn't replace the entire wall. He went up to just under the shower head and all the way to the back corner of the shower. In the front edge of that wall, where the glass doors would be attached, he stopped short about 6-8" with the purple drywall. Regular drywall that was existing went all the way to the front edge. It looked like he was just focused on putting moisture-resistant drywall where water was most likely to hit. There was about a 1/4" gap between the regular drywall and the moisture-resistant drywall. He did not tape and mud the gap, instead, a 12" tile was straddling it. The tiles were glued directly to the drywall. There wasn't any type of rubber membrane or moisture barrier like I've seen used in the DIY shows. (But I also know that sometimes those shows are just intent on showing a sponsors product.) I've done a lot of tiling, but never a shower. But to my untrained eye, it looks like it's only a matter of time before water seeps back there and causes a mess. Am I right on this? Or is this accepted practice? Quote
Tpt life Posted January 27, 2014 Report Posted January 27, 2014 In my experience you are right to question. I would not accept any of what you describe. I am so used to seeing cement board backer in showers with those joints filled. Quote
Freddie Posted January 27, 2014 Report Posted January 27, 2014 Grout isnt waterproof, should be cement board behind the shower. Your friend will eventually have oatmeal for sheetrock holding those tiles up. Quote
Dave H Posted January 27, 2014 Report Posted January 27, 2014 You get what you pay for, when doing any job be it tile or roofing or what ever you always consider the worst case scenario, it doesn't sound like this guy has done that. I would have used hardie board for backer I would never have went directly over dry wall that stuff wheather it is water resistant or not eventually turns to snot when water infiltrates between the tile and, the drywall. But the question is do you want to get involved between friends this friend trusts the handyman so if it was me I would just ask questions like "I was watching a DYI show and they used Hardie board for backer instead of drywall wouldn't that be more water proof, I'm just curios". Than once that's out in the open let them figure it out wash your hands of the whole thing unless your friend asks for your opinion. Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted January 27, 2014 Report Posted January 27, 2014 +1 more "No cement board?" Quote
bobcrosley Posted January 27, 2014 Author Report Posted January 27, 2014 I have no idea what was there before. I literally never saw the bathroom. It's a friend of my wife's, and this bathroom was unusable for years. They're just now redoing it. Quote
sjeff70 Posted January 27, 2014 Report Posted January 27, 2014 No one seals grout in the shower so it will leak eventually, especially with a 1/4 inch grout line. Mike Holmes thinks using only cement board is minimum code, and because of that never uses it or advises it. If anyone knows Mike he always installs a Schluter shower system! But since it's already built I would thinset a Schluter waterproof membrane over the drywall/resistant drywall, then tile. You can get a roll at Lowes, but it is a little pricey. But so is redoing the shower every 5-10 years because of a moldy shower. Quote
PaulMarcel Posted January 27, 2014 Report Posted January 27, 2014 When I prepped my shower for granite, I ripped the drywall off, tacked up plastic, covered in backerboard. The drywall has no place there. The lack of backerboard is definitely a red flag. For one, if you are installing tile on the bathroom floor, you are required to put a waterproof membrane down in case of an overflow with standing water. That's for a floor in the off chance water sits there awhile; a shower is worse! As you mention, it'll be sanded grout; at least unsanded is more like caulk, but I wouldn't trust that, either. We had a "pro handyman" live across the street. When he moved, completely coincidentally, friends of mine moved into his house. It is a disaster of half-ass repairs and 'improvements'. I think some people think they can be a pro handyman if they DVR the DIY channel. Quote
sjeff70 Posted January 27, 2014 Report Posted January 27, 2014 Yea, you would think a show dedicated to home improvement would occasionally have some good advice. Generally speaking, people really have to look behind the intent when they want to empower themselves. Quote
Jerry_in_SD Posted January 28, 2014 Report Posted January 28, 2014 When we redid our master bath years ago, I did all the work except the actual tile work. Our very good tile guy instructed to put up green board with a layer of cement board on top. We did not bother taping and muding the joints however. I'm sure the thinset filled those small gaps. Quote
TerryMcK Posted January 28, 2014 Report Posted January 28, 2014 +1 on a waterproof backer board Quote
dwacker Posted January 28, 2014 Report Posted January 28, 2014 We used Kerdi membrane and have had good luck. The developer I do work for suggested it and has never had a problem. We had ours done by a professional. Quote
sjeff70 Posted January 28, 2014 Report Posted January 28, 2014 It's good stuff PB, completely waterproof. Tom Silva says you don't even have to tile over it. How colorful would that be? Anyway, I wouldn't try that with cement board! Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.