Recommended Posts

Posted

Hi :)

 

I've been looking at getting a nice router table setup recently. 

 

Here is my question...

Should I spend $300 for the Porter Cable router motor that everyone loves and another $350 for the router lift, or will I be just as well to get a Triton router for $250 that has the built in lift system?

 

All the reviews I have read seem to point towards the Triton being a very good choice, especially in a hobby setup like mine. Full on production, I can see needing the Porter Cable unit with lift.

 

Thoughts?

Posted

I'm not familiar with the Triton that has the built in lift system.  I'm gonna go out on a limb and assume it's going to be nowhere near as accurate or convenient as one of the top-of-the-line lifts.  That assumption could make me look like an ass, but it's mine nonetheless. :)

 

The PC 7518?...the 3.25HP one...is almost universally considered the router table king.  I've heard about a few problems with the speed switch going bad...other than that...crickets.  Mine is still going strong, no issues.

Posted

Hi :)

 

I've been looking at getting a nice router table setup recently. 

 

Here is my question...

Should I spend $300 for the Porter Cable router motor that everyone loves and another $350 for the router lift, or will I be just as well to get a Triton router for $250 that has the built in lift system?

 

All the reviews I have read seem to point towards the Triton being a very good choice, especially in a hobby setup like mine. Full on production, I can see needing the Porter Cable unit with lift.

 

Thoughts?

Full on production neither but both are fine as far as routers go. The PC can be had as motor only to save a few dollars. I think a good lift is worth the investment.

Posted

Full on production neither but both are fine as far as routers go. The PC can be had as motor only to save a few dollars. I think a good lift is worth the investment.

 

Poor choice of words on my part.

 

Perhaps, really enthusiastic hobbyist :)

 

This is why I am torn... I know I would be happy with the PC and a nice lift and for basically twice the money. The thing I don't know, is would I be fine with the Triton, with money left over to buy something else, like my Incra fence.

 

I don't mind spending the money on the PC and lift is there is a definite advantage. But I don't want to spend needlessly either.

Posted

The price difference in lifts may dictate quality in the fine adjustability of the lift. I would read reviews on the triton and see how the well the lift works. If its a pita to walk it into a setting with no effort, then it will not be a worhwhile investment.

Posted

Exactly Freddie.

I don't know... Most reviews I've read say the Tra001 is great for table use.

I would expect a difference in quality between the internal mechanism on the Triton and a nice lift like the Jessem/Incra lift I'm eyeing up.

How much of a difference in actual use? I don't know.

Posted

Hmm, interesting.  I'll stick with my ASSumption that it will be lacking in one way or another, but it definitely appears to be a budget-friendly option.  What about the plate, though?

Posted

The Incra plate can be ordered to fit it. Just have to use 1/4x20 screws the site says.

I like the Incra plate with the magnet inserts. Any issues with that Eric?

I don't want to come across as a budget seeker either, I sure don't mind spending money :) I prefer to spend it where it matters though.

Posted

Lifts are rigid well the good ones anyways. The plunge parts don't really seem to compare in terms of strength. I really see it more of an improvised solution rather than a long term purchase.

Posted

I like the Incra plate with the magnet inserts. Any issues with that Eric?

 

 

Nope, love it.

 

Be sure to figure in the cost of the plate...now the table tilts.

  • Like 1
Posted

I have had the Triton for a few years. Had to replace the switch. Triton guys in Canada were great to deal with. It works great for what I need it for. Need to drill a hole in the plate for an above table adjustment. (Just drill the hole in the right place. Don't ask me how I know this.) It has plenty of power and doesn't seem to be a pain to set up for me. I don't have the PC so no comparison here.

Posted

I have posted a couple of times about switching future plans from the PC to the Triton. This week I put my money where my mouth is. I got the TRA001 and the Kreg plate (predrilled) and the Kreg levelers. Total cost of $320 plus tax, plus I got the Triton palm belt sander for free.

I just installed the plate in a new router table top a few hours ago, and hope to have the carcass built this weekend. I'm designing it tonight and tomorrow morning.

There is a minute amount of play up and down when you set the height, but gravity should render that moot. The Kreg plate is great, I love not having to use a screwdriver to remove the rings.

I think where the Triton shines is the automatic spindle lock. I will be loving that.

Sent from my HTC One using Tapatalk

Posted

 I have the 7518 mounted in the jessem excel 2 and love it. There is zero slop, and with the wixey digital readout on it, it's extremely accurate. The only thing I'm not particularly in love with is jessem's fence system, I think a center slide fence like incra has would be a lot nicer.

Posted
Unknown. I haven't even plugged it in yet. Unfortunately I don't have one of those bits to test. Sent from my HTC One using Tapatalk
Go play with it. :)

I have the 7518 mounted in the jessem excel 2 and love it. There is zero slop, and with the wixey digital readout on it, it's extremely accurate. The only thing I'm not particularly in love with is jessem's fence system, I think a center slide fence like incra has would be a lot nicer.
Exactly the reason I am building my own table. :)
Posted

Tomorrow. :)

There is the plunge lock. That could be the difference.

Sent from my HTC One using Tapatalk

 

I can't wait to hear your review on this. 

Posted

I can't wait to hear your review on this. 

 

Some picture thingys to tide you over:

 

IMAG0246_zpslxac7qxe.jpg

 

Kreg plate is the same in long dimension, one inch wider in the short than a Rockler plate. Kreg is thicker because it is phenolic vs the aluminum. Kreg is thicker than a Grizz/MLCS/Harbor Freight phenolic plate. All the holes lined up perfectly. It has two winder holes; assuming that the little brother Triton is just a touch different.

 

IMAG0250_zps53qcb1f5.jpg

 

Testing the mounting. Perfect.

 

In the box is the router, manual, wrench, 1/2" and 1/4" collets, wide base plate and I assume a edge accessory for the plate. The wide plate is huge. The insert plate came with all necessary mounting hardware including longer screws to capture the router. The levelers came with 8 threaded levelers, 12 course thread 1.25" pocket screws, and a short Robertson bit (that was a nice bonus).

 

IMAG0253_zps81gvmfxy.jpg

 

Bought the project panel 3/4" and 1/2" MDF from Home Depot, as I generally hate MDF but love it for router tops. Haven't decided on how long the table will be, but as you can see it will be offset to use with an Incra Positioner (17). Still some more work to do, but a good start to get a router table back in the shop.

  • Like 1
Posted

Looks like a nice setup! I will be purchasing the Incra 25" pretty soon, only because it's about the same price as the 17". Other than that, it looks like we have a very similar idea.

 

I have way too many things going on right now to even think about this, but that's how I am :) I have to keep moving!

 

And before Eric says something, I'll get moving on my FrakenShaker bench soon! :) 

Posted

 

 

And before Eric says something, I'll get moving on my FrakenShaker bench soon! :)

 

Ferris Bueller would say, "A man with priorities so far out of whack doesn't deserve such a fine router table." :D

  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.