Llama Posted March 1, 2014 Author Report Posted March 1, 2014 lol I can't even find the time to get my shop organized. It is driving me nuts! I plan on getting the boxes ready for finish, and doing some organizing this weekend. Once the boxes are delivered, I will continue on the bench. Commissions have to come before personal projects. I'd say my priorities are ok. Quote
wdwerker Posted March 1, 2014 Report Posted March 1, 2014 The built in lifts are not as accurate or long lasting as the separate units. Have had a couple of built in lifts die or have parts fail. Never had a moments trouble out of my Rockler lift( built by Jessem I think) . I can move a bit up or down 128th of an inch in seconds and it stays there until I change it. As to the PC 7518 Multi speed motor and it's predecessors I have one that is 20 years old and going strong ! Quote
Tom King Posted March 1, 2014 Report Posted March 1, 2014 I have one of the big Tritons and 4 7518s. The PCs cut much smoother, And the built in lift mechanism is a PIA more than it's worth it to me. I have the Triton in a saw wing, and keep,a 3/8s spiral bit in it to run a quick dado with if I need to. Otherwise, My first preference is one of my router tops that you might have seen. I'd rather twist a 7518, than fight the Triton lift. I set the 7518s to the thousandth in the sash job in amazinglynquick order just by twisting the stock mount. The Triton works okay when it doesn.'t have any sawdust in it, but that's not often. it might just be the one I have, but it has never run really smoothly. I'd just as soon it was back where it came from, but it was a gift. I'd never buy another one at any price. Quote
Cochese Posted March 1, 2014 Report Posted March 1, 2014 Shame, that's the first negative review I've read on it. I suppose nothing's perfect. Quote
Freddie Posted March 1, 2014 Report Posted March 1, 2014 Holy crap, I just watched the incra video. At what point does it become machine operating and no longer woodworking! All ya gotta do is watch a 6 hour video, read a 400 page manual, then you're all set to start turning knobs. Quote
Eric. Posted March 1, 2014 Report Posted March 1, 2014 At what point does it become machine operating and no longer woodworking! CNC 1 Quote
Freddie Posted March 1, 2014 Report Posted March 1, 2014 CNC Yea and this is the next closest thing Quote
tim0625 Posted March 1, 2014 Report Posted March 1, 2014 Holy crap, I just watched the incra video. At what point does it become machine operating and no longer woodworking! All ya gotta do is watch a 6 hour video, read a 400 page manual, then you're all set to start turning knobs. I have the Incra router table and fence system with an Incra lift and a Makita 1101 that has a soft start. The instruction books are well written and easy to follow. It really is as easy as Mark (bearded man) demonstrates....he's just in hyper speed. His statement is that he "has made thousands of dovetail boxes" with it. Guess you get quicker uh? I also have the TSLS system for my TS. No more bump and measure. Set the fence using the hairline cursor and cut....dead on every time. It's a neat system. I think Eric is right though....the next step would be CNC. I'm kind of like you Mel...."enthuiasist hobbyist"....unlike Particle and many of you, I don't do this for a living so a Makita 2 1/4HP router is sufficient for me. At the rate I go, it will probably last a lifetime but I put more money in a tool sometimes not just for the durability, but for the quality. My time is limited so when I go to the shop, I DON'T want to spend time fighting a tool because I wouldn't spend a few more dollars and get the one with the bugs worked out. I hear you guys talking about fighting things like switches on routers and micro-adjustment features. The heck with that....spend a few more dollars up front and enjoy your time in the shop. Don bought a Grizzly TS (TS?) and didn't like it and sold it at a loss....ok for what he's doing, the Grizzly wasn't high enough quality. That's understandable but for me, it's fine. Ok heck, if a PM or a Stop Saw falls in my lap, heck yeah I'll upgrade but for what I do, it's fine. Quote
Eric. Posted March 1, 2014 Report Posted March 1, 2014 Yea and this is the next closest thing It's just a dovetail jig with more options...still requires a brain and manual operation in order to achieve the desired effect, as opposed to pushing a button and sitting down with a beer. Is a Leigh jig the next closest thing, too? Is a HCM the next closest thing because the same result could be had with a chisel and a mallet? I draw the line at full automation. As long as you're physically participating in the task, it's still woodworking. Quote
Freddie Posted March 1, 2014 Report Posted March 1, 2014 It's just a dovetail jig with more options...still requires a brain and manual operation in order to achieve the desired effect, as opposed to pushing a button and sitting down with a beer. Is a Leigh jig the next closest thing, too? Is a HCM the next closest thing because the same result could be had with a chisel and a mallet? I draw the line at full automation. As long as you're physically participating in the task, it's still woodworking. Ruffled feathers, mission accomplished! 1 Quote
rodger. Posted March 1, 2014 Report Posted March 1, 2014 I have a 3.5 hp Freud plunge router in my table. I removed the springs, and it works great. I don't have a lift, but it's easy enough to reach under and turn the large knob without bending down, or even looking. In my opinion, I would rather spend the 400 dollars that a lift costs on something else. The plunge router stays where i set it, and can be adjusted with great accuracy. Quote
Llama Posted March 1, 2014 Author Report Posted March 1, 2014 Pug, I probably have the same Freud router you do. I've thought about using it, but couldn't seem to find information about using it in a table. Which model do you have? Quote
rodger. Posted March 1, 2014 Report Posted March 1, 2014 Pug, I probably have the same Freud router you do. I've thought about using it, but couldn't seem to find information about using it in a table. Which model do you have? It's an older one, and I have the instructions somewhere for how to remove the springs and use it as a table router. Let me dig around a bit, and I'll repost. Quote
Bobby Slack Posted March 1, 2014 Report Posted March 1, 2014 I own a Freud 3-1/2 HP router and works well enough. Like you decided to buy the router's height adjustment capabilities. Quote
rodger. Posted March 1, 2014 Report Posted March 1, 2014 Okay here is the article/instructions on removing the springs for table use. My router is the FT2200VCE. The instructions are for either the FT2000 or FT2200 series. http://www.freud.ca/PDFs/SpringRemoval.pdf Quote
Llama Posted March 1, 2014 Author Report Posted March 1, 2014 Okay here is the article/instructions on removing the springs for table use. My router is the FT2200VCE. The instructions are for either the FT2000 or FT2200 series. http://www.freud.ca/PDFs/SpringRemoval.pdf Thank you! Quote
Llama Posted March 1, 2014 Author Report Posted March 1, 2014 Mine says it's the LR106530, but it came with the FT2200/FT2000 manual. I'm guessing I got a newer version of that one. Mine is red and black. Quote
Cochese Posted March 1, 2014 Report Posted March 1, 2014 I have the Incra router table and fence system with an Incra lift and a Makita 1101 that has a soft start. The instruction books are well written and easy to follow. It really is as easy as Mark (bearded man) demonstrates....he's just in hyper speed. His statement is that he "has made thousands of dovetail boxes" with it. Guess you get quicker uh? I also have the TSLS system for my TS. No more bump and measure. Set the fence using the hairline cursor and cut....dead on every time. It's a neat system. I think Eric is right though....the next step would be CNC. I'm kind of like you Mel...."enthuiasist hobbyist"....unlike Particle and many of you, I don't do this for a living so a Makita 2 1/4HP router is sufficient for me. At the rate I go, it will probably last a lifetime but I put more money in a tool sometimes not just for the durability, but for the quality. My time is limited so when I go to the shop, I DON'T want to spend time fighting a tool because I wouldn't spend a few more dollars and get the one with the bugs worked out. I hear you guys talking about fighting things like switches on routers and micro-adjustment features. The heck with that....spend a few more dollars up front and enjoy your time in the shop. Don bought a Grizzly TS (TS?) and didn't like it and sold it at a loss....ok for what he's doing, the Grizzly wasn't high enough quality. That's understandable but for me, it's fine. Ok heck, if a PM or a Stop Saw falls in my lap, heck yeah I'll upgrade but for what I do, it's fine. That's the reason I went with the Triton over my current router. The Craftsman routers are some of the best power tools you can buy at Sears (I know, jokes galore). However I haven't been happy with table use with them. Handheld is brilliant. I hated trying to engage the collet lock, the height adjustment was spotty (motor would drop down alarmingly when the lock was disengaged - there is a fix, but I never took care of it). I'm hoping that this will make my life a lot easier. Quote
rodger. Posted March 1, 2014 Report Posted March 1, 2014 Mine says it's the LR106530, but it came with the FT2200/FT2000 manual. I'm guessing I got a newer version of that one. Mine is red and black. You may be reading the serial number instead of the model number. Here is what mine looks likehttp://www.freud.ca/English/Pages/Tools/Routers/Routers2.html Quote
Llama Posted March 1, 2014 Author Report Posted March 1, 2014 You may be reading the serial number instead of the model number. Here is what mine looks likehttp://www.freud.ca/English/Pages/Tools/Routers/Routers2.html Could be. I'm out of place trying to look at power stuff. I am used to hand planes You are right! It's a FT2200VCE. I never knew that Quote
rodger. Posted March 1, 2014 Report Posted March 1, 2014 Could be. I'm out of please trying to look at power stuff. I like hand planes You are right! It's a FT2200VCE. I never knew that Excellent. This means that the directions will work for your router, if you choose to place it in the table. Quote
Llama Posted March 1, 2014 Author Report Posted March 1, 2014 That's what I'll do! It's too big for handheld use. I'll use it until it dies, then get the PC and a lift. No need to let it sjt Quote
Llama Posted March 7, 2014 Author Report Posted March 7, 2014 That's the reason I went with the Triton over my current router. Any update on this? I would also like to know if you are happy with the MDF top with the Incra LS unit. Thanks! Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.