Recommended Posts

Posted

I see that Rockler  (and others probably) are having a 15% off sale on all Jet products. I have been needing/wanting a drum sander for the longest and 15% off just might be the reason to make me take the plunge. I'm looking at the 1.5 hp w/ 16" - 32" sanding capacity. Does anyone have any input on this machine?

Posted

I like mine a lot, one of those things that is an absolute luxury, but "what" a luxury it is. Ironically I don't use it a lot for sanding "per say," at least when it comes to finishing, but it's mega-helpful in flattening boards too big to go through the jointer, flattening very figured woods that my planer would rip up, or especially flattening strips for bent lamination or generally small things.

 

Probably the most time consuming and frustrating thing about it is the initial adjustment / alignment of the drum. You have to get it juuuuuuusssst right if you want to be able to flip the board and sand without a line being left in the middle, and that includes considering deflection. I know this something that I know they could absolutely improve on but they continue to use the same old way with the bolts. I tried all the jigs and measurement tricks on the web and had no success (this way doesn't consider deflection), in the end I made some modifications to the bolts on the right hand side for microadjustments and ran a board of pencil marked MDF through the sander a bunch of times until I got it right. Now I can sand and flip boards with no mark left. The adjustment is locked down pretty tight and I haven't had to readjust it since.

 

Changing the paper is a bitch to get right at first, but you eventually learn the technique. Think I was screwing with getting it right for an hour the first time I tried, but now I can do it in about a minute or two. As far as dust collection, it's very good provided you have a four inch dust port.

 

In addition, there is just slightly a bit of a learning curve with how this kind of drum sander works with materials. You only want it to "kiss" the top when feeding it through, as trying to take too much off at once will not only bog down the sander, but can cause deflection due to too much pressure and the side being open. Also consider that the grits work a bit differently than you would expect with grits from a random orbit sander or something. The drum sander sandpaper is much rougher than you'd normally expect with other types of sandpaper, so adjust accordingly.

  • Like 2
Posted

This is the kind of stuff I was looking for, thanks. I plan to do Marc's Morris chair and didn't want to have to depend on my planer to get the laminate strips thin enough. I have wanted one for a while but have never had the justification (must be a word cause spell check didn't change it) to get one! I see that two grits, 150 & 220 are offered and they aren't cheap, so maybe they last longer than the disc for the os. With your experience, which one should I start with or get both? Also, I didn't even consider dust collection. Currently I just have a mobile shop vac that goes to which ever machine I'm using. Think maybe that's not enough?

Posted

I have the jet 16-32 I really like it I had a home made one that attached to my lathe and even though it worked great it could only do 18" and wasn't open ended and was a chore to switch back to lathe mode and vise-a-versa.

post-2926-0-01697300-1314567863_thumb.jp
Posted

This is the kind of stuff I was looking for, thanks. I plan to do Marc's Morris chair and didn't want to have to depend on my planer to get the laminate strips thin enough. I have wanted one for a while but have never had the justification (must be a word cause spell check didn't change it) to get one! I see that two grits, 150 & 220 are offered and they aren't cheap, so maybe they last longer than the disc for the os. With your experience, which one should I start with or get both? Also, I didn't even consider dust collection. Currently I just have a mobile shop vac that goes to which ever machine I'm using. Think maybe that's not enough?

 

No, the paper isn't cheap but as long as you're not terribly abusive to the paper and burning it by trying to use the drum sander like a planer, taking off too much at a time, etc, it will last a good while. At least when I bought my 16-32, it came with a few rolls already (can't remember all the grits it came with). What grit to get / use wildly depends on what you're doing, but I think I keep an 80 grit on mine to do what I need.

 

I've never tried a shop vac with a drum sander, but I suppose it would be better than nothing, maybe might work just fine, the only thing I can guarantee is that you don't want to run it without dust collection period if you're indoors. My concern, aside from the reduced hose size, is that smaller hoses are better suited to collect dust concentrated in one area (think routers, palm sanders, etc) whereas the drum sander has the entire width to consider if running a large board, a large volume of dust a 4-inch dust collector is better suited for.

Posted

I bought the Supermax 19-38 a while back and I love it.  Supermax was originally Performax and they were the company from whom Jet bought their design and worked with for the original Jet models.  Eventually the contract ended and Performax turned into Supermax and went out on their own.  They went on to re-engineer these drum sanders, vastly improving the old design that Jet has kept in production.  Many of the complaints you hear over and over again about the Jet units (and there are several you hear VERY often), Supermax has addressed and fixed.  IMHO you're overpaying for the Jet units because they have Jet's name on them, and they aren't as good as the Supermax units.

 

I just went down this road very recently...I had actually ordered a Jet 22-44 Pro from Amazon, and cancelled the order before it ever even arrived because of a huge pile of buyer's remorse.  And I'm really glad I did...I ended up with a better unit, minus a small bit of capacity that I hardly needed anyway, for a MUCH better price.  And it's a great machine.  Whenever I see the Jet 16-32 now, it's like comparing a Cadillac to a Kia.  Seriously.  Even the fit and finish on the Supermax units are of higher quality.

 

 

http://www.acmetools.com/shop/tools/supermax-tools-71938-d?cm_mmc=Google-_-PRODUCTFEED-_-SUPERMAX%20TOOLS-_-71938-D&CAWELAID=600009240000015506&CAGPSPN=pla&catargetid=600009240000085501&cadevice=c&gclid=CjgKEAjw2KCcBRCQ_6mztcunhEgSJABPxOF1KMw66nrWjfUx267dsul9r1aktKy6PqeSFtpHc2y1kfD_BwE

 

19-drum-with-wood-on-open-stand.jpg

Posted

kiki, The Acme link shows the 19-38 to be $1399 and the Jet 16-32, is on sale for $951. In your opinion, not considering the difference in capacity, do you think the supermax is that much better?

Posted

If you disregard the difference in capacity then it's a tougher call.  But with it factored in, yes, IMO I do think it's worth the extra expense.  But that's just my opinion.  It depends on where your point of diminishing returns lands...that's different for everyone.

 

The 19-38 is tax free (assuming you're not in the same state as Acme) and ships free.  Same for the Jet?

Posted

I already knew the Jet was the Performax, but what I didn't know is that Supermax was the Performax team, and that's great news that they've improved on the design, definitely looks like a finer unit than the Jet / old Performax. When I got my Jet, I got it on sale for $799 which I think was worth it despite it's quirks and I don't know if I would have personally spent the additional money for the Supermax. On the other hand, if it was up against the regular retail price of the Jet ($1099, I think?) versus the Supermax, then I might definitely give the Supermax a lot more thought.

Posted

Now I don't know whether to s#*t or go blind, especially since my vac is probably not large enough. Time to get my consultant out of the fridge. I've made some of my most important decisions after a beer or two.

Posted

Now I don't know whether to s#*t or go blind, especially since my vac is probably not large enough. Time to get my consultant out of the fridge. I've made some of my most important decisions after a beer or two.

 

I can equally attribute every Bridge City purchase from browsing their site with red wine in hand.  Careful!

Posted

For some reason or another, everyone of us seem to use a similar consulting firm, Mine happens to have it's headquarters in Lynchburg, Tennessee!, and they sure know their business!

  • Like 1
Posted

Shop vac alone isn't remotely going to cut it.  I built my own drum sander originally and I had my own dust shroud setup that worked okay with the shop vac that was all I had, but this was much more closed in and fit tighter to the drum than what you get with a Jet.  That is it worked okay for about 10 minutes at which point the filter would be hopelessly clogged.  So at a minimum you'd have to put a cyclone between the vac and the drum sander to be able to do anything.  But really, you need a proper dust collector.

 

I also find it's very difficult to get the paper installed such that the last inch or so on the right side doesn't stick out ever so slightly more than the rest of the drum, which causes it to wear out really fast and then start to leave burn marks while the rest of the drum is still fine.  So I pretty much consider that last inch on the right to be a no go zone.  It's just a stupid design of the clamps that hold the paper.  They don't have enough travel to pull it tight.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 44 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined