bgreenb Posted December 3, 2014 Report Posted December 3, 2014 I have the Grizzly G0490X (http://www.grizzly.com/products/8-Jointer-w-Spiral-Cutterhead/G0490X), which I've been very happy with. Took about an hour to get dialed in right and it's been cutting great ever since. I've yet to rotate the cutters, and I've been using it pretty aggressively (for a hobbiest) for a couple years now, and it still cuts like the day I got it. In terms of bang for your buck I highly recommend it. I have the Dewalt 735X planer - much has been written about it here so I won't repeat it, other than to say I've been incredibly happy with it and don't see myself replacing it for a long time. The dust collection in particular is phenomenal. Quote
bushwacked Posted December 4, 2014 Author Report Posted December 4, 2014 so far it sounds like I should spend my money on a good joiner ... and then save some on the planer and go dewalt, and possibly another tool with the savings? Quote
..Kev Posted December 4, 2014 Report Posted December 4, 2014 The problem is that you need them both to mill stock. Nothing wrong with your plan but, I think I'd do the planer first. Quote
Eric. Posted December 4, 2014 Report Posted December 4, 2014 I'll pile on the jointer bandwagon...8" is way better than 6", and the bells and whistles you're considering are well worth the extra cost, IMO. The parallelogram beds make for easier adjustments, and the Shelix head allows you to mill figured woods without tearout and requires FAR less frequent sharpening. I don't have a Shelix yet but it's on my upgrade short list. The jointer tends to be one of the more finicky machines and hardest to get dialed in. And as a double-edge sword...also one of the most critical that it BE dialed in. If you can't get your stock square, the whole project is a mess from the start. Dead-square stock makes everything easier and, obviously, makes for much higher-quality work. I'm happy I have a 15" floor model planer, but if I was forced to trade in either my jointer or planer for a smaller and more limited model, it would definitely be the planer. Quote
bushwacked Posted December 4, 2014 Author Report Posted December 4, 2014 The problem is that you need them both to mill stock. Nothing wrong with your plan but, I think I'd do the planer first. Dewalt planer or a better more expensive planer? Quote
bushwacked Posted December 4, 2014 Author Report Posted December 4, 2014 I'll pile on the jointer bandwagon...8" is way better than 6", and the bells and whistles you're considering are well worth the extra cost, IMO. The parallelogram beds make for easier adjustments, and the Shelix head allows you to mill figured woods without tearout and requires FAR less frequent sharpening. I don't have a Shelix yet but it's on my upgrade short list. The jointer tends to be one of the more finicky machines and hardest to get dialed in. And as a double-edge sword...also one of the most critical that it BE dialed in. If you can't get your stock square, the whole project is a mess from the start. Dead-square stock makes everything easier and, obviously, makes for much higher-quality work. I'm happy I have a 15" floor model planer, but if I was forced to trade in either my jointer or planer for a smaller and more limited model, it would definitely be the planer. Thanks for the input. Glad I'm kinda on the right path. Getting the jointer right will definitely be a task for me. Quote
..Kev Posted December 4, 2014 Report Posted December 4, 2014 Dewalt planer or a better more expensive planer? That's pretty much the cream of the crop for a lunch box planer. The issue is the capacity. It is a lunchbox.. Quote
bushwacked Posted December 4, 2014 Author Report Posted December 4, 2014 That's pretty much the cream of the crop for a lunch box planer. The issue is the capacity. It is a lunchbox.. Like how thick it can handle or how wide or how many board feet it goes through before breaking or what? Quote
..Kev Posted December 4, 2014 Report Posted December 4, 2014 Thickness isn't really the issue, width is. The 735 is 12 1/2" max width - Same with the Grizzly and a few others. The price jump to a 15 is pretty significant. Quote
Vyrolan Posted December 4, 2014 Report Posted December 4, 2014 I'll mention it simply because it hasn't been brought up in this thread, but don't forget the combination jointer/planer options. Sure a lot of them are crap, but there are potential advantages. They save space for one but also if you get a helical one then you have helical for jointing and planing instead of having to buy two helical heads for two machines. Quote
wtnhighlander Posted December 4, 2014 Report Posted December 4, 2014 @Bushwhacked: The DW735 is top of the heap, as long as you are talking about portable planers. Anything that handles more width will be a fixed installation, but taking that step gives you more hp as well. Personally, I am quite happy with my 735. If i ever need to plane more than 12" at a time, I'll just use a router sled and/or hand planes. Portability is a must for me. Quote
bushwacked Posted December 4, 2014 Author Report Posted December 4, 2014 I'll mention it simply because it hasn't been brought up in this thread, but don't forget the combination jointer/planer options. Sure a lot of them are crap, but there are potential advantages. They save space for one but also if you get a helical one then you have helical for jointing and planing instead of having to buy two helical heads for two machines. Space won't be an issue. I do see what you are saying though. What's a price of a good combo? @Bushwhacked: The DW735 is top of the heap, as long as you are talking about portable planers. Anything that handles more width will be a fixed installation, but taking that step gives you more hp as well. Personally, I am quite happy with my 735. If i ever need to plane more than 12" at a time, I'll just use a router sled and/or hand planes. Portability is a must for me. Ya I don't see myself planing more than 12" at least anytime in the near future. Most likely I'll plane 2 prices and just glue if I need to. Thickness isn't really the issue, width is. The 735 is 12 1/2" max width - Same with the Grizzly and a few others. The price jump to a 15 is pretty significant. Ya almost double the price for 15" and a floor standing model. Not sure I'd need to spend another $500ish for 3 extra inches. Quote
..Kev Posted December 4, 2014 Report Posted December 4, 2014 Ya almost double the price for 15" and a floor standing model. Not sure I'd need to spend another $500ish for 3 extra inches. I feel the same way about Jointers Quote
Vyrolan Posted December 4, 2014 Report Posted December 4, 2014 Space won't be an issue. I do see what you are saying though. What's a price of a good combo? Hard to say...a lot of the small ones are wrought with problems...one I've looked at is Jet's 12" combo which helical...it's just under 3K if you buy during the 15% off sales. That's a lot but you get full 12" jointing and helical for both jointing and planing and a higher HP unit. For me the space is somewhat of a concern is why I look at them. I think the general consensus is if the space is not a concern, get separates. Quote
estesbubba Posted December 4, 2014 Report Posted December 4, 2014 Not only do you get 3 more inches but a 15" can take more off with each pass. I can't remember if the feed rate is also faster. A 15" is loud but a lunchbox is freakin' loud. Quote
bushwacked Posted December 4, 2014 Author Report Posted December 4, 2014 Not only do you get 3 more inches but a 15" can take more off with each pass. I can't remember if the feed rate is also faster. A 15" is loud but a lunchbox is freakin' loud. I've seen some reviews saying the dewalt only hit something like 104 decibal. Loud yes but in marks video his joiner before the spiral cutters was hitting 114 decibels. Which who knows how accurate the dewalt decibel reader was. Quote
..Kev Posted December 4, 2014 Report Posted December 4, 2014 Look, we'd all love the 15 but, fact is for some, space and power become an issue. Quote
Vyrolan Posted December 4, 2014 Report Posted December 4, 2014 The Dewalt is also substantially quieter if you upgrade it to a shelix head. Quote
bushwacked Posted December 4, 2014 Author Report Posted December 4, 2014 Look, we'd all love the 15 but, fact is for some, space and power become an issue. Hah! Forgot $$$ as well The Dewalt is also substantially quieter if you upgrade it to a shelix head. Oh I didn't know you could upgrade those blades on the dewalt. That's not bad then Quote
estesbubba Posted December 4, 2014 Report Posted December 4, 2014 I had the 733 and the 735 could be quieter. All I know is with any planer, make sure the wife isn't on the phone in the house when you fire it up or you'll be sleeping next to the planer... 1 Quote
Vyrolan Posted December 4, 2014 Report Posted December 4, 2014 Oh I didn't know you could upgrade those blades on the dewalt. That's not bad then Not cheap...but many report better performance (the spiral action helps with lower power) and better quality cuts and much less noise...all around a worthwhile upgrade. I've not read anyone say they regretted the upgrade. http://www.amazon.com/Byrd-Tool-Shelix-cutterhead-Dewalt/dp/B008CS2QAE Quote
bushwacked Posted December 4, 2014 Author Report Posted December 4, 2014 Thanks for the link Vy ... Ok so just throwing this out here. By the time I got the 735x and the shelix cutter I'm all of about $200 from that grizzly. I'm sure I could catch the grizzly on sale sometime. I'm assuming the stock blades on the grizzly are much better than dewalt? Then maybe a year or so grab the shelix? I know this is a slippery slope with more and more money. But just curious because $200 or so when not on sale I could justify ... Quote
..Kev Posted December 4, 2014 Report Posted December 4, 2014 You'll always be happier with a 15" floor planer than a 12 1/2" lunchbox if you have the space, and the wallet. Quote
estesbubba Posted December 4, 2014 Report Posted December 4, 2014 I have the Shop Fox brother of that Griz and it's been a solid performer. Quote
Freddie Posted December 4, 2014 Report Posted December 4, 2014 I had thought about the shelix upgrade for my dewalt a couple of times, but I could never justify putting that cutter head on that machine when it costs about as much as the machine itself. Womp Womp Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.