dwacker Posted December 3, 2014 Report Posted December 3, 2014 I have 11 Forrest dado king sets all 8" all have been sharpened 3 times and I am having all of them sharpened for the 4th time. All have new unused shims and the plastic carriers. Are these worth putting up on crags list. I don't want to bother if they will only sell for 10 or 20 a set. If they are not worth anything I'll just donate them to the high school. What is a good asking price. Quote
Tom Cancelleri Posted December 3, 2014 Report Posted December 3, 2014 Since they're 275 new I would say 4 sharpenings and used maybe 50-60 bucks tops. Quote
dwacker Posted December 3, 2014 Author Report Posted December 3, 2014 how many times do you think they can be sharpened? Without think too hard I guess I'd pay $50, assuming that maybe I could get one more sharpening out of it. But if they are good for 10 sharpenings then maybe they should go for a lot more. Brand new it is $280 right now. 6/10 * 280 = 168, so factor in the risk you might not get as much time between sharpenings maybe $125-$150 is fair. Thanks I think I'll have the service tell me how much life is left before making a decision. Im thinking they should go 8-10 times. Its that time of the year got to get rid of all the unused blades, cutters and groovers. Quote
duckkisser Posted December 3, 2014 Report Posted December 3, 2014 I always say give to a high school but I'm biased as a teacher. 1 Quote
ponderingturtle Posted December 4, 2014 Report Posted December 4, 2014 Do you have enough high schools with active enough wood working programs to be able to use them? Quote
dwacker Posted December 4, 2014 Author Report Posted December 4, 2014 Do you have enough high schools with active enough wood working programs to be able to use them? We have a couple but it really is not as simple as walking down to the shop class and saying you want to donate. You have to donate to the district and you can ear mark a portion but not all of multiples, politics. We donated an SS ICS last year and it was difficult to get it into the intended school without buying one for every school and that was not going to happen. Quote
ponderingturtle Posted December 4, 2014 Report Posted December 4, 2014 We have a couple but it really is not as simple as walking down to the shop class and saying you want to donate. You have to donate to the district and you can ear mark a portion but not all of multiples, politics. We donated an SS ICS last year and it was difficult to get it into the intended school without buying one for every school and that was not going to happen. Sounds like a much larger district that I was thinking of. In the district I went to unless the maintence staff got it, it could only have ended up in the junior high or high school. Quote
knotscott Posted December 4, 2014 Report Posted December 4, 2014 I don't think you'll have much trouble getting $50-$75 set, depending on the cosmetic appearance and remaining carbide. A freshly sharpened high quality dado set will last the average weekend warrior quite a while between sharpenings. Quote
dwacker Posted December 4, 2014 Author Report Posted December 4, 2014 My thinking was it would cost a hobby person about $50 a set to have sharpened. Since I have a tooling contract and pay one fee no matter how many I send in I could have them done and get the $50 and an extra $50 for the set. I doubt most hobby people would ever have a full set sharpened. A couple small projects or even a kitchen a year would last years. I guess I may be wrong, buts thats why I asked. Quote
Vyrolan Posted December 4, 2014 Report Posted December 4, 2014 My first reaction upon seeing the thread was that surely people would gobble them up for like $100 per set if they're fresh from Forrest sharpening services...that's more than 50% off and from what I understand of Forrest and their service that they should generally be expected to be exactly as good as new. For a hobbyist who would likely never use them enough to get to the point they could no longer be resharpened, 50% off sounds like a tremendous deal...to me at least. Quote
dwacker Posted December 4, 2014 Author Report Posted December 4, 2014 My first reaction upon seeing the thread was that surely people would gobble them up for like $100 per set if they're fresh from Forrest sharpening services...that's more than 50% off and from what I understand of Forrest and their service that they should generally be expected to be exactly as good as new. For a hobbyist who would likely never use them enough to get to the point they could no longer be resharpened, 50% off sounds like a tremendous deal...to me at least. You would think. I listed a bunch of groovers on CL and had a few people look at them but no takers. No one had ever seen a tablesaw groover so they were afraid of them for some reason. Really all they are is one piece 8 and 10" fixed 24t dado blades. I understand nobody wanting moulder knives and having to eBay those. The sharpening service offered $50 ea for the dado blades so I think I'll just let them have them for that. Quote
wtnhighlander Posted December 5, 2014 Report Posted December 5, 2014 Got a photo of a groover, PB? Never seen one myself. Sounds useful. Quote
dwacker Posted December 5, 2014 Author Report Posted December 5, 2014 Got a photo of a groover, PB? Never seen one myself. Sounds useful. I don't have any pics but am having my machines moved back I can take one for you. They look similar to these but with a lot more teeth and the teethe are flat topped. http://www.wmooreprofiles.com/c-795-brazed-carbide-cutters.aspx This is also the place I buy them. If you want one you have to call they start at about $100 for a new 24t 8" x 1/4 and go up to about 1" wide. Quote
Vyrolan Posted December 5, 2014 Report Posted December 5, 2014 I've been watching early episodes of New Yankee Workshop and Norm used a beading blade like that on some project...I was like "wtf is that"...never seen a profiling/shaping cutter for the table saw...those are pretty cool. I also love how much he uses the dado in the radial arm...can't do THAT with a miter saw. =p Quote
dwacker Posted December 5, 2014 Author Report Posted December 5, 2014 I prefer the groovers to dado's but in the end they do the same thing. Most shops just buy Byrd groover bodies and have them tipped, they are pretty cheap. W Moore has always treated me right. I call one day and asked for the cutter on their website banner and they said it was not really a stock cutter but made one up for me custom bored for the bolt on my PM. Really can't beat their service. Quote
Tom King Posted December 5, 2014 Report Posted December 5, 2014 My thinking was it would cost a hobby person about $50 a set to have sharpened. Since I have a tooling contract and pay one fee no matter how many I send in I could have them done and get the $50 and an extra $50 for the set. I doubt most hobby people would ever have a full set sharpened. A couple small projects or even a kitchen a year would last years. I guess I may be wrong, buts thats why I asked. I can tell you for a fact that a set will last years with just a couple of sets of cabinets a year. I bought a set in 92 or 93, built one spec house a year through 2007, and the Dado King made every set of cabinets in those houses, and still is plenty sharp enough to last maybe that long again. I'd get them sharpened, and put them on various woodworking forum classifieds for 120 plus whatever the cost of a flat rate box they'd go in. It would still be about half of new, and last hobby woodworkers forever. What size groovers are you selling? Quote
dwacker Posted December 5, 2014 Author Report Posted December 5, 2014 What size groovers are you selling? All the groovers are gone except one 1/4" x 8" 24t that may be back up for sale if my buddy can't use it on his SS. He doesn't want to turn off the brake so if SS says no then it will be $25 they sell new for $100. If he gives it back I can let you know. I will have more groovers for sale in July or Aug 1/4" - 5/8" Every year I liquidate used cutters to depreciate off the books. Quote
wtnhighlander Posted December 6, 2014 Report Posted December 6, 2014 I don't have a sawstop. I'd sure be interested in one of those groovers sometime. I cut grooves on a lot of projects, either with multiple saw passes or the router table, because I am too lazy to set the dado stack up correctly. A 1/4" fixed size cutter would be great! Last tabletop I made, I cut tongue & groove with just the standard saw blade. The groover would have been much quicker. Quote
Vyrolan Posted December 6, 2014 Report Posted December 6, 2014 A 1/4" fixed size cutter would be great! Last tabletop I made, I cut tongue & groove with just the standard saw blade. The groover would have been much quicker. As an alternative, you could use one of the box joint 2pc sets. Perfect flat bottom grooves at either 1/4 or 3/8. They're not technically designed for it (especially across the grain), but it seems like tons of people use them for that. Certainly with the grain it'd work well. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.