Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

FIrst Time Finishing

Featured Replies

I'm going to be building the Bottlehead Crack Headphone Amplifier (linked here http://bottleheadnginx.bottleheadcorp.netdna-cdn.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/Crack-OTL-Headphone-Amplifier-Kit.jpg) and am planning on dying the base black. I've never stained and finished wood before and want to be sure not to mess anything up. I am planning on dying the alder wood with General Finishes Ebony Black Dye Stain. I'm not sure which type of clear finish would be my best option, though. I'm also not 100% sure about steps like spritzing and sanding the wood so some clarification would be appreciated. I just want to make sure that I do this correctly. 

 

Thanks,

 

Andrew

Black is deceptively tough to get right… Unfortunately, it’s kind of easy to shoot for black and end-up with deep purple (there’s music joke in there somewhere)…

 

What species of wood is the base?

 

Is the wood finished at all from the factory? If you can ask for it unfinished, so much the better…

 

You’ll need practice stock of the same species… A lot of practice stock…

 

Once we get some info, we can help… But we need to manage expectations – black can be a tough target to hit…

 

==>General Finishes Ebony Black Dye Stain

Good place to start, but you'll need some India ink --- around 1 to 2 oz/qt...

 

BTW: It's been a while since I had a tube-setup -- so I could be out of date, but for an OTL design, that small black box looks suspiciously like an output transformer... :)

  • Author

Hey, thanks for the reply. The base is Northwest Alder wood according to Bottlehead's site. The wood is not finished from the factory; the amp is sold as a DIY kit so the base is meant to be finished. Additionally, someone on Bottlehead's forum used Charles Neil's Pre-Color Conditioner - Blotch Control in combination with the Ebony Black Dye Stain and Arm-R-Seal Urethane Topcoat (pictured here http://puu.sh/dEBgA.jpg). That seemed to have worked well for achieving a good black color so I'm not sure if India Ink would be necessary (or would it still be recommended?). 

 

Also, regarding the amp, all of the circuitry is attached to the bottom side of the aluminum plate and the wood base simply houses the amp. 

Charles Neil's blotch control is spot on!  The Arm-R-Seal top coat is also spot on!

  • Author

Charles Neil's blotch control is spot on!  The Arm-R-Seal top coat is also spot on!

 

Awesome, glad to hear that those are good choices. Do you think it would be wise to use the three products I listed in my previous post or should anything be added (such as the India Ink) or changed?

Run a test board and make sure you like the finish you're looking at.  Pictures and video can be deceiving!

 

It sounds like a good sequence so I say, trust but verify!  Run a test board.

Could just be the lighting, but it looks to have a purple cast compared to the table it's resting on... GF JetB frequently leaves a purple cast by itself -- hence the ink... What you've got should work AOK. ARS is an easy topcoat. I've never colored Alder, so don't know if CN's BC would help or hurt... Test board is the way to go...

  • Author

Thank you for the advice. I'll definitely run a test board prior to starting on the actual project. Are there any preferred retailers for picking up or ordering some more pieces of alder for use as the test board? 

Some big box stores will carry alder but, suggest checking with a local hard wood dealer.

==>more pieces of alder

Since it's a kit, can you get more from the amp guys? There are several species lumped into 'Alder', so you would have a better chance of getting an exact match...

  • Author

==>more pieces of alder

Since it's a kit, can you get more from the amp guys? There are several species lumped into 'Alder', so you would have a better chance of getting an exact match...

My kit will be arriving in a couple days and shipping from the company I ordered from, at least for the amp kits, takes a substantial amount of time (4-6 weeks). I probably should have done this research earlier in order to ask for an extra piece but had been planning on waiting until my current winter break to work on the project. At this point I think that the best option will be to pick up a piece from a separate retailer, as long as a slightly different type of wood will suffice as a test piece. Additionally, as I said in a previous, more specifically the wood is Northwest Alder. I don't know if that helps.

My kit will be arriving in a couple days and shipping from the company I ordered from, at least for the amp kits, takes a substantial amount of time (4-6 weeks). I probably should have done this research earlier in order to ask for an extra piece but had been planning on waiting until my current winter break to work on the project. At this point I think that the best option will be to pick up a piece from a separate retailer, as long as a slightly different type of wood will suffice as a test piece. Additionally, as I said in a previous, more specifically the wood is Northwest Alder. I don't know if that helps.

 

Take a piece from the kit to your local hard wood dealer and try to match as close as possible..

  • Author

Take a piece from the kit to your local hard wood dealer and try to match as close as possible..

Okay, sounds good. A local place supplies Alder (listed as a Western Hardwood) so hopefully that will be close enough. 

Okay, sounds good. A local place supplies Alder (listed as a Western Hardwood) so hopefully that will be close enough. 

 

Just make sure it's the same species (alder) and that the coloring is close to what you have..  That's the only way to run a fair test on the finish you wish to achieve..

  • Author

Just make sure it's the same species (alder) and that the coloring is close to what you have..  That's the only way to run a fair test on the finish you wish to achieve..

Definitely. I'll probably pick up the test board along with the other products within the next couple days and see how it goes. 

Definitely. I'll probably pick up the test board along with the other products within the next couple days and see how it goes. 

 

Best of luck and I do hope you let us know how it turned out!

  • Author

Best of luck and I do hope you let us know how it turned out!

Thank you. I'll post the results once finished. Hopefully everything works out well. 

  • Author

One last question as well - is it necessary to sand the wood at any time during the finishing process? If so, what grit should be used?

 

Also, what would be a viable alternative to Charles Neil's Pre-Color Conditioner - Blotch Control? I'm only planning on doing this one project for now and I can't find it available anywhere convenient, or for less than $20, so something cheaper would be better. Would it be okay to skip this step completely?

 

Thanks.

Spent some time looking at coloring Alder -- it's prone to blotching... Sorry...

 

You don't need CN's product -- I wouldn't purchase it if you’re only doing this one project -- what would you do with the rest of the $19.95 of the stuff?

 

There are several other things that work well to control blotch -- folks have been using diluted PVA (white glue) in a 10%PVA to 90% warm H2O for decades... CN's works a bit better, but not for this type of job --- Ebonizing hides the figure, so the clarity of CN's product is a waste of money... Folks also use a #1ct super blonde de-waxed shellac with great success…

 

As a side note: is CN’s blotch control ‘better’ than the traditional formulations? Yes and no… It doesn’t really control blotch all that much better – some, but it’s not ‘night and day’ better… Where it shines: dries clear and doesn’t have the yellow and/or blue tint common with other solutions… So if you're shooting a simple tone match and not obscuring figure, going WB to avoid yellowing, then CN’s product is worth looking at…

The CN stuff is no better than white gorilla glue and water. The Mohawk clear stain base is probably the best out there, next in line I would reluctantly give it to General finishes RTM clear base diluted. I will say that Alder will blotch if you don't use some sort of an equalizer. That being said I don't have a clue how well it will fare with ebonizing my guess is that it can't be much worse than any other faux ebonized domestic wood.

Definitely. I'll probably pick up the test board along with the other products within the next couple days and see how it goes. 

   You might consider using a piece that will go unseen for a test board, and replace it with one you get from your local supplier, That way visible pieces will be uniform to the test piece.

Instead of getting a test board, simply do your testing on what will be the inside of the amp. Nobody will see it after it is assembled.

Instead of getting a test board, simply do your testing on what will be the inside of the amp. Nobody will see it after it is assembled.

 

Awesome idea!

  • Author

Instead of getting a test board, simply do your testing on what will be the inside of the amp. Nobody will see it after it is assembled.

Hey, thanks for the suggestion! Using the non visible sides of the boards will definitely be the most accurate way to do the testing. 

 

As for the base, a mixture of White Gorilla Glue with water would be the most convenient option for me. Is the product linked below what I need (and is 1:9 glue:warm water what I should be mixing?)?

 

 http://www.gorillaglue.com/white-gorilla-glue

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.