Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Dust Collection Setup and Design for New Shop

Featured Replies

First time poster.  Slowly working my way into the world of woodworking.  I got interested in it by refinishing furniture for a living for a couple years now (family business).  Now we are wanting to add a bit to our business by not only refinishing, but building, some pieces for customers.  That being said, I am quickly finding out how little I know about all things wood shop and how to set it up.  I've done my research on tool layout in the shop and I feel good about that (good enough to start anyway), but the DC aspect of the shop seems to get more complicated the more I research it.  Could someone provide a link, or just briefly educate me, on the basics of DC and how to set up an efficient system, such as duct sizes/length, static pressure, and any recommendations on dust collectors?  Thanks!

  • Popular Post

Can of worms.  Start with the Bill Pentz website and work your way back to reality from there.

I read a little on the BP site but is a cluster of information and I lost interest. The manual for my cyclone was pretty straightforward on calculating SP loss and the CFM at each machine. See my post here for links to my manual and my ductwork.

==>basics of DC and how to set up an efficient system, such as duct sizes/length, static pressure

Contact Oneida-Air. They have an intro tract on the basics of DC and ductwork design. The title is something like 'Dust Collection Resource Kit' or 'Ductwork Design' or something like that -- it's about forty pages and a good place to start -- certainly better than BP's site...

 

There are some SP calculators available on-line, but I’d pay the $250 for a ductwork design… Why? You need velocity (FPM) to collect and transport sub-0.5u dust… On-line SP calculators and BP’s site talk CFM and SP, but not velocity – that’s where a pro design comes-in (unless you took some lectures Bernoulli’s Law and on fluid dynamics at some point) :)… Velocity is the ugly little secret at the heart of the 6” ductwork universe… If you run 6” ductwork from inlet to drop, you are almost guaranteed to not to collect sub-0.5u dust… Sorry for the bad news, that’s just the way it is… I’ve seen too many WTO members get themselves very nice cyclone setups, and then kill any ability to collect fine dust with poor ductwork decisions… To spend a couple grand for a DC setup, but have no hope of collecting sub-0.5u fines… Well, respirators are cheap…

 

==>and any recommendations on dust collectors?

You’ve got to be wary of the specificaiton game when purchasing a DC system… To be blunt: some mfgs claim totally bogus specs developed with creative test methodologies… Many publish CFM and SP performance curve sans filter media or at the fan and not before inlet... Mfgs that certify their systems with filter media installed say so (Oneida, Penn State)... Those that don't tend not to mention it... And what diference does this make? About the same as getting a 5HP cyclone instead of a 3HP cyclone -- it makes that much diference... Which is why some mfgs test that way... For the small shop operating mostly 4" inlet tools one at a time, a 7” inlet 3HP system is just fine assuming the specs are real...

 

When we get to filtering, the real specification games begin... Why, because a sealed PTFE/HEPA canister filter is between $450 and $700 and a spun-poly “sounds like HEPA, but not actually HEPA” filter media is about $160 - $250… Why does this matter? Because hobbyists are increasingly adding stationary sanders to their workflow - which generate lots of sub-0.5u dust… Further, some mfg’s will ‘upgrade’ a unit with a HEPA filter at time of purchase. But you need to pay close attention to the fine print: they say the filter's HEPA certified, but still don’t state that the system's HEPA compliant (but they will imply it)… Why? Well if you slap HEPA media to a cyclone, you are adding between 2" and 3" WC/SP to the back end... What comes in to the cyclone is in-part limited by what can be pushed out ---- so the CFM/SP curve drops by 2" to 3" SP and velocity (FPM) accordingly --- Note: this is approximetly the diference between a 2HP and 3HP cyclone... The with HEPA media installed, the velocity of the system  drops below what's needed to capture sub-0.5u dust (the HEPA stuff)... So you have a HEPA-certified filter, but no way to collect and transport sub-0.5u HEPA dust... That's the key part of the equation that some mfg's hide...

 

For some time, CV had the edge for small shops limited to 4” inlet tools operating one at a time on a tight budget. Today, I’d get the new polycarbonate V-System from Oneida over anything from Clear-Vue... The new V-system is the Clear-Vue killer... Penn State makes a good unit… Lot of folks like the Grizzly...

I'm also new at this but one thing I do recommend is to ensure your DC provides proper filtering up to 0.3 microns. In my research Oneida and ClearVue were 2 brands I found that offered this - you may find others. I found many other brands were from 30 micron down to 1 micron. Make sure the specs say the filters are HEPA rated for at least 99.7% at 0.3-0.5 micron.

Personally, I ordered the new style Oneida V-3000 2-stage system yesterday. I should get in next 3 weeks or so!

The reason I'm fixated on small particulate filtration is that I just came out of the Asbestos abatement industry - sold my company last summer. The tiniest particles can be the most dangerous. This is particularly true in a shop where you work for long periods of time and feel safe because the air appears to be clean. Proper dust collection/filtration at the source of the dust, is the best option.

  • Author

First of all, thanks to all of ya for the different responses.      Can the sub 0.5u dust particles be taken care of by an air filtration setup?  I've read some places online that highly recommend the 1-2 punch of dust collection and air filtration as the only way to maintain a safe shop environment.  

==>Can the sub 0.5u dust particles be taken care of by an air filtration setup?

Most consumer units have filtration on the order of 1u. There are certainly industrial units, but those are price prohibitive... I’ll do some googling and see if I find something down to 0.3u at a reasonable cost… But to answer your question, the air filtering units can’t hurt… But you’re better off collecting the dust at the source…

  • Author

Here is a link to one that we have been looking at for a while now.  Let's see if I am understanding this correctly:  It is possible, with a standard DC system, to collect the sub 05.u dust.  But I would be better off investing in a DC system design to ensure the system can collect those fine particles.  Does this then mean that I would not need to purchase the air filtration system?  In essence, spend the money on the DC system design instead of the air filtration unit?

 

http://jdstools.com/air-tech-hp-air-cleaner.aspx#reviews

We’re getting into that wonderful realm, “It depends”…

 

Keeping a space clean, reducing airborne dust in finishes, protecting your lungs, etc are separate, but related, goals…

 

Deploying a top-flight DC setup with all vintage milling kit isn’t going to do you much good… DC starts when and where dust is created…

 

Tell us something about your shop… Do you have separate milling, assembly and finishing spaces? The more you combine operations in a single space, the more circulating air cleaners can help you…

 

There’s a bunch of factors at play… Start with Oneida’s intro text and get the basics down… Then we can be in a better position to help…

It's a bag of snakes getting into dust collection theory. I currently have a I micron filtrarion set up, single stage unit, that I wheel around to my machines using a 5" hose. It does a great job, but I still wear a respirator (NIOSH p100) when doing anything thwt makes dust. It's near impossible to get it all, no matter what system you run (though some are certainly wayyyy better than others).

  • Author

We are putting up a new shop that is very near completion.  The main part of the business has been, and will likely continue to be, strictly furniture refinishing.  That being said, we will have the majority of the shop set up with two strip tanks, spray booth, and drying area.  We have ordered shop curtains that will slide along a track, but stay extended most of the time to completely separate the wood shop from the refinishing shop.  The wood shop will be right around 450 square feet of usable space and will contain any and all dust-creating operations that would occur with our business.   

 

In terms of the respirators, is it something that would need to be worn at all times, and not just while cutting/sanding/milling etc?  If so, I feel like I, and many others, would not be disciplined enough to wear it at all times.

I recommend using positive pressure in the refinishing areas, to help keep dust from moving into those areas.  I'd recommend wearing respirators with organic filters whenever doing finishing, and with particulate filters whenever making sawdust.

 

If you have good ventilation / air filtration / dust collection, then you don't need to wear the respirators all the time.

 

In the states, It doesn't matter what anyone on this forum thinks.  You'd need to find the regulations for your type of business.  I'm guessing things are similar in the UK.

 

Marc has a good video on respirators.

First time poster.  Slowly working my way into the world of woodworking.  I got interested in it by refinishing furniture for a living for a couple years now (family business).  Now we are wanting to add a bit to our business by not only refinishing, but building, some pieces for customers.  That being said, I am quickly finding out how little I know about all things wood shop and how to set it up.  I've done my research on tool layout in the shop and I feel good about that (good enough to start anyway), but the DC aspect of the shop seems to get more complicated the more I research it.  Could someone provide a link, or just briefly educate me, on the basics of DC and how to set up an efficient system, such as duct sizes/length, static pressure, and any recommendations on dust collectors?  Thanks!

 

You need to speak with the regulatory authority in your area. Some just use federal regulations some have more strict local regulations. Hobby shop dust collection is very different from businesses. Since you deal with hazmat already the regulations may get even more confusing. You also need to discuss the types of equipment that can and can't be used in a business. Many hobby shop machines can't be used in a business without modifications.

None of this techno babble is going to do you a bit of good if you don't understand the rules. 

  • Author

I've made contact with the people who will be "checking us out" for regulations in the shop.  Going back to the topic of having a DC system designed-is that worth the money I would spend on it?  Or is it possible to get enough assistance from other woodworkers (on here and locally) to get a properly setup system?

I've made contact with the people who will be "checking us out" for regulations in the shop.  Going back to the topic of having a DC system designed-is that worth the money I would spend on it?  Or is it possible to get enough assistance from other woodworkers (on here and locally) to get a properly setup system?

 

The problem is most are hobby folks and most don't know your local regulations along with not knowing your set up it would be impossible to get everything you need on a web forum.

 

I can tell you what is required here and federally but your rules may be more strict and I don't know how they are affected by your hazmat generation. You can't run a cyclone in your shop it has to be mounted outside if you intend to have any bigger dust generators like belt sander, drum sander or wide belt. With a pro shop a drum of wide belt is a must have. That being said you can't use one of the hobby type drum sanders like the supermax unless its modified to stop the feed when a hand goes in by accident. You can't return the DC exhaust to the shop unless you have a blast setup which is quite expensive usually costing much more than the DC itself. You can't use one of those plastic cyclones unless its conductive. 

 

And the list can go on and on. I would talk to some of the local cabinet shops and see just how strict they are in your area. If you find that they really don't spend resources on regulation check the court cases and fines handed out for non compliance. They may only care once you have an accident, then they stick it to you.

I can tell you what is required here and federally but your rules may be more strict and I don't know how they are affected by your hazmat generation. You can't run a cyclone in your shop it has to be mounted outside ...

 

PB, I checked, and MHRestorations is located in the UK.  So, even our federal rules don't apply.  I'm guessing UK / EU rules are more strict.  Maybe one of our UK pros can chime in. 

 

As far as using a design service, I can't speak from personal experience, but Marc has several videos on installing dust collection systems and several people have posted over the years.  I can't recall anyone who used a design service service who regretted it.  In the US, most of the vendors will do a design for free if you buy the ducts and fittings from them.  I assume that it's the same in the UK.

PB, I checked, and MHRestorations is located in the UK.  So, even our federal rules don't apply.  I'm guessing UK / EU rules are more strict.  Maybe one of our UK pros can chime in. 

 

 

 

:) Try IL. Thunk you got the wrong company, unless we gave IL to the UK and nobody told me.

==>having a DC system designed-is that worth the money I would spend on it?

You are talking about expanding a business --- that puts you in a separate category… There are specific requirements for commercial DC… The short answer: it’s worth the $200 - $250 for a design… In many cases, the design fee is credited back at time of purchase…

 

 

==>is it possible to get enough assistance from other woodworkers (on here and locally) to get a properly setup system?

Getting design information via internet is not advised… There are some who could provide guidance, but dozens more would taint good information with bad… However, there is a bigger issue: even asking the question about pro design raises a serious red flag… If you have a business, paying for a pro should not really be a question…

The problem is most are hobby folks and most don't know your local regulations along with not knowing your set up it would be impossible to get everything you need on a web forum.

 

I can tell you what is required here and federally but your rules may be more strict and I don't know how they are affected by your hazmat generation. You can't run a cyclone in your shop it has to be mounted outside if you intend to have any bigger dust generators like belt sander, drum sander or wide belt. With a pro shop a drum of wide belt is a must have. That being said you can't use one of the hobby type drum sanders like the supermax unless its modified to stop the feed when a hand goes in by accident. You can't return the DC exhaust to the shop unless you have a blast setup which is quite expensive usually costing much more than the DC itself. You can't use one of those plastic cyclones unless its conductive. 

 

And the list can go on and on. I would talk to some of the local cabinet shops and see just how strict they are in your area. If you find that they really don't spend resources on regulation check the court cases and fines handed out for non compliance. They may only care once you have an accident, then they stick it to you.

 

Everytime I read one of these kinds of responses from PB or Trip, I wonder how in the heck people ever go from hobbyist to pro.   I mean wouldn't all of these restrictions technically apply to the guy working out of his garage selling stuff locally/online?  Is that guy just an insurance disaster waiting to happen?

Everytime I read one of these kinds of responses from PB or Trip, I wonder how in the heck people ever go from hobbyist to pro.   I mean wouldn't all of these restrictions technically apply to the guy working out of his garage selling stuff locally/online?  Is that guy just an insurance disaster waiting to happen?

 

Its a balancing act for sure. 

==>Is that guy just an insurance disaster waiting to happen?

Yes and no…  PB put it well, it's a balancing act...

 

 

Here’s the rub: you won’t know if its a disaster until something goes spectacularly wrong... If your house burns-down because of your DIY shop sub-panel or your helper loses a finger because you decided against a SawStop, will your residential policy cover it? Best not to find out... :)

  • Author

Beechwood Chip -- Sorry for the confusion.  MHRestorations is short for Maplehill Restorations.  Although I did see the MHRestorations in the UK you were talking about.  Name is just MHR now to keep things simple!

 

TripleH -- You make a good point about paying for pro design.  But as with many small businesses looking to take that next big step to become a little less "small", saving a dollar here or there is always on my mind.  I wasn't aware that the design fee can sometimes be credited back with a purchase, so thank you for the info.  

 

PB -- Our business is located in an area where, like you said, there are not many resources directed toward regulation.  As I mentioned in an earlier post, this wood shop is going to be used as a small compliment to our refinishing business.  By no means is this (as of now) a full on industrial wood shop.  In terms of the tools I have accumulated over the years of personal woodworking and what we will put in the new shop, it is much closer to a hobbyist woodshop than anything else.  What I want to do in terms of safety (mainly with DC) is get setup in such a way where we can potentially expand this side of the business if we need to down the road.  

Most folks who make sawdust want to have a dedicated finishing room to keep the sawdust out of the drying finish.  In your case, you probably want to have a dedicated sawdust room, since most of your shop is devoted to finishing.

  • Author

Agreed.  We will have the two areas separated to try and avoid the problems that can occur when the two mix.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.