Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Dust collection - don't kill me

Featured Replies

==>The planer is your prime enemy
Yea, the planer and jointer have the most potential for clogging ductwork. In my shop, I believe both are 150mm (6in) inlet... Both tools can throw a big stream of chips... I suspect that if I ever took a full-width full-depth pass on either, I’d overwhelm the DC... Never tried it because I don’t have cleanouts in my setup (an oversight) and wouldn’t want to deal with the mess...

 

 

However, the prime enemy for your lungs are the stationary sanders... Nothing throws fine particles like a drum, double-drum, wide-belt, etc... They are the polar opposite to the planer/jointer --- they don’t throw chips that can clog the ductwork, but they do throw sub-0.5u particles which can clog your lungs... Fine particles present two very different problems for your DC: they are harder to collect & transport then their larger (1u+) brethren and they can re-circulate if you don’t vent outside or have HEPA filtering... The real issue is you can’t see sub-0.5u particles... So your shop can ‘look clean’, but loaded with ultra-fine dust... Historically, this wasn’t a big issue: hobbyists didn’t have stationary sanders --- and why hobby-level DC could be treated as a nice-to-have... Today, more and more hobbyists are adding them to their workflow, but using hobby-level DC and not wearing a respirator... That’s bad... One solution is to wear a respirator; another is to get a mongo-DC... A more cost effective solution is to have a pro design the system and procure the right sized DC for the dust load... Since HEPA filters are quite a bit more costly and need a bigger cyclone to drive a HEPA setup, a hybrid solution is to get a setup with enough CFM/H2O to collect fines and enough FPM to transport them, but vent outside to prevent recirculation --- at the cost of make-up air.

 

For the OP -- I seem to remember from an old thread that your shop isn't exactly a hobby setup... If not, you may fall under OSHA (or some other regulations), so your solution set may be more limited...

But at least the sanders have some semi-logical engineering in regard to DC.  At least mine does.  It may produce the largest amount of fine dust of all the machines, but mine seems fairly accommodating to the DC...at least to the naked eye.  For me, the bandsaw and table saw are the two biggest culprits.  Not because they produce the most dust or the finest dust, but because the DC engineering is so pathetic.  They may as well have included a fan that just blows everything in your face.  I've done some modifications on both tools, but they remain the worst offenders.

 

My planer and jointer are at the bottom of my list of DC concerns.  They both create primarily chips rather than dust, and as long as you have even a mediocre DC and appropriate pipe size, they clear just fine.

Yea, pickup on stationary sanders tends to be pretty good... On the other hand, pickup on band saws tends to be terrible. Table saws are hit or miss... Some are just about passable, but many are just terrible... I bet it’ll improve over time, but that doesn’t do much for us now...

 

If you really want a show, forget to open the blast gate on a sander running a 220g belt and a big panel – it’s like a fog bank blooming from the conveyer... I keep forgetting to add a little sign to the master-switch reminding me to check the blast gate...

 

For the chip makers, DC is more about keeping the shop clean... That’s why hobby DC has the history it does... The average consumer-oriented DC unit offered today is light-years ahead of the average consumer-unit a decade ago... But most hobby setups still see a world without stationary sanders... At some point, every mfg will bite the bullet and incorporate HEPA to manage stationary sanders, but until then, a personal respirator is a very good idea...

Just so you know, I did try to search the forum and google for some basics, but couldn't find what I'm looking for.

Any good sites/sources that sum up how to effectively hook up dust collection? HP, hose size, hose length?, how many machines, etc?

I have 4 things available to me currently, and will upgrade to a serious system eventually. But here's what I got now

3HP Woodtek

2HP drum top with baldor motor

1/2HP Drum top with baldor motor

Shop vac (which I use for sanders)

Not asking for you guys to do the work for me, but thiught I'd let you know what I have. Anyway, just lookin for some rough guidelines.

I'm not going to try to provide guidelines--I'll just tell you what I've got and how it works.

 

My shop has an upstairs and downstairs portion.  I wanted to put in one large system, but couldn't get it to fit without major reconstruction, including foundation.  So I put in 2 Oneida Mini-Gorillas. I run 1 machine at a time.

 

In terms of at-machine dust capture, my findings are similar to some of the other posters.

1. Table saw is the worst, by far.  I have a Sawstop PCS 3 HP. Love the saw itself, but...With the over table accessory DC arm in

    place it's pretty good at dust collection.  But with that arm removed, the saw spews dust from the slot in the zero clearance

    insert.

2. Euro machines are much better.  I have a Felder Jointer/planer and a Felder bandsaw. The Felder bandsaw has 2 ports on it,

    as opposed to my Jet bandsaw that only has one. Neither of the Felder machines puts any appreciable dust into the air.  The

   Jet bandsaw is a moderate offender.

3. I have a Supermax drum sander. It allows very little dust to escape from the DC system.

4. I have a lot of Festool tools that I bought not so much for any other reason than that they are so much better at dust

    collection than any other portable tool brand I've used.

 

 

In terms of the Mini-Gorillas, I was disappointed.  They're well made, they suck a lot of air, they're not horribly loud, there's a lot good to say about them.  But, long before the collection drum gets full, the filter on the top of the machine is collecting fines. Eventually, it gets to the point that you have to take the filter off and clean it.  The "eventually" happens a lot faster than you would think it would, and ends up being a real pain.  So, After watching Mathias Wandel's video, and Marius Hornberger's video, and several others, I decided that what was really needed was the insertion of a Thien baffle before the dust/chips make it to the Mini-Gorilla. Lo and behold, home-made baffle in place and Mini-Gorilla works much better now.

 

My take--if you're inclined you could build yourself a great system that will work very well, and you can save yourself some significant money.  For me, the "professional" system was good, but could have been better.  Now with my efforts it is better.

 

My understanding, which may be wrong, is that Phil Thien approached the major makers with his baffle design as a way to improve their systems' function, but they declined.  So he patented his design, and now they can't use it. But you can.  If you use his design the decent thing to do would be to donate a little something at his website.  But, unless you start producing and selling baffles based on his design, there shouldn't be an issue either way.  I just wish I'd done more investigating BEFORE I set up my system, but I'm happy with what I've got now.

 

Alternatively, if you can do what "shaneymack" did in the"I'm officially filterless"thread, that would probably be even better.  But you need to be in a place where neighbors aren't too close and making up air in the shop is not a problem.

Since you need to use your machines now, then honestly just experiment with the DC's you have and see which work best for each machine.  You may be able to add a separator with a huge storage can for little money.  Look around in your local craigslist, and you may find people selling 55 gal plastic drums for $30 or less -use one or more of those as with a separator for the planers.

 

And keep in mind that the dust collector is only part of the solution.  Pay special attention to how dust is collected on some of the machines like the table saw and bandsaw.  This is where I think the Pentz site is very good -look at the modifications for better dust collection documented there.  experiment yourself, and you may find ways to significantly improve the dust collection.

 

And finally, the best advice I can give, wear the respirator all the time!

But at least the sanders have some semi-logical engineering in regard to DC.  At least mine does.  It may produce the largest amount of fine dust of all the machines, but mine seems fairly accommodating to the DC...at least to the naked eye.  For me, the bandsaw and table saw are the two biggest culprits.  Not because they produce the most dust or the finest dust, but because the DC engineering is so pathetic.  They may as well have included a fan that just blows everything in your face.  I've done some modifications on both tools, but they remain the worst offenders.

 

 

We must have the same table saw.

  • Author

Well, too many good things to go back and quote. But thanks again to all.

Correct, it is not a hobby shop. It is a "business", which is why I'm concerned. We have actual employees in there now. While I certainly don't want lung problems, I'm considerably less concerned about my lungs than theirs.

Currently, my planer is the only tool with dust collection and the least problematic. It has 4" pvc running maybe 12' to the 2HP in a straight horizontal run. I just need a better bag. I might need to get a separator for the other planer, though.

The only thing I can't really alter is the bandsaw. The dust port is part of the cast iron frame. And seems like it's purpose is to keep dust out of the machine, not my lungs.

So here's my take-away:

Most machines have crap DC design

4" is not good enough

Wear a respirator

Do the best I can

Don't make dust in California

With a band saw you can make your own shroud for under the blade that closes it in and connect a 4" there.  I split a 6" to two 4" and a 2-1/2".  The 2-1/2" runs to the back of the lower door, which I cut a hole in, to knock down the worst of what gets missed and would come shooting up from the lower wheel or make it all the way around and end up on the table, but that part is minor compared to getting a port right under the table.  Of course you can't tilt the table with it in place, but how often does anyone do that?

 

post-13721-0-36650100-1436765627_thumb.j

Since you’re operating a business with employees, then you should be getting advice from compliance experts, not a hobby forum... You insurance carrier most likely has a health & safety compliance program that can provide the expertise you need to keep your employees safe and you out of court... But then again, these are the same folks who will tell you to replace all your table saws with SawStop, so what do they know... :)

  • Author

Since you’re operating a business with employees, then you should be getting advice from compliance experts, not a hobby forum... You insurance carrier most likely has a health & safety compliance program that can provide the expertise you need to keep your employees safe and you out of court... But then again, these are the same folks who will tell you to replace all your table saws with SawStop, so what do they know... :)

Well, I pretty much agree, and I definitely didn't think of that. But for now, I'm trying to minimize risk without putting us in the position have having to fork over thousands of dollars just to have guys work. So I'm wanting to use what I have the best I can.

Like I said, when we move/upgrade our shop, I'll have professionals design a for real dust collection system. But knowing about things I can alter to improve that is great, too.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.