Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Dust collection - don't kill me

Featured Replies

Just so you know, I did try to search the forum and google for some basics, but couldn't find what I'm looking for.

Any good sites/sources that sum up how to effectively hook up dust collection? HP, hose size, hose length?, how many machines, etc?

I have 4 things available to me currently, and will upgrade to a serious system eventually. But here's what I got now

3HP Woodtek

2HP drum top with baldor motor

1/2HP Drum top with baldor motor

Shop vac (which I use for sanders)

Not asking for you guys to do the work for me, but thiught I'd let you know what I have. Anyway, just lookin for some rough guidelines.

More info is need. What machines are you running? Ridgid ducting? What size pipe? How long are your runs?

I have found a few DC setup tools on the old interweb. I think grizzley has one.

So, I'm in the process of researching for my shop's upgrade as well. 

 

Since money isn't the issue (I'll buy once and cry once) I'm looking at the Grizzly, Clear View, and Oneida.  I'm currently traveling for work so, I just haven't had the time I really need to make the final choice and pull the trigger.

 

If you look on Oneida's website, they'll design a system for you based on your shop and needs. 

Clear vue has a design function as well. Marc has 2 videos on clear vue, they are 200 and 201. The nordfab ducting seems the best way to go. Supposedly you can even buy the duct work from clear vue. If I ever get the chance to have real dust collector in my shop, this would be the route I go. For now Festool CT and other shop vacs will have to do the job.

I bought a clearvue not yet installed. They do have a duct design through them that costs 250 I believe she told me that is refunded toward the purchase if u buy from them

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

==>I'm currently traveling for work so, I just haven't had the time I really need to make the final choice and pull the trigger.

When you get closer, drop me a PM... I've got some reference stuff that may help.

==>I'm currently traveling for work so, I just haven't had the time I really need to make the final choice and pull the trigger.

When you get closer, drop me a PM... I've got some reference stuff that may help.

 

Thanks Trip, I really appreciate that!

  • Author

Thanks all. I'll check out all that.

I am currently running:

Grizzly 15" planer

Grizzly bandsaw

Delta unisaw table saw

6x48 belt sander

Will potentially have:

A second 15" planer

22" drum sander (or there abouts; donated and haven't gotten it set up yer)

Slot mortiser (fd 250 or lbm 200)

I bought the 4" clear tubing from grizzly. Our runs vary, but the longest would be 20+ ft, from machine, to ceiling, to dc. If that's absurdly long, I might be able to move some stuff. But I've heard change is dangerous and scary.

Eventually, we will have a for reals dust collection system, but we're holding off on that until the shop move.

So for now, I'm trying to make the best of what I got.

Ducted dust collection is one of those things that I can't seem to wrap my head around. I know it's possible, but from everything I see/hear everyone does it wrong. So my take is there is no correct way to do it. If there is a correct way to do it, it's written in cyphers and codes, and the only way to decrypt it is to dissect a unicorn. Or at least that's what it seems like. 

  • Author

Ducted dust collection is one of those things that I can't seem to wrap my head around. I know it's possible, but from everything I see/hear everyone does it wrong. So my take is there is no correct way to do it. If there is a correct way to do it, it's written in cyphers and codes, and the only way to decrypt it is to dissect a unicorn. Or at least that's what it seems like.

Yeah, was reading some of Bill Pentz' stuff, and that's the feeling I got. Seems like I need to manipulate physics so I don't get cancer. Hoping when I hire someone to do a real system, they have that power.

Oneida publishes a dust collection system resource kit. It’s a 40 page ‘dust control for dummies’ booklet that walks you through the process. It’s a very good place to start – far better than the Pentz site. It’s available free --- and if you ask, they may send you the pdf...

There is a right way and a wrong way...the problem is the right way would cost you a fortune and you'd have to modify almost all of your tools...most hobby tools are not designed for efficient DC even if you had the best DC in the world.

 

I read the whole Pentz site when I was getting started and he had me chasing my tail.  Then I woke up one morning and said screw Bill Pentz, put together a cheap system that collects most of the mess and didn't look back.  If I die from breathing wood then so be it.  It seems anything can kill you these days.  If you worried about all of it you'd have to live in a bubble.  That's right, a bubble.

It seems anything can kill you these days.

Super sharp bits of carbide moving around at high speed...no problem. Some dust in the air...THE END IS NIGH. I'm as paranoid about dust as the next guy, but it does always crack me up when I do something that is kinda unsafe and wrong but at least I'm wearing my respirator and safety glasses!

There is a right way and a wrong way...the problem is the right way would cost you a fortune and you'd have to modify almost all of your tools...most hobby tools are not designed for efficient DC even if you had the best DC in the world.

 

I read the whole Pentz site when I was getting started and he had me chasing my tail.  Then I woke up one morning and said screw Bill Pentz, put together a cheap system that collects most of the mess and didn't look back.  If I die from breathing wood then so be it.  It seems anything can kill you these days.  If you worried about all of it you'd have to live in a bubble.  That's right, a bubble.

 

Gotta agree. It doesn't help that his site looks and is written like a Shamwow ad. I think that a person could definitely go the route he says and be safe, but I think you can do a whole lot less and be safe as well. There is a variable to cancer that can't be quantified by anyone really. Example - My mom died from smoking related cancer after 30 years of smoking. My wife's parents have been smoking 55 years and are fine. This shows you that the easiest way to avoid smoking related cancer is to not smoke but the extreme opposite is not a guaranteed death sentence either. It depends on genetics and who knows what else.

 

In other words, I think Bill Pentz had some real bad luck and found a way to make money afterwards. This doesn't mean his information isn't valuable and correct for the safest possible air quality, but I feel like my shop vac, open garage door and respirator works awesome - until I can afford/have the space to go the distance.

Then why not take up smoking? Oh, that’s right – it’s bad for you...

 

For most of us, it’s all about pre-disposition... At current state of the art, you can’t know the setting of the slot machine’s first wheel – why add weight the others? It depends on how lucky you feel... Why not take up smoking?

 

Smoking’s an interesting analogy... In all fairness, most hobby woodworkers won’t mill enough wood to make a difference – similar to the pack-a-month social smoker. But species has an impact – some are decidedly more toxic than others – re: filtered-vs-un-filtered...

 

To Eric’s point, most hobby gear has crap DC – although it’s getting better... And for those of you using Euro gear, you can already see how much better DC can get if you design it in from the get-go...

 

What 's funny is folks know to use a dust mask when hand sanding, yet do nothing about DC for a drum sander – go figure? Just because you can’t see the dust, doesn’t mean that it’s not there... In fact, it’s the dust you can’t see that’s the most damaging... You can have a perfectly clean shop that appears 'dust free’, yet have loads of sub-0.05u dust...

 

If you work for a large company, borrow a particle counter from the Environmental, Health & Safety Officer... Try it in your shop for a weekend to see exactly what you’re actually breathing...  Do you feel lucky? Well, do you?*

 

 

 

*70’s movies for $100, Alex...
OK, the one’s also easy... so no hints...

Then why not take up smoking? Oh, that’s right – it’s bad for you...

 

For most of us, it’s all about pre-disposition... At current state of the art, you can’t know the setting of the slot machine’s first wheel – why add weight the others? It depends on how lucky you feel... Why not take up smoking?

 

Smoking’s an interesting analogy... In all fairness, most hobby woodworkers won’t mill enough wood to make a difference – similar to the pack-a-month social smoker. But species has an impact – some are decidedly more toxic than others – re: filtered-vs-un-filtered...

 

To Eric’s point, most hobby gear has crap DC – although it’s getting better... And for those of you using Euro gear, you can already see how much better DC can get if you design it in from the get-go...

 

What 's funny is folks know to use a dust mask when hand sanding, yet do nothing about DC for a drum sander – go figure? Just because you can’t see the dust, doesn’t mean that it’s not there... In fact, it’s the dust you can’t see that’s the most damaging... You can have a perfectly clean shop that appears 'dust free’, yet have loads of sub-0.05u dust...

 

If you work for a large company, borrow a particle counter from the Environmental, Health & Safety Officer... Try it in your shop for a weekend to see exactly what you’re actually breathing...  Do you feel lucky? Well, do you?*

 

 

 

*70’s movies for $100, Alex...

OK, the one’s also easy... so no hints...

 

Nobody said to pick up smoking. But Pentz's site is incredibly overdramatic. He's taking a fairly unique set of circumstances that were unfortunate for him and applying them to everyone as if it was guaranteed fact. And he's doing it at massive expenditure to people that buy into the whole thing. Like I said, it's not bad to do it, but it's not entirely necessary. I'd love to get to what he recommends one day, but it will be a multi-year investment. 

 

That's all I'm saying. 

Yeah, was reading some of Bill Pentz' stuff, and that's the feeling I got. Seems like I need to manipulate physics so I don't get cancer. Hoping when I hire someone to do a real system, they have that power.

 

Everyone knows woodworking only causes cancer in California.

From one guy trying to make it work to another:

 

1) The planer is your prime enemy.  It's really the only thing that can overwhelm/clog up/generally cause mayhem to your system.  If it's going into an improvised ducted system make it come into the first Y from the collector.  Any junction between it and the collector is a place for it to cause mayhem.  You may want to try one of those garbage can lid poor man's cyclone separators to get the bulk of the chips into an easier to empty container and less chance of mayhem.  Did I mention planers cause mayhem to your dust collection? 

 

2) Everything else is just degrees of how poorly it's going to work.  Sorry.

 

3) Dust collectors are high volume, low pressure.  Shop vacs are low volume, high pressure.  Don't hook up a dust collector to something with a tiny port or a shop vac to something with a huge one.

  • Author

From one guy trying to make it work to another:

1) The planer is your prime enemy. It's really the only thing that can overwhelm/clog up/generally cause mayhem to your system. If it's going into an improvised ducted system make it come into the first Y from the collector. Any junction between it and the collector is a place for it to cause mayhem. You may want to try one of those garbage can lid poor man's cyclone separators to get the bulk of the chips into an easier to empty container and less chance of mayhem. Did I mention planers cause mayhem to your dust collection?

2) Everything else is just degrees of how poorly it's going to work. Sorry.

3) Dust collectors are high volume, low pressure. Shop vacs are low volume, high pressure. Don't hook up a dust collector to something with a tiny port or a shop vac to something with a huge one.

Hey thanks!!!

I use 1.5 hp single stager, with a large impeller. This generats plenty of cfm - given that one does not overdo it.

My collector came with a y fitting (5" to double 4"), which I immediately removed. 4" DC fittings cannot move enough air - they choke even the best collectors.

Then I modified my machine ports to accept 5" (using HVAC takeoffs), and bought 8 feet of 5" flex hose.

As long as I only collect one machine at a time, this works very well.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.