Felder/Hammer/Minimax J/P Combo Owners...Help!!


Recommended Posts

Posted

Hi all,

I am in the final throws of making a commitment for big shop upgrades.  I will be able to spend what I need to to do it right.  For Owners of jointer/planer combos (A3-31 or 41, FS30, AD531, AD741), I would love to know of your motivations for making these machines a part of your shop.  Quality of the Euro Machines?  Space efficiency?  In general, if a craftsman wants the use of 12-16" jointing capacity (at a given price point of $4-7k), the choice is a European combo machine or separates (12" parallelogram jointer and 15" planer) from an imported source (Grizzly or Jet I suppose).  With the separates comes convenience by not having to make conversions but  some step down in quality and the typical requirement to put some time into finishing the manufacturing on your own.

For those who have made this decision, if space were no issue for you, would you still place higher value on the combination machine you own (which speaks highly of your appreciation of the machine quality) or would you opt for the greater convenience of separates although giving up on quality and engineering of the machine?

 

Thanks for your inputs!

Steve

Posted

As a straw man argument, I'd buy the 12" powermatic jointer and 15" powermatic planer (with Byrd head).  They wil be 15% off starting black friday, so you will be able to get both machines for ~6800.  The quality of some european machines might be better (I don't know), but for a high end hobby shop or small scale commercial shop I really think the powermatics will be great (definitely a step up from grizzly/jet) and the convenience of separates can't be beat.   I own a few powermatic machines and they require no additional "finishing".  Some minor assembly (i.e. installing fences), yes, but I think you will find that with any brand.  Their build quality is superb and they have required no major tweaking or tuning.  

^^^^^ +1

Posted

If you say you have the money to buy what you want, so why are you looking at combo machines?  Seems like you'd just be introducing inconvenience into your shop for no apparent reason. Different strokes different folks, but every time I had to change the machine from jointer to planer (or vice versa) I'd wanna throw it in the dumpster,  no matter how high quality a machine. 

  • Like 1
Posted
I bought an A3 41 earlier this year (16" combo planer/jointer).  It's still sitting on a pallet waiting for the shop to be built (excavation should start next week) so I'm commenting on my decision making process not how it actually turned out!
  1. I decided I wanted a combo machine for a smaller foot print.  Given the way I was envisioning the new shop, I liked having a single material handling "lane" for lumber for two operations.  This is a personal thing, but for me I didn't want to have tools on wheels, I wanted a good workflow and material handling flow with my machines stationary.  Even with a decent shop foot print (22x36), I still wanted to conserve space as much as I could.  ( I was thinking 8-10 feet in front of the machine, 8-10 feet after the machine... that's a lot if you have it with the jointer, planer, tablesaw, bandsaw)
  2. I'm not concerned about machine change-over.  I have a friend with the A3 31 and it doesn't seem that inconvenient.  I guess I'll have to see how it is in "production"
  3. I felt that, at the worst, I could leave the combo machine as a jointer and buy a separate planer if changeover gets that frustrating
  4. I wanted a wide jointer - I had been limited by my old narrow jet 6" jointer and wanted to be able to joint wide boards.  I'm sure a 12" (like the PM) would have been ok for 95% of what I do, but I decided to plan for 99% of what I do.
  5. I wanted a helical head on both machines - in my opinion it was better to buy one head and use it twice.  For the price I paid, I don't believe I could get a Powermatic 12" HH jointer and a Powermatic 15" HH planer, even with a 15% discount, for that money.
  6. I didn't want a Jet or Grizzly machine.

Unfortunately I bought before the euro took a huge dump, so I probably paid more in January than I would today!

 

 

  • Like 2
Posted

I can't speak to any of the Euro machines having not used them or even really looked into them much (mostly due to lack of a local dealer as far as I'm aware), but I do own the 12" Jet combination jointer/planer and have been using it for about 9 months now. My reasoning was pretty straightforward. I needed machines for both functions and my shop is a two-car garage. It's a dedicated shop, but I still try to preserve as much space as possible because in the middle of a project it can get pretty cramped with materials sitting around. Cost really wasn't even a consideration.

I looked at other combination machines and anything that required removing components for conversion was right out. I didn't want to spend time taking off fences, etc. With the Jet 12", you flip some levers, drop a retaining pin, and flip over the dust collection shroud and you're done as far as going from jointing to planing. Converting back to jointing take a couple extra moments because you have to crank down the planer bed to flip the dust shroud back to the original position. Overall I've been happy with the quality of the machine.

That said, if space wasn't a consideration I would absolutely go with separate machines. My primary reason has to do with the bed/table lengths on the combination machines. Running 8' boards over the jointer was a bit of a pain because of the short table. The bed for the planer is even shorter, so if you're not careful it is pretty easy to get significant snipe on your boards. This is solved with learning techniques to deal with the shorter bed and it's generally not an issue anymore, but I would give my left arm for longer tables/beds when dealing with longer boards just for the sake of keeping things simple.

My wife and I are actually looking at moving here in the next year or so and a three-car garage is on the menu. If that goes through, I will be getting a dedicated 8" jointer and 15-20" planer. I probably won't get rid of this one, though. I do find that I run into 9-10" wide boards fairly often and that 12" jointing capacity is very nice to have when it is needed and the footprint is pretty small.

Posted

The biggest downside of the combos isn't the switchover IMHO...it's the length of the jointer tables.   The A3 31 being discussed here has a 1400mm table...only just over 55 inches.   The 16" one is slightly better at just under 71" table length.    However compare either of those to separates...for PM, the 6" is already 66" long and the 8" is 82" long...even the Grizzly 8" one is 76" long.   The 12" width may be nice, but 55" length of the table can be pretty limiting unless you're willing to work around it with rollers and whatnot.

Posted

The biggest downside of the combos isn't the switchover IMHO...it's the length of the jointer tables.   The A3 31 being discussed here has a 1400mm table...only just over 55 inches.   The 16" one is slightly better at just under 71" table length.    However compare either of those to separates...for PM, the 6" is already 66" long and the 8" is 82" long...even the Grizzly 8" one is 76" long.   The 12" width may be nice, but 55" length of the table can be pretty limiting unless you're willing to work around it with rollers and whatnot.

great point. They do have table extensions (which I bought) that can be used in the jointing or planing operations. I believe they can be used on the bandsaws as well. 

Posted (edited)

==>The quality of some european machines might be better (I don't know)

If we’re talking PM –v- Felder, Martin, et al -- we’re talking a different ballpark (think Honda –vs- BMW M-series)... If we’re talking Grizzly and the like, think Yugo... It’s a different decision path. Hammer is value-line Felder, but still very good (think Toyota –v- Lexis)... Felder/Hammer is having a sale that started last week – I’ve gotten several flyers in the last two weeks, but not in the mood to upgrade anything at the moment, so didn't pay attention to the details...

Having lived with Euro (separates and combo) & PM -- sometimes in the same shop at the same time -- there are differences in workflow when approaching a given operation... So part of the equation is space, part is money and part is desired workflow... For example,combo jointers have a shorter infeed/outfeed... If you tend to excavate components prior to rough milling, this should not be much of an issue. If you're the type to try to get every last usable component from a stick, this constraint may drive you crazy...

To address your question... When I relocated to a bigger shop, I went separates to improve reliability (problems with controls)... I plan to relocate again in a few years (to around 1200sq ft), and I'll be back to a five-station combo unit...

If you have specific questions, you can PM me.

 

Good luck.

 

Edited by hhh
  • Like 1
Posted

I have not bought it yet either, but I have been considering a combination machine.  In particular the Jet JJP-12HH with the helical head).  

I have a large basement space (23 x23 ish), but by the time I carve out space for the door way into the shop and the door to the outside and the traffic way between and access to the windows to open them and don't forget that dang lolly column and the sump pump... Well, it's not so big as it looks.  So space savings is important.  

Also at this point I don't yet know how I want my shop organized, so I plan to keep as much on movable stands  as possible.  I'm figuring that if I am going to joint some boards I will likely plane them as well.  Both operations can happen in the same space so I only have to move (and put away) one machine.

 The switch over to me seems a small price to pay.  I am one guy working alone doing woodworking as a hobby,  Some of the forum members are in commercial production or at least making some money at this and if that's the case I can certainly see that switching back and forth would be a significant production cost.  Ditto, if you're trying to work with someone else in the shop at the same time.

Speaking of switch over, I hope to be moving in 3 to 5 years.  I can dream about how grand my the next shop will be (that's fodder of a whole nuther post), but let's face it,  it could end up being a lot smaller.  But if I spend a few to several thousand dollars on a power tool I am going to expect to have to live with it the rest of my life.  Hence the foot print argument again.  

Another consideration for me is electricity.  I put in a single 220v line with my electrician friend last Spring. He's coming back this fall to put in a second 220v circuit which I need for heat.  So I will have one 220v circuit for power tools.  That's not a problem, talented as I intend to become I can only run one tool at a time.  But then comes the outlet question.  How many?, where?, which of the many different NEMA 220v plug styles?    Powering one tool rather than two is a more minor issue, but it has it's expense, and makes the two in one unit look better to me.

That said, the issue about short infeed and outfeed tables is a concern. I will have to look into that more as concerns my own needs.  

Posted

Mark J, I was enamored with that same Jet unit.  I think it is a great machine from everything I've read.  Very few downsides other than the short tables, and the cost and space savings are impressive.   If you're in a basement, really long boards may not make as much sense anyway. If you're always roughing out to length beforehand, the short tables are less of a concern. 

Posted

Thanks Vyrolan.  That's a good point.  Did you end up with one of these, something else or still considering your options?  

Still considering because I still haven't upgraded the electrical in my garage and until I do I can't really do much of anything with bigger machines.    However I've gone away from desiring the combo machine in favor of separates.    The space is not as big of an issue for me as I thought initially and I'm not a fan of the shorter tables as I do see myself doing plenty of full-sized furniture projects.   If I thought I'd only be doing smaller stuff, I would probably still favor the Jet combo just for space/cost/etc.  Good luck!

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 43 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined