Recommended Posts

Posted

Looking to upgrade my 14" jet for numerous reasons. One, six inches of resaw is limiting in quite a few respects. Two, I want a better fence and guide system for increased accuracy. Three, I want a larger/powerful/accurate/stable machine. My knowledge and setup of band saws is not leagues deep. Quite the opposite, I have been using mine for 8 months! I have been using it long enough to know that it simply isn't up to snuff to the rest of my equipment, and doesn't perform to the level I want it to. Im sure some guys can setup a 14" jet to perform beautifully, but I would rather have a machine that sets me up for success out of the gate. Hopefully that makes sense of where I am coming from. This means I need a sort of renaissance man band saw. I need it to be able to cut semi-tight curves, I need it to be able to resaw, and I need it to handle my non-table saw joinery. Lastly, I need it to fit in my basement shop that is becoming increasingly tight with a full sub panel. I assumed I would be best suited to a 18-20" machine with 3hp+ that would handle everything I needed. Now I am seriously considering a pair of MM16s on the used market that might be able to handle everything I need in a smaller footprint. I want to keep my budget to $2000 or under if possible. I have hand tools and a few more festool items on the list that I would like to get to this year.

 

First up, MM16 that is in pretty awesome shape and posted on here before. $2400+6 hour drive and rental fees. I should note this is Gen III saw. Original Euro guides

Next, Gen I or Gen II MM16 for $1200+$350 shipping. I have no idea if the Gen I or Gen II MM16s were drastically inferior, but they had 3.6hp motors and only 13" resaw versus the new 4.8hp and 16" resaw capacity. This thing has been used, and has minor surface rust on the guide post, but the machine looks good and its from a hobbyist shop. Lets say its 10ish years old. Retrofitted with carter guides. I think the switch is broke and needs replaced.

Laguna 16 LT-3000. Taiwan saw with ceramic guides, 3hp leeson motor. I think the guy wants $1400, but can most likely be talked down off that ledge. same $350 shipping

 

Laguna LT20HD for $3000+shipping. might be able to negotiate this, but the saw is in very good shape, so maybe not.

 

Lastly, Felder 610 that looks like it just came off the assembly line for $3000ish + transportation/shipping costs.

 

Or do I keep waiting for a particular model/go new? I just don't feel like $2000 is going to get me the quality that I want new, which sounds insane to me considering I have a shop full of great tools and none of them cost over $2000--well, aside from the new PM209 that has yet to arrive. Is the Minimax everything I have dreamed of and more? Is there something drastic between the new gen MM16 versus the older gen? Finally, are laguna's Taiwan saws really that hit or miss? In a perfect world, I think an Italian made 20" would probably be perfect, but good luck to me finding one within my budget. We all don't have Tom's luck and a sponsorship from evaporust.

 

 

Posted

Not sure what your work entails in terms of size (you may not need bigger than 14"?), but I am really pleased with my Laguna 14bx (I have the 110V/1.75hp version, but also available in more powerful version if you prefer). It is a new saw - both to me and in the market, but an updated version of the popular 14/12 bandsaw. This may be all you need and you'd save money based on what you said you want it to do. There are often 10-15% off Laguna sales, which is what I got from thisiswoodworking.com.

It has the ceramic guides, 12" resaw capacity (actually more like 13") - I just resawed a few 10" boards this past week and it cut through very cleanly with little effort.  This was on both cherry and walnut boards with a new 1/2" Highland Woodworking woodslicer resaw blade.

Setup for the saw was a breeze - all I really had to do was light assembly - put the table on, install and tension blade, align fence and I was good to go. Laguna has a good video series on their website that goes through all the set up.

This is the first bandsaw I've owned, so in the same boat as not being incredibly knowledgeable nor wanting to spend time restoring/setting up, etc.  This was good to go right away, which is what I wanted. Couldn't be happier so far (I bought it when it came out around Nov last year).

Posted
8 minutes ago, Janello said:

Out of your list > Felder. Nuff said. No contest.

haha that bad, huh? It was outside of the budget, and at 23-24" possibly too big for my space anyways. It looks so awesome though...

Posted

I have to echo the general question of what are you making that requires bigger then 14"? I can understand the desire to have a solid saw and a lot of the old delta clones (of which I believe the older jets certainly are amongst that line and maybe the newer ones as well) are not particularly sturdy saws compared to some of the saws with large cast iron trunnions. However there are saws in the 14" range that are made of stronger materials.

Posted

Just furniture and bowl blanks. Yeah, im not saying 14" saws are crap, but I am saying 6" resaw with a 1hp motor is crap. Ive heard such mixed reviews on riser kits. Some guys love them, Marc and Shannon mentioned they transformed the saw completely and not in a good way. Here is the saw I own http://www.jettools.com/us/en/p/14-closed-stand-bandsaw-1hp-1ph-115-230v/708115K

 

I have a 12" jointer, so I don't plan on resawing more than 12", but it would make sense to have a band saw that could match my jointing capabilities. My stash isn't comprised of all 12"+ boards, but I have my fair share. I don't plan on making my own veneer on a consistent basis, but it might be a one off thing I do here or there for a project. Other than that vague description, I am kinda just starting my woodworking journey and I have no idea where I am headed. I just know enough to know that big and heavy typically equals safer, effective, more stable, and easier to work with. I.e. 6" rigid jointer shifting around with 8-9' boards on it compared to a 1300lb 12" jointer that I can barely budge with all my strength. Or, dewalt portable saw tipping over versus a unisaw that never moves. I don't need a 3000lb oliver or northfield(too bad I cant fit them, there are plenty of them well under budget around me), but I do want something that's not going to get tippy on me or move around. This jet makes me nervous, because it does move around when you apply pressure to your work piece. Also, the jet's table is at an absurd height. It is at my chest height, I think. It's atleast 15-18" higher than the height of my table saw, which doesn't help the instability of the machine.

I think im pretty well sold on one of the minimax saws. Just don't know if there is enough difference between the earlier model mm16 versus the newer model mm16 to justify the extra grand.

Posted

I put a riser block on my Delta 14" years ago. I now have 12 1/2" of re-saw capacity. Im not sure what these mixed reviews are about. All the riser block does is give the saw more capacity. Everything you need is with the kit but larger saw blades. What are the negatives you hear about? Sometimes you have to question peoples motivation. I have done a lot of re-sawing over the years and never complained about my 14" Delta.

Now, if you plan on doing any re-sawing...may I suggest to keep your saw, take the savings and purchase a drum sander if you don't already have one. In my opinion re-sawing and drum sander go hand in hand. 

Also, my saw would walk around the shop floor due to the uneven cement it stands on. I took squares of carpet and placed under each foot. Now my saw it is rock solid. 

Good luck on the new saw purchase. 

 

-Ace-

Posted

Ace, the primary negatives I hear from riser blocks are it kills the rigidity of the saw, and you are left with a saw that technically has 12" free under the guides, but still doesn't have the motor, rigidity, or strength to tension a blade and resaw 12". Like I said, some guys, like you, absolutely love the riser kits on their 14" saws. Other guys have serious remorse.

 

I have a unisaw with vsct fence, 12" jointer, cyclone, PM209hh, supermax 37x2 drum sander, 1960s 15" delta drill press, nova dvr xp lathe, jessem mast r lift excel + PC motor + mitre slide, and the jet band saw. This band saw upgrade is the last major feather in my cap to happen for the next 5ish years until I move. Even then, most of that stuff will not requiring upgrading. That is where I am with this band saw purchase. Aside from a festool vac and maybe a stationary spindle sander I am done with purchases over $500. This is it, I will be married in a few months, kids on the horizon im sure, all fun and games will be ending soon--Overly dramatic, but my point is this is it for tools. I have a few years to get it all in before the tap is diverted to college funds and other nonsense. I don't want to buy a 17" grizzly right now only to have it crap the bed in 3-4 years when I have a newborn with a second on the way.

Posted

Congratulations are in order on the upcoming Marriage, as well as, acquiring your pre-marital assets, smart man :P. One word of advice ~ make sure your new shop space is not in your basement. Loud tool's and sleeping baby = unhappy Wife = unhappy Life...don't ask me how I know this:D. Oh yeah....your tools will shortly become friend's you use to know!

Sounds like you have things figured out except the part of buying more tools over 500.00. This woodworking thing is a big monster that keeps yelling.....FEED ME!

Hey man, all the best and the good changes to your life!

 

-Ace- 

 

 

 

  

Posted

The problem with these types of questions is they really are asking two different questions at the same time only one of which can be answered by someone other then the original poster. 

The first question being asked is "what tool can do what I want?" 

The second question is "will I value my new tool at least as much as I value the money it costs?"

The first question the internet can answer.  The second question takes into account variables such as your present financial situation, your desire for a particular tool or feature,  and perceptions of other tools, along with other things. This question the internet lacks the data necessaryto answer. 

Regarding the first question, the jet saw you linked is the old delta clone style I spoke of previously. I was not happy with a similar saw either.  There are saws in the 14" size range which are better.  Take a look at the Laguna options.  They have beefy cast iron trunnions as compared to the pot metal trunnions on the jet. I think you will find this makes a large difference how the saw feels. You can see it demo'd at a woodworking show if you happen to live near one or a woodcraft store. Also there are lots of videos online. 

Certainly all of the saws you list are capable of doing what you want. There are cheaper options as well. It is up to you to decide if the extra money is worth it to you. My advice is to look at the cheaper options in person, thenif not happy go looking for a bigger saw.

And congratulationson getting married.  As a recently married guy I can say it's a fun experience! 

Posted

I am not very experienced, so take my advise with a grain of salt. I am in a similar situation and it's always a tough choice. 

The Italian saws are really great, but you may have problems finding spare parts, service, etc. in the US. 

One model I liked is the Powermatic 15",  priced at about $2800. 

At a lower level you will find the 17" Grizzly - a good performer for the money.  

Jet offers their 18" model - a friend of mine uses that tool at work and he is very pleased. Roughly $1900 new. 

Anyway, it will be interesting to know what you chose at the end.  

Posted
On Friday, March 18, 2016 at 10:38 AM, AceHoleInOne said:

Congratulations are in order on the upcoming Marriage, as well as, acquiring your pre-marital assets, smart man :P. One word of advice ~ make sure your new shop space is not in your basement. Loud tool's and sleeping baby = unhappy Wife = unhappy Life...don't ask me how I know this:D. Oh yeah....your tools will shortly become friend's you use to know!

Sounds like you have things figured out except the part of buying more tools over 500.00. This woodworking thing is a big monster that keeps yelling.....FEED ME!

Hey man, all the best and the good changes to your life!

 

-Ace-

 

 

 

 

haha thanks for the advice, but im screwed because the tools ARE in the basement! Im sure kids will flip my life on its head. The $500ish purchases are easy to sweep under the rug, and they typically don't weigh 800lbs!

 

I guess to answer the other questions about value and performance, the 2.5hp 14" laguna could fulfill my needs very well im sure, but it feels a little on the lighter side of the spectrum. It's about 250-270lbs, the table isn't enormous, 14" to the spine isn't awesome, and im nervous it will leave me wanting more. I was pretty pleased with the cuts and accuracy I received from my delta contractor table saw, but I prefer my unisaw much more for the stability, power, and how it holds its settings. No doubt I had a lot of fun making things with the contractor saw, but the cabinet saw is more pleasurable to use, which is where my head is at on this purchase. I feel like I have the portable table saws of the band saw world, and I would rather jump to the one and done cabinet saw of the band saw world. My inexperience with band saws leaves me wondering what the direct comparison model would be? In my head, I have built it up to be a 16-20" saw with 3hp motor and 12"+ resaw. Oddly enough I have a couple Powermatic 24"ers that would fit within my budget, or just out, but those footprints are GIGANTIC, and I simply couldn't fit it. Same to be said for the old PM81 20" saw. Tough to find the right power/capability that will fit in my 36" by 36" by 85" volume I have to work with. It would be even better to have it on some form of mobile base to move out 2-3' from the wall when in use to rip long boards. Built in mobility is a convenient feature of the Italian saws.

 

Posted

I have a very old Delta 14" with riser.  I put a 1-1/2 hp Baldor on it.  It will do just fine resawing up to its capacity, which would be fine for making a small number of pieces of furniture a year, but is very slow in comparison to a big saw that will pull bigger teeth on a wider blade much faster.  I had a job come up where I needed to resaw 10,000 lineal feet of Cypress, so I now have an old 24" Italian saw, bought for dirt cheap, that will resaw what I needed to as fast as one can push it through-3 seconds to cut 24".  I wouldn't want to bother to change blades often on the big one.  The 14" is a snap to change blades on for different jobs. I keep a 3/8" blade on it now, and don't need to think about resawing anything with it.  You can't have it all in one bandsaw.  There will always be some sort of trade-off. The most important first step is to decide what you need to do with one.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   3 Members, 0 Anonymous, 76 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined