Recommended Posts

Posted

I purchased a 14" Porter Cable bandsaw at a local big box long before I ever heard of resawing. I haven't used it a lot but it doesn't do a very good job of resawing. I've purchased $100+ saw blades which help but it still not close to my friends saws who made for this. Is it possible to upgrade to make it better or should I just try to get rid of it and get a better saw?

Posted

For me the jump to a bandsaw that would be good for resawing is something I've also considered. I currently have a 14" Grizzly with no riser block. However every time I look into the cost of upgrading I ask myself truly how much resawing I plan on doing. I don't work with logs or have much thick stock. I tend to buy my wood from a lumber yard on a project-by-project basis so I am already buying pretty much the thickness I need. For those few occasions where I have a thick board that I need thinner I just sacrifice it and plan it down. Yes I'm losing a bit of money on wood but not enough to justify upgrading my bandsaw.

Posted

Both responders so far make good points. I sold my smaller saw when I bought a larger saw only to turn around and buy another smaller saw about a month later when I realized I really didn't want to be without it. This was the expensive way to do it, don't do that.

The other thing to consider of course is just how much resawing you will do. I resaw on almost every project so this is an easy decision for me. If it's only 6 times a year, I'd spend my money elsewhere.

  • Like 1
Posted
5 minutes ago, Hammer5573 said:

Do you think that replacing the existing guides with bearing guides would help..?

That bandsaw is not worth spending money on IMO to attempt to turn it into a resaw machine.  If you want to resaw on a regular basis you simply need more saw than a 14" cast iron Delta clone, particularly when the clone is a lower end clone.

Posted

If I had the room, I might have a second band saw for tighter curves. Chances are I wouldn't want another 14" cast iron saw. I hated the jet I had. I have a 20" Laguna that is fantastic. 95% of the time it has a 1-1/4" resaw king on it. It's really no problem to swap out blades to a 3/8 or 1/2 blade for tight curves. If I had the space, I wouldn't pick up a 14" saw, I would get one of the old school 24-36" saws and run a skinny blade on it for curved work. The 14" jet had a tiny table, vibrated like heck, and was crap to work with. Bigger saws are much nicer to work with, in my opinion. 

Posted
1 hour ago, Pwk5017 said:

If I had the room, I might have a second band saw for tighter curves. Chances are I wouldn't want another 14" cast iron saw. I hated the jet I had. I have a 20" Laguna that is fantastic. 95% of the time it has a 1-1/4" resaw king on it. It's really no problem to swap out blades to a 3/8 or 1/2 blade for tight curves. If I had the space, I wouldn't pick up a 14" saw, I would get one of the old school 24-36" saws and run a skinny blade on it for curved work. The 14" jet had a tiny table, vibrated like heck, and was crap to work with. Bigger saws are much nicer to work with, in my opinion. 

 

If you get a older cast 28-36" saw you would be better off making the old saw your resaw.  Even the lower quality ones will be stiffer than the ACM built Laguna.

Posted
8 hours ago, Hammer5573 said:

Do you think that replacing the existing guides with bearing guides would help..?

Nice guides can make a nice saw nicer. As with the expensive blade, trying to overcome a poorly tracking saw through force via new guides is throwing good money after bad.  Sorry.

Posted
On 1/27/2017 at 11:15 PM, HuxleyWood said:

If you get a older cast 28-36" saw you would be better off making the old saw your resaw.  Even the lower quality ones will be stiffer than the ACM built Laguna.

Good point, I was thinking about the older saws accepting a skinnier blade than my ceramic guides. I think I can only go down to 3/8". Never had to use it, because I cut 75% of my curves with the resaw king. Everything else gets a 1/2" blade. I simply don't incorporate a lot of tight curves in my work as of yet. And it depends, there's a 36" Oliver in my area for like $200-300 with a 1.5hp single phase motor. Something like that would be a nice dedicated machine. I love the table size on the old bigger saws. The 14" saws give you a dessert plate to work on. 

Posted
11 minutes ago, wdwerker said:

I would wonder what that 36" saw weighs and how tall it is.

While that depends on the brand etc a 36" cast saw usually runs just over 2,000 pounds up to 3,000 pounds and height from just over 100" to around 115" for most of the "standard" builds.

Posted

At $200-300 it must need work or have missing parts I bet. There was a great article in FWW years ago about how much a free bandsaw can cost. Moving a machine like that is definitely a job for the pros.

  • Like 1
Posted
8 hours ago, wdwerker said:

At $200-300 it must need work or have missing parts I bet. There was a great article in FWW years ago about how much a free bandsaw can cost. Moving a machine like that is definitely a job for the pros.

 

While I have seen some stupid low prices on big saws that is on the "scrap iron" end of pricing.  One has to keep in mind tires alone on a 36" saw can run 600-700 bucks.  Plus the 1.5hp motor is pretty suspect, for a old 36" saw you want to see 5, 7.5 or even 10hp and DMD is always preferable to belt drive if the motor is solid (you do NOT want to have a big old DMD motor rewound, DAMHIK.  Plenty of those size saws get moved by old arn lovers but it is not for the faint of heart or ill equipped and many (most?) hobbyists don't have the vertical clearance to get them through the door.  

While an interesting subject, to me anyway, I doubt the OP is contemplating the jump from a 14" PC to a 36" behemoth.

Posted

Just my two cents on a few aspects of this...

Not sure what $100 blade you bought, but on the 14" delta clonesI doubt that a heavy duty re-saw blade makes much sense.  I found that even the thin (0.022"?) 3/4" Timberwolf blade really can't be tensioned very well on these saws.  It is supposedly designed to run lower tension, but I didn't find that to really be optimum.  Initially I thought  they were pretty good, but ultimately I found problems.  Running the necessary tension for those blades to really perform destroyed the tensioning arm on my saw in about a year of not very heavy re-saw use.  I built about 100 mountain dulcimers in that year and did all the re-sawing of the sides and sound boards, so it was used a good bit but not like a production shop making furniture.

I decided that a 1/2" blade gave as good or better re-saw results compared to the 3/4" one on these saws.

I am not convinced that it is worth upgrading  the guides to carters or whatever.  I think that on a properly tuned saw the guide choices are not super critical to the cut quality.  For me one key was setting up the tracking so the bottom of the gullets was in the middle of the tire or at least close (a problem with the 3/4" blades).

I have found that for my work my 14" delta is fine.  Maybe not ideal, but Ok.  It is slower and the results might require more passes through the thickness sander than a bigger better saw would require, but for my work that is acceptable.  If it was a higher production shop doing the same work I might be able to justify the expense and space taken by a bigger saw.  In that case I'd want to keep the 14" saw for cutting curves and avoid changing blades on the big saw leaving the re-saw blade on it most or even all of the time.

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 54 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined