Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

what the heck are all these white lines???

Featured Replies

Hello All! I epitomize the word "novice" and as such, I desperately need help with my project (my very first go at refinishing).  I wanted to refinish a 20 year old maple coffee table for my wife. 

After doing a lot of reading and enlisting the help of a buddy of mine who used to make cabinets professionally, I began my journey. This was my second attempt at this table (we can summarize attempt one by saying that testing first is not a step one should skip) So for attempt 2, I went to a woodworking specialty store and after showing them some photos of my disaster, they recommended 3 General Finishes products: Seal-a-Cell (an oil based pre coat) to use as a pre stain conditioner, oil based gel stain, and "high performance" (water based poly) 

Here's what I did:

1) random orbital sander 80, 120, 220. Then, checked the raw surface very carefully using a shop light at a low angle and cleaned up a couple swirls 

2) since I'd read that water based finishes can raise the grain, I spritzed with distilled water and wiped on with a shop towel. waited an hour, then lightly hand sanded the raised grain out with 220 

3) applied the seal a cell with a foam brush then wiped off the excess with a shop towel. waited about 30-60 minutes

4)  applied the gel stain with a foam brush, then wiped off with a shop towel as soon as I'd finished covering the surface. 

The first picture is just the sanded wood for reference. The second is stained table in normal overhead light...which both my wife and I were very pleased with.  (MUCH better than the first time). We decided  the color was dark enough so I wasn't even going to do a second coat of stain. I read that if you're putting a water finish over an oil stain, you need to make sure to give it PLENTY of time to dry so I was going to wait 3 or 4 days. 

Anyway, I went back out to the garage to clean up a couple hours later and as I was putting away my shop light, I happened to notice the table top while I was holding the light at a very low angle. At first I thought it was just dust but after lightly wiping with a cloth to no avail, I started to become concerned. I went and got a bright flashlight and held just above the surface at a very low angle. This is the third picture. It looks like a white dust is on the table (and it's the ENTIRE table. depending on where you aim the light, you can see it everywhere. Looking at it very closely the white lines appear to follow the grains of the wood and are  most pronounced on the darker grains of wood. Feeling the surface it feels very smooth (not like the slightly rough/textured feel it had after applying the water). It's strange because if the light is directly overhead, the table looks great, but as you move the light lower and lower, it starts to appear almost immediately and gets worse and worse as you go. 

After a couple hours of searching online, I'm finding all sorts of different explanations but nearly all of them have to do with the finish, NOT the stain.  

So here are my questions:

 Is this normal? (or normal for gel stain)

 will the poly cover it up (or at least reduce it).... I think I could live it with it if I'd only ever see it as the setting sun catches the table at just the right angle through the window....

If it's not normal and/or the poly won't get rid of it, is there anything that can be done, short of sanding it all out and starting over? (I've already sanded it down twice and I'm afraid of revealing the screws if I sand anymore....plus my wife wants her table back)

And again if it's not normal, what did I do wrong and how might I best avoid it in the future? 

Thank you all in advance for your help and for humoring a clueless newbie. 

 

 

 

 

20170402_135606.jpg

20170402_172141.jpg

20170402_214445.jpg

Use overhead lighting instead of low angle lighting in the room. Jus kidding. Probably a dumb question, but did you wipe/blow the dust off first , before the first coat of finish. It appears that the white is mostly in the lower part of the grain.

  • Author

Thanks to both of you for responding!

K Cooper: yes I wiped it off with a terry cloth. My first thought was dust too but it's literally covering the whole table  (if I move the light around, there isn't a single area that isn't showing this) not just a couple of places.

 

ChrisG: No, General Finishes website indicated that when using the seal-a-cell to prestain wood, you should apply the stain before the seal a cell dries. It was consistent with what they told me at the store so that's what I was going based off of. 

 

If it isn't dust that's trapped in the pores.Then my guess from a thousand miles away is the old finish wasn't completely removed.That might have been a seal coat.

It doesn't really matter because your finished table looks great.And like Cooper mentions keep raking off it in the house.

Aj

A few thoughts. It does look to me like the white material is more concentrated in the softer part of the grain which initially could indicate the original finish sunk in deeper to those spots and unfortunately is left behind.

I don't believe a top coat will do anything more than make a thicker later on top of the residue. 

I don't use any of those finishes except high performance and quite honestly, I am less than thrilled with it. If you want it to look good, you're already there. It looks lots better than a lot of the "help" topics that are started. If you want better than good, it looks like that top needs brought back down to actual bare wood.

5 minutes ago, Brendon_t said:

A few thoughts. It does look to me like the white material is more concentrated in the softer part of the grain which initially could indicate the original finish sunk in deeper to those spots and unfortunately is left behind.

I don't believe a top coat will do anything more than make a thicker later on top of the residue. 

I don't use any of those finishes except high performance and quite honestly, I am less than thrilled with it. If you want it to look good, you're already there. It looks lots better than a lot of the "help" topics that are started. If you want better than good, it looks like that top needs brought back down to actual bare wood.

+1

Sounds like you were pretty thorough with your surface prep. Thats an odd one. Applying stain to a wet sealer sounds odd to me but if thats what GF recommends its hard to site that as the issue. This being a second attempt at refinishing and third finish applied to the piece, maybe something got left behind.

 

I agree with the others, it looks great in normal lighting. Topcoat it and love it.

 

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G890A using Tapatalk

 

 

  • Author

Thanks again for all your responses! (and thanks for the compliments, I'd like to think I did okay for a newbie!)  Some seem to think the top coat will help and others not. I guess it'll be easier to try it and see what happens. If I have to sand it again anyway, a layer of poly will only mean a bit longer with the sander. 

C Shaffer: I have only done the top. The sides have the original finish on them and are going to be painted. 

Mike: I think you might be onto something because it does look like the darker grains are showing more of the white...though if that's really the case or they just show up more because they contrast the darker color below, who can say. 

Does anyone think that a light sanding on the stain would help? I was sort of thinking a light 220 sanding and perhaps another layer of stain...we like the color as is but a bit darker would be okay too....good idea? bad idea? waste of time??

If not, I think I might just take the simple advice of "top coat it and love it". I'll just first have to find out if sunlight shows the white because that will determine whether or not I can live with it. 

And for a third time I will say thanks again to all of you! I'm glad I've stumbled on such a friendly community of people who know a lot more than me about something I'm trying to get good at!

8 minutes ago, MDHeinze said:

Does anyone think that a light sanding on the stain would help? I was sort of thinking a light 220 sanding and perhaps another layer of stain...we like the color as is but a bit darker would be okay too....good idea? bad idea? waste of time??

I think going over with some 400/600 or even steel wool might be a good idea. See if the white stuff is at the surface or not. Don't go below 320 though, you don't really want to remove any material, and Gel Stain is thin. In my experience with Gel Stain, it looks best with a couple coats, though I've only used their darker tints.

First, you don't need to raise the grain with water since you didn't use a water-based sealer and stain. The topcoat you used being water-based, wont raise the grain because the oil based products sealed the wood.

******You may of trapped water in the wood and sealed it in with the seal-a-cell then gel stain causing the white appearance.   

Second, the results could be the remains of the disaster you spoke still down in the grain of the maple from your first attempt 

******If this were me, I would use a good chemical stripper remove the finish and start over. Sorry, but no easy way out if you want  the job done right.

 

-Ace-

 

 

 

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.