Marmotjr Posted May 12, 2017 Report Posted May 12, 2017 A couple years ago I picked up a grab bag box of 30lbs of pen blanks. They are random domestics and exotics. Some I could Identify, some I cannot. These are the blanks from my Scrap box Special project I'm working on. If anybody has a clue about any of them, it'd be appreciated. If not, oh well, I'll make something up, like I do when I sell these as pens. Apologies for the focus. I should have broken out the macro adapter for this. They looked ok on the preview screen, but when I downloaded them, ugggh. I already have the blanks in the first glue up, so end grain shots are out. A) C) D) E) Walnut? F) Thanks Guys! Quote
kyokahn Posted May 12, 2017 Report Posted May 12, 2017 This is often an exercise in futility, but why not give it a shot? C) White Oak? D) Can you plane it just a bit so the grain shows? E) That end grain is definitely not walnut. Is it especially heavy (does it sink in water)? Oily? It looks an awful lot like Katalox (Mexican ebony) Quote
Eric. Posted May 12, 2017 Report Posted May 12, 2017 Not great sample pics man...too small, some are too rough. A) mahogany-ish B ) exotic, unidentifiable - too small of a sample C) walnut - likely, definitely not white oak, not even close D) unidentifiable - too rough, too small E) not walnut, wrong grain - exotic, unidentifiable with that sample F) exotic, possibly bubinga - unidentifiable, too small, too blurry 2 Quote
Marmotjr Posted May 13, 2017 Author Report Posted May 13, 2017 All the sides shown are fresh cut from the table saw, even the fuzzy ones. The blanks are all about .75 x .75 x 5 in, so I really can't get better samples. While the focus can be a bit blurry, as I was very close to the samples, the colors are spot on, no distortion. So, @Eric, I'm really doubting C is Walnut, unless it's sapwood, the color is more like a creamy cappuccino rather than the dark brown I'm familiar with, but If you still insist it's walnut then, I'll go with that. I knew it was a shot in the dark. Most of the blanks are pretty meh for pen turning (no figure, boring color), but some are pretty amazing (The Tulipwood, paduak, and whatever B is), with vibrant colors and grain. But they should all make for really neat segments. Quote
Eric. Posted May 13, 2017 Report Posted May 13, 2017 Walnut comes in a variety of colors. I wouldn't have a better guess without better pics. Pretty sure it's walnut. Go turn it and take a whiff, then you'll know for sure. 1 Quote
Eric. Posted May 13, 2017 Report Posted May 13, 2017 3 minutes ago, davewyo said: Sample B looks like Chechen to me. Not a bad guess. But there are SO many exotics that look SO similar to that. @phinds will surely have the same opinion...no way to confidently ID with those samples. Also that particular sample is all end grain...tough to think of anything you can do with that piece...headed for the trash bin regardless...unless Marmot has more of it it's probably moot. Edit...forgot you were into segmented turning...scratch that last thought. 2 Quote
phinds Posted May 13, 2017 Report Posted May 13, 2017 On 5/13/2017 at 8:26 AM, Eric. said: Not a bad guess. But there are SO many exotics that look SO similar to that. @phinds will surely have the same opinion...no way to confidently ID with those samples. Also that particular sample is all end grain...tough to think of anything you can do with that piece...headed for the trash bin regardless...unless Marmot has more of it it's probably moot. I agree. I had not jumped in on this thread because while the photography seems quite good, the pieces that the pics are of are too scantily shown (especially the end grain) for much of a chance at a decent ID. I agree w/ what you've said about them. I'd be surprised if B is chechem but it's possible. Those sharply defined, tiny black streaks on the face don't seem like chechem to me. 1 Quote
Marmotjr Posted May 13, 2017 Author Report Posted May 13, 2017 51 minutes ago, Eric. said: Walnut comes in a variety of colors. I wouldn't have a better guess without better pics. Pretty sure it's walnut. Go turn it and take a whiff, then you'll know for sure. Nope, not walnut. I definitely noticed the Tulipwood though. I like that smell, for about 20 seconds, then it starts to burn. Appreciated everybody, I know the samples are tiny, and I don't have much to go on. Even the original listing didn't know what they were, just gave a list of possibilities, including "many more". ID isn't that important, other than being able to list what I've used. Also, if I happen to like the wood, it would be nice to know what it is for future reference if I want to use it in a bigger project. Quote
QHC Posted May 13, 2017 Report Posted May 13, 2017 Walnut comes in a variety of colors. I wouldn't have a better guess without better pics. Pretty sure it's walnut. Go turn it and take a whiff, then you'll know for sure. The smell test will go a long way. . . Sent from my SM-N920P using Tapatalk 1 Quote
Marmotjr Posted May 13, 2017 Author Report Posted May 13, 2017 One more for you guys, I'm thinking this one should be a lot easier. Still a scrap box find, I had a guess before I cut it down for the base of the project, but after seeing the cuts, I'm not sure anymore. So I'm hoping it's my second guess, but I'll hide my ignorance till later. Face (it's old and somewhat dirty, it's been planed, but I don't know how many years ago, sides are rough on the main piece): Side: End grain: Quote
Eric. Posted May 13, 2017 Report Posted May 13, 2017 If that's not cherry I smoked some crack this morning. 2 Quote
Marmotjr Posted May 13, 2017 Author Report Posted May 13, 2017 Sweet! That's what I was hoping. Given that it was a scrap find, I assumed it was just pine. But after cutting it, I thought to myself, I think this is Cherry. It's 5/4, 20" x8". Well, 4" shorter now after I cut the base for the mug. I don't have a lot of experience with cherry, but I'm (long term) planning on doing a coffee table and 2 end table set out of cherry, and this just cemented it for me, I like this wood. 1 Quote
Eric. Posted May 13, 2017 Report Posted May 13, 2017 Cherry is the most underrated species out there. I mean obviously a ton of guys use it all the time, and historically speaking it's possibly the most used species in American history (at least in terms of consistency, over the centuries). But all you seem to hear about these days is walnut, walnut, walnut. And for good reason. But I think cherry is equal to walnut in every imaginable way. Different, but equal. And cheaper. It only takes about a year, and it turns such a beautiful reddish brown. So rich and warm. 2 Quote
phinds Posted May 13, 2017 Report Posted May 13, 2017 2 hours ago, Eric. said: If that's not cherry I smoked some crack this morning. I hope the crack is good. That's maple. 2 Quote
Eric. Posted May 13, 2017 Report Posted May 13, 2017 Well not only am I a crackhead but I'm colorblind, too. Not joking. I believe you're right, Paul, now that you say it...but it looks to have a little red in it, no? Or is that just my poorly functioning eyeballs? In my defense, if cherry and maple were the same color, they would be difficult to distinguish...very similar grain. Quote
Marmotjr Posted May 13, 2017 Author Report Posted May 13, 2017 hehehehe... still doesn't change my mind about the coffee table choice. Quote
phinds Posted May 13, 2017 Report Posted May 13, 2017 1 hour ago, Eric. said: Well not only am I a crackhead but I'm colorblind, too. Not joking. I believe you're right, Paul, now that you say it...but it looks to have a little red in it, no? Or is that just my poorly functioning eyeballs? In my defense, if cherry and maple were the same color, they would be difficult to distinguish...very similar grain. Even hard maple can have a slight red tint in pics. The ray flakes are the giveaway. Cherry has them but they don't look like that set. Also, the rays tend to be a bit more pronounced in cherry, not so much because they are bigger but because the ones in maple tend to blend into the surrounding tissue. 1 Quote
Eric. Posted May 13, 2017 Report Posted May 13, 2017 8 minutes ago, phinds said: The ray flakes are the giveaway. Cherry has them but they don't look like that set. You're 100% right. I should have taken the extra nano-second to look more closely. I defer to Paul for all future ID issues. His eyes work. 1 Quote
Popular Post Woodenskye Posted May 13, 2017 Popular Post Report Posted May 13, 2017 Don't worry E, it's not a bad thing to switch from crack to weed! 3 Quote
Eric. Posted May 13, 2017 Report Posted May 13, 2017 True story...for some reason the guy who owns my lumberyard has 8/4 maple right next to 8/4 cherry. Doesn't matter how many years I spend handling these boards...if the maple is old and the cherry is new...I still have to stop and take a closer look from time to time because they tend to get mixed together when Mr. Sloppy Ass goes through the stacks. They can look pretty damn close in some cases. Quote
Marmotjr Posted July 28, 2017 Author Report Posted July 28, 2017 I have the piece of 'maple' sitting between a another piece of maple and a piece of cherry. I will defer to phinds' learned answer, but I have a real hard time believing it's not cherry. Just had to bump this. Continue on, nothing to see here. Quote
rodger. Posted July 28, 2017 Report Posted July 28, 2017 I don't have a lot to add to this thread, but it sure is a good read! 1 Quote
wdwerker Posted July 28, 2017 Report Posted July 28, 2017 Cherry can have a sweet smell when fresh cut. Maple has a more toasty/earthy smell to me, of course after almost fifty years working wood and bad sinuses subtle aromas elude me. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.