Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Rough lumber and grain patterns

Featured Replies

Can anyone give a hint or two how you go about seeing the grain pattern in rough lumber? I bought several bd ft of QSWO and picked out 3 boards for the top of a table. Done good on two of them but the widest board  I completely missed seeing it. It's not a bad pattern but there are probably better in the pile. 

The fleck in rough QSWO is really hard to see.  I'd lightly skip plane the boards before laying out for parts.  Not much else you can do.

I had trouble with this recently too, but with walnut. I hand picked some great looking rough boards and planed them down only to find that the sapwood "edges" i saw in the rough were actually 3" wide bands just below the surface.

 

My only advice is look closely including the ends, analyzing whats going on with the grain to the best of your ability. And buy more than you need for a project.

 

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G890A using Tapatalk

 

 

This is the main reason I prefer not to buy rough lumber.  By the time you toss the garbage boards that come out of your planer, you're no better off than if you would have paid a little more buying skip-planed or surfaced lumber.  I know this is not the "purist" mindset...but I don't like buying boards I can't use, regardless of the price.  I want to SEE the boards I'm buying before I buy them.  Can't do that in the rough.  You can make educated guesses, but every time I've taken the gamble...I got burned.

If you're going to be doing this, find an old, cheap blockplane with an iron that's not pitted too badly.  You'll find grit in the dust on a lot or rough boards, and it's not worth using a good tool on dirty boards.  Put a small camber on the iron so the edges don't dig in.  You don't need one with an adjustable mouth.  I don't own a $165 block plane, but it would be foolish to put one of those to this task.

I've had that problem with Roughsawn walnut the way it's steamed to even out the color can hide alot.

A block plane is dandy but that's only going to show maybe  1 or 2 % of the board.

I buy extra boards esp for table tops.

Aj

Sheperd's point about looking at the end grain is especially helpful if we're talking QSWO.  If you can get a clean look at the end grain it can be very telling.  Ray fleck is extremely finicky stuff, and if the cut deviates from quartersawn by even just a few degrees, the fleck will diminish to those tiny, closely gathered flecks that kind of run in the same direction, and then disappear altogether.  When the end grain is dead nuts vertical, that's when you most often get those big, fat, wandering flecks that can stretch across the entire board.  That's the good stuff.  So if the guys at your yard are cool (and not too busy) the best thing to do after you've picked a few boards out would be to ask them to slice about 1/16" off the end of the board so you can inspect the end grain (both ends of the board would be better in case the cut deviates at any point from end to end...this is fairly common).  This won't give you any information about color or presence of sapwood, etc...but it should allow you to form a good guess about what the fleck probably looks like.

Then, once you get home, I would still skip plane (or sand with coarse grit if thickness is an issue) before laying out for parts.  Use your best boards for the most prominent parts of the piece, and the weaker boards for the less visible parts to help minimize waste.

I have 3 choices:

1) Go to the retail yard where everything is skip planed and customers can pick their own board.  Sounds good in concept but all of the domestics are ridiculously picked over at my local yard, especially walnut and cherry.  the 4/4 stuff is crap.    The only boards not picked over are the wide, long, 8/4 stuff because your average weekend warrior and contractor don't have the tooling or budget to process that material.  

2) Buy wholesale in 50BF minimums, site unseen.   Believe it or not this has worked out well for me.  The stack is not picked over so the quality is pretty good.  They grade walnut using oak scale and bin based on sap content for cherry   

3) Buy from the mill, where I can pick my boards, but they are rough sawn.  However the price is right.  

No perfect answer for me. 

I only have access to S3S QSWO...which sucks for thickness but for most projects that doesn't matter.  QSWO stays pretty flat because it's so stable, so there isn't a whole lot of milling needed once I get it home.  I can almost always maintain 3/4"...and don't usually need even that much thickness.

I do have the benefit of pick of the litter because I know when new shipments come in.  If you talk to the guys at your dealer they may give you a head's up on the shipment scheduling.

  • Author

Here is what I got and I am going with. The outside boards have good curl but the middle one is week. It had curl on the ends and the end grain was about straight up as possible. Looking like the rest of it will be getting skipped through the planer. 

For the record, this is the pre-build of a coffee table that my daughter will be building for 4-H. I always try to build ahead of her project, in case a problem comes up, we have an answer. Plus she see's the first one so I better on her own. The first piece gets given usually to my mom. Win-win 

IMG_20170521_172004.jpg

5 minutes ago, Southwood said:

curl

It's ray fleck, FYI...not curl.  They're both types of figure but they're different.

Will this table have aprons? If so, I might use that center board for the aprons and go find another board with better fleck to replace it.  The lack of fleck and the different look of that board won't be nearly as obvious if used for apron material.  The top is the focal point.  That strip of sapwood on the left board I would also find irritating. :) But that's me.

  • Author

I meant fleck, sorry. Actually had to do work at work today and just a little bit tired. Getting to old to work at work. 

No aprons. The sap will be ripped off, once to final width. 

I think they are all nice and I think the center board is fine.  You could move the center board to the outside so that the flek is concentrated on one side.  It might look more natural that way, and the flek will be more obvious if it is grouped together.  

 

  • Author
  • Popular Post

Ok got all the boards skipped. Culled 2 boards, but do have a place for them so no real loss. Don't know for sure if you can see the flecks in the pics or not, but I can see them and the different color shades of the boards. The red marks on the couple boards are areas not worth using. Paid $2 bd ft and it started at 1 1/8 for 4/4 so I am happy. 

IMG_20170522_182530.jpg

IMG_20170522_182524.jpg

13 minutes ago, Southwood said:

Paid $2 bd ft and it started at 1 1/8 for 4/4 so I am happy.

Yeah at that price it's hard to complain if you get a couple duds.  That's a screamin' deal.

For the record, I'd use the 2nd, 4th, and 5th boards (from left to right, bottom pic)...for the top. :) ...if they're long enough.

  • Author
15 minutes ago, Eric. said:

 

For the record, I'd use the 2nd, 4th, and 5th boards (from left to right, bottom pic)...for the top. :) ...if they're long enough.

That's my plan but I want her to make that choice, or at least ask. 

I do get really good prices on lumber, as so many dealers are in the area and I sometimes the junk along with the good. I never complain and always pay cash. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,011 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • bobtjanitor Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.