bushwacked Posted November 13, 2017 Report Posted November 13, 2017 In my research the only thing that really seems to be consistent is that the parallelogram beds are "easier" to square up over a dovetail bed. Is that the only difference? When I was researching jointers, they do not have them for 6" jointers so I never really paid much attention to them while I was buying mine. Now since I am bored at work it has sparked my interest, but I dont hear much else about them. Quickly looking over prices, they seem to be about $300 more as well. What am I missing that make there a $300 price jump? Yes, they are a lot bigger machines from the look of it. Also, seem to have slightly longer beds too. Anyways, thanks for entertaining my crazy question ...curiosity has really gotten to me on this one. Quote
Tom King Posted November 13, 2017 Report Posted November 13, 2017 Sorry, I don't have any experience with them. I've only ever owned wedge beds, and think the last time I adjusted one was in the mid 1970's, but don't remember it being so horrible. Quote
Pwk5017 Posted November 13, 2017 Report Posted November 13, 2017 The DJ-15 offered parallelogram beds in a 6" format. Little brother of the popular DJ-20. I cant understand why the bed design would increase cost. If anything, milling accurate dovetail ways should be more expensive. You took into account that the DT jointers tend to have shorter beds. I think either bed design gets the job done. More important to have flat tables, flat fence, and correctly calibrated to be co-planer. After that, the parallelogram beds get you dialed in a little faster and easier. I think the parallelogram beds also move the beds in an arc, and maintain a consistent distance to the cutterhead. In theory, the DT ways move in a linear motion away from the cutterhead. Deeper cut=farther distance from the cutterhead. In my mind, it's width capacity>bed length>cutterhead design>bed design in that order. Obviously weight and motor are important too, but i rarely take off more than a 1/16" each face pass, so im not too concerned about HP. 1 Quote
Mark J Posted November 13, 2017 Report Posted November 13, 2017 Interesting question to me too. I don't really understand the difference in how they are engineered. Is there a diagram somewhere? Quote
gee-dub Posted November 14, 2017 Report Posted November 14, 2017 P-beds were on my “must have” List when I was shopping for a new jointer. That’s because I had had enough experience fiddling with dovetail way tables. If you’ve never had to fool with them, or it’s been long enough that you don’t remember how painful it is then it’s not really a big deal. As for being a job to align if and when that becomes necessary, no contest. One is adjusted with Shim stock and the other is adjusted with independent cams. Grizzly used to offer a 6 inch with P beds, probably a clone of the DJ 15 just as the popular G0490 is a clone of the DJ 20. If p- beds are not on your shortlist then they probably don’t really matter to you. LOL, just noticed the speech to text said "As for being a jerk to align", I fixed that to "As for being a job to align". Quote
fastev Posted November 14, 2017 Report Posted November 14, 2017 There is a 6" Grizzly P-bed on craigslist near me right now... Having disassembled and rebuilt both styles I think the p-bed would actually be far easier to manufacture. There are quite a few more pieces, but there is also far more tolerance for manufacturing errors on the p-bed. I think most of the issues on the wedge bed models stem from cheaper castings that warp or simply don't have the material to support the beds hanging off the base. My Delta 6" was a champ, and it was about 20 years old. Easy to adjust, and held those adjustments perfectly. I only upgraded because I found an Brazilian-made Invicta DJ-20 with a Byrd cutter for $400. My brother was given a Ridgid 6" a few years ago. It was only used a couple times, but stored in a leaky shed with crap all over it. I rebuilt it for him, and the dovetails required significant shimming to get everything square. This is usually a pretty reliable model, but his was a turd. Didn't hold settings well at all. He gave it to some other poor soul when he got a DJ-15. We rebuild that, and it's been solid as could be ever since. The parallelogram beds are the only way to go if you are in the market if I have any advice to offer. I don't think the castings of the wedge beds are anything near the quality they once were. I suspect the $300 you are seeing is because they are the "new" technology, which, as we all know, is worth more... Quote
Tom King Posted November 14, 2017 Report Posted November 14, 2017 I will add that my only experience with wedge beds is on jointers that were made long enough ago when quality of product was more important than quick profit. Castings were left outside to equalize for long periods of time before they ever were brought in to be machined. If I was buying a fresh one, I'd get a parallel bed one. Quote
bushwacked Posted November 14, 2017 Author Report Posted November 14, 2017 12 hours ago, gee-dub said: P-beds were on my “must have” List when I was shopping for a new jointer. That’s because I had had enough experience fiddling with dovetail way tables. If you’ve never had to fool with them, or it’s been long enough that you don’t remember how painful it is then it’s not really a big deal. As for being a job to align if and when that becomes necessary, no contest. One is adjusted with Shim stock and the other is adjusted with independent cams. Grizzly used to offer a 6 inch with P beds, probably a clone of the DJ 15 just as the popular G0490 is a clone of the DJ 20. If p- beds are not on your shortlist then they probably don’t really matter to you. LOL, just noticed the speech to text said "As for being a jerk to align", I fixed that to "As for being a job to align". lol, maybe cause I am spoiled with the 6" PM but my dovetails seemed fine to set up .. minimal tinkering really. So I have not had the beat down experience some of you have had I guess to really appreciate the P-beds setup. Maybe one day I will see the glory in all of that ... 10 hours ago, fastev said: There is a 6" Grizzly P-bed on craigslist near me right now... Having disassembled and rebuilt both styles I think the p-bed would actually be far easier to manufacture. There are quite a few more pieces, but there is also far more tolerance for manufacturing errors on the p-bed. I think most of the issues on the wedge bed models stem from cheaper castings that warp or simply don't have the material to support the beds hanging off the base. My Delta 6" was a champ, and it was about 20 years old. Easy to adjust, and held those adjustments perfectly. I only upgraded because I found an Brazilian-made Invicta DJ-20 with a Byrd cutter for $400. My brother was given a Ridgid 6" a few years ago. It was only used a couple times, but stored in a leaky shed with crap all over it. I rebuilt it for him, and the dovetails required significant shimming to get everything square. This is usually a pretty reliable model, but his was a turd. Didn't hold settings well at all. He gave it to some other poor soul when he got a DJ-15. We rebuild that, and it's been solid as could be ever since. The parallelogram beds are the only way to go if you are in the market if I have any advice to offer. I don't think the castings of the wedge beds are anything near the quality they once were. I suspect the $300 you are seeing is because they are the "new" technology, which, as we all know, is worth more... hmmm interesting ... ya in my area I get about 1 powermatic a year pop up in C List ... it is crap for buying used tools. Quality on most this is not anywhere near what it used to be though. 9 hours ago, Tom King said: I will add that my only experience with wedge beds is on jointers that were made long enough ago when quality of product was more important than quick profit. Castings were left outside to equalize for long periods of time before they ever were brought in to be machined. If I was buying a fresh one, I'd get a parallel bed one. yep, quality is not what it used to be ... Why would you go P-bed? Just for ease of setup? Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.