Ron Swanson Jr. Posted July 18, 2024 Report Posted July 18, 2024 Von Do you ever use shellac? I can see wanting the protection that poly offers for your project, but shellac and wax has become my go to. It's a lot less futzy than poly IMO. 1 Quote
Von Posted July 19, 2024 Author Report Posted July 19, 2024 On 7/18/2024 at 12:26 PM, Ron Swanson Jr. said: Von Do you ever use shellac? I can see wanting the protection that poly offers for your project, but shellac and wax has become my go to. It's a lot less futzy than poly IMO. I've tried some pre-mixed Zinsser's Shellac for shop projects. It did go on nicely but had a yellow hue on the pieces and left a strong unpleasant odor. Not sure that is what you are referring to. Things moving along on the finishing. I shifted to using a high-grit 3M pad for between coat smoothing. Two coats on everything but the edge pieces where I had to take a day redoing the staining. Probably do 3 or four coats total. 2 Quote
Ron Swanson Jr. Posted July 19, 2024 Report Posted July 19, 2024 On 7/19/2024 at 1:33 PM, Von said: I've tried some pre-mixed Zinsser's Shellac for shop projects. It did go on nicely but had a yellow hue They have 2 varieties in most stores, an Amber and Clear. I wonder if you had the amber. It doesn't smell great when wet. I guess i haven't noticed a smell when it's dry but my sniffer isn't all that sensitive. Either way, you're project is coming along very nicely! 1 Quote
wtnhighlander Posted July 19, 2024 Report Posted July 19, 2024 I like Zinsser 'Seal Coat' shellac. It is a thinner cut, dewaxed, and very blond. Most of the smell is from the alcohol solvent. 1 Quote
Von Posted July 20, 2024 Author Report Posted July 20, 2024 On 7/19/2024 at 4:40 PM, Ron Swanson Jr. said: They have 2 varieties in most stores, an Amber and Clear. I wonder if you had the amber. Yep, I have the Amber. On 7/19/2024 at 4:40 PM, Ron Swanson Jr. said: It doesn't smell great when wet. I guess i haven't noticed a smell when it's dry but my sniffer isn't all that sensitive. Yes, it was when wet I noticed the bad odor. Dry it's totally fine. On 7/19/2024 at 4:40 PM, Ron Swanson Jr. said: Either way, you're project is coming along very nicely! Thank you On 7/19/2024 at 7:15 PM, wtnhighlander said: Most of the smell is from the alcohol solvent. That jives with my experience. 1 Quote
Von Posted July 22, 2024 Author Report Posted July 22, 2024 Finishing continues to be my bane. Not happy with the water-based poly - I'm seeing too many brush strokes. I picked up some wipe-on semi gloss, and also rattle cans of poly and clear shellac. Playing with the rattle cans seems promising. We're off to the west coast Tuesday for a vacation, so I'm going to set this aside, get the shop cleaned up tomorrow, and reassess when I get back. 1 Quote
gee-dub Posted July 22, 2024 Report Posted July 22, 2024 On 7/21/2024 at 6:23 PM, Von said: Finishing continues to be my bane. The water borne polys have left me sour although they are making progress. The General Finishes High Performance product line left me unimpressed. I hear that GF Enduro Var II does well but at $60 a quart I have not gone there yet. The good news is that once you find your groove with whatever the product is, you will be able to get pretty predictable results. 1 Quote
Von Posted July 22, 2024 Author Report Posted July 22, 2024 On 7/22/2024 at 12:38 PM, gee-dub said: The water borne polys have left me sour although they are making progress. The General Finishes High Performance product line left me unimpressed. I hear that GF Enduro Var II does well but at $60 a quart I have not gone there yet. The good news is that once you find your groove with whatever the product is, you will be able to get pretty predictable results. Yeah, I gravitated to the water borne finishes because of the low HOVs, but I should branch out and see if that is worth it. The rattle cans have increased my temptation to try buying an entry-level spray gun and I welcome any thoughts on that topic. Quote
Ron Swanson Jr. Posted July 22, 2024 Report Posted July 22, 2024 My .02 The water based poly doesn't seem to give wood the warm, inviting finish that the oil based does. It dries much faster, easier clean up but I've always felt that's the trade off. Not sure if others share that opinion or not. 2 Quote
wtnhighlander Posted July 23, 2024 Report Posted July 23, 2024 Water bourn poly is great for a lot of things, but if that was all I had for finishing walnut, I'd just quit. You can't fake the deep amber richness that oil based finishes give to darker woods. 2 Quote
Von Posted August 3, 2024 Author Report Posted August 3, 2024 Back from vacation and into the shop finishing today. Looked everything over and sanded a couple of pieces back that I was unhappy with. I decided to give the rattle can water-borne poly a try, constructing the "Amazon spray booth" in the photo below. Taking it slow, just doing a couple of pieces at a time. I enjoyed the rhythm of finishing outside: spray, work on other stuff in the shop for a half hour while it dries, and then repeat. Continuing to use the high-grit (maroon, light grey, and white) 3M pads between coats. Probably need 1 or 2 more days of shop time to complete. 2 Quote
Popular Post Von Posted August 12, 2024 Author Popular Post Report Posted August 12, 2024 Glued up one of the two boxes. I goofed up my last piece of felt for the other one, so ordered some more before gluing it up. 3 Quote
Von Posted August 17, 2024 Author Report Posted August 17, 2024 A bit of a disaster today, I took the clamps off the second box to find what you see in the image below. From what I can tell, the dowel somehow got unseated from the main body during glue up and resisted going back in, breaking through the side below instead. After confirming I could not press the material flat, I cleaned it up with a chisel and yep, there is the dowel closer to the surface than it should be. I'm hoping the black dye will hide a lot of this if I can get it flat, so I cleaned it up some more, put some Timbermate on it and am working to smooth it. We'll see how it looks once the Timbermate dries, I touch up the dye and put another couple coats of poly on it. 4 Quote
Popular Post Von Posted August 22, 2024 Author Popular Post Report Posted August 22, 2024 Well, I think I salvaged the damage to "if you look for it under a raking light" status. This lighting is as unflattering as it gets. Thinking about what I did wrong, I tried to glue up too much a once. I should have glued the dowels on one side first and then maybe even one end at a time. I got the boxes finished today and gifted. Fairly happy with how they turned out. Appreciate the advice on the inlays which I'm very happy with. 4 Quote
wtnhighlander Posted August 22, 2024 Report Posted August 22, 2024 I bet the recipients were pleased! 1 Quote
Popular Post Mark J Posted August 22, 2024 Popular Post Report Posted August 22, 2024 Well done (and nice save). This should put you firmly into most favorite uncle status. 3 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.