Sergio Escudero Posted April 19 Report Posted April 19 I want to start buying handsaws and I've been learning a bit about the subject but I feel like I need a little more help. Since I want to work purely by hand, I feel the need to cut rough planks by hand, so I need a couple of big handsaws (rip and crosscut) and a couple of panelsaws. The thickness of the planks I'll be working with can vary widely, between 25-60mm, but normally around 40-50mm. How does the tooth count of the saw affect cutting different thicknesses? Looking at old saws, I've found a large rip handsaw W.Tyzack & Sons that's 77cm long with 3 1/2 tpi and another similar Disston Canada with 6 tpi. Would that be a good choice to cover my rough rip cutting range? What tpi should I look for in a rough crosscut saw? As for panel saws, I understand that the tooth count should be higher to make clean cuts cutting near the waste line. The thickness of the boards I'll be working with like that will probably be between 10-30mm frequently. I think here cutting clean is more important than fast. I'd like to have a small chart of what I should look for in each saw so I can buy as I find good opportunities. Quote
Tpt life Posted April 19 Report Posted April 19 I use Sandvik (sp?) Fully pleased with saws that are at least as old as I am. Tooth size that makes for “gullet” depth help clear in thick cuts. Rake and and tooth set matter a little more for different purposes, and tooth count is more about aggression or speed of cut in my experience. Quote
Ron Swanson Jr. Posted April 19 Report Posted April 19 So first, a slight correction on your terminology. These are panel saws: Smaller saws like this below (tenon, carcase, dovetail, etc.) are typically called back saws, because they have a stiff back. Usually, for panel saws, you'll see a much smaller toothcount for rip saws and a higher tooth count for cross cut. The teeth will also be profiled, set and sharpened differently for rip v. Crosscut. As a rule of thumb, i was taught that you want a minimum of 4 teeth across the thickness of your workpiece. I don't personally find that i need a huge number of saws. I do most of what i do with 2 panel saws, a carcase saw (which is my bellcow) and a dovetail saw. I do have a few larger tenon saws, but i don't use them nearly as much. So i guess that's where I'd start off if i were in your shoes, 2 panel saws, a small backsaw (dovetail) for small work and a medium carcase or tenon saw for most of everything else. From that base you can let your work tell you if you need anything more. Hope this helps. 2 Quote
Popular Post wtnhighlander Posted April 19 Popular Post Report Posted April 19 Having tested my patience by rip sawing a 7" thick by 8' long log cant with a 7 tpi saw, I can tell you it can be done. I'll also say that a 3 or 4 tpi saw would have made the job much faster. Smaller teeth, with smaller gullets, get packed with waste only a small distance into the kerf, and don't clear until they exit the other side. This means very little cutting is accomplished with each stroke. For rough cuts, I would want one long hand saw / panel saw with 3 to 5 teeth per inch, filed for ripping. Cross cutting can be done well enough with 7 to 9 teeth per inch, even in thick stock, since the total cut is usually less that a foot or so. A pair of back saws with more teeth per inch will cover your joinery needs. Alternatively, all those tasks can be accomplished reasonably well with a single 'Ryoba', the japanese pull saw with teeth on both edges. 3 Quote
Popular Post Tom King Posted April 20 Popular Post Report Posted April 20 Handsaws are 26" long and some longer. Panel saws are shorter versions of handsaws typically 20 to 24" long. I don't own any, never having a good reason to need a shorter saw. Backsaws have a stiff extra piece over the top of the saw plate. 8 pt. is a good handsaw for shortening boards. I use 10 pt. for cutting wood siding boards. 12 pt. make nice clean cuts on finish work in hardwood. Sometimes a 7 pt. for soft (softer than Yellow Pine) framing lumber. 3-1/2 pt. is a beast of a rip saw, especially if you are trying to rip hardwood thicker than 4/4. 4-1/2 might not sound like much difference, but it is and is my most used size. I especially like a Disston D8 with 28" plate and thumbhole for the second hand thumb in the handle. A 6 pt. is okay, but slow and slow is harder on the arm than getting it done. Since the question was about handsaws, I won't get into backsaws. A lot of new woodworkers call backsaws handsaws. Don't. The second picture shows a saw box that I built in 1974 and still use. I sat on that box eating my lunch many days. The picture with more saws in it was made maybe 20 years ago just to keep the accumulation in a safe place. I also like Sandvik saws. I think they stopped making them in the late 1980's, so I've bought up some unused ones to keep as spares-ones still in new sleeves in the newer box. I also have a number of others other than the Sandviks that work good too. If you use a handsaw to amount to anything, you need to be able to sharpen them. Long backsaw in old box came with Langdon-Acme miter box that I bought new and still use sometimes. 3 Quote
Popular Post Botch Posted April 20 Popular Post Report Posted April 20 If you're cutting rough lumber, have you considered a bowsaw? Because the blade is in high tension it can be much thinner, which would make the work go much quicker. The Wood by Wright channel on EweTube uses bowsaws a lot, and has some good information (he uses one that is almost as tall as he is!) EDIT: Sergio, your post got me to re-watch a few of James Wright's videos, and this one was particularly good: 5 Quote
JustAnotherGuy Posted April 20 Report Posted April 20 Lower TPI cuts faster for thick stock, higher TPI gives you more control and a cleaner cut on thinner stuff. For your 40–50mm boards, 3.5–6 TPI rip saws are a solid combo, around 7–9 TPI works well for rough crosscuts, and for panel work (10–30mm) look more in the 10–14 TPI range so you can stay close to your line without tearing things up. 2 Quote
curlyoak Posted April 25 Report Posted April 25 Tom, I love the set of saws! If hand saws will be in a lot of use, then you will need a saw vice, a saw set, and a few files and a few file handles. 2 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.